3 Best Cakes in Evansville, IN

“Piece of Cake is an award-winning and locally owned cake shop that offers delicious special occasion cakes, beautiful wedding cakes, made-from-scratch cookies, and treats. Cate and Kristi wanted to share their family recipes with their hometown. The cake shop has been making decadent wedding cakes for Evansville couples for over 27 years. They are known for their delicious special occasion cakes, beautiful wedding cakes, made-from-scratch cookies, and treats. Piece of Cake also makes gift baskets and party trays filled with cookies made from family recipes. They use the same quality ingredients that have made them a favorite in Evansville. The cake shop also serves micro-roasted whole-bean drip coffee and lattes. Piece of Cake also makes whole pies to order, gourmet gift baskets, and dog treats that are good for your pup.”

Read more

“GaylaCake makes unique and enchanting cakes and cupcakes. The cake shop is a local bakery owned by Gayla Bell. She and her team specialize in custom-decorated cakes and other homemade desserts. The cake shop takes pride in not using chemical flavors or additives in its delicious creations, ensuring exceptional quality. GaylaCake offers a rotating variety of delicious cupcake flavors, plus some favorites you can get. They change their cake menu yearly to provide new flavor combinations and seasonal ingredients and return old favorites. They are dedicated to providing every customer with outstanding customer service. GaylaCake also offers milk-free cakes.”

Read more

“Bea Sweet Treats specializes in all-occasion specialty cakes, wedding cakes, cinnamon rolls, and a large variety of pastries. The cake shop was founded by the mother-daughter team, Stephanie and Ashley. Bea Sweet Treats is located 11.3 miles from downtown Evansville. They are so excited to be in business together to create beautiful and tasty treats for special events and occasions in your life. Bea Sweet Treats also offers a multi-purpose room that can be rented out for parties, showers, and more. Bea Sweet Treats makes their wedding cakes perfectly. The cake shop also offers a multi-purpose room that can be rented out for parties and showers. Bea Sweet Treats also offers macarons and desserts.”

Read more