3 Best Bakeries in Evansville, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bakeries in Evansville, Indiana. All of our bakeries actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Panaderia San Miguel - Evansville, IN Bakeries
Panaderia San Miguel - Evansville, IN Bakeries
Panaderia San Miguel - Evansville, IN Bakeries
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PANADERIA SAN MIGUEL

2004 Washington Avenue,
Evansville, IN 47714 Directions

Since 1993

Specialty:

Bread Buns Cakes Savory Giant Tostadas Burritos and Soups Pan Dulce Flatbreads Pastries JalapeñoMexican Cheesecake Cookie Custom Cakes Tortas

"Panaderia San Miguel makes bakery products with skilled artistry and dedication to quality. Their pastries are made with the finest ingredients to ensure everything is fresh and delicious. Their commitment lies in delivering excellent bread and pastries fresh every day. Their team is dedicated to crafting baked goods without any chemicals or preservatives. Their baker is dedicated and works long hours to create excellent treats. Panaderia San Miguel's prices are more than reasonable. Their sandwiches are crafted with fresh, handmade bread. Panaderia San Miguel creates a warm, welcoming atmosphere where neighborhood people can get together to relax, work, and visit each other. The bakery is located in a Mexican neighborhood.

2026 Update: Panaderia San Miguel specializes in delicious Mexican bread and Tres Leches cakes. They are recognized as Evansville's Hispanic bakery and are known for producing healthier pastries. You can try their bolillo (freshly kneaded white rolls), conchas, empanadas, cream horns, and bread pudding."

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Contact:

(812) 814-8037

Mon,Tue,Thu-Sun: 8am - 9pm
Wed: 8am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BE HAPPY PIE COMPANY

2818 Mt Vernon Avenue B,
Evansville, IN 47712 Directions

Since 2015

Specialty:

Signature 'Be Happy' Cherry Apple Streusel Awesome Apple Banana Cream Blackberry Crumb Blueberry Streusel Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Bourbon Pecan Brownie Pie Bites Scrappies Scones Chocolate Chip Chocolate Crinkle Oatmeal Raisin Snickerdoodle 'grandma Good' Cookies Oatmeal Cream Pies/ Monster Cookie Pies/ Peanut Butter Cookie Pies Cookie Pies Muffins Cherry/ Chocolate Chip/ Plain/ Turtle Cheesecakes Energy Bites Fiesta Taco Pie Roasted Vegetable with Feta Quiche Sausage and Cheddar Quiche

"Be Happy Pie Company specializes in pies, scones, cookies, coffee cakes, sweet rolls, cheesecakes, cookie pies, and cream puffs. Jenny Lamble is the founder and owner of Be Happy Pie Company, who has a lifelong passion for baking, which was inspired by her grandmother’s "Grandma Backes" recipes and early childhood experiences. The bakery takes pride in making its products from scratch and baking them perfectly for you to enjoy. They are committed to using only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients because they believe the best flavors come from superior sources. The bakery aspires to bake happiness in their desserts, creating joy whether celebrating life's simple moments or milestones. Be Happy Pie Company strives to keep its kitchen and products as nut-free as possible. The Be Happy Pie Company team is driven by a passion for delivering exceptional products and outstanding customer service.

2026 Update: They bake locally and ship nationally. They are founded on three pillars, including freshness, quality, and friendliness. Their mission is to dedicate themselves to creating joy for both simple daily moments and major life milestones through their desserts. They are also located at 6225 E Virginia Street, Suite C, Evansville, IN, and Paducah, KY."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Signature Pies
Signature Be Happy Cherry Pie From $12.50
Loaded Chocolate Pecan Pie From $11.50
Chocolate Chess Pie From $11.50
Loaded Pecan From $11.50
Awesome Apple Pie From $12.50
Gooseberry Crumb Pie From $37.00
Apple Streusel Pie From $11.50
Bumbleberry Crumb Pie From $11.50
Bourbon Chocolate Pecan Pie From $12.50
Cherry Crumb Pie From $11.50
Blackberry Crumb Pie From $11.50
Chess Pie From $11.50
Bourbon Pecan Pie From $12.50
Blueberry Streusel Pie From $11.50

Discount:

April Pie of the Month Starts at $7.50

Contact:

(812) 449-7718

Tue-Fri: 7:30am - 5pm
Sat: 8am - 12pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Panera Bread - Evansville, IN Bakeries
Panera Bread - Evansville, IN Bakeries
Panera Bread - Evansville, IN Bakeries
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PANERA BREAD

220 North Burkhardt Road,
Evansville, IN 47715 Directions

Since 1993

Specialty:

Chocolate Chipper Cookie Candy Cookie Coconut Macaroon Chocolate Coconut Macaroon Brownie Oatmeal Raisin with Berries Cookie Kitchen Sink Cookie Cinnamon Roll Almond Pastry Cherry Pastry Cranberry Orange Slice Pecan Braid Chocolate Croissant Blueberry Muffin Chocolate Chip Muffin Orange Scone Chicken Bacon Rancher Ciabatta Cheesesteak Chipotle Chicken Avo Melt Toasted Frontega Chicken Toasted Italiano Spicy Fiesta Chicken Toasted Garden Caprese Smokehouse BBQ Chicken Sandwich Autumn Squash Soup Hearty Fireside Chili Rustic Baked Potato Soup Bacon Mac and Cheese Broccoli Cheddar Soup Fuji Apple Chicken Salad

"Panera Bread is a counter-serve bakery chain serving sandwiches, salads, and more. They focus on quality, clean ingredients to serve you in a warm and welcoming environment. All their baked goods are prepared and served with passion, energy and innovation. Their team uses natural ingredients to make the finest quality cakes, bread, pies, and puddings. They provide delicious baked goods at affordable prices. The bakery has a great selection of bread and cakes of the highest quality. Panera Bread also offers coffees, smoothies, tea, and bottled beverages. They also have sandwiches. Their gift cards are a perfect gift idea for any occasion. Dine-in, pickup, and delivery options are also available at Panera Bread.

2026 Update: Panera Bread is situated in East Lloyd Commons shopping mall. You can enjoy a coffee and use their free Wi-Fi. You can try their Broccoli Cheddar Soup, Mac & Cheese, and various toasted sandwiches like the Chicken Green Goddess Caprese Melt."

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

New Asiago Croissant Twists $2.39
Tulip Cookie $4.19
New Dubai Style Chocolate Pistachio Cookie 4-Pack $9.89
Tulip Cookie 6-Pack $14.29
New Farmhouse Duo Asiago Bagel Stack $8.69
New Dubai Style Chocolate Pistachio Cookie $3.69
Chicken Roma Asiago Bagel Stack $9.89
Spicy Steak Asiago Bagel Stack $9.89
Iced CrèMe
ûLéE Latte $6.19
Strawberry Basil Lemonade Fresca $5.19
New Passionfruit Paradise Energy Refresher $5.19
CrèMe
ûLéE Latte $6.19
New Toasted Caprese Focaccia $11.89
New Cherry Lime Fresca $5.19
New Dragonfruit Sunset Energy Refresher $5.19
Harvest Medley Salad $12.19
Harvest Medley Chicken Salad $16.19
New Wake-Up Blt Asiago Everything Bagel Stack $8.69
New Asiago Everything Bagel $2.29
Sandwich And Salad $12.38
Soupmac And Salad $12.58
Sandwich And Soupmac $12.58

Discount:

Free Pastry and Free Delivery when You Sign Up

Contact:

(812) 476-7477

Mon-Sat: 6am - 9pm
Sun: 7am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report: