3 Best American Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI

Expert-recommended Top 3 American Restaurants in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. All of our american cuisines actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BLUE'S EGG

317 North 76th Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53213 Directions

Since 2010

Specialty:

Buen Dia Breakfast Burrito Steak and Eggs Guacamole On English Fritatta Ranchero Monkey Bread Daily Coffee Cake Crunk Monkey Hail Mary Eggs Blue's Classic Benedict Dubliner Benedict Chicken Chorizo Omelette Florentine Benedict Pulled Ham Omelette Roasted Mushroom Omelette Blue's Crab Cake Rooted Veggie-hash Blue's Hoppel Poppel House-made Corned Beef Hash The Blue Hammer Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich Bacon and Tomato Grilled Cheese Turkey Clubhouse Caesar Avocado Citrus Salad Loose Leaf Wedge Salad Roasted Beet Salad

"Blue's Egg serves American-style breakfast and lunch with flavors from around the world. The restaurant is located in Jennings village. Their chef created a modern menu that’s often called the best brunch in Milwaukee. The brunch includes classics like eggs, pancakes, and healthy grain bowls. They use high-quality, local ingredients whenever possible. Blue's Egg also hosts events like weddings, office parties, and birthdays. They customize each event to fit your needs and offer cocktail, buffet, and family-style meals. In the evening, the café becomes a more elegant dining space. They also offer take-out coffee and pastries in a stylish art deco setting. You can make a reservation, and the café welcomes kids and serves vegan options too. They also serve great cocktails. Their Hail Mary Eggs has 3 deviled eggs, house bloody mary mix, cherrywood bacon, and celery seed.

2026 Update: Blue's Egg also takes table reservations for parties up to 6 for seven days a week."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #314351

Price:

Eggs & Stuffs
2 Local Eggs: $14.50
Buen Dia Breakfast Burrito: $16.95
Steak & Eggs: $25.95
Guacamole On English: $15.95
Fritatta Ranchero: $17.95
Get 'Er-Movin
Monkey Bread: $4.95
Daily Coffee Cake: $4.95
Crunk Monkey: $5.95
Hail Mary Eggs: $7.95
Goodness Gracious
Blue'S Classic Benedict: $17.50
Dubliner Benedict: $17.50
Chicken Chorizo Omelette: $17.50
Florentine Benedict: $16.50
Pulled Ham Omelette: $18.25
Roasted Mushroom Omelette: $17.50
Classic Blue'S
Blue'S Crab Cake: $22.95
Rooted Veggie-Hash: $17.50
Blue'S Hoppel Poppel: $16.50
House-Made Corned Beef Hash: $18.50
On Bread
The Blue Hammer: $15.95
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Sandwich: $16.95
Bacon & Tomato Grilled Cheese: $14.95
Turkey Clubhouse: $15.95
Salad
Avocado Citrus Salad: $15.95
Roasted Beet Salad: $16.50

Contact:

(414) 299-3180

Mon-Sun: 7am - 2pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

HONEYPIE

2569 South Kinnickinnic Avenue,
Milwaukee, WI 53207 Directions

Since 2009

Specialty:

Roasted Airline Chicken Steak Frites Au Poivre Seasonal Risotto Macaroni and Cheese Seared Salmon Mushroom Stroganoff Chicken Biscuit Pie Friday Fish Fry Dinner Roasted Cauliflower Fried Brussels Sprouts Corn Riblets Honeypie Burger Grilled Cheese French Dip Mushroom Melt Steak Hoagie Fried Chicken Pork Belly Bahn Mi Friday Fish Fry Sandwich French Onion Soup Tomato Soup House Salad Grain Bowl Cobb Salad Salmon Nicoise Warm Kale Salad Midwestern Deviled Eggs Spinach Artichoke Dip Clockshadow Cheese Curds Truffle Fries Bakeshop Dinner Rolls

"Honeypie provides creative comfort food and tasty desserts made with local ingredients. They cook the way their grandparents did, using fresh, local meat, fruits, and veggies whenever they can even their pickles and pie crusts are made from scratch. They offer a great selection of drinks, including local beers, good liquor, and house-made cocktails. You can enjoy breakfast all day and a hearty weekend brunch with fresh buttermilk biscuits and house-infused Bloody Marys. The Honeypie Burger has ground brisket, American cheese, tomato, bacon, caramelized onions, secret sauce, a sunny-side-up egg, and a sesame bun. They offer gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian dishes. There’s free street parking, and the restaurant is kid-friendly. You can also try their Pan-Seared Chicken, which comes with jalapeño grits, fried green tomatoes, collard greens cooked with bacon, and Alabama-style sauce. You can also order your favorite dishes from home.

2026 Update: Honeypie provides catering orders for larger bakery orders for parties, weddings, and other events. Well-behaved dogs are welcome on the restaurant patio."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Brunch in 2016 by Milwaukee Magazine
Best Burgers in 2012 by Milwaukee Magazine
Best of Milwaukee in 2010 by Milwaukee Magazine
License #C073656

Price:

Entrees
Roasted Airline Chicken: $25
Steak Frites Au Poivre: $31
Seasonal Risotto: $26
Macaroni + Cheese: $19
Seared Salmon: $29
Mushroom Stroganoff: $22
Chicken Biscuit Pie: $20
Friday Fish Fry Dinner: $20
Seasonal Vegetables
Roasted Cauliflower: $10
Fried Brussels Sprouts: $13
Corn Riblets: $12
Sandwiches
Honeypie Burger: $19
Grilled Cheese: $17
French Dip: $18
Mushroom Melt: $16
Steak Hoagie: $24
Fried Chicken: $19
Pork Belly Bahn Mi: $18
Friday Fish Fry Sandwich: $18
Soups & Salads
French Onion Soup: $12
Tomato Soup: $6
House Salad: $13
Grain Bowl: $16
Cobb Salad: $19
Salmon Nicoise: $19
Warm Kale Salad: $16
Starters
Midwestern Deviled Eggs: $12
Spinach Artichoke Dip: $13
Clockshadow Cheese Curds: $13
Truffle Fries: $14
Bakeshop Dinner Rolls: $9

Discount:

Kids Eat Free with the Purchase of an Adult Meal

Receive a Free $10 Gift Card for Every $50 Gift Card Purchased

Contact:

(414) 489-7437

Mon-Sun: 9am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

STORY HILL BKC

5100 West Bluemound Road,
Milwaukee, WI 53208 Directions

Since 2014

Specialty:

Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls Crayfish Rangoons Twin Mushroom Hand Pies Chicken Meatball Escargot Rosemary Brie Pull-Apart Bread Quark and Bread Baked Tomato Bread Avocado Toast House Smoked Ham Cherry Wood Bacon Rustic Toast (Two Slices) Roasted Potatoes House-Made Sausage Patty Fresh Fruit and Berries Two Local Eggs Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie House-Made Cinnamon Roll Sausage Roll Dark Chocolate Chiffon Pie Smoked Yukon Au Gratin Barbecue Roasted Carrots Roasted Cauliflower Salad Roasted Asparagus Cedar Plank Steelhead Trout Puttanesca Pork Tenderloin Root Vegetable Agnolotti Butter Chicken Thighs

2026 Update: Story Hill BKC provides seasonal American dishes and weekend brunch, with retail wines, beers and spirits. The restaurant offers shared plates and seasonal vegetables. They have 5 parking place behind the building, and additional parking is available across the greenhouse. They can also take table reservations for parties of 6 or more. The restaurant has a private dining room that offers a warm and inviting atmosphere. They can accommodate parties of 8 to 12 guests. The restaurant's happy hour is a great place for drinks and casual meetups. Story Hill BKC offers online orders, cocktails and bar area.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #S100109

Price:

Taste
Fresh Baked Butter Flake Rolls: $9
Crayfish Rangoons: $17
Twin Mushroom Hand Pies: $18
Chicken Meatball: $9
Escargot: $19
Toasts
Quark And Bread: $9
Baked Tomato Bread: $10
Avocado Toast: $17
Sides
House Smoked Ham: $7.50
Cherry Wood Bacon: $7.50
Rustic Toast (Two Slices): $3.50
Roasted Potatoes: $7.50
House-Made Sausage Patty: $8.50
Fresh Fruit And Berries: $8.50
Two Local Eggs: $5.50
Pastries
Brandy Chocolate Chip Cookie: $4.50
House-Made Cinnamon Roll: $5.50
Sausage Roll: $5.50
Dark Chocolate Chiffon Pie: $11.00
Bindings
Smoked Yukon Au Gratin: $16
Barbecue Roasted Carrots: $17
Roasted Cauliflower Salad: $15
Roasted Asparagus: $17
Pass
Puttanesca Pork Tenderloin: $36
Root Vegetable Agnolotti: $33
Butter Chicken Thighs: $36
Beef Short Rib Gnocchi: $37.50

Discount:

$2 Off All Tap Beer and Cocktails, Plus $8 Glasses of Happy Red, White, Rosé, and Sparkling Wine

Contact:

(414) 539-4424

Tue-Fri: 11am - 2pmI5pm - 9pm
Sat & Sun: 9am - 2pmI5pm - 9pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: