3 Best Barbecue Restaurants in Columbus, OH

Expert-recommended Top 3 BBQ Restaurants in Columbus, Ohio. All of our barbecue restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

CITY BARBEQUE

2111 West Henderson Road,
Columbus, OH 43220 Directions

Since 1999

Specialty:

Pitmaster Pork Plate Not a Sloppy Joe Brisket Taco Turkey Taco Triple Que Taco Pork Taco Pulled Chicken Taco Two Meats Two Sides Three Meats Two Sides City Sampler the Motherload Family Pack Blue Ribbon Chips and Queso Fried Pickle Chip Basket 6 Wings 50 Wings Pitmaster Nachos Hush Puppy Basket Basket of Fresh-Cut Fries

City Barbeque and Catering has a warm, friendly atmosphere that makes it easy to enjoy their delicious food. They serve lunch and dinner and want to give you a great barbecue experience you’ll remember. Their menu includes award-winning BBQ, different sandwiches, fresh salads, handmade sides, and desserts. Everything is full of rich, tasty flavors. Their pitmasters smoke brisket for up to 18 hours, making it so tender and juicy that it feels like a true Texas barbecue experience. Their sides and cookies are made fresh every day in the restaurant to ensure they taste their best. For over 20 years, they’ve been successfully catering events, with a helpful team ready to meet customers’ needs. The restaurant is a great place to celebrate with family and friends. City Barbeque and Catering promises a tasty, satisfying meal whether you eat in or take food to go. They also support their team and local communities by giving back to charities and non-profits.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

SAMPLERS
Founder's Plate: $21.98
Pitmaster Pork Plate: $9.99
Two Meats, Two Sides: $18.99
Three Meats, Two Sides: $22.99
City Sampler: $30.99
The Motherload: $77.99
Family Pack: $39.98
SANDWICHES
Texas Pastrami Reuben: $9.99
Pastrami Sandwich: $9.99
Dirty Bird: $9.69
Pulled Pork: $9.98
LoLo's Pulled Pork: $10.48
Not A Sloppy Joe: $9.29
Pulled Chicken: $9.98
Nashville Hot Chicken: $10.48
More Cowbell: $9.99
Smoked Turkey: $9.98
Beef Brisket: $11.48
Texas-Style Sausage: $6.99
SMOKEHOUSE TACOS
Brisket Taco: $5.00
Turkey Taco: $4.00
Triple Que Taco: $4.00
Pork Taco: $4.00
Pulled Chicken Taco: $4.00
CHICKEN
6 Wings: $8.99
12 Wings: $16.99
18 Wings: $24.99
50 Wings: $64.99
Half Bird: $12.99
Breast/Wing: $9.99

Contact:

(614) 538-8890

Mon-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm
Sun: 11am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PECAN PENNY'S

113 East Main Street,
Columbus, OH 43215 Directions

Since 2018

Specialty:

Brisket Pulled Pork Smoked Whole Chicken St. Louis Ribs Smoked Wings Penny’s Salad Downtown Sampler Family Meal Smokehouse Burger Costanza Veggie Burger Mount Nacho Philly's Chili Soft Pretzel Sticks Chips + Dip Kool-Aid Pickles Smoked Pecans Wedge Salad Brisket Philly Smoked Chicken Sandy Chicago Beef Grilled Pineapple Pork Sandy

Pecan Penny's serves smoked meats and classic sides in a modern, welcoming space. This is a great place for business meetings, parties, family get-togethers, graduations, or birthdays. Their meats are dry-rubbed with a special spice mix and slow-cooked over pecan and oak wood, making the BBQ tender, juicy, and full of flavor. Be sure to try their tasty dishes and check out their drinks menu, which includes craft cocktails, craft beers, wine, and their popular OYO-spiked Cheerwine slushies that go perfectly with the BBQ. Pecan Penny's is open for lunch and dinner, and you can also order carryout to enjoy their food anywhere. They offer full-service dining, carryout, and catering every day of the week. Their Grilled Pineapple Pork Sandy is pulled pork topped with cilantro, grilled pineapple, and G-Daddy sauce, all served on a toasted brioche bun.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

CRAWFISH BOIL
Crawfish Ticket: $35.00
Back Porch Tea Single: $10.00
Back Porch Tea Double: $20.00
Haku Espresso Martini: $10.00
Draft Margarita: $9.00
Hazy Jane Draft: $6.00
Elvis Juice Draft: $6.00
Cold Beer Bucket: $30.00
FOOD
Costanza: $18.00
Smokehouse Burger: $17.00
Veggie Burger: $16.00
Cheeseburger: $12.00
Brisket: $14.00
Pulled Pork: $11.00
Smoked Chicken: $11.00
St. Louis Ribs: $12.00
Wings: $11.00
Downtown Sampler: $34.00
Family Meal: $40.00
Smoked Chicken Sandy: $16.50
Chicago Beef: $17.50
Grilled Pineapple Pork Sandy: $16.50
Pork It: $16.50
Brisket Philly: $18.50
Fried Foghorn: $16.50
KB’s Dog: $7.00
Chi-Town Dog: $8.00
Double Down Dog: $10.00
The Whitaker: $9.00
Ol’Faithful: $5.50
Ghost Dog: $8.00
SIDES
Baked Beans: $5.50
Cheesy Grits: $5.50
Coleslaw: $5.50

Contact:

(614) 826-0750

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm
Brunch:
Sat & Sun: 11am-3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

IRON GRILL BARBECUE & BREW

5295 North High Street,
Columbus, OH 43214 Directions

Since 2012

Specialty:

Hungry Man and German Bologna Breakfast Smoked Sausage and Eggs Country Fried Steak and Eggs Tour of The Farm Waffle and Eggs Iron Corned Beef and Hash BBQ Breakfast Platter Steak and Eggs Meat Lovers Breakfast Wrap Iron Breakfast Burrito and Bowl Biscuits and Gravy (with eggs) Buckeye Omelet Country and Western Omelet Spinach and Feta Omelet Porky and Cheese Lovers Omelet BBQ Omelet

Iron Grill Barbecue & Brew is known for slow-smoked meats and hand-pulled pork, served with a great selection of beers. They cook their BBQ slowly, giving barbecue lovers a delicious meal. Iron Grill focuses on cooking meats slowly with dry rubs to keep them flavorful and juicy. The restaurant is clean and welcoming, perfect for celebrating with friends and family. Their meats are smoked for 12 to 14 hours using hickory and other hardwoods, making them tender and easy to pull apart. You can enjoy tasty meals in a friendly setting or order party packages with fresh buns and sauces. They deliver online orders quickly. You can also enjoy drinks like tall drafts, domestic bottles, and appetizers at half price, making it a fun place to hang out. They also serve happy hour food and great cocktails. They provide plenty of parking options.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

APPETIZERS
Crispy Stuffed Carolina Rolls: $11.99
Crispy Stuffed Corned Beef Rolls: $12.99
Pulled Pork Nachos: $11.99
Fried Mac'n'Cheese Bites: $9.95
BBQ Quesadilla: $11.99
Hand Battered Onion Rings: $9.49
Chicken Tenders: $11.99
Fried Pickles: $8.99
Hand Battered Mushrooms: $9.49
SIDES
Tater Tots: $4.99
BBQ Beans: $4.99
Steamed Garlic Broccoli: $3.99
Rice: $3.99
Mac'n'Cheese: $4.99
Corn Pudding: $3.99
Corn Bread: $2.99
Sweet Potato Fries: $4.99
Fresh Fruit: $3.99
Onion Rings: $4.99
DESSERTS
Home Made Cheesecake: $7.99
Home Made Carrot Cake: $7.99
Home Made Chocolate Vake: $7.99
Home Made Bread Pudding: $7.99

Contact:

(614) 885-4744

Mon-Fri: 11am - 9pm
Sat: 8am - 9pm
Sun: 8am - 2pm

TBR® Inspection Report: