ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED LEXINGTON, KY PIZZA PLACES

3 Best Pizza Places in Lexington, KY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Lexington, Kentucky. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Goodfellas Pizzeria - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Goodfellas Pizzeria - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Best Pizza Places in Lexington KY - Goodfellas Pizzeria video
11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

GOODFELLAS PIZZERIA

(4.9 Score)
1228 Manchester Street,
Lexington, KY 40504 Directions

Since 2006

Specialty:

✓ Goodfella ✓ Wiseguy ✓ The Don ✓ Tommy two Times ✓ The Vinny ✓ The Boss ✓ Taste Of Naples ✓ Nonna's Pie ✓ Paulie's Favorite ✓ The Bootlegger ✓ Fuhgetaboutit ✓ Al Pacino ✓ Zeroyale ✓ 16 Half and Half Pie ✓ 22 Half and Half Pie ✓ Four Roses Oeso ✓ Blanton's Gold pity The Fool ✓ Woodford Reserve Masters Classic Malt ✓ Upland Champagne Velvet ✓ Blue Stallion Dunkel ✓ Emerald City ✓ Piggyback Spritz ✓ Carolina Dreamin' ✓ Eagle Rare 17yr Package ✓ Holiday Manhattan Kit ✓ Corazon Extra Añejo Bp

"Goodfellas Pizzeria Distillery is a chain pizza restaurant known for its New York-style pies and wide selection of bourbon. They use fresh and seasonal ingredients to craft their pizzas. They make pizza dough by mixing a quality flour with water and allowing it to ferment for several hours. Goodfellas Pizzeria Distillery provides a lunch and dinner menu for dine-in, pick-up, and delivery. The restaurant offers private dining options for special occasions. The restaurant also offers gluten-free pizza options. The restaurant has branches in Louisville, Covington, Cincinnati, Indianapolis, Bloomington, and Chattanooga.

2026 Update: Their authentic, hand-tossed pizza has been a local favorite, consistently voted "the best" by the communities they serve. They offer gift cards, happy hour foods, and great cocktails to guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #22934

Price:

Dirty Little Secret: $9.00
Nice Guys Finish Last: $9.00
Calmer Seas: $8.00
Nawgroni: $9.00
Zeroyale: $8.00
San Pellegrino Pompelmo: $6.00
San Pellegrino Aranciata Rossa: $6.00
Rosie Red: $10.00
Agent Orange: $7.00
Berry The Evidence: $8.00
Red Nose: $7.00
Winter Drift: $6.00
Me Espresso: $8.00
Nah-Rajillo: $9.00
Alcohol Free Aperol Spritz: $12.00
Phoney Negroni: $11.00
Amaro Falso: $11.00
Corazon Reposado - Eagle Rare: $35.00
High West Campfire Package: $75.00
1792 Mr. Pink Retail: $60.00
Weller Full Proof Package: $125.00
Sazerac Rye Busgy: $45.00
Corazon Extra Anjeo Bp: $65.00
Elijah Craig Wiseguy Pick: $75.00
Four Roses Bp: $90.00
Little Book Chapters Sevan : $225.00
Bookers 2016 Le Rye: $2,000.00
Knob Creek 18yr Package: $180.00
Charter Oak Finest Package: $80.00

Discount:

Enjoy 50% Off All 12" Pizzas

Contact:

(859) 523-5280

Mon -Wed: 11am - 10pm
Thu: 11am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 1pm
Sun: 11am – 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Best Pizza Places in Lexington KY - Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom video
5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM

(4.8 Score)
1924 Pavillon Way,
Lexington, KY 40509 Directions

Since 1976

Specialty:

✓ Chicago 7 ✓ Meat Me ✓ Double Deckeroni ✓ Thai Pie ✓ Farmers Daughter ✓ Veggie 7 ✓ Chicken Bacon Ranch ✓ Craft Your Own ✓ Twisted Tenders ✓ Spaghetti Pie ✓ Chicken Parmesan ✓ Chicken Pesto Alfredo ✓ Spaghetti and Meatballs ✓ Calzone ✓ Chicago Fire Calzone ✓ Craft Your Own Calzone ✓ Chicken and Bacon Mac ✓ Nashville Hot Chicken Bacon Mac ✓ Oh My Spaghetti Pie ✓ Spaghetti Pie With Meatballs ✓ Spaghetti Pie With Chicken ✓ Twisted Tenders Meal ✓ Grilled Chicken Alfredo ✓ Spicy Shrimp and Andouille Pasta

"Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Lexington is a family-friendly chain pizza restaurant featuring Italian entrees along with a wide beer selection. The restaurant is located in the Hamburg Pavilion. All of their pizzas are prepared using fresh, locally grown ingredients to create high-quality dishes. Savor their Meat pizza, a hearty option loaded with Italian sausage, Canadian bacon, andouille sausage, pepperoni, green olive garnish, and fresh basil. Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Lexington offers a full bar, free Wi-Fi, a kids’ menu, large party accommodations, catering services, and a patio area. The restaurant also offers a happy hour menu.

2026 Update: They specialize in providing 110 craft beers that serve as the milestones of their renowned World Beer Tour®, a rewards program that tracks your journey from hometown favorites to global standouts in the craft beer world. They offer Vegetarian options and great cocktails to guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Party Pack For 4: $29.99
Party Pack For 6: $59.99
Pizza Party To-Go: $125.00
Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls™: $11.49
Buffalo Chicken Rolls: $11.49
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks: $9.99
Twisted Tenders: $11.49
Fried Pickles: $9.49
Mozzarella Sticks: $9.49
Spinach Artichoke Dip: $11.49
Italian Nachos: $13.99
Cheesy Dippin' Strips: $9.99
Firecracker Shrimp: $13.99
Bone-In Chicken Wings Short: $10.99
Bone-In Chicken Wings Tall: $16.99
Boneless Chicken Wings Short: $9.49
Boneless Chicken Wings Tall: $13.49
Chicago 7™ Calzone: $13.99
Chicago Fire Calzone: $13.99
Craft Your Own Calzone
Spaghetti & Meatballs: $13.49
Chicken Parmesan: $14.99
Chicken & Bacon Mac: $13.99
Nashville Hot Chicken Bacon Mac: $14.98
Chicken Pesto Alfredo: $14.99
Oh My Spaghetti Pie: $13.99

Discount:

You can take $10 Off any large pizza for a limited time.

Contact:

(859) 977-4640

Mon-Thu: 11am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 12am
Sun: 11am -11pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

PIES & PINTS - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
PIES & PINTS - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
PIES & PINTS - Lexington, KY Pizza Places
Best Pizza Places in Lexington KY - PIES & PINTS video
10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PIES & PINTS

(4.8 Score)
401 West Main Street, Suite 106,
Lexington, KY 40507 Directions

Since 2003

Specialty:

✓ Pizza Pie ✓ White Pie ✓ Nashville Hot Chicken ✓ Peppadew ✓ Italian ✓ Street Corn ✓ Grape and Gorgonzola ✓ Margherita ✓ Black Bean ✓ Mushroom Garlic ✓ Mozzarella Caprese ✓ Sriracha Shrimp ✓ Thai ✓ Steak and Mushroom ✓ Chicken Gouda ✓ Chipotle Chicken ✓ Hot Mama ✓ Cuban Pork ✓ Pine and Swine ✓ Kid's Pizza Bread ✓ Sm. Chicken Gouda Pie ✓ Baja Bean Pie ✓ Sm. Barbacoa Pie ✓ Kid's Draft Root Beer ✓ Gf Char-grilled Wing Pie

"Pies & Pints offers a variety of specialty pizzas, salads, sandwiches, and cocktails. The restaurant is located next to the Lexington Visitors Center in The Square, formerly known as Victorian Square. All specialty pies begin with a blend of provolone and mozzarella on their house-made, hand-tossed dough. The Steak & Mushroom pizza is a savory combination of caramelized onions, tender steak, roasted mushrooms, gorgonzola, horseradish crema, and fresh scallions. The restaurant features a happy hour menu from Monday to Friday and offers unique gift cards.

2026 Update: They are conveniently located beside the Lexington Visitors Center in The Square, formerly Victorian Square, directly across from the Convention Center and Triangle Park, and just a short walk from Rupp Arena."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0875118

Price:

Pizza
Pizza Pie $12
White Pie $13
Nashville Hot Chicken $16
Peppadew $15
Italian $18
Street Corn $15
Grape & Gorgonzola $14
Margherita $14
Black Bean $15
Mushroom Garlic $14
Mozzarella Caprese $15
Sriracha Shrimp $16
Thai $16
Steak & Mushroom $17
Chicken Gouda $18
Chipotle Chicken $16
Hot Mama $17
Cuban Pork $18
Pine & Swine $16
Classic $17
Startsers
Char Grilled Hot Wings $15
Rosemary & Roasted Garlic Flatbread $11
Pizza Skins $15
Garlic Bread $7
Garlic Bread With Cheese $8
Chips & House Made Salsa $6
Pork & Pepper Nachos $15

Discount:

Use Code Getsome at Checkout to Get $5 Off* Any Online Carryout Order

$1 Off on select pints & house wines and $2 Off appetizers.

Contact:

(859) 231-7437

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for PIES & PINTS

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

GOODFELLAS PIZZERIA REVIEWS

One of my favorite spots in Lexington. The atmosphere is incredible. The amount of food you get for the price is unreal and the service is generally quick lots of selection on the premade pizza and drinks if you’re looking for a place to visit for a low price, this is your spot.

First time here. . Food was surprisingly good as well as the bar.. .get here early. . Or be waiting out the door you been warned. Definitely recommend going at least once.

Nice area, outside eating area was an additional benefit. Good atmosphere. Food was good. Pizza lunch special was good price. Staff was friendly.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM REVIEWS

This place is amazing! I would recommend Old Chicago to people who haven’t eaten here before. The lady serving us was nice and really friendly; she even offered to take a picture for us. The pizza that we ate had a thick crust and the dough was nice and fluffy. The service staff of Old Chicago was always there when you needed them. None of the food was raw or overcooked, but cooked to perfection. If you are looking for a perfect restaurant, this is the place.

After being seated and receiving a menu, it was awhile before anyone came to take my order. However, after the slow start, everything turned out alright. The deep dish Chicago pizza is excellent. The Garden Salad was cold and fresh. And the lemonade was standard lol. I highly recommend this establishment.

The boneless wings were just ok but the Sicilian pizza rolls were amazing. The pizza looked delicious as well. Can accommodate large groups.

PIES & PINTS REVIEWS

Great food and atmosphere! Came by twice in my short visit to Lexington and both times were exceptional. From the food to the selection of beer, you won’t be disappointed. Big shout out to Lucas, he was very personable and made my visit even better through his recommendations and conversation. Definitely a worthwhile visit if you’re in the area.

Always love Pies and Pints. Great pizza options, yummy appetizers, great place to bring kids. Always love the food. Wish there were some more cocktail options as I don't like beer and only kind of like cider, but that's just personal preference.

Wow, had some fantastic food tonight at Pies and Pints. We had the pizza skins, house salad, sausage pizza and the steak and mushroom pizza. Everything was just amazing. Also, TONs of beer choices plus they even had Root Beer on tap for the kiddos. 100% chance the next trip we make to Lexington will include a stop at Pies and Pints!!!!.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

GOODFELLAS PIZZERIA Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Acknowledgments: 8
Current Evaluation: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Video: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM Total Inspection Points: 116/120
Reviews Study: 8
Current Evaluation: 9
Legitimate Ratings: 9
Business Hours: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Variety of Menu: 10
Video: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

PIES & PINTS Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Current Evaluation: 8
Acknowledgments: 9
Complete Info: 9
Social Media: 9
Business Hours: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Video: 10