3 Best Seafood Restaurants in Peoria, IL

Expert-recommended Top 3 Seafood Restaurants in Peoria, Illinois. All of our seafood restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

JONAH'S SEAFOOD HOUSE

2601 North Main Street, East Peoria,
Peoria, IL 61611 Directions

Since 1986

Specialities:

Our Great Seven Layer Crabbie Salad Salmon Caesar Grilled Gulf Shrimp Spinach and Artichoke Dip East Coast Blues Fresh Pan-fried Oysters Oysters Rockefeller Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Shrimp and Crab Skins Gazpacho Shrimp Crab Tortilla Dip Oyster Sampler Crab Cakes Crab and Shrimp Nachos Apalachicola Sesame Crusted Tuna Grilled Chai-Thai Tuna Creamy Cape Cod Clam Chowder Cape Cod Clam Chowder Spicy Bayou Gumbo French Onion Soup Fresh Vegetables Fresh Seasonal Hand-cut Fruit Grape Tomato Salad Red Beans and Rice Fat Fries

" Jonah's Seafood House offers a surf 'n' turf menu, an oyster bar, chowder, and more. The restaurant continues the tradition of serving fresh seafood flown in daily. Jonah's is located 2.2 miles from downtown Peoria. Their menu is based on quality, consistency, and dedication to excellence on every level. They also offer a variety of eight or more fresh fish for guests to choose from. Their staff is amiable and accommodates guests throughout their entire dining experience. They serve a fantastic menu that has plenty of craft beer, wine, and cocktail choices. The restaurant provides banquet rooms that can accommodate up to 125 guests and Audio/Visual equipment.

2026 Highlights: Jonah's Seafood House offers gift cards and table reservations. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Seafood Restaurant by Peoria Journal Star (Community's Choice Awards) in 2026
License #CORP_54091249

Menu:

Oysters And Stuff
Spinach And Artichoke Dip $7.90
East Coast Blues $9.80
Fresh Pan-Fried Oysters $9.90
Oysters Rockefeller $9.90
Gulf Shrimp Cocktail $9.90
Shrimp And Crab Skins $11.70
Gazpacho Shrimp $11.90
Crab Tortilla Dip $11.90
Oyster Sampler $12.30
Crab Cakes $13.50
Crab And Shrimp Nachos $13.90
Apalachicola $14.80
Sesame Crusted Tuna $16.80
Grilled Chai-Thai Tuna $16.80
Entree Salads
Our Great Seven Layer $7.50
Crabbie Salad $10.50
Salmon Caesar $14.90
Grilled Gulf Shrimp $14.90
Specialties
Caramel Apple Martini $6.75
Jolly Rancher $6.75
Jonah's Sunset $7
Suffering Bastard $7.25
Caribbean Kiss $7.25
West Indies Yellowbird $7.50
The Jamaican Ten Speed $7.50
Chicken Platter $10.50
Bayou Style Jambalaya $13.50
Jumbo Shrimp $14.90

Contact:

(309) 694-0946 (309) 694-0947

Tue-Thu: 11am - 8pm
Fri: 11am - 12am
Sat: 12am - 8am|11am - 12am
Sun: 12am - 8am
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

THE FISH HOUSE

4919 North University Street,
Peoria, IL 61614 Directions

Since 1976

Specialities:

Florida Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Deep Fried Oysters Baked Oysters Rockefeller Crab Stuffed Mushroom Caps Shrimp Dijon Cheese Sticks Fried Alligator Fried or Sautéed Mushrooms Calamari Fritti French Fried Onion Rings Crab Cake Appetizer Crab Turnovers Seared Tuna Appetizer Grilled Oysters Connecticut Blue Points New England Clam Chowder Lobster Bisque Chicken Caesar Salad Combination Seafood Salad Our House Tossed Salad Caesar Salad Broiled South African Lobster Broiled Alaskan King Crab African and Alaskan

" The Fish House is a traditional seafood restaurant specializing in fresh seafood dishes from around the globe, with an eclectic mix of chicken and pasta dishes to satisfy all appetites. The restaurant atmosphere is charming, with candlelight. They have been serving great and fresh seafood for over 45 years. Their wide menu of over 75 entrées includes chicken, hand-cut in-house aged steaks, pasta, and a kid's menu. It also provides early dinner menus to its guests. The restaurant offers a seared tuna appetizer that is marinated in a ginger sauce and rolled in spicy Caribbean spices with sesame seeds, then pan-roasted, sliced, and served with wasabi.

2026 Highlights: The Fish House offers gift cards and reservations for the customers. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Dining Winner by The Peoria Journal Star / Peoria Community's Choice Awards via Facebook in 2024
License #50920401

Menu:

Appetizers
Florida Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Half Dozen $9.90
Florida Gulf Shrimp Cocktail Full Dozen $18.80
Deep Fried Oysters Five $16.90
Baked Oysters Rockefeller $17.90
Crab Stuffed Mushroom Caps $11.90
Shrimp Dijon $11.90
Cheese Sticks $8.90
Fried Alligator $11.90
Fried Or Sautéed Mushrooms $7.90
Calamari Fritti $10.90
French Fried Onion Rings $8.90
Crab Cake Appetizer $14.90
Crab Turnovers $13.90
Seared Tuna Appetizer $17.90
Grilled Oysters $17
Connecticut Blue Points Half Dozen $14.90
Connecticut Blue Points Full Dozen $29.80
Lobster And Crab
Broiled South African Lobster One Tail $46.90
Broiled South African Lobster Two Tails $85.90
Broiled Alaskan King Crab Market Price
African And Alaskan Market Price
African Lobster And Jumbo Prawn $66.90

Discount:

$50 Off on 14 oz Lobster Tail Anniversary Deal

Contact:

(309) 691-9358

Mon-Thu & Sun: 4pm - 9:30pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

HOLY CRAB

205 River Road,
Peoria, IL 61611 Directions

Since 2021

Specialities:

Hush Puppies Cheese Sticks Popcorn Shrimp Onion Rings French Fries Sweet Potato Fries Crab Cake Chicken Wings Crispy Pork Potstickers Fried Oysters Fried Calamari Holy Cream Cheese Holy Crab Sampler King Crab Legs Clams Green Mussels Black Mussels Shrimp Snow Crab Legs Blue Crab Crawfish Dungeness Crab

" Holy Crab serves Cajun seafood boils including crawfish, shrimp, and alligator bites. The restaurant offers great food, fast service, and genuine hospitality—every single day. Their menu is packed with mouthwatering seafood classics, all seasoned to perfection and crafted with input from their loyal customers. They provide juicy shrimp and snow crab legs, custom boil combos, and crave-worthy sides. Their chef makes every dish with passion and serves it with love. They serve bold Cajun flavors, fan-favorite seafood boils, creamy shakes, and also a kids' menu.

2026 Highlights: Holy Crab offers online orders for their customers. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Seafood in East Peoria by Quality Business Awards USA in 2026
License #CORP_73388864

Menu:

Appetizers
Hush Puppies (10pcs) $4.20
Cheese Sticks (6pcs) $6.30
Popcorn Shrimp $8.40
Onion Rings $5.25
French Fries $4.20
Sweet Potato Fries $4.20
Crab Cake (2pcs) $10.50
Chicken Wings $8.40
Crispy Pork Potstickers (6pcs) $5.25
Fried Oyster (8pcs) $11.55
Fried Calamari (8pcs) $9.45
Holy Cream Cheese $8.40
Holy Crab Sampler $18.90
Create Your Own Combo
Create Your Own Combo $0.00
King Crab Legs (1 Lb) $62.98
Clams (12 Lb) $12.12
Clams (1 Lb) $14.64
Green Mussels (12 Lb) $12.12
Green Mussels (1 Lb) $14.64
Black Mussels (12 Lb) $12.12
Black Mussels (1 Lb) $14.64
Shrimp (12 Lb) $13.12
Shrimp (1 Lb) $21.99
Snow Crab Legs (12 Lb) $17.32
Snow Crab Legs (1 Lb) $30.39
Blue Crab (12 Lb) $9.39
Blue Crab (1 Lb) $15.69
Crawfish (12 Lb) $11.02
Crawfish (1 Lb) $14.64

Discount:

$6 Off on 1 lb Snow Crab Legs with Purchase of 1 lb King Crab Legs

Contact:

(309) 966-1145

Mon-Thu,Sun: 11am - 9:30pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report: