Best Italian Restaurant in Columbus, OH

Handpicked Top 3 Columbus Italian Restaurants. How do we actually find the most highly rated italian restaurant? Our 50-Point Inspection includes everything from checking reputation, history, complaints, local reviews, nearness, satisfaction, trust and cost to the general excellence. That's not all... businesses do not pay us to list them. You deserve only the best!


615 N High Street, Columbus, OH 43215

Since 2007

Sicilian Caponata, Calamari, Salami, Mozzarella, Parmesan Crusted Onions, Beef Carpaccio, Sausage, Salmon, Beet Salad, Caesar, Mushroom, Fettucine and Meatball, Spaghetti and Meatball, Sausage Rigatoni, Lasagne Alla Bolognese, Gnocchi Con Bolognese, Chicken Picatta, Risotto Del Giorno & Seared Salmon

Serves in two locations within Ohio - Try Gnocchi con bolognese $17

2015 Marcella's best Italian & happy hour

Price: $4-$24.50

Sun - Thu 4:00 pm - 10:00 pm Fri - Sat 4:00 pm - 12:00 am

Marcella's has grown to be a favorite for my wife and I. The food and service are both top notch, but the best part is the atmosphere! This is a great place to go for dinner with a group of friends or on a date
write a review


445 N High Street, Columbus, OH 43215

Since 1995

Mozzarella, Fritto Misto, Arancini, Bruschetta, Lobster Risotto, Antipasto Della Casa, Zuppa Pomodoro, Caesar, Martini Salad, Panzanella , Chicken Carbonara, Lasagna , Butternut Squash, Fettuccine, Shrimp Marinara, Parmesan, Marsala, Picatta, Ribeye, Tenderloin, Sea Scallops, Salmon, Milanese, Veal Chop & Tuna

Join them for wine night at martini modern Italian and enjoy half price wines by the bottle on Sunday nights

Price: $9-$49

Mon - Thu 4:00 pm -10:00 pm Fri - Sat 4:00 pm - 11:00 pm Sun 4:00 pm - 9:00 pm

Excellent chilled martinis. Beet salad was quite good and bread was served with dipping sauces. Wife had beef carpaccio which we really enjoyed. I had fettuccine with clams. Pastas was made there and the broth was excellent We had a limoncello strawberry dessert which we shared and thought quite tasty.Would definitely recommend this especially if going to theatre downtown.Oh and server (Janada?) was quite attentive as well. And the pricing was quite reasonable.
write a review


1368 Grandview Avenue, Columbus, OH 43212

Since 2005

Chef Crafted Italian Salumi, House Made Fresh Ricotta, Grilled House Made Sausage, House Made Fresh Mozzarella, Roasted Vegetable Board, Grilled Wagyu Flank, Pork Chop Milanese, Braised Lamb, Veal Chop Saltimbocca, Baked Ricotta Gnocchi, Smoked Chicken Ravioli, Lasagna Bolognese & House Made Sausage

Meatball Mondays: choice of any salad, fresh spaghetti, housemade meatballs & cannolis, 3 courses for $25 - Tuscan tapas Tuesdays: choice of 7 uniquely designed small plates ($4 each)

Certificate of Excellence 2016 winner from Trip advisor

Price: $8-$35

Mon - Sat 5.00 pm - 10.00 pm

This was our first visit here. Best food I have had in a long time. Everything was fresh and prepared to perfection. I went with our servers suggestion and had the goat cheese ravioli which was DELICIOUS! The pistachio gelato was amazing as well. Will definitely be repeat customers.
write a review