3 Best Caterers in Evansville, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Caterers in Evansville, Indiana. All of our caterers actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Just Rennie's LLC Catering - Evansville, IN Caterers
Just Rennie's LLC Catering - Evansville, IN Caterers
Just Rennie's LLC Catering - Evansville, IN Caterers
3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

JUST RENNIE'S LLC CATERING

100 Southeast 4th Street,
Evansville, IN 47708 Directions

Since 2003

Specialty:

Chicken Cordon Bleu Roasted Chicken Arroz Con Pollo Risotto With Chicken Chicken Fettuccini Alfredo Skirt Steak Churrasco With Chimichurri Pan Seared Sirloin Steak Prime Rib Shredded Beef Sprouts Beef Tenderloin Rib Eye Steak Prime Rib OCCASIONS: Weddings Corporate Events Bridal and Baby Showers Celebration Of Life/funerals Graduations Home Party Anniversary and Birthdays

"Just Rennie's LLC Catering is an exclusive caterer providing meals and desserts for a variety of their customers' events. Marla Rennie started the catering company. The catering company did so well that Marla's husband Doug Rennie left his position as Executive Chef at Victoria National Golf Club in Newburgh, Indiana, to help Marla grow the business. Their attentive staff is always available to ensure a seamless catering experience from start to finish. Just Rennie's Catering facility will need a couple of days to prepare your order. They offer a wide range of options, all prepared to order using the freshest ingredients, to simplify your catering needs for your celebration.

2026 Update: Just Rennie's LLC Catering is a family-owned business. The company has been providing catering services for 23 years. They provide 11 mouthwatering cookie flavors, and the cookies are baked fresh every day. Whether you are hosting at the old post office or grabbing a gift box to go, they deliver exceptional taste and service every time."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #2003082600120

Price:

Bbq Sauce $30
Gluten Free House Made Ground Beef Meatballs $30
Bacon-Wrapped Water Chestnuts $24
Vegetarian Or Ham Quichettes $24
French Brie On Toasted French Bread $24
Mushroom Vol-Au-Vent $24
Italian Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms $30
Gluten Free Italian Sausage Stuffed Mushrooms $30
Chicken Vol-Au-Vent $27
Gluten Free Italian Chicken Skewers $27
Asian Chicken Skewers $27
Gluten Free Bacon Wrapped Medjool Dates $27
Spicy Fried Chicken Bites $30
Gluten Free Fried Chicken Bites $30
Fried Chicken Sliders $42
Grilled Burger Sliders $42
Pulled Bbq Pork Sliders $42
Mini Beef Wellingtons $42
Gluten Free Hokkaido Scallops $54
Fresh Maryland Crab Cakes $54
6" Clear Plastic Plates $4
7" Clear Plastic Plates $5
9" Clear Plastic Plates $6
10" Clear Plastic Plates $8
7" Plates (Plastic China Style) $6
10" Plates (Plastic China Style) $10

Contact:

(812) 401-8098

Mon-Fri: 9am - 3pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

MILLER’S CATERING

10108 Schaeffer Road,
Evansville, IN 47720 Directions

Since 2016

Specialty:

Guacamole Shrimp Wonton Cups Chicken Cordon Bleu Pears With Blue Cheese and Prosciutto Deviled Eggs Creamy Chicken Piccata Lemon Parmesan Esto Chicken Chicken Marsala OCCASIONS: Wedding and Event Catering Corporate Events Get-Together Parties Wedding Rehearsal Dinners Receptions Graduation Parties and Backyard Events Birthday Parties Retirement Parties Company Shutdowns Funeral Catering Pharmaceutical Catering Picnic Catering

"Miller's Catering offers quality and wood-cooked food items with prime-selected and all-natural meats complemented by their unique recipes. Warren and Dianna Miller founded the catering company. Their talented chefs aim to turn every wedding day into a sensory feast and a true celebration of love. Their ongoing goal is to continually enhance their menus, allowing customers to select from diverse sides and meats to suit their preferences. Miller’s Catering is a dedicated team that can customize each event to your preferences, handling everything from securing the perfect venue to logistics like catering and entertainment. Their commitment to detail is reflected in every element of the event, including creative invitations and themed décor that help create a truly unforgettable celebration

2026 Update: Miller’s Catering has been providing catering services for 20 years. They provide BBQ catering services. They offer a range of customizable options, allowing you to tailor the menu to suit the specific needs and cultural preferences of your guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Pulled Pork $13.95
Smoked Chicken Breast $13.95
Smoked Kielbasa $14.95
Prime Beef Brisket $19.95
Pork Loin Chop $16.95
Ribs $19.95
Smoked Salmon $19.95
Loaded Baked Potato Bar $14.95
Miller’S Tex-Mex Bar $14.95
All Beef Burgers $13.95
All Beef Hotdogs $13.95
Organic Salad Mix $89.95
Millers Chips $25
Millers Cheese Sauce $39
Mac $2.95
Mashed Potatoes $2.95
Assorted Cookies $59.95
Brookies $59.95
Banana Pudding $59.95
Oreo Pudding $59.95
Tea Lemonade Ice And Cups $4.95

Discount:

Get a 5% Special Offer [USE CODE: THREEBESTRATED]

Contact:

(812) 454-2744

Open 24 Hours

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

QDOBA MEXICAN EATS

922 North Burkhardt Road, Suite 101,
Evansville, IN 47715 Directions

Since 1995

Specialty:

Fresca Salad Hot Bar Boxed Meals Drinks Aco Kit Party Packs OCCASIONS: Wedding Parties Birthday Parties House Warming Parties Baby Shower Functions

"QDOBA Mexican Eats provides a catering menu with popular meals like a customizable mexican food hot bar or a taco kit complete with sides like rice, beans, guac, and salsa. Their food is freshly prepared with high-quality ingredients delivered straight to your event. The caterers are experts in Fresca Salad featuring romaine lettuce with pico de gallo and pickled red onions, served with cotija cheese, tortilla strips, picante ranch, and citrus lime vinaigrette dressings on the side. They also offer rewards for delicious food. QDOBA Mexican Eats provides catering delivery for its customers. They will accept orders with a minimum of 24 hours' notice at most locations.

2026 Update: QDOBA Mexican Eats has been providing catering services for 31 years. They provide online orders for pickup or delivery to enjoy the Mexican food in town."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Chicken Queso Bowl $12.65
Cholula Hot & Sweet Chicken Bowl $13.25
Fajita Veggie Post-Workout Bowl $11.40
Quesabirria Burrito $14.70
Southwest Steak Burrito $13.85
Chicken Queso Burrito $12.65
Steak Fajita Quesadilla $13.85
Quesabirria Quesadilla $14.70
Smoky Chicken Cheese-Crusted Quesadilla $14.35
Mega Burrito 10-Pack $123
Drinks By The Gallon $12.30
Citrus Lime Chicken Salad $13.50
Street Style Chicken Tacos $12.65
Street Style Pork Carnitas Tacos $13.25
Quesadilla Kids Meal $8.10
3-Cheese Nachos Kids Meal $8.10
Salsa & Chips $4.90
Hand-Crafted Guacamole & Chips $6.10
Side Of Guacamole $2.50
Side Of 3-Cheese Queso $2.50
Side Of Brown Rice $2.50
Side Of Queso Diablo $2.50
Side Of Cilantro Lime Rice $2.50
Side Of Black Beans $2.50
Cup Of Tortilla Soup $4.90

Contact:

(888) 736-2224 (812) 401-0800

Mon-Sat: 10:30am - 9pm
Sun: 10:30am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report: