ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED FORT COLLINS, CO AMERICAN RESTAURANTS

3 Best American Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO

Expert-recommended Top 3 American Restaurants in Fort Collins, Colorado. All of our american cuisines actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Austin's American Grill - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Food Image
Austin's American Grill - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Restaurant Exterior Image
Austin's American Grill - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - collage image(highlights)
Best American Restaurants in Fort Collins CO - Austin's American Grill video
10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

AUSTIN'S AMERICAN GRILL

(5.0 Score)
100 West Mountain Avenue,
Fort Collins, CO 80524 Directions

Since 1997

Specialities:

✓Chicken Salad Sandwich ✓Colorado Cheeseburger ✓French Dip ✓Haystack Chicken Sandwich ✓Nashville Hot Pork Sandwich ✓Turkey Club ✓Mushroom Swiss Burger ✓Balsamic Blue Burger ✓Quarter Rotisserie Chicken ✓Half Rotisserie Chicken ✓Delmonico Ribeye ✓New York Strip Steak ✓Bison Stirrup Steak ✓Northwest BBQ Salmon ✓Grilled Bison Meatloaf ✓Combo Plate ✓Full Rack Pork Ribs ✓Half Rack Pork Ribs ✓Chicken Pot Pie ✓Fried Walleye

" Austin's American Grill serves American food in a relaxed setting, along with special cocktails and fresh desserts. They use natural buffalo meat, perfectly seasoned and their cornbread is baked in an iron skillet with honey and butter on top. They offer a special cocktail made with chilled fruit juice. Their rich, homemade desserts are made fresh every day, perfect for when you want a sweet treat that feels like home. Austin's American Grill's chef uses a secret ingredient to make the food extra tasty. Their juicy roasts and chicken are cooked over an open flame in a rotisserie you can see. Be sure to try their sandwiches and French Dip. Free street parking is available. Their Chicken Salad Sandwich features red bird chicken with sundried cranberries, lettuce, tomato, and wheat bread. They also serve at Old Town Fort Collins, Harmony Road, and Greeley.

2026 Highlights: They feature a front of house open flame rotisserie where savory roasts and chicken are cooked right in view of diners. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20011227412

Menu:

FAMILY PACKAGES:
Rotisserie Chicken Family Pack: $40.95
Pork Ribs Family Pack: $59.95
Bison Meatloaf Family Pack: $59.95
Family Combo Pack: $69.95
APPETIZERS:
Brussels Sprouts: $13.95
Buffalo Wings: $15.95
Chicken Street Tacos: $11.95
Coconut Shrimp: $13.95
Crispy Crab Stuffed Avocado: $14.95
Artichoke Dip: $11.95
Queso: $11.95
Skillet Cornbread: $7.95
SOUPS:
French Onion Soup - Cup: $5.95
French Onion Soup - Bowl: $7.95
Beer Cheese - Cup: $5.95
Beer Cheese - Bowl: $7.95
Chicken Tortilla - Cup: $5.95
Chicken Tortilla - Bowl: $7.95
SALADS:
Garden Salad: $10.95
Hill Country Salad: $11.95
Baby Bleu Salad: $11.95
House Caesar: $11.95
Coco Shrimp Salad: $17.95
Cobb Salad: $17.95
Side Garden Salad: $6.95
Side Hill Country Salad: $7.95
Side Baby Bleu Salad: $7.95

Discount:

Get 10 Points Automatically in the Month of Your Birthday

Contact:

(970) 224-9691

Mon-Sat: 11am - 9pm
Sun: 10am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Choice City - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Food Image
Choice City - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Restaurant Exterior Image
Choice City - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - collage image(highlights)
Best American Restaurants in Fort Collins CO - Choice City video
CALL EMAIL

CHOICE CITY

(5.0 Score)
104 West Olive Street,
Fort Collins, CO 80524 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

✓Patty Melt ✓Blt ✓Tandoori Turkey Melt ✓Choice Philly ✓Beets & Greens ✓Chicken Caprese Sandwich ✓Best Damn Veg ✓Butter Chicken Parm Sandwich ✓Spicy Italian ✓the Black & Blue ✓the Classic ✓Reuben ✓Choice Couscous ✓Choice Club ✓Ld - Tandoori Turkey Melt ✓Ld - Butter Chicken Parm ✓the Og Breakfast ✓Hot Honey Chicken

“ 2026 Highlights: Choice City serves fusion comfort food in a trendy, historic setting at the Armstrong Hotel. They use premium choice meats, perfectly seasoned, and are famous for the Choice City Burger alongside old world wines and craft cocktails. They offer a unique breakfast menu and local craft beers. Their artisan desserts are made fresh daily, perfect for a sweet treat after a great meal. Choice City's kitchen uses fresh ingredients to make the food extra tasty. Their juicy steaks and pork shanks are cooked in a lively environment. Free street parking is available. Their Choice City Burger features quality beef with gourmet toppings on a fresh bun. They also serve breakfast, lunch, and dinner in Old Town Fort Collins. ”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20021295300

Menu:

SANDWICHES:
Blt: $16.00
Tandoori Turkey Melt: $17.00
Choice Philly: $20.00
Chicken Caprese Sandwich: $19.00
Best Damn Veg: $19.00
Butter Chicken Parm Sandwich: $17.00
Spicy Italian: $19.00
The Classic: $19.00
Reuben: $18.00
Choice Club: $18.00
Patty Melt: $19.00
Ld - Butter Chicken Parm: $18.00
Ld - Bacon City Grilled Cheese: $18.00
Ld - Tandoori Turkey Melt: $18.00
LUNCH SPECIALS:
Hot Honey Chicken: $16.00
Beat The Heat Burger: $19.00
Strawberry Chamomile Ice Cream: $7.00
Ld - Butter Chicken Parm: $18.00
Ld - Bacon City Grilled Cheese: $18.00
Ld - Tandoori Turkey Melt: $18.00
THE BURGERS:
Beat The Heat Burger: $19.00
The Choice City: $20.00
The Black & Blue: $20.00
The Og Breakfast: $20.00

Contact:

(970) 490-2489

Mon,Wed-Sun: 11am - 9pm
Tue: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Food Image
The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - Restaurant Exterior Image
The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm - Fort Collins, CO American Restaurants - collage image(highlights)
Best American Restaurants in Fort Collins CO - The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm video
CALL EMAIL

THE FARMHOUSE AT JESSUP FARM

(4.9 Score)
1957 Jessup Drive,
Fort Collins, CO 80525 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

✓Scratch-Made Biscuits ✓Goat Cheese Caprese ✓Goat Cheese Bites ✓Truffle-Parm Brussels ✓Carnitas Tacos ✓Pork Belly Bites ✓Sausage and Mushroom Tarts ✓Minestrone ✓Tomato Soup ✓Farmhouse Salad ✓Caesar Salad ✓Rancher's Salad ✓Harvest Salad ✓Hanger Steak ✓Cassoulet ✓Pan Roasted Chicken Breast ✓Red Snapper ✓Brown Butter Salmon ✓53rd Street Chicken ✓Sweet Potato Gnocchi ✓Pappardelle ✓Fried Chicken Sandwich ✓Farmhouse Burger ✓Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake ✓Apple Cake ✓Dark Chocolate Brownie ✓Poached Pear Tart

“ 2026 Highlights: The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm serves rustic American farm-to-table food in a renovated farmhouse, along with craft cocktails and fresh baked goods. They use ingredients from their backyard garden, and their pork belly benny is served in a hot cast iron pan. They offer half-price wine bottles on Wednesdays. Their rich, scratch-made desserts are crafted daily, perfect for a sweet date night treat. The Farmhouse's chef uses seasonal local sourcing to make the food extra tasty. Their crispy fried chicken and burgers are cooked with care in a bustling kitchen. Be sure to try their biscuits and sandwich. Free lot parking is available. Their Fried Chicken Sandwich features a buttermilk battered breast with pickles and mayo on a bun. They serve at the Jessup Farm Artisan Village in Fort Collins. ”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #03-05132

Menu:

MAINS:
Hanger Steak: $36.00
Cassoulet: $32.00
Pan Roasted Chicken Breast: $25.00
Red Snapper: $30.00
Brown Butter Salmon: $30.00
53rd Street Chicken: $25.00
Sweet Potato Gnocchi: $24.00
Pappardelle: $24.00
Fried Chicken Sandwich: $18.00
Farmhouse Burger: $18.00
SWEET TREATS:
Pumpkin Pie Cheesecake: $9.00
Apple Cake: $9.00
Dark Chocolate Brownie: $9.00
Poached Pear Tart: $9.00
EXTRAS:
Avocado: $3.00
Fried Egg: $4.00
Bacon: $3.00
Grilled Chicken: $8.00
Chicken Tenders: $8.00
Grilled Salmon: $9.00
Pork Belly: $9.00
Steak: $9.00
Gluten Free Breadbun: $1.00
LARGE SALADS:
Rancher's Salad: $17.00
Harvest Salad: $17.00

Discount:

Get 50% Off during All Bottles of Wine during Happy Hour during Wednesday

Contact:

(970) 631-8041

Tue-Fri: 11am - 2pm|4pm - 8:30pm
Sat & Sun: 9am - 2pm|4pm - 8:30pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for The Farmhouse at Jessup Farm

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

AUSTIN'S AMERICAN GRILL REVIEWS

Popped in for a bite to eat whilst working in the area and the place was spot on. The food, the service and the atmosphere were perfect, could not fault the place. Ordered the coconut shrimp to start which were fat and succulent, had the New York Strip Steak for main which was perfectly cooked to my liking and they were happy to swap out the baked potato for the roasted garlic mashers. Would definitely eat here again.

It’s a great location in downtown. They cook the rotisserie right there and lop off your dinner cowboy style! Fresh and delicious. Coconut shrimp always a winner. Service good and atmosphere is really pleasant.

If you like the bleu cheese, try the Brussels sprouts. The half sandwich combo (with soup or salad) is a great way to try a couple different menu items.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

CHOICE CITY REVIEWS

Gem of a place...Our food ran a little behind due to a large party before us, but it didn't bother us because the vibe felt right...They kept bringing us this delicious seasoned popcorn to keep us chewing while we waited...our server was kind and attentive...the flavors were thoughtfully combined on everything we had...my wife kept saying "I think this is the best meal I've had in Fort Collins"...and we've been out here 6 years...

We absolutely loved Choice City!!! From the food, to the most fabulous cocktails, to our server and angel, Dil!! We cannot wait to come back. Atmosphere, energy and hospitality is top tier!!.

What a fantastic meal. We ordered 2 different burgers and was impressed by the freshness and quality of the ingredients. I’m definitely putting this place on my to go to list.

THE FARMHOUSE AT JESSUP FARM REVIEWS

First time here and we will be back! Tge biscuits were delicious but the duck fat tater tots were spectacular!! Must try other things on the menu. After mimosas, biscuits and tots, I was completely full. Took my chicken and half a waffle home! Go and enjoy!.

Came here for brunch and everything was incredible food, drinks, service, atmosphere, and price are all 5/5. Will be back again.

Outstanding brunch spot. Good service, good food and good drinks. All you need is to bring the company.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

AUSTIN'S AMERICAN GRILL Total Inspection Points: 120/120
Acknowledgments: 10
Table Reservations: 10
Contact Info: 10
Gift Certificates: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Real Discounts: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 3.9K: 10
Video: 10
Extensive Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

CHOICE CITY Total Inspection Points: 119/120
Current Evaluation: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Gift Certificates: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 3.6K: 10
Video: 10
Extensive Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

THE FARMHOUSE AT JESSUP FARM Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Experience: 8
Current Evaluation: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Contact Info: 10
Gift Certificates: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Real Discounts: 10
Video: 10
Extensive Menu: 10
Table Reservation: 10