3 Best Sandwich Shops in Pueblo, CO

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Pueblo, Colorado. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

ARBY'S

719 West Us Highway 50,
Pueblo, CO 81008 Directions

Since 1964

Specialty:

Classic Roast Beef Double Roast Beef Half Pound Roast Beef Classic Beef 'n Cheddar Double Beef 'n Cheddar Classic French Dip and Swiss Roast Beef Gyro Smokehouse Brisket Corned Beef Reuben Ham and Swiss Melt Greek Gyro Roast Turkey Ranch and Bacon Sandwich Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Chicken Bacon and Swiss Classic Crispy Chicken Sandwich Roast Buffalo Chicken Sandwich Roast Classic Chicken Sandwich Curly Fries Crinkle Fries Potato Cakes Mozzarella Sticks Jalapeño Bites White Cheddar Mac 'n Cheese Chicken Tenders Apple Pie Shake Jamocha Shake Chocolate Shake Vanilla Shake Apple Turnover

"Arby's is a prominent sandwich shop that has been recognized for serving fresh, delectable meals. As the first nationally franchised sandwich chain that spans the entire coast, they are committed to providing the perfect sandwich, with options ranging from the traditional Classic Roast Beef and French Dip to the deli-style Market Fresh line. The Arby's brand strives to inspire smiles through delicious experiences. They offer a range of hot and cold sandwiches, fries, and shakes. With over 3,400 restaurants worldwide, Arby's is a leading global quick-service restaurant company that aims to create delightful experiences that bring smiles to customers' faces. They offer take-out services and are wheelchair accessible. Gift cards are also available.

2026 Update: Arby's has transitioned to a digitally integrated model featuring automated drive-thrus, mobile-order pickup cubbies, and expanded delivery. The corporate sustainability initiatives have fully replaced single-use plastics with compostable packaging across all domestic franchises."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Great Oak Award in 2015
Best and Brightest Companies to Work For in the US in 2015
National Restaurant Neighbor Award in 2016

Price:

Roast Beef:
Classic Roast Beef $5.59
Double Roast Beef $7.09
Half Pound Roast Beef $8.77
Classic Beef 'N Cheddar $6.49
Double Beef 'N Cheddar $7.99
Classic French Dip & Swiss $7.29
Roast Beef Gyro $6.49
Smokehouse Brisket $7.99
Corned Beef Reuben $6.99
Ham & Swiss Melt $5.29
Chicken:
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $5.99
Chicken Bacon & Swiss $6.69
Classic Crispy Chicken Sandwich $5.59
Roast Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $6.39
Roast Chicken Bacon & Swiss $7.09
Roast Classic Chicken Sandwich $5.99
Sides & Snacks:
Curly Fries $2.29
Crinkle Fries $2.29
Potato Cakes $2.49
Mozzarella Sticks $3.89
Jalapeño Bites $5.59
Desserts:
Apple Pie Shake $3.99
Jamocha Shake $3.99
Chocolate Shake $3.99
Desserts:
Apple Pie Shake $3.99
Jamocha Shake $3.99
Chocolate Shake $3.99

Discount:

$1.99 Off on Sliders

20% Off for Next Order When You Spend $20+

25% Off for First Order for New Rewards Members

$7.99 Off onMeat & 3 Box Meal Deal

$9.99 Off on Premium Meat & 3 Box Meal Deal

2 for $7 Off on Sandwich Deal

2 for $6 Off on Value Deal

4 for $10 Off on Mix & Match Deal

View Coupon

Contact:

(719) 543-7750

Mon-Sun: 9:30am - 12am

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

MCALISTER'S DELI

1425 Highway 50 West,
Pueblo, CO 81008 Directions

Since 1989

Specialty:

Memphian The Italian Cuban Sandwich French Dip Spicy Turkey Melt McAlister's Club McAlister's Club Wrap King Club Grilled Chicken Club Grilled Chicken King Club Black Angus Club Black Angus King Club Honey BBQ Pork Melt Jalapeño Turkey Crunch Smoky Pepper Jack Turkey Spicy BBQ Crunch Chicken Sandwich Spicy Southwest Chicken Four Cheese Melt Harvest Chicken Salad Grilled Chicken Turkey Ranch BLT Ham and Cheese Melt The New Yorker BLT + Avocado Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap Reuben The Rachel The Veggie Fresh Salads Starters Giant Spuds Soups Kids Meals Sides Desserts Cheese Spud Spud Max Spud Ole Veggie Spud

"McAlister's Deli is a counter-service chain and popular for its delectable sandwiches, stuffed baked potatoes, and sweet tea for over 37 years. Their menu has retained its traditional appeal and features a range of mouth-watering sandwiches, spuds, and salads that will satisfy any appetite. Their signature McAlister's Club and generously proportioned Spuds are garnished with your favorite toppings. Their goal is to provide simple and gratifying handcrafted food and sweet tea for everyone, even the most discerning eaters. They take well-known flavors and add a special McAlister's twist that sets them apart. With more than 500 restaurants spread across 28 states, McAlister's Deli remains committed to serving exceptional food with genuine hospitality.

2026 Update: McAlister's Deli has expanded to over 570 locations while updating its infrastructure with modernized and enhanced digital ordering. The new feature includes digital beverage customization, GLP-1-friendly options, and menus like vegetarian and seasonal items. These financing options make the customers feel satisfied and make ordering easy."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Entrepreneur Magazine Franchise 500 Award in 2021
License #20221468460

Price:

Sandwiches:
Honey BBQ Pork Melt $12.89
Jalapeño Turkey Crunch $14.59
Smoky Pepper Jack Turkey $12.49
Spicy BBQ Crunch Chicken Sandwich $14.89
Spicy Southwest Chicken $13.79
Turkey Ranch BLT $12.69
Ham & Cheese Melt $11.19
Four Cheese Melt $11.19
Harvest Chicken Salad Sandwich $12.49
Grilled Chicken $12.19
The New Yorker $15.89
BLT + Avocado $12.59
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap $12.59
Reuben $15.89
The Rachel $15.89
The Veggie $11.19
The Veggie Sandwich $7.49
Garden Fresh Turkey Sandwich $8.99
BLT With Avocado $8.99
Fresh Salads:
Pecanberry Salad $15.69
Caesar Salad $7.99
Garden Salad $7.29
Chef Salad $9.79
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad $9.79
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad From $8.29
Up To $12.19
Garden Salad From $5.99
Up To $9.29

Discount:

$30 Off on Catering Orders of $250+

15% Off on Service Fee (Max $7.50) on Orders Under $50

$0.99 Off on Delivery Fee

$7.99 Off for 30 Days of Daily Big Tea

View Coupon

Contact:

(719) 543-7698

Mon-Sun: 10:30am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

PASS KEY NORTHERN

3416 West Northern Avenue,
Pueblo, CO 81005 Directions

Since 2016

Specialty:

Hoagie Dutch Lunch Hamburger Cheeseburger Bacon Cheese Burger Fried Egg Sandwich On Toast Grilled Cheese Corn Dog Hot Dog Bacon Sandwich Fish Sandwich Chili Dog Patty Melt Chili Burger Ham and Cheese Fried Chicken Sandwich Grilled Chicken Sandwich Hot Wings Chile Cheese Fries Mozzarella Sticks Onion Rings Beer Batter Onion Rings Chicken Strips With Fries Chicken Parmigiana Spaghetti or Rigatoni Dinner Meatball Sandwich Hamburger Steak Green Chile Strips Side Of Ranch Tomatoes Extra Cheese Extra Peppers

"Pass Key Northern Restaurant is owned and operated by the Pagano family and has been serving the community for over 50 years. They offer tasty and satisfying meals that have stood the test of time. With multiple locations in Pueblo, Pass Key continues to serve up delicious food with fast and friendly service, making it a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The ambience at Pass Key Northern is welcoming and cozy, making it an ideal place for tourists to unwind after exploring the sights of Pueblo. Don’t miss out on trying their signature sandwiches, which have garnered rave reviews from customers. The menu boasts an impressive variety of sandwiches, each prepared with fresh ingredients and bold flavours that are sure to satisfy any palate.

2026 Update: Pass Key Restaurant is focusing on high-capacity service, digital ordering, and a rewards program. They also provide an integrated digital payment system for their customers."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20161209708

Price:

Sandwiches:
Hamburger $3.30
Cheeseburger $3.60
Bacon Cheeseburger $4.90
Fried Egg Sandwich On Toast $3.20
Grilled Cheese $3.45
Corn Dog $2.75
Hot Dog $2.75
Bacon Sandwich $4.00
Fish Sandwich $4.00
Chili Dog $4.00
Patty Melt $4.25
Chili Burger From $4.25
Upto $4.75
Ham & Cheese $4.00
Fried Chicken Sandwich $4.20
Grilled Chicken Sandwich $4.20
Munchies:
Hot Wings (10) $6.25
Chile Cheese Fries $5.95
Mozzarella Sticks $4.20
Onion Rings $3.95
Beer Batter Onion Rings $4.25
Chicken Strip Baskets:
5 Pieces With Fries $5.95
3 Pieces With Fries $3.95
Pasta:
Chicken Parmigiana $7.95
Spaghetti Or Rigatoni Dinner $6.25
Half Order Spaghetti Or Rigatoni Dinner $5.25
Meatball Sandwich $4.75
Extra Sides:
Green Chile Strips $1.25
Side Of Ranch $0.50
Tomatoes $0.30

Contact:

(719) 564-1046 (719) 547-7747

Tue-Sat: 11am - 8pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: