ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED CAPE CORAL, FL PIZZA PLACES

3 Best Pizza Places in Cape Coral, FL

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Cape Coral, Florida. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Nice Guys Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Menu Image
Nice Guys Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Restaurant Exterior Image
Nice Guys Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Food Image
Best Pizza Places in Cape Coral FL - Nice Guys Pizza video
11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

NICE GUYS PIZZA

(4.9 Score)
1404 Cape Coral Parkway East,
Cape Coral, FL 33904 Directions

Since 2013

Specialities:

✓Hot Honey ✓My Cousin Vinny ✓The Heart Attack ✓Street Corn Named Desire ✓Big Mick ✓Some Like It Hot ✓Final Desecration ✓Black Gold ✓Washington Carver ✓General Tso's ✓The Cuban ✓Chicken and Waffles ✓Chicken Pizza Masala ✓Burrizza ✓Chicken and Waffles Pizza ✓Vegan Truffle Shuffle ✓The American Pie ✓Dank Nuggets ✓Cajun Honey Butter BBQ ✓Garlic Parm ✓Deep Fried Oreos

“Nice Guys Pizza is a cozy, no-frills bar offering pizza and pub food, plus craft beer and weekly trivia nights. They prepare pizza dough using fresh ingredients. They use organic ingredients and offer many vegetarian and vegan choices for everyone to enjoy. You can customize your pizza with their variety of toppings. Join them for Trivia Night on Wednesday, April 30th, from 8 PM to 9:30 PM, and don't miss 20% off all bombers every Thursday from 4 PM to 2 AM starting May 1st. Nice Guys Pizza offers a full-service bar with an extensive cocktail menu and a wide selection of beers. The restaurant offers happy hour menus.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #BEV4602308

Menu:

PIZZA:
Truffle Shuffle $19.00
Hot Honey $19.00
My Cousin Vinny $19.00
The Heart Attack $19.00
Street Corn Named Desire $19.00
Big Mick $19.00
Some Like It Hot $19.00
Final Desecration $19.00
Black Gold $19.00
Washington Carver $19.00
General Tso'S $19.00
The Cuban $19.00
Chicken And Waffles $19.00
Don'T Worry Brie Happy $19.00
Chicken Pizza Masala $19.00
Burrizza $19.00
BUILD YOUR OWN PIZZA:
Small $13.00
Medium $15.00
Large $17.00
STARTERS:
Scooby Snacks $9.00
Truffle Fries $3.00
Garlic Knots $10.80
Sauce Flight $2.00
Dank Nugz $15.50
Wings $23.50
Corn Dogs (2) $12.00
Cheese Styxx $11.00
Stinky Buns 2.0 $17.00
House Salad $9.00
Man Salad $14.00
BYO Pizza $13.00
Toppings $2.75
Drizzles $2.50
Starters & Sweets:
Vegan Garlic Knots $7.00

Discount:

20% Off all Bombers every Thursday

Contact:

(239) 549-7542

Tue-Thu & Sun: 4pm - 12am
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 2am
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Menu Image
Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Restaurant Exterior Image
Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Dish Image
CALL EMAIL

OVERTIME PIZZERIA & SPORTS PUB

(4.8 Score)
1708 Cape Coral Parkway West,
Cape Coral, FL 33914 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

✓Specialty Pies ✓Vegetarian ✓Shrimp Fra Diavolo ✓Buffalo Chicken ✓BBQ Chicken ✓Greek ✓Meat Lovers ✓Spinach and Ricotta ✓Lil' Philly ✓Hawaiian Classic ✓Chicken BLT ✓Deluxe ✓Margherita ✓Eggplant Florentine and Cut NY Strip ✓Chicken Marsala ✓Baked Penne ✓Chicken Parmesan ✓Eggplant Parmesan ✓BBQ Ribs ✓Citrus-glazed Salmon ✓Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo ✓Cajun Shrimp Alfredo ✓Penne Alla Vodka

"Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub is a perfect hangout place for pizza, calzones, Italian and American tavern fare, plus sports on TV. The restaurant is a family-friendly restaurant with an elegant dining atmosphere. You can enjoy their Shrimp Fra Diavolo, which features shrimp, basil, mozzarella, and a spicy roasted garlic plum tomato sauce. Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub offers daily specials menus with reasonable prices. Their upcoming events are Cinco de Mayo, Mother's Day, National Bourbon Day, Father's Day, and National Martini Day. The restaurant is the perfect place to celebrate a private party with family and friends.

2026 Highlights: Each event is bespoke to your tastes and needs to offer the best experience possible for you and your guests."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #P15000043108

Menu:

PIZZAS:
Large Pizza $11.95
Small Pizza $7.95
Cauliflower Crust Pizza $10.95
Margherita Pizza $18.95
Vegetarian Pizza $18.95
Buffalo Chicken Pizza $18.95
Meat Lovers Pizza $18.95
Spinach & Ricotta Pizza $18.95
Deluxe Pizza $18.95
Eggplant Florentine Pizza $18.95
Hawaiian Pizza $18.95
Philly Pizza $18.95
APPETIZERS:
Wings $15.45
Chicken Tender Basket $14.95
Boneless Wings $14.95
Mozzarella Sticks $10.45
Meatball Trio $8.95
Pepperoni Rolls $12.95
Potato Skins $13.95
Onion Rings $6.00
Bacon Cheese Fries $13.45
Nachos $14.45
Pretzel Bites $10.95
Calamari $15.95
Chicken Quesadilla $15.45
SALADS:
Classic Caesar $11.95
Overtime'S House $10.95
Wedge Salad $11.45
SANDWICHES:
Classic BLT $12.95
Philly Cheese Steak $16.95
Reuben Sandwich $15.45

Contact:

(239) 541-3367 (239) 984-2586

Sun-Thu: 11am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 11pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Chicago Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Menu Image
Chicago Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Restaurant Exterior Image
Chicago Pizza - Cape Coral, FL Pizza Places - Dish Image
Best Pizza Places in Cape Coral FL - Chicago Pizza video
7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

CHICAGO PIZZA

(4.8 Score)
1341 SouthEast 47th Terrace,
Cape Coral, FL 33904 Directions

Since 1987

Specialities:

✓Chicago White Out ✓Hawaiian ✓Meat ✓Veggie ✓Chicago ✓Pepperoni Lover’s ✓Gluten-free ✓Cauliflower Crust ✓Build Your Own ✓Deluxe Deep Dish Pizza ✓Spaghetti or Penne ✓Baked Penne ✓Lasagna ✓Chicken Parmigiana ✓Eggplant Parmigiana ✓Chicken Piccata ✓Stuffed Shells ✓Chicago Mary ✓Da Linebacker ✓Italian Sausage ✓Buffalo Chicken ✓Chicago Italian Beef ✓Bruschetta ✓Buffalo Strips ✓Midway Monster Dog

"Chicago Pizza is a family-owned and operated pizza restaurant that offers a variety of pizzas, sandwiches, and other comfort food. The restaurant has been serving customers for over 30 years. They specialize in providing you with the Midwest charm of Chicago right here in Florida with their Chicago-style pizza options. If you’re a fan of Fontanini Sausage, Italian Beefs, Chicago Dogs, and incredibly flavorful, made-to-order pizza, this is the place for you. At Chicago Pizza, you can enjoy their special cocktails, which include the Chicago Mary, 'Da Linebacker,' Wrigley-Rita, and Windy City Tea. The restaurant provides happy hour menus and also offers dine-in, take-out, and delivery options.

2026 Highlights: They are proud to be a local gathering place where families, friends, and sports fans come together to enjoy great food, cold drinks, and all the big games."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #BEV4606556

Menu:

PIZZAS:
Thin Crust $14.00
Deep Dish $18.00
Chicago $19.00
Veggie $19.00
Meat $19.00
Pepperoni Lover'S $17.00
Hawaiian $18.00
Chicago White Out $17.00
Calzones & Stromboli:
Calzone $13.00
Stromboli $13.00
EntréEs:
Stuffed Shells $16.00
Chicken Piccata $18.00
Chicken Parmigiana $17.00
Eggplant Parmigiana $17.00
SALADS:
Garden Salad $10.00
Chef Salad $12.00
Greek $12.00
Caprese $12.00
Caesar $12.00
Antipasti Plate $16.00
SANDWICHES:
Combo $11.00
Italian Sausage $11.00
Italian Sub (Hot Or Cold) $9.50
Tuna $9.00
Meatball Sub $10.00
Chicken Parmigiana $11.00
Buffalo Chicken $10.00
Chicago Italian Beef $11.00
SIDE ORDERS:
3 Meatballs In Marinara $6.00
Fontanni Sweet Italian Sausage $6.00

Contact:

(239) 945-2262

Mon: 11am - 8pm
Tue-Fri: 11am - 9pm
Sat: 12pm - 9pm
Sun: 12pm - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Chicago Pizza

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

NICE GUYS PIZZA REVIEWS

I had an excellent experience. Great vibe, the pizza was awesome and the vegan menu is super cool. Vegan pepperoni with onion and pineapple. If I lived near this place, it would easily be a weekly haunt for me. I highly recommend trying this place.

Nice Guys is a staple for us. We love to try all the pizzas. The atmosphere is busy. There are only high tables, which is hard for wheelchair users, the outdoor area gets better and better with plenty of seating.

Huge surprise finding this place. Loved it. Pizza is high quality and holds up very well as leftover. Interior of the place is great with rock and metal music. Highly recommend.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

OVERTIME PIZZERIA & SPORTS PUB REVIEWS

We stopped at Overtime Pizzeria & Sports Pub to get some pizza for dinner. On Tuesdays they have specials on martinis. Our pizzas came out hot and fresh from the kitchen. Our server was friendly and quick to help with what we needed. The atmosphere is very much a sports bar, but it is fun and there are TVs everywhere.

Excellent experience! Our server Em was so polite and friendly. Food was delicious!!! We loved it all! Cauliflower pizza crust was great and I’m glad they offered it as we needed a gluten free option. Next time we are in the area, we will visit again.

Our first visit and we were impressed. A great sports bar atmosphere , the food is excellant and the sevice was spectacular...thank you Colby.

CHICAGO PIZZA REVIEWS

First time here. Nice little local vibe. Great service. My waitress “Sky” was fantastic. They didn’t have any deep dish pizza which was my reason for coming. I’m not a fan of thin crust. Sky has them stack two thin crusts dough to make it thicker. The meatballs were cold, the pizza was good not great. The caprese was good. Would still like to try the deep dish sometime.

In town from NJ visiting family in the area. Stopped in for dinner and really enjoyed it here. Being from NJ, we have great pizza here so there was a high bar set. We ordered a Chicago deep dish and Chicago thin crust. Soooo good!! I enjoyed leftovers for breakfast the next morning.

This Chicago deep dish pizza was very dry and overcooked, with not much flavor at all. I gave it a 3 stars because the wings were fairly better than the pizza.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

NICE GUYS PIZZA Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Experience: 8
Social Media: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Business Hours: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 5.6K: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Video: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

OVERTIME PIZZERIA & SPORTS PUB Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Experience: 8
Acknowledgments: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 3.1K: 9
Social Media: 9
Business Hours: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Responsiveness: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Video: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

CHICAGO PIZZA Total Inspection Points: 114/120
Acknowledgments: 8
Reviews Study: 8
Reviews Accuracy of 3.7K: 9
Social Media: 9
Business Hours: 10
Complete Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Review Analysis: 10
Video: 10