3 Best Sandwich Shops in Tallahassee, FL

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Tallahassee, Florida. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

JASON'S DELI

2335 Apalachee Parkway,
Tallahassee, FL 32301 Directions

Since 1976

Specialities:

Oven Roasted Turkey Sandwich Smoked Turkey Sandwich Salami Sandwich Ham Sandwich Tuna Salad Sandwich With Egg Bigger Better BLT The Carmela Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich Chicken Panini Club Royale Deli Club Beefeater Reuben The Great Reuben The Great With Pastrami Hot Pastrami Sandwich Hot Corned Beef Sandwich New York Yankee Spicy Sicilian Sub Chicken Caprese Panini Caprese Panini Ham and Salami Muffaletta Grilled Cheese and Tomato Soup Combo Ranchero Wrap Southwest Turkey Club

" Jason's Deli is a family-owned restaurant with over 250 delis scattered across 28 states. Their menu caters to a wide range of healthy and indulgent palates and comprises high-quality ingredients free from artificial trans fats, high-fructose corn syrup, processed MSG, and dyes. To provide gluten-free options, Jason's Deli has devised a special kit to ensure the safe preparation of their gluten-free menu items. They also take great care in sandwich preparation by using gluten-free bread on parchment paper to avoid contamination. Dine-in side dishes are served in to-go containers, and chips are given in an unopened, single-serve bag on the dine-in plate. With their emphasis on quality, value, and ingredient sourcing, choosing Jason's Deli is a decision that you can make with confidence.

2026 Highlights: Jason's Deli provides catering and rewards for customers with points on every order. They have also introduced refer and earn options using a personal code. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Golden Chain Award by Nation's Restaurant News Magazine in 2008
Best Sandwich or Sub Shop (Ranked #2) by USA TODAY 10Best Readers' Choice Awards in 2025
License #SEA4703465

Menu:

Sandwiches
Oven Roasted Turkey Sandwich $11.59
Smoked Turkey Sandwich $11.59
Salami Sandwich $11.59
Ham Sandwich $11.59
Tuna Salad Sandwich With Egg $11.59
Bigger Better BLT $10.99
The Carmela $12.19
Santa Fe Chicken Sandwich $12.49
Chicken Panini $12.99
Club Royale $13.79
Deli Club $14.29
Beefeater $14.29
Reuben The Great $15.59
Reuben The Great With Pastrami $15.59
Hot Pastrami Sandwich $13.79
Hot Corned Beef Sandwich $13.79
New York Yankee $17.59
Spicy Sicilian Sub $12.49
Chicken Caprese Panini $13.69
Caprese Panini $11.69
Ham & Salami Muffaletta $11.69+
Grilled Cheese & Tomato Soup Combo $11.29
Ranchero Wrap $12.49
Southwest Turkey Club $13.79
Soups
Tomato Basil $6.99
Irish Potato $6.79
Chili $6.79
Chicken Pot Pie $6.79

Contact:

(850) 402-0135

Mon-Sun: 8am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

PANERA BREAD

2009 Apalachee Parkway,
Tallahassee, FL 32301 Directions

Since 1987

Specialities:

Grilled Cheese Toasted Frontega Chicken Bacon Turkey Bravo Tuna Salad Sandwich Chicken Roma Asiago Bagel Stack Chicken Bacon Rancher Ciabatta Cheesesteak Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich Grilled Chicken and Avo BLT Tomato Basil BLT Toasted Caprese Focaccia Smokehouse BBQ Chicken Turkey and Cheddar Sandwich Mediterranean Veggie Spicy Steak Asiago Bagel Stack

2026 Highlights: Panera Bread is a family and locally owned business; they are operated as a major corporate brand, bringing over 35 years of service to the local community since first opening in Florida. They provide a warm, cozy environment where people can enjoy high-quality breakfast, lunch, and dinner daily. The specialty of the restaurant is their fresh sourdough bread bowls, clean salads, and warm toasted sandwiches. Some of the Tallahassee locations are naturally located near beautiful trees and greenery, which gives guests a peaceful view. Inside, visitors will find spacious seating arrangements with comfy booths and tables. For people who like fresh air, they offer great outdoor facilities like sunny patio spaces. Panera Bread provides flexible payment options, fast takeout options, and rapid pick-up shelves. They run multiple branches in town to serve everyone, including locations on Apalachee Parkway, Thomasville Road, and Ocala Road. They provide a monthly plan promotions for customers through sip club.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Panera Bread Warmth Initiative Employee Excellence Pins by PR Management Corp / Panera Bread Facebook in 2025
Best Fast Casual Restaurant by USA TODAY 10Best Readers' Choice Awards in 2025
License #SEA4703437

Menu:

Sandwiches
Grilled Cheese $7.49
Toasted Frontega Chicken $11.19
Bacon Turkey Bravo $11.19
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.09
Chicken Roma Asiago Bagel Stack $9.99
Chicken Bacon Rancher $11.19
Ciabatta Cheesesteak $11.69
Cranberry Walnut Chicken Salad Sandwich $7.99
Grilled Chicken and Avo BLT $11.69
Tomato Basil BLT $8.39
Toasted Caprese Focaccia $8.79
Smokehouse BBQ Chicken $9.09
Turkey and Cheddar Sandwich $9.09
Mediterranean Veggie $7.49
Spicy Steak Asiago Bagel Stack $9.99
Chipotle Chicken Avo Melt $11.19
Chicken Roma Asiago Bagel Stack $9.99
Soups & Mac
Mac and Cheese $8.49
Bacon Mac and Cheese $9.59
Homestyle Chicken Noodle Soup $8.49
Cream of Chicken and Wild Rice Soup $8.49
Creamy Tomato Soup $8.49

Discount:

20% Off on Gift Cards

Contact:

(850) 216-1595

Mon-Sat: 6am - 9pm
Sun: 7am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

NEWK'S EATERY

1400 Village Square Boulevard, Suite 35,
Tallahassee, FL 32312 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

Turkey Melt Cajun Shrimp Po'boy Newk's Philly Newk's q Sandwich French Dip Newk's Chicken Salad Sandwich The Italian Sandwich Chicken Bacon Club Turkey Avocado Newk's Club Portobello Veggie Sandwich Pesto Chicken Sandwich Pimiento Cheese Ham and Swiss Turkey and Swiss Roast Beef Adult Grilled Cheese Red White and Blueberry Salad Cajun Shrimp Comeback Salad Pesto Pasta Chicken Caesar Newk's Favorite Ultimate Salad Greek Salad

" Newk's Eatery serves sandwiches, soups, salads, pizza, mac and cheese, and desserts for over 20 years. Nothing is pre-sliced, pre-chopped, or pre-packaged. Whether you’re craving timeless Newcomb family classics or the latest trending flavours, they have an option for you. The restaurant blends many influences to create high-quality food with exceptional flavours a little Southern, a little Italian, and all delicious. At Newk’s, you’ll find salads bursting with vibrant goodness, sandwiches piled high with culinary creativity, crispy pizza made to order, and hearty soups.

2026 Highlights: Newk’s Eatery has introduced redeem points, free drinks, and allows customers to earn points in store or online orders. They also offer catering, and group orders along with gift cards. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Silver Plate Award (CEO Chris Newcomb) by International Foodservice Manufacturers Association / Nation's Restaurant News in 2017
License #SEA4702729

Menu:

Sandwiches
Turkey Melt $13.79
Cajun Shrimp Po'Boy $17.29
Newk's Philly $17.29
Newk's "Q" Sandwich $14.19
French Dip $15.99
Newk's Chicken Salad Sandwich $13.19
The Italian Sandwich $14.19
Chicken Bacon Club $14.39
Turkey Avocado $14.79
Newk's Club $14.19
Portobello Veggie Sandwich $12.89
Pesto Chicken Sandwich $14.19
Pimiento Cheese $12.49
Ham and Swiss $12.29
Turkey and Swiss $12.29
Roast Beef $14.99
Adult Grilled Cheese $10.99
Salads
Red White and Blueberry Salad $15.39
Cajun Shrimp Comeback Salad $18.79
Pesto Pasta Chicken Caesar $14.39
Newk's Favorite $16.29
Ultimate Salad $15.39
Wraps
Chipotle Shrimp Caesar Wrap $17.19
Greek Salad $8.79

Contact:

(850) 329-7162

Sun-Mon: 10:30am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report: