3 Best Bakeries in Peoria, AZ

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bakeries in Peoria, Arizona. All of our bakeries actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

THE SICILIAN BAKER

9780 West Northern Avenue, Suite 1100,
Peoria, AZ 85345 Directions

Since 2020

Specialty:

Cannoli Dolce Duo Mini Cannoli Seasonal Cannoli Traditional Cannoli Cannoli Cream Amaretti Cookies Green Almond Cookies Italian Wedding Cookies Assorted Cookies Cassatina Chocolate Caramel Tart Flag Cookie Napoleon New York Cheesecake Nutella Lobster Tail Sfogliatelle Tiramisu Vanilla Lobster Tail Lobster Tail Italian Dessert Platter Americano Bakerato Cappuccino Caramel Hazelnut Latte Coffee Decaf Coffee Espresso Double Espresso Flat White Honey Nut Macchiato Latte Nutella Latte Raspberry White Mocha Salted Caramel Mocha

The Sicilian Baker Peoria dedicated team provides an array of freshly baked bread, rolls, sourdough, cakes, sandwiches, hot savories, buns, and doughnuts, all made to order. The bakery takes pride in curating a lovely collection of baked goods, each reflecting their commitment to quality and taste. Their cakes, handmade on the premises, feature seasonal fruits in their baked tarts, infusing a delightful burst of flavors. The bakery boasts a diverse selection of bread and cakes, each characterized by the highest quality standards. The Sicilian Baker Peoria has something to delight your taste buds, making it a go-to destination for all your bakery needs. The bakery has been serving the Phoenix and Chandler locations.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #23390434

Price:

Cannoli $10.75
Dolce Duo $8.50
Mini Cannoli
Seasonal Cannoli $9.50
Traditional Cannoli Starts From Per dozen $42.00
Traditional Cannoli Per dozen $81.50
Regular Cannoli Gift (12) Pack $79.00
Mini Cannoli Gift (20) Pack $65.00
Mini Cannoli Gift Pack (30) $90.00
12 Lb Amaretti Cookies $13.25
1 Lb Amaretti Cookies $26.50
12 Lb Green Almond Cookies $9.50
1 Lb Green Almond Cookies $19.25
12 Lb Italian Wedding Cookies $10.75
1 Lb Italian Wedding Cookies $21.50
1 Lb Assorted Cookies $21.50
2 Lb Assorted Cookies $43.25
Cassatina $7.75
Chocolate Caramel Tart $9.00
Flag Cookie $4.50
Napoleon $10.75
New York Cheesecake $15.50
Nutella Lobster Tail $9.50
Sfogliatelle Single $6.00
Tiramisu $15.50
Vanilla Lobster Tail $9.50
12 dozen Lobster Tail $54.00
1 dozen Lobster Tail $108.00

Discount:

SIGN UP FOR OUR EMAILS AND GET 10$ OFF YOUR NEXT MEAL

Contact:

(623) 471-5721

Sun-Thu: 9am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 9am - 10:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

NEW YORK WEST BAKERY & CAFE

10101 West Grand Avenue, Sun City,
Peoria, AZ 85351 Directions

Since 2000

Specialty:

Apple Turnover Sfogliatelle Chocolate Cigar Raspberry Cigar Elephant Ear Cherry Cheese Puff Apricot Cheese Puff Chocolate Cheese Puff Almond Horn Puff Cherry Turnover Cinnamon Crisp Piepockets Hamantash Cookies Fig Cookies Pretzel Cookies Oatmeal Cookies Rainbow Sprinkle Cookies Pfeffernüsse Cookies Peanut Butter Cookies Macaroons Wedding Cookies Chinese Chocolate Cookies Black and White Cookies Sugar-free Cookies Snickerdoodle Cookies Linzer Tart Cookies Butter Cookies Chocolate Chip Cookies Gluten-free Cookies Fruit Strips Meltaways Pies Tamales Pizza Dough Tortillas Jelly Honey Giardiniera

New York West Bakery is a team committed to baking superior-quality bread, pastries, cookies, and other baked goods. The shop is 2.4 miles from downtown Peoria. Their talented team of baking professionals uses high-quality ingredients to create products to enjoy individually or in groups and with family. They are committed to treating everyone with respect. They strive at NYW Bakery to send you home with one-of-a-kind desserts. Their pastry creations are not to be found elsewhere, and they pride themselves on being one-of-a-kind. Try their delicious cakes, cookies, and other delights at your next wedding or event. They offer on their online orders section of their website items that you're able to purchase and take home to enjoy with the family.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Apple Turnover $4.55
Sfogliatelle $6.43
Cigar Chocolate $4.55
Elephant Ear $4.55
Cherry Cheese Puff $4.55
Cigar Raspberry $4.55
Apricot Cheese Puff $4.55
Chocolate Cheese Puff $4.55
Almond Horn Puff $4.55
Cherry Turnover $4.55
Cinnamon Crisp $4.55
Piepocket Lemon $4.55
Piepocket Blueberry $4.55
Piepocket Pumpkin $4.55
Piepocket Keylime $4.55
Piepocket Apple $4.55
Piepocket Cherry $4.55
Hamantash Cookie $4.55
Fig Cookies (Per#) $24.68
Pretzel Cookie $4.55
Oatmeal Cookies $3.25
Rainbow Sprinkle Cookies $2.58
PfeffernüSse Per# Cookies $25.98
Peanut Butter Cookies $3.25
Macaroon Per# $24.68
Wedding Per# Cookies $23.33
Chinese Chocolate Cookie $3.25
Cookies 34 # $17.53
Cookies Tray #1 $23.33
Black N White Cookies $4.55
Cookies 14 # $5.85
Sugar-Free Per# Cookies $11.63

Contact:

(623) 583-7620

Mon-Sun: 7am - 3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

DONUTSVILLE

8275 W Lake Pleasant Parkway,
Peoria, AZ 85382 Directions

Since 2014

Specialty:

Donuts Cake Donuts Raised Donuts Specialty Donuts Filled Donuts Glazed Donuts Chocolate Frosted Donuts Old Fashioned Donuts Sprinkle Donuts Boston Cream Donuts Raspberry Filled Donuts Jelly Filled Donuts Apple Fritters Cinnamon Rolls Bear Claws Maple Bacon Bars Donut Holes Breakfast Sandwiches Breakfast Burritos Kolaches Croissant Sandwiches Bagel Sandwiches Ham Egg and Cheese Sandwiches Sausage Egg and Cheese Sandwiches Bacon Breakfast Burritos Sausage Breakfast Burritos Chorizo Breakfast Burritos Savory Kolaches Coffee Tea Iced Lattes Vanilla Lattes

"Donutsville is a casual and welcoming chain known for its modern takes on classic American cuisine and freshly baked pies. They also offer diverse bakery products, from cookies and bread to pastries and sandwiches. Their cakes are perfect for birthdays, anniversaries, wedding receptions, and many more. They have been providing delicious cakes and pastries to the Peoria community for many years. Donutsville is the perfect destination to enjoy mouthwatering pastries at an affordable price, making it an ideal choice for pastry enthusiasts. Their bakery items never contain any chemical additives or substances.

2026 Update: Donutsville is fully open and operating normally, serving up its popular fresh donuts and breakfast sandwiches daily via dine-in, takeout, and its convenient drive-thru."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #L19065894

Price:

Donut Holes (Half Dozen) $3.50
Donut Holes (Per Dozen) $5.99
Mixed Donuts (Half Dozen) $14.99
Apple Pie $14.50
Pumpkin Pie $14.50
Cherry Pie $16.50
Pecan Pie $15.50

Discount:

Buy 2, Get 1 Free on select items or surprise customers with a promotional gift valid for their next visit

Contact:

(623) 825-4406

Mon-Sun: 5am -2pm

TBR® Inspection Report: