3 Best Insurance Agents in Buffalo, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Insurance Agency in Buffalo, NY. All of our insurance agents actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

7+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

WILLOUGHBY INSURANCE

1523 Main Street,
Buffalo, NY 14209 Directions

Since 1952

Specialty:

Auto Home Renters Condo Umbrella Interactive Graphic Watercraft Classic Car Home and Auto (bundled) Individual Long-term Care Mobile Home Off-road Vehicle Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Pet Rental Property RV Secondary Home Short-term Rental Snowmobile Valuable Possessions and Yacht Insurance

" Willoughby Insurance is your dedicated insurance agency led by CEO Craig Willoughby. With 3 generations of family ownership, they continue to emphasize strong relationships and community-based service. The agency has been proudly serving Buffalo, Binghamton, Albany, Syracuse, and all of New York for over 70 years. Their team is dedicated to delivering their customers with the highest quality insurance services integrated at the lowest rates available. Their outstanding insurance agents will work with you to ensure that you get a tailored solution specifically to meet your needs. They provide accessible and personal insurance solutions. They are well-equipped to provide coverage that adapts to your needs. The agency offers unparalleled service and competitive quotes to clients throughout the entire State of New York. They have the knowledge and expertise to provide an insurance solution to every customer that offers value, security, and peace of mind.

2026 Highlights: Willoughby Insurance published several new educational articles covering rising insurance rates, contractor insurance, business insurance costs, workers’ compensation, and home-and-auto bundling."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #6517045

Contact:

(716) 885-8100 (888) 756-2600

Mon-Fri: 8am - 6pm
Sat: 9am - 12pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

MATTHEW DORR

COMPARION INSURANCE AGENCY
400 Essjay Road, Suite 300,
Buffalo, NY 14221 Directions

Since 2017

Specialty:

Car Insurance Home Insurance Umbrella Insurance Life Insurance Consulting Boat Insurance ATV Insurance Condo Insurance Motorcycle Insurance Pet Insurance Renters Insurance RV Insurance Snowmobile Insurance 401(k) Consulting Annuities Helping Select Coverage Limits Income Replacement and Asset Protection

" Matthew Dorr-Comparion Insurance Agency aims to provide you with quality coverage at a fair price. He is fluent in English and Spanish. He works personally with his customers to recommend coverage levels and choices tailored for each life stage. He utilizes his expertise in residential insurance to assist you with issues related to your current insurance provider, including coverage, rates, and enhancements. He promises to ensure you and your loved ones are comprehensively protected. The team specializes in reviewing Life, Home, and Auto insurance policies to find the best options for their clients across a wide range of carriers, both regional and national in size. You can contact them to get a quote.

2026 Highlights: Comparion has more than 2,000 agents across approximately 180 cities in 44 states, supported by a leadership team with more than 200 years of combined insurance experience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #BR-1469773

Contact:

(716) 809-9161

Mon-Fri: 8:30am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Joe Czaja - Buffalo, NY Insurance Agents - Portrait
Joe Czaja - Buffalo, NY Insurance Agents - Office Exterior Image
Joe Czaja - Buffalo, NY Insurance Agents - Office Interior Image
CALL EMAIL

JOE CZAJA

STATE FARM® INSURANCE AGENT
3557 Seneca Street, West Seneca,
Buffalo, NY 14224 Directions

Since 2008

Specialty:

Auto Homeowners Condo Renters Personal Articles Business Life Health Banking Mutual Funds Annuities Pet and Motorcycle Insurance

" Joe Czaja, State Farm® Insurance Agent, is the President of the agency. The agency is located 10.8 mile from Buffalo. The agency has proudly served Western New York for over 15 years. They can also help you with your seasonal needs, such as snowmobiles and other recreational vehicles. They can help with State-to-State transfers to relocate your auto insurance, homeowners insurance, or renters insurance. They aim to help people manage the risks of everyday life, recover from the unexpected, and realize their dreams. They provide a Personal Price Plan. They provide free personalized quotes for your auto insurance, homeowners insurance, renters insurance, and life insurance.

2026 Highlights: The agency provides online options for requesting quotes, filing claims, making payments, and obtaining insurance ID cards, while customers can also contact the team by phone or text."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #NY-LA-1736624

Contact:

(716) 674-3654

Mon-Thu: 9am - 5pm
Fri: 9am - 4pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: