Here’s The Deal: Piece of Cake is an Award-winning and locally-owned cake shop in Evansville. Cate and Kristi wanted to share their family recipes with their hometown. The cake shop has been creating decadent wedding cakes for Evansville couples for over 26 years. They are known for their delicious special occasion cakes, beautiful wedding cakes, made-from-scratch cookies, and treats. The cake shop specializes in making cakes that look as good as they taste. Piece of Cake also makes gift baskets and party trays filled with cookies made from family recipes. They use the same quality ingredients that have made them a favorite in Evansville. The cake shop also serves micro-roasted whole-bean drip coffee and lattes. They also make party trays, gift baskets, handmade candy, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and more. Piece of Cake has cakes for birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, and other events. Gluten-free option is also available at Piece of Cake.
3 Best Cakes in Evansville, IN
Expert recommended Top 3 Cakes in Evansville, Indiana. All of our cake shops actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!
TOP 3 PIECE OF CAKE REVIEWS
We needed a last minute wedding cake for our small intimate wedding and Piece of Cake helped us out. We made an appointment and picked out our flavor and style of cake same day. They also delivered our cake on time on a Saturday and put our last minute decorations on the cake at our house. We forgot to mention we needed something to transport our cake in so they left and came back with a box to transfer our cake, which was super helpful and appreciated. The staff was easy to work with and our cake turned out delicious and beautiful-just like we wanted. Thank you for delivering our yummy cake and thank you for the excellent customer service.
I ordered a cake for my grandson's baptism. The cake went over very well. Everyone loved it. Top notch customer service. We were looking for someone who could make a lamb cake. The owner reached out to me personally with several designs to choose from. Exceeded my expectations on every level. Thank you from the bottom of my heart for going above and beyond for our special occasion.
From my wedding cake to baby shower to birthdays I have always been blown away. This is the first bakery I have ordered from and I wont go anywhere else. Their cheesecake is amazing! The cakes are light with a balanced flavor and the icing is perfect and not overly sweet so you can enjoy the flavor the cake.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.
Here’s The Deal: GaylaCake is a custom cake bakery in Evansville, Indiana. The cake shop is a local bakery owned by Gayla Bell. She and her team specialize in custom-decorated cakes and other homemade desserts. The cake shop takes pride in not using chemical flavors or additives in their delicious creations, ensuring exceptional quality. GaylaCake is a lively bakery that makes unique and enchanting cakes and cupcakes, offering options for vegans and those who need gluten-free treats. Each day, they offer a rotating variety of delicious cupcake flavors, plus some favorites you can get. They change their cake menu yearly to provide new flavor combinations and seasonal ingredients and return old favorites. They are dedicated to providing every customer with outstanding customer service. You can also choose your flavors and fillings in the cakes.
Specialty:
$Price:
8" Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake - $13.20
Contact:
Working Hours:
Thu-Tue: Closed
TBR® Inspection Report:
TOP 3 GAYLACAKE REVIEWS
I was in a last minute pinch of needing cupcakes for my daughter's birthday party. I reached out to Gayla 2 days before the party, not expecting her to be able to help. To my surprise, I was able to get the cupcakes, which were delicious by the way! Gayla went out of her way to help me out! This isn't the first time I have ordered from GaylaCake, and I know for sure know that it won't be my last.
The cake I got from Gayla was perfect. Everything my daughter asked for on her birthday cake. Handcrafted mermaid on top of the cake just like she asked for. It was also the first confetti cake I've tasted that wasn't dried out and still delicious. Gayla crushed it.
Had the opportunity to try Gayla cupcakes today and was extremely pleased. Absolutely great tasting. Shared some with my fellow employees and clients, everyone had the same impression. Loved everything about them! Thank you.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.
Here’s The Deal: Bea Sweet Treats is a well-known cake shop in Evansville. The cake shop was founded by the mother-daughter team, Stephanie and Ashley. Bea Sweet Treats is located at 11. 3 miles distance from downtown Evansville. They are so excited to be in business together to create beautiful and tasty treats for special events and occasions in your life. The cake shop offers everything from cakes to breakfast cinnamon rolls. They specialize in all-occasion specialty cakes, wedding cakes, cinnamon rolls, and a large variety of pastries. They also offer a Multi-purpose room that can be rented out for parties, showers, and more. Bea Sweet Treats make their wedding cakes so perfectly. They help pin some beautiful flowers and place their cake topper so it looks amazing. They also offer Macarons and Dessert.
Specialty:
$Price:
Cupcakes Prices Start at $30 per Dozen
Cookie Cakes Prices Start at $12
BIRTHDAY BASH
6 inch: $52
8 inch: $62
6 inch: $50
8 inch: $60
CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH
6 inch: $55
8 inch: $65
CHOCOLATE FUDGE RASPBERRY CHOCOLATE
6 inch: $52
8 inch: $62
BUTTER BLACKBERRY STREUSEL BUTTER CAKE
6 inch: $52
8 inch: $62
COCONUT CREAM
6 inch: $52
8 inch: $62
Contact:
Working Hours:
Sat: 7am - 2:30pm
Mon & Sun: Closed
TBR® Inspection Report:
TOP 3 BEA SWEET TREATS REVIEWS
Bea Sweet Treats made the cake and cupcakes for our wedding. I cannot say enough positive things about these ladies! They are so sweet and easy to work with. Our cake was absolutely breathtaking, and our cupcakes were so delicious! They were even able to make a batch of vegan cupcakes for my niece who has a dairy allergy. We had people asking if they could take some of the extras home! Their attention to detail and friendliness will ensure that we will ask them to make any other cakes we will need in the future.
Ashley and Stephanie did my wedding cake and were absolutely wonderful to work with! They did exactly what I asked for and were incredibly accommodating. The cake turned out absolutely beautiful and delicious! If you haven’t tried their cake or any of their goodies yet you are missing out! I promise you will love Bea Sweet Treats.
I ordered a cake from Bea Sweet and I’m extremely satisfied. I come from NJ so I have high standards for desserts and I was blown away with their Red velvet cake. So delicious. Will definitely order again.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.