3 Best Sandwich Shops in Indianapolis, IN

“Shapiro's Delicatessen is a family-owned and operated business for more than 110 years. Shapiro's Delicatessen shop is famous for enormous portions and award-winning corned beef, pastrami, and brisket sandwiches. They specialize in piled-high sandwiches, and their meats (corned beef, pastrami, brisket) are still slow-cooked in-store. Their homemade dishes like macaroni, cheese, and matzo ball soup are second to none. Shapiro's Delicatessen offers incredible cheesecakes, delicious rye bread, NY-style bagels, and delectable desserts to keep Indianapolis residents and visitors returning for more. For birthdays, holidays, Father's Day, or hostess gifts, gift cards are available in any amount and will never expire. Dine-in and takeout are also available. This finest sandwich shop conveniently serves in two locations.”

Read more

“McAlister's Deli is an easygoing counter-service that offers sandwiches, stuffed baked potatoes, and sweet tea. They provide hand-crafted sandwiches, fresh salads, and ginormous spuds. They are always made-to-order just for you and served with a heaping spoonful of "McAlister's Genuine Hospitality." McAlister's Deli Indianapolis is one of the most famous sub-shops in the region. They bring delicious and iconic flavors of traditional delis and deliver them with their signature approach. They are dedicated to serving great food with genuine hospitality. McAlister's Deli also offers Kid's menus and gift cards. They invite you to come for the food and stay for the experience. The restaurant allows catering with sandwich trays, box lunches, desserts, and a hot spud bar. For tea lovers or anybody who loves the idea of a refreshing pick-me-up at a ridiculously great value, they created the Tea Pass. 30 days of tea, starting at $7.99.”

Read more

“Potbelly Sandwich Shop is a retro-style counter-serve chain known for made-to-order toasted sandwiches, salads, and baked goods. The shop is owned by Peter Hastings, who has many years of experience. They decide to start serving sandwiches to their curious, collecting customers. Potbelly Sandwich Shop believes you can taste the difference when simple, high-quality ingredients are used in whole roasted turkey breast. You can enjoy a live local musician playing good tunes. They proudly host fundraisers for local schools, sports teams, and other non-profit groups. Potbelly Sandwich Shop serves simple ingredients done right, such as toasty warm sandwiches, crave-able salads, and delicious soup. Join Potbelly Perks and get one free Original sandwich after your first order of $5 or more. Plus, earn points towards free food and more. From oven-toasted sandwiches, hot soups, fresh baked cookies and more, get rewarded for every purchase with Potbelly Perks.”

Read more