3 Best Cakes in Evansville, IN

Piece of Cake is a locally-owned and award-winning cake shop that has delighted customers since its establishment in 1998. Founded by two talented sisters, Cate and Kristi, who possess a deep passion for baking and a keen artistic sense, the shop aims to share their family's cherished recipes with their hometown. Renowned for their delectable special occasion cakes, stunning wedding cakes, homemade cookies, and delectable treats, Piece of Cake remains committed to using high-quality ingredients that have earned them a devoted following in Evansville. As a bonus, the shop also serves micro-roasted whole-bean drip coffee and lattes to accompany their delectable offerings. Additionally, Piece of Cake caters to various needs, offering party trays, gift baskets, handmade candies, chocolate-dipped pretzels, and more. Whether you're celebrating a birthday, anniversary, holiday, or any other special event, Piece of Cake has the perfect cake. They also provide a gluten-free option, ensuring everyone can indulge in their mouthwatering creations.

GaylaCake is a vibrant bakery specializing in crafting enchanting and unique cakes and cupcakes, catering to individuals with various dietary preferences, including vegans and gluten-free. Gayla, the owner of the cake shop, oversees the operation with passion and creativity. Each day, their talented team prepares all products from scratch, using only the finest ingredients. This dedication ensures a consistently superior experience for their cherished customers. Notably, GaylaCake takes pride in refraining from using chemical flavors and additives in its delightful creations, upholding their commitment to exceptional quality. Furthermore, all desserts served at their location are prepared without eggs and dairy, making them vegan-friendly. Additionally, their sprinkles are carefully selected to be free from confectioners' glaze, aligning with their dedication to providing high-quality and inclusive treats for all. GaylaCake is a vibrant bakery specializing in crafting enchanting and unique cakes and cupcakes, catering to individuals with various dietary preferences, including vegans and gluten-free. Gayla, the owner of the cake shop, oversees the operation with passion and creativity. Each day, their talented team prepares all products from scratch, using only the finest ingredients. This dedication ensures a consistently superior experience for their cherished customers. Notably, GaylaCake takes pride in refraining from using chemical flavors and additives in its delightful creations, upholding their commitment to exceptional quality. Furthermore, all desserts served at their location are prepared without eggs and dairy, making them vegan-friendly. Additionally, their sprinkles are carefully selected to be free from confectioners' glaze, aligning with their dedication to providing high-quality and inclusive treats for all.

Bea Sweet Treats is a renowned cake shop that has gained popularity in the area. Founded by the mother-daughter duo Stephanie and Ashley, they are thrilled to work together, creating delectable and visually appealing treats for special events and memorable occasions. The shop offers a wide range of delicious options, ranging from cakes to breakfast cinnamon rolls. They specialize in crafting specialty cakes for all occasions, including weddings and a diverse selection of pastries. Additionally, they provide a Multi-purpose room that can be rented for parties, showers, and other gatherings. Bea Sweet Treats is highly regarded for their exceptional wedding cakes, which are visually stunning and delicious. Their process is straightforward, ensuring a seamless experience, with careful attention paid to pinning beautiful flowers and placing the cake topper for a fantastic presentation. Macarons and desserts are also among the delightful offerings available. Situated just 11.3 miles from downtown Evansville, Bea Sweet Treats is conveniently located to serve the community.