McGinniss Himmel Insurance Agency is an autonomous insurance agency in Tallahassee, Florida. Their area of expertise lies in offering insurance policies to individuals and families, which includes auto, home, and life insurance. Their objective is to provide their clients with customized, proficient, and local assistance, along with one-of-a-kind solutions that can aid them in recovering from unexpected life events. They deeply understand the complexities of insurance issues, potential risks, and ways to minimize insurance costs. Their agency is structured to help match their clients with the insurance company and coverages most suitable for their specific needs and circumstances. They are solely focused on providing insurance to individuals and families, and they thoroughly explain the options in plain language. This allows their clients to make the best decisions regarding their insurance coverage for themselves and their families. Contact them to receive an insurance quote.
Best Insurance Agents in Tallahassee
Handpicked Top 3 Insurance Agency in Tallahassee, Florida. All of our insurance agents actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence.
We have a strict “No Pay to Play” policy.
MCGINNISS HIMMEL INSURANCE AGENCY REVIEWS
The homeowners insurance agency that I've had my policy with for the past 4 years is pulling out of the February. So, I reached out to a friend for referrals to get quotes for a new policy. They gave me Larry Robert's number and I contacted him. He was very professional and honest. He was able to assist me in binding a new, very affordable, policy right away. I'll definitely recommend him and his agency to all of my family and friends. It's nice working with a local agency that you can trust.
McGinniss Himmel Insurance is hands down the most helpful and responsive agency I have ever experienced. They are a pleasure to deal with. They provided multiple quotes with great narratives of the pros and cons of each. We highly recommend them for all of your homeowners or auto insurance needs.
Highly recommend Josh at McGinnis Himmel Insurance. He was very knowledgeable and helpful when we were setting up our new homeowners and auto insurance policies. Very responsive and answered all of our questions and made sure we secured the policies that best fit our needs.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.

Jim Smith is a highly reputable and experienced Geico Insurance Agent based in Tallahassee, FL, located on North Monroe Street. He can help you save money on various insurance policies, including auto, motorcycle, and renters insurance. Jim has assembled a team of licensed insurance agents committed to meeting your Florida insurance needs. Their knowledgeable staff can always provide expert assistance with your business, benefits, and personal insurance requirements. The team at Jim Smith's agency comprises insurance professionals with diverse backgrounds and extensive experience in the industry who are recognized as regional and national leaders in their respective fields. They are dedicated to providing exceptional customer service and developing long-term client relationships. Contact them today to start an insurance quote and find out how they can assist you in securing the best coverage at an affordable price.
Specialty:
Contact:
Working Hours:
Sat & Sun: Closed
TBR® Inspection Report:
JIM SMITH - GEICO INSURANCE AGENT REVIEWS
Jade is an excellent Geico agent. She is pleasant, knowledgeable, efficient and explained all our options for coverage clearly and concisely. We were going to shop around for rates as adding a new teen driver would affect coverage with carrier we had, but after meeting with Jade, we decided to look no further due to great rates and a great agent.
Jade Weeks did an absolutely wonderful job of getting me a quote for my insurance. She was extremely nice and nice to talk to while figuring everything out. Also very informative with everything I needed to know. If you call this branch I would definitely reach out to Jade.
Geico quoted me $30 cheaper than every other insurance agency I spoke to. Jade was very professional and I was very grateful for her help. She made the insurance process very simple and stress free which isn't something I can say often about purchasing insurance.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.

Bill Reardon is a highly professional and dedicated State Farm insurance agent who has been serving clients in Tallahassee, Florida, for more than 26 years. He graduated from Eastern Illinois University and is known for his friendliness and efficiency when working with clients. Bill Reardon leads a team of experts who strive for excellence every day, and his office is conveniently located near the Centre of Tallahassee, formerly known as the Tallahassee Mall. Bill Reardon and his team at State Farm Insurance Agent aim to establish strong relationships with clients, which serves as the foundation for their ability to protect clients and their families from the risks of everyday life, recover from unexpected events, and achieve their dreams. They are committed to offering exceptional service and are pleased to provide free auto and homeowners insurance quotes to clients across Florida.
Specialty:
Contact:
Working Hours:
Sat & Evenings: By Appointment
Sun: Closed
TBR® Inspection Report:
BILL REARDON - STATE FARM INSURANCE AGENT REVIEWS
I have been a client of Bill Reardon’s for almost 20 years, but a State Farm client for almost 30 years (if not longer) and you couldn’t ask for a better agent. Bill’s staff; especially, Tyler is AMAZING! He goes above and beyond to help the customer! Great customer service by all. I would recommend my agent and his staff to anyone. Bill Reardon State Farm is the best in Tallahassee.
I have had such a great experience working with the team at State Farm. They make getting insurance an enjoyable experience. I would highly recommend them to anyone in the market for a change in provider. I would like to especially thank Chase Bohannon for his knowledge and attention to detail. He provided a high level of customer service. Thank you.
Tyler L did a great job today helping me. I was challenged with making a claim online and working with the third party to arrange my repair. Tyler went above and beyond to straighten everything out, checking on items and getting back to me promptly. He turned around a frustrating situation. Always great service here.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.