Best Cakes in Milwaukee

Expert recommended Top 3 Cakes in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. All of our cake shops face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!


817 North 68th Street, Wauwatosa, Milwaukee, WI 53213 Directions

Since 1982

Simma’s Bakery is a small family-run bakery in Milwaukee committed to superior quality and taste. The walls of the bakery are now adorned with hundreds of awards and plaques that celebrate the endless achievements of the dream-inspired layout. Their bakers are committed to delivering the standard and genuinely superior products that Simma has become nationally known for. They use only the finest quality ingredients, ensure consistency in every order made, and concentrate their attention on every aspect. This tradition of a family-like work atmosphere is what makes it possible for Simma’s to offer these quality goods and services to its customers. Their traditional, award-winning cheesecake has a scrumptious bottom of chocolate cake, a thin layer of raspberry filling, and is lined with a chocolate ganache blanket. Simma’s has an array of “conventional” cakes to suit all palates. All of their cakes are tortes with multiple layers of cake and filling.

Chocolate, Vanilla Mousse, Genoise (Yellow), Espresso Mousse, Red Velvet, Banana, Poppyseed, Carrot, Birthday, Marble, Irish Cream Mousse, Chocolate Mousse, Lemon Mousse, Wedding Cakes, Hazelnut, Raspberry Mousse, Raspberry Chambord Mousse, Assorted Fillings: Butter Cream, Chocolate Butter Cream, Mocha Mousse & Cream Cheese Cakes

Wedding Wire Couple's Choice Award 2015 - Bride's Choice Awards 2009 to 2011

Price: Starts from $3.75

[email protected]


Tue - Fri 7:00 am - 6:00 pm
Sat 7:00 am - 4:00 pm
Sun 8:00 am - 12:00 am
Mon Closed

TBR® Inspection Report


7328 West Greenfield Avenue, West Allis, Milwaukee, WI 53214 Directions

Since 1977

Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop is home to Milwaukee's finest cake & pastry delivery service. Aggie's exquisite cake and original buttercream recipe have been impressing customers since 1977, and their reputation for consistency, beautiful designs, and incredible flavors is unparalleled. They're a family-owned and run the bakery, and it's their pleasure to make something exceptional for your upcoming celebration. Aggie's Bakery & Cake Shop is now under their third generation of family ownership, and her son Adam and daughter Ashley are actively engaged in the business. The bakery is also surrounded by a qualified staff of great people who shared their vision of making the finest quality baked goods. Their bakers help to fulfill your sweet tooth cravings and make delicious desserts for all your gatherings and celebrations. Aggie's Bakery products have since been distributed to all of Milwaukee County and parts of Waukesha.

Baby Shower, Edible Image and Picture, Cupcakes Mini Pastries and Sweet Tables, Holiday, Baked Goods, Cookie Boxes, Cheesecakes, Novelty, Smash, Seasonal, Bars, 3D and Custom, Kid's and Character, Cupcake, Pies, Sports, Quinceañera, Decorated Cookies, Two-Tier, Breakfast Pastries, Anniversary Cakes, Coffee & Donuts

Price: Starts from $12

[email protected]


Mon - Fri 7:00 am - 6:00 pm
Sat 7:00 am - 5:00 pm
Sun Closed

TBR® Inspection Report


825 North Jefferson Street, Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 2010

Classy Girl Cupcakes was set up by Erica Elia when she made cupcakes for her own wedding in 2009. An entrepreneur at heart, Erica knew how much she enjoyed baking and wanted a creative outlet to support her career further than being just a lawyer. They were such a success that friends and family asked her to bake for their own special occasions. She created a website, leased a kitchen, and in her first summer as a Milwaukee cupcake catering service, and Erica hosted 35 weddings. Classy Girl Cupcakes has since expanded from one to more than 25 employees, delivers all over southeastern Wisconsin, and caters hundreds of corporate events & weddings. In addition, it serves its retail customers, partners with several local businesses, and fills special orders, seven days a week. The bakery provides 25+ scratch-baked flavors daily, including cupcakes, jumbo filled cupcakes, truffles, cheesecake cupcakes and mousse parfaits. Gluten-free, vegan and dietary options are available.

Ghirardelli Chocolate, Peanut Butter Delight, Mini, Anniversary, Two Tiered Birthday, Grooms, Buttercream Wedding, Cheesecake, Almond, Jumbo Filled, Party Trays, Cupcakes: Milwaukee Wedding Cupcake Catering, Cupcake Push Pops, Truffles, Confetti, Cookies and Cream, Red Velvet, Vanilla, Vanilla Salted Caramel & Bananas Foster Cakes

Price: Starts from $3

[email protected]


Mon - Fri 8:00 am - 6:00 pm
Sat & Sun 10:00 am - 4:00 pm

TBR® Inspection Report