BEST RATED INDIANAPOLIS, IN SANDWICH SHOPS

3 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Shapiro's Delicatessen - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Dish Image

Shapiro's Delicatessen - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Restaurant Entrance Image

Shapiro's Delicatessen - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - collage image(highlights)

CALL

SHAPIRO'S DELICATESSEN

808 South Meridian Street,
Indianapolis, IN 46225 Directions

Since 1905

Specialities:

✓Sandwiches ✓Reuben ✓Rebecca Reuben ✓Corned Beef Sandwich ✓Pastrami Sandwich ✓NY Pastrami Reuben ✓NY Reuben ✓Brisket Sandwich ✓Pastrami Reuben ✓PLT Sandwich ✓Corned Beef/Pastrami Sandwich ✓Peppered Beef Sandwich ✓Albacore Tuna Sandwich ✓Chicken Salad Sandwich ✓Rare Roast Beef Sandwich ✓Pure Beef Burger ✓Salami Sandwich ✓Chopped Liver Sandwich ✓Kosher Frank ✓Roasted Turkey Sandwich ✓Smoked Turkey Sandwich ✓Corned Beef/Brisket Sandwich ✓Pastrami/Turkey Sandwich ✓Corned Beef Pastrami Reuben ✓Turkey Reuben ✓NY Turkey Reuben ✓Grilled Cheese ✓Rebecca Sandwiches ✓Rebecca Corned Beef Sandwich

"Shapiro's Delicatessen is a family-owned and operated business since more than 110 years. The restaurant is famous for enormous portions and award-winning corned beef, pastrami, and brisket sandwiches. The shop also specializes in piled-high sandwiches, and their meats are still slow-cooked in-store. Their homemade dishes like macaroni, cheese, and matzo ball soup are second to none. Shapiro's Delicatessen also offers incredible cheesecakes, delicious rye bread, NY-style bagels, and delectable desserts to keep residents and visitors returning for more. The restaurant provides both dine-in and takeout facilities.

2026 Highlights: Shapiro's Delicatessen is expanding beyond traditional cafeteria-style deli lines and integrating modern corporate and events catering structures. They also provide specialized online ordering, fully custom boxed lunches, and multi-tier buffet setups to serve the customers."

| |

Sandwiches:
Reuben $23.75
Rebecca Reuben $15.50
Corned Beef Sandwich $22.70
Pastrami Sandwich $23.25
Ny Pastrami Reuben $24.70
Ny Reuben $23.75
Brisket Sandwich $22.70
Pastrami Reuben $24.70
Plt Sandwich $11.50
Corned Beef Pastrami Sandwich $24.00
Peppered Beef Sandwich $19.25
Albacore Tuna Sandwich $10.90
Chicken Salad Sandwich $10.90
Rare Roast Beef Sandwich $21.20
Pure Beef Burger $8.15
Salami Sandwich $9.45
Chopped Liver Sandwich $11.00
Kosher Frank $6.50
Roasted Turkey Sandwich $12.15
Smoked Turkey Sandwich $12.15
Corned Beef Brisket Sandwich $22.00
Pastrami Turkey Sandwich $22.00
Corned Beef Pastrami Reuben $24.70
Turkey Reuben $13.20
Ny Turkey Reuben $13.20
Grilled Cheese $8.75
Rebecca Sandwiches:
Rebecca Corned Beef Sandwich $14.00
Rebecca Pastrami Sandwich $14.25

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

McAlister's Deli - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Dish Image

McAlister's Deli - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Restaurant Entrance Image

McAlister's Deli - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - collage image(highlights)

CALL

MCALISTER'S DELI

9702 East Washington Street, Suite 600,
Indianapolis, IN 46229 Directions

Since 1989

Specialities:

✓Sandwiches ✓6 and 12 Sandwiches ✓Memphian® ✓Memphian® 12 ✓The Italian ✓The Italian 12 ✓Cuban Sandwich ✓Cuban Sandwich 12 ✓French Dip ✓French Dip 12 ✓Spicy Turkey Melt ✓Spicy Turkey Melt 12 ✓Club Sandwiches ✓McAlister's Club ✓King Club ✓Black Angus Club ✓Black Angus King Club ✓Grilled Chicken Club ✓Grilled Chicken King Club ✓McAlister's Club Wrap ✓Bold Sandwiches ✓Spicy Southwest Chicken ✓Smoky Pepper Jack Turkey ✓Buffalo Chicken Sandwich ✓Jalapeño Turkey Crunch ✓Honey BBQ Pork Melt ✓Spicy BBQ Crunch Chicken Sandwich ✓Classic Sandwiches ✓The Veggie ✓The Rachel ✓Turkey Ranch BLT ✓Horseradish Roast Beef and Cheddar ✓Four Cheese Melt

"McAlister's Deli is a counter-service restaurant that offers sandwiches, stuffed baked potatoes, and sweet tea. The restaurant provides hand-crafted sandwiches, fresh salads, and ginormous spuds. The sandwich shop is always made fresh just for the customers and served with a big helping of friendly McAlister’s service. They bring delicious and iconic flavors of traditional delis and deliver them with their signature approach. The restaurant is dedicated to serving great food with hospitality. McAlister's Deli also provides catering with sandwich trays, box lunches, desserts, and a hot spud bar. The shop also includes amenities like a wheelchair-accessible parking lot, Wi-Fi, and plenty of parking for visitors' comfort.

2026 Highlights: McAlister's Deli has updated its fast-casual dining experience with menu innovations, digital ordering features, and financing options for its catering services. They have also introduced a dedicated vegetarian menu focused on high-protein, meat-free dining, and a newly developed GLP-1 friendly lunch option that prioritize balanced nutrition and portion control."

| |

6" & 12" Sandwiches:
Memphian $14.19
Memphian12" $19.69
The Italian $13.89
The Italian 12" $19.69
Cuban $13.89
Cuban 12" $19.69
French Dip $14.99
French Dip 12" $20.59
Spicy Bbq Crunch Chicken Sandwich $14.89
Spicy Southwest Chicken $13.79
Chicago Style French Dip $16.49
Chicago Style French Dip 12" $22.89
Spicy Turkey Melt $13.69
Spicy Turkey Melt 12" $19.49
Classic Sandwiches:
Horseradish Roast Beef & Cheddar $13.49
Turkey Ranch Blt $12.69
Ham & Cheese Melt $11.19
Four Cheese Melt $11.19
Harvest Chicken Salad Sandwich $12.49
Grilled Chicken $12.19
The New Yorker $15.89
Blt + Avocado $12.59
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.59
Reuben $15.89
The Rachel $15.89
The Veggie $11.19
Fresh Salads:
Pecanberry Salad $15.69
Savannah Chopped Salad $15.69

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Dish Image

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - Restaurant Entrance Image

Potbelly Sandwich Shop - Indianapolis, IN Sandwich Shops - collage image(highlights)

CALL

POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP

55 Monument Circle,
Indianapolis, IN 46204 Directions

Since 1977

Specialities:

✓Avo Turkey ✓Prime Rib Steak ✓Italian ✓A Wreck® ✓Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup ✓Sandwiches ✓Prime Rib Steak ✓Cubano ✓Sweet Heat Pork BBQ ✓A Wreck® ✓Italian ✓Avo Turkey ✓Chicken Club ✓BLTA ✓Veggie Melt ✓Pizza Melt ✓Mediterranean ✓Turkey Breast ✓Smoked Ham ✓Grilled Chicken ✓Tuna Salad ✓Chicken Salad ✓Grilled Cheese ✓Wraps ✓Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap ✓Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap ✓Salads ✓Farmhouse Salad ✓Apple Walnut Salad ✓Powerhouse Salad ✓Chicken Salad Salad ✓Pick-your-pair ✓Skinny Sandwich + Cup of Soup ✓Half Salad + Cup of Soup ✓Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad ✓Mac and Soups ✓Broccoli Cheddar ✓Chicken Pot Pie Soup

"Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a counter-serve chain specializing in toasted sandwiches, salads, and baked goods. The restaurant strongly believes that customers can taste the difference when simple, high-quality ingredients are used in whole roasted turkey breast. Customers can also enjoy a live local musician who is playing good tunes. The sandwich shop is dedicated to serving simple, high-quality ingredients, like toasty sandwiches, tasty salads, and delicious soups. Potbelly Sandwich Shop also lets customers enjoy their delicious food with dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. The sandwich shop is also wheelchair accessible and offers outdoor seating for the convenience of visitors.

2026 Highlights: Potbelly Sandwich Shop has become a focused powerhouse, moving away from its traditional corporate-heavy layout into a growth phase that aims for 500 active units. The brand is utilizing fresh financial backing to expand its footprint with 50 new locations."

| |

Sandwiches:
Prime Rib Steak $14.09+
Cubano $12.59+
Sweet Heat Pork BBQ $12.89+
A Wreck® $12.59+
Italian $12.59+
Avo Turkey $12.89+
Chicken Club $12.89+
BLT $12.89+
Veggie Melt $12.29+
Pizza Melt $12.59+
Mediterranean $12.89+
Turkey Breast $11.99+
Smoked Ham $11.99+
Grilled Chicken $11.99+
Tuna Salad $11.99+
Chicken Salad $11.99+
Grilled Cheese $10.99+
Wraps:
Chicken Bacon Ranch Wrap $13.29+
Southwest Avo Chicken Wrap $13.29+
Salads:
Farmhouse Salad $12.89+
Apple Walnut Salad $12.89+
Powerhouse Salad $12.89+
Chicken Salad Salad $12.89+
Pick-Your-Pair:
Skinny Sandwich + Cup Of Soup $13.09
Half Salad + Cup Of Soup $13.49
Skinny Sandwich + Half Salad $14.79
Mac & Soups:
Broccoli Cheddar $6.29+
Chicken Pot Pie Soup $6.29+
Chili $6.29+

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

I can't go down East Washington Str without stopping into this place. I was with my wife and son and we ate til I eyes popped out. The food was good , hot , juicy and inexpensive for a good meal. Great service at a reasonable price. I recommend you have a drop in and see for yourself.

Best location period. Great service too. Great employees and managers who go the extra mile for you. Always pleasant. Food is always on point too.

Always have a great meal here. Line is usually pretty quick. I always get the choose 2 meal with savanna chopped salad and spicy turkey melt sandwich. Delicious.

We decided to stop here for a quick meal while we were out exploring the Soldiers & Sailors Monument. The ladies working at Potbelly were friendly and quick to help us with our order. I would highly recommend eating here.

I had the best tuna fish sandwich on multigrain bread that I ever had in my entire life! Friendly staff and excellent customer service.

Best sandwich chain for sure. Also today the sandwich was picture perfect. Perfect ingredient distribution.

Awards History: 10

Business Hours: 10

Menu Images: 10

Complete Info: 10

Contact Info: 10

Exact Services: 10

Experience: 10

Online Order: 10

Pricing: 10

Real Discounts: 10

Social Media: 10

Video: 10

Our Inspection includes everything from checking reviews, ratings, reputation, history, complaints, satisfaction, trust and cost to the general excellence. If you are looking for full list of our 50-Point Inspection, the following list will give you a clear picture. Few items may not be applicable to all businesses.

3 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

SHAPIRO'S DELICATESSEN

Since 1905

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

MCALISTER'S DELI

Since 1989

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP

Since 1977

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

Success

Error occurred

Your request has been sent!

Oops! Something went wrong

3 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

SHAPIRO'S DELICATESSEN

Since 1905

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

MCALISTER'S DELI

Since 1989

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP

Since 1977

Specialities:

Menu:

Discount:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Potbelly Sandwich Shop

Success

Error occurred

Our Review Process:

Contact Business

Your request has been sent!

Oops! Something went wrong

SHAPIRO'S DELICATESSEN REVIEWS

MCALISTER'S DELI REVIEWS

POTBELLY SANDWICH SHOP REVIEWS

TBR® Inspection Score Report

TBR® Inspection Score Report

TBR® Inspection Score Report