3 Best Insurance Agents in Tallahassee, FL

Expert-recommended Top 3 Insurance Agency in Tallahassee, Florida. All of our insurance agents actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

MCGINNISS HIMMEL INSURANCE AGENCY

2367 Centerville Road,
Tallahassee, FL 32308 Directions

Since 2008

Specialty:

✓Auto Insurance ✓Homeowners Insurance ✓Renters Insurance ✓Boat Insurance ✓Car Insurance ✓Disability Insurance ✓Life and Business Insurance

" McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency offers personalized, expert local guidance and tailored solutions to help clients navigate life's unexpected events. Their mission is to accurately provide families and individuals in the Southeast US the best value for the most appropriate protection possible with an emphasis on potential life-changing coverages. They understand the issues involved, potential pitfalls, and ways they can help save you money on your insurance. Their agency is focused on insurance for individuals and families. They take the time to explain the options in understandable terms. Their clients make the best decision for their families regarding their coverage. They provide quality coverage tailored to fit your requirements and budget.

2026 Highlights: McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency allows them to search for the best fit and value for each of their clients based on their specific situation."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #L092483

Contact:

(850) 329-6996

Mon-Thu: 8:30am - 5pm
Fri: 8:30am - 4:30pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

WATERHOUSE INSURANCE & FINANCIAL SERVICES

2880 Apalachee Parkway,
Tallahassee, FL 32301 Directions

Since 1989

Specialty:

✓Business ✓Automobile ✓Homeowner’s ✓Commercial ✓General Liability ✓Worker’s Compensation ✓Commercial Liability ✓Directors’ and Officers’ ✓Malpractice ✓Group Homeowners/Auto ✓Recreational ✓Other Business-Related Coverage ✓Life Insurance

" Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services offers discount insurance protection for hundreds of families, individuals, and companies. The team represents tested, trustworthy insurance products and outstanding customer service. They take pride in the precision, thoroughness, and quality of their work. They excel in fulfilling the requirements of their employees, stockholders, clients, and communities while treating all with courtesy, respect, honesty, and fairness. They guarantee that you’re covered today as well as in the future so that you can focus on what is important to you and your family. They provide outstanding customer service at low cost because their insurance agency can customize services to your specific requirements. Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services also offers free quotes.

2026 Highlights: Waterhouse Insurance & Financial Services licensed professionals take a hands-on, old-fashioned approach to service, ensuring every client receives personalized attention and guidance."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #L100688

Contact:

(850) 412-1099

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

5+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

BILL REARDON

STATE FARM 1835 Fiddler Court,
Tallahassee, FL 32308 Directions

Since 1991

Specialty:

✓Auto Insurance ✓Motorcycle Insurance ✓Homeowners Insurance ✓Condo Insurance ✓Renters Insurance ✓Business Insurance ✓Life Insurance ✓Health Insurance ✓Pet Insurance ✓Boat Insurance ✓Recreational Vehicle Insurance

" Bill Reardon is a State Farm Insurance Agent who has been helping clients in a friendly and efficient manner for over 26 years. Bill Reardon and his team of experts strive for excellence every day. Their goal is to create healthy relationships that serve as the foundation for their ability to protect you and your family from the risks of everyday life, to recover from the unexpected, and to realize your dreams. They help clients in Tallahassee and throughout Florida to handle risks, recover from the unexpected, and achieve their financial objectives. They make it comfortable for out-of-state transfers of auto insurance to Florida. They are happy to provide free auto and homeowners insurance quotes all over Florida.

2026 Highlights: Bill Reardon and his team are committed to providing friendly, personalized service."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #FL-R005769

Contact:

(850) 562-0760

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat & Evenings: By Appointment
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: