3 Best Bakeries in Fayetteville, NC

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bakeries in Fayetteville, North Carolina. All of our bakeries actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SUPERIOR BAKERY

2433 Hope Mills Road,
Fayetteville, NC 28304 Directions

Since 1956

Specialty:

Round Cakes Sheet Cakes Two Tier Cakes Carrot Cake Coconut Cake Strawberry Cake Pineapple Cake German Chocolate Cake Birthday Sprinkle Cake Chocolate Mint Bliss Cake Red Velvet Cake Lemon Cake Oreo Cake Golden Caramel Cake Funfetti Cake Donuts Fried Croissants Donut Holes Long Johns Chocolate Long Johns Eclairs Cannoli Crème Horns Cheese Pockets Cheese Stik Pastelillo Apple Fritter Honey Bun Brownie Cinnamon Raisin Bun Cinnamon Roll With Cream Cheese Turnovers Apple Strudel Butter Croissant Almond Croissant Filled Croissant Napoleon Baklava Kataifi Nut Rolls Cookies Wedding Cookies Almond Horn

Superior Bakery offers donuts, pastries, and other baked goods in a quaint, low-key location. The bakery has been a cherished local institution since its founding in 1956 by John S. Poulos. Superior Bakery remains in the family and is operated by their son Nicko Poulos. The Poulos family is grateful and honored to have served the community for over 60 years. All their bakery items are prepared with the best ingredients without synthetic and frozen products. Vegan and gluten-free bakery items are available at Superior Bakery. Whether you're a local resident or just visiting Fayetteville, Superior Bakery offers a delightful experience with its exceptional baked goods and genuine Southern hospitality. You must try their croissants, maple bars, maple bacon, fried croissants, glazed donuts, apple fritters, and glazed croissants.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0260783

Price:

4" Round $10.99
6" Round $21.99
8" Round $32.99
10" Round $67.99
14 Sheet $41.99
12 Sheet $58.99
Full Sheet $89.99
6" & 8" Two Tier Cake $84.99
Carrot $39.99
Coconut $39.99
Strawberry $39.99
Pineapple $39.99
German Chocolate $39.99
Birthday Sprinkle $39.99
Chocolate Mint Bliss $39.99
Red Velvet $39.99
Lemon $39.99
Oreo $39.99
Golden Caramel $39.99
Funfetti $39.99
Donutsfried Croissants $1.69
Donutsfried Croissants (½ Dozen) $9.39
Donutsfried Croissants (1 Dozen) $15.99
Donut Holes $1.39
Cookies $1.49
Jumbo Cookies $2.99
Wedding Cookies $2.99
Long Johns $2.09
Almond Horn $2.99
Chocolate Long John $2.19
Coconut Macaroon $2.99
Eclairs $3.79
Rice Krispie Treat $1.99
Cannoli $3.79
Lemon Bar $2.59
CrèMe Horns $2.29
Biscotti $1.49

Contact:

(910) 424-4242

Tue-Sat: 6am - 3pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BURNEY'S SWEETS & MORE

3319-B Raeford Road,
Fayetteville, NC 28303 Directions

Since 2016

Specialty:

Croissants Filled Croissants Glazed Croissants Mini Croissants Donuts Donut Holes Cakes Birthday Cakes Red Velvet Cake Chocolate Cake Lemon Italian Cream Cake Cheesecakes Pies Cupcakes Eclairs Cannoli Cream Horns Cinnamon Rolls Apple Fritters Muffins Macarons Cookies Brownies Cake Pops Danish Pastries Turnovers Bread Pudding Banana Pudding Tiramisu Chocolate Covered Strawberries Peanut Butter Balls Oreo Truffles Key Lime Bars Acai Bowls Coffee Specialty Desserts

"Burney's Sweets & More is a beloved local bakery known for creating fresh, handcrafted desserts that bring people together for every occasion. From decadent cakes and colorful cupcakes to fluffy donuts and their signature apple fritters, each treat is prepared from scratch using carefully selected ingredients and time-tested recipes. The bakery has built a strong reputation for delivering quality, flavor, and value, making sweet indulgences accessible to everyone. Burney's Sweets & MoreWith a welcoming atmosphere, friendly service, and a commitment to freshness.

2026 Update: Burney's Sweets & More continues to be a favorite destination for families, celebrations, and anyone craving homemade baked goods made with care."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #1213642

Price:

Mardi Gras Croissant $2.99
Mini Glazed $1.35
Apple Cinnamon Croissant $2.99
Chocolate Dipped Croissant $2.99
Flavor Of The Month $2.99
Biscoff Cookie Butter Buttercream $2.99
Buttercream Festive Croissant $2.99
Specialty Ast Dozen $30.99
Turtle Croissant $2.99
Filled Croissant $2.99
Mini Filled $1.45
Maple Bacon Croissant $2.99
Glazed Croissant $1.95
Dozen Chocolate Covered Strawberries Heart Box $32.99
King Cake $40.99
Love Stinks Cupcakes $3.99
Dozen Macaroons Heart Box $41.99
Dozen Peanut Butter Ballsoreo Truffles Heart Box $25.99
Dozen Mini Glazed Croissants Heart Box $21.99
Dozen Mixed Cake Pops Heart Box $39.99
Pumpkin Muffin $4.99
Rice Krispie Treats Decorated $2.99
Pumpkin Cheesecake $7.99
Apple Crisp Cake Donut $2.99
Cherry Pie $22.99
Pumpkin Pie $21.99
Apple Pie Dutch $22.99

Contact:

(910) 745-8975

Tue-Fri: 7am - 6pm
Sat: 7:30am - 2pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

CINNABON

419 Cross Creek Mall,
Fayetteville, NC 28303 Directions

Since 1985

Specialty:

Cinnamon Rolls Bonbites Minibons Caramel Pecanbon Cotton Candy Crunch Bon Center Of The Roll Cinnasweeties Cinnapacks Topped Bons Cinnapacks Quick Bites Pack Churros Lemonade Frozen Lemonade Cold Brew Frozen Coffee Flavored Cold Brew Mochalatta Chill Chillattas Raspberry Swirled Soda Cinnamon Roll Swirled Soda Cream Cheese Frosting Chocolate Sauce Caramel Topping Pecans

Cinnabon Fayetteville specializes in cinnamon rolls, baked goods, and specialty frozen beverages. They operate on a counter-service model, providing customers with a variety of cinnamon rolls, baked goods, and unique frozen drinks in a comfortable and inviting atmosphere. Their commitment is to offer delicious baked goods that are freshly made on-site daily, including bread, pastries, and confectionery. Cinnabon Fayetteville has expanded to include a growing list of wholesale clients such as bakeries, cafes, coffee shops, convenience stores, sandwich bars, and schools. They also provide catering options and the ability to ship Cinnabon products nationwide. Catering services are also available for weddings, corporate events, and birthday parties.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0326490

Price:

Lemonade $6.09
Frozen Lemonade $7.09
Cotton Candy Lemonade $5.29
Cotton Candy Chillatta $6.79
Cotton Candy Crunch Bon $6.29
Cinnamon Roll Swirled Soda $4.24
Raspberry Swirled Soda $4.24
Cold Brew Frozen Coffee $7.59
Chillattas $7.59
Minibon $5.29
Classic Roll $7.19
Coffee & Bon Bundle $1.00
Bonbites $5.89
Flavored Cold Brew $6.09
Mochalatta Chill $7.59
Caramel Pecanbon $6.29
Bonbites Cinnapacks $22.99
Topped Bons Cinnapacks $28.99
Minibon Cinnapacks $22.99
Classic Cinnapacks $22.99
Quick Bites Pack $22.99
Cinnasweeties $4.69
Center Of The Roll $7.19
Side Of Chocolate Sauce $1.79
Side Of Caramel Topping $1.79
Side Of Pecans $1.99
Side Of Cream Cheese Frosting $1.79

Discount:

Get a free 4-count of BonBites for signing up

Get a free 16 oz Cold Brew coffee on their birthday every year for members

Contact:

(910) 223-9139 (707) 253-1327

Mon-Thu: 11am - 8pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 9pm
Sun: 12pm - 6pm

TBR® Inspection Report: