3 Best American Restaurants in McKinney, TX

Expert-recommended Top 3 American Restaurants in McKinney, Texas. All of our american cuisines actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

HARVEST AT THE MASONIC

215 North Kentucky Street,
McKinney, TX 75069 Directions

Since 2014

Specialities:

House Hamburger Chicken Fried Steak Wagyu Filet Ribeye Pork Tenderloin Duroc Porkchop Roasted Half Chicken Pork Carnitas Enchiladas Crispy Chicken Breast Summer Squash and Braised White Beans Creole Pan Seared Shrimp Blackened Striped Bass Pan Roasted Red Fish Crispy Catfish Deviled Eggs Pimento and Cheese Green Garden Hummus Beef Skewers Fried Shrimp Chef’s Seasonal Dip Oysters “half Shell” Cheese and Charcuterie Board Masonic House Serrano Caesar Beet and Spinach Salad Arugula and Fennel Salad White Chocolate Silk Pie Tiramisu Chocolate Ice Cream Sundae Lemon Goat Cheese Icebox Pie Apple Brown Betty

"Harvest at the Masonic offers fresh, seasonal American dishes made with locally sourced ingredients. Andrea Shackelford is the Executive Chef, and Roberto Garcia is the Sous Chef of the restaurant. The restaurant focuses on farm-to-table dining in Historic Downtown McKinney, using produce and products from local farms, including their own organic farm, Water Boy Farms. This farm supplies flowers, microgreens, honey from their beehives, and more to the restaurant. They make the most of every ingredient, turning leftovers into preserves, powders, or even making their own sausage and stock. The restaurant also has three private dining spaces for special events and offers a unique atmosphere with functional artwork, like pickling jars and drink infusions. There is free parking, and you can buy gift cards. They also provide dine-in and in-store pickup.

2026 Highlights: Harvest at the Masonic Chef Dre’s Room accommodates up to 48 guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0803861645

Menu:

Ranch
House Hamburger $17
Chicken Fried Steak $21
Wagyu Filet $55
Ribeye $50
Farm
Pork Tenderloin $26
Duroc Porkchop $36
Roasted Half Chicken $23
Pork Carnitas Enchiladas $19
Crispy Chicken Breast $19
Summer Squash & Braised White Beans $17
Water
Creole Pan Seared Shrimp $21
Blackened Striped Bass $25
Pan Roasted Red Fish $27
Crispy Catfish $23
Smalls
Deviled Eggs $9
Pimento & Cheese $11
Green Garden Hummus $12
Beef Skewers $13
Fried Shrimp $18
Chef’S Seasonal Dip $12
Boards
Oysters “Half Shell” $18
Cheese & Charcuterie Board $22
Greens And Grains
Masonic House $11
Serrano Caesar $11
Beet & Spinach Salad $12
Arugula & Fennel Salad $11
Sweets
White Chocolate Silk Pie $8
Tiramisu Chocolate Ice Cream Sundae $10
Lemon Goat Cheese Icebox Pie $8

Contact:

(214) 726-0251

Tue-Thu: 5pm- 10:30pm
Fri: 5pm - 12am
Sat: 10:30am - 2:30pm|5pm - 12am
Mon & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SUGARBACON PROPER KITCHEN

216 West Virginia Street, Suite 101,
McKinney, TX 75069 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

Ribeye Tacos Short Rib Sandwich Sugarbacon Hot Chicken Sandwich B.l.t. Proper Burger Short Rib Shrimp and Grits Gulf Scallops Roasted Chicken Chicken Fried Steak Chicken Fried Chicken Beef Tenderloin Pasta Seared Salmon Bone-in Pork Chop Creamy Chicken Pesto Pasta Filet Strip Ribeye Tomahawk Fried Green Tomatoes Deviled Eggs Hushpuppies Crab Cake Escargot Gold Rush Queso Lone Star Flatbread Texas Steak Bites Sugarbacon Mac and Cheese Grilled Asparagus Housemade Cheddar Grits Crispy Brussels Sprouts Truffle Fries

"Sugarbacon Proper Kitchen serves New American dishes with a Southern twist, along with cocktails, beer, and wine. Benjamin R is the manager of the restaurant. The restaurant is located in a building that was once a service station for over 80 years. Now, it’s been transformed into a modern, vibrant spot that brings fresh energy to Historic Downtown McKinney. They have a modern, cozy vibe with great atmosphere and friendly service. The restaurant offers a chef-driven menu with top-notch service in a relaxed and welcoming setting. There is a parking lot right in front, plus free street parking nearby. Their popular dishes include Ribeye Tacos, Deviled Eggs, and their signature Sugarbacon. They also serve happy hour food and great cocktails.

2026 Highlights: Sugarbacon Proper Kitchen private party that can accommodate up to 40 people."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0803841041

Menu:

Handhelds
Ribeye Tacos $16
Short Rib Sandwich $18
Sugarbacon Hot Chicken Sandwich $17
B.L.T. $15
Proper Burger $19
EntréEs
Short Rib $28
Shrimp & Grits $23
Gulf Scallops $30
Roasted Chicken $26
Chicken Fried Steak $26
Chicken Fried Chicken $23
Beef Tenderloin Pasta $23
Seared Salmon $28
Bone-In Pork Chop $28
Creamy Chicken Pesto Pasta $18
Steaks
Filet 6 Oz $35
Filet 10 Oz $49
Strip 10 Oz $35
Strip 16 Oz $52
Ribeye 14 Oz $54
Starters
Fried Green Tomatoes $12
Deviled Eggs $9
Hushpuppies $10
Crab Cake $16
Escargot $15
Gold Rush Queso $14
Lone Star Flatbread $16
Texas Steak Bites $16
Sugarbacon $13
Sides
Mac And Cheese $9
Grilled Asparagus $8
Housemade Cheddar Grits $7
Crispy Brussels Sprouts $12
Truffle Fries $8

Contact:

(469) 631-0075

Mon-Thu: 4pm - 9pm
Fri: 4pm - 10pm
Sat: 10am - 10pm
Sun: 10am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

LOCAL YOCAL BBQ & GRILL

350 East Louisiana Street,
McKinney, TX 75069 Directions

Since 2018

Specialities:

Wood Grilled 6oz Wagyu Sirloin Gulf Shrimp and Grits Smoked Chicken Fried Steak Loyo Mac N’cheese Add Chopped Brisket Brisket Plate Ribs Plate Brisket and Ribs Plate Turkey Plate Sausage Plate Add Another Meat The Hamilton the Og Loyo Burger the Texan Caprese Steak Sandwich Chili Crisp Chicken Sandwich Smoked Turkey Sandwich Ham and Cheese Croissant Smoked Onion Dip The Pickles and The Pig Smoked Red Pepper Pimento Cheese Hummus Loyo House Hydromaine Caesar Health-Nut Grain Bowl Ranch House Chopped

"Local Yocal BBQ & Grill offers a true Texas dining experience, focusing on beef and serving down-to-earth, delicious food made with care. This is a family-owned business with a lot of heart and passion behind every meal. They are committed to quality, sustainability, and sharing the stories behind their food. Their menu features seasonal, chef-driven dishes made with locally grown produce, plus classic favorites. You can reserve a table for a home-cooked meal, a warm welcome, and enjoy one of the best bars in the area. They also offer catering for events, and you can treat someone to a gift card for a special surprise. Their Grilled Summer Peaches dish features sweet, grilled peaches paired with creamy burrata, fresh watercress, pickled red onions, and fennel, all drizzled with a light lemon-lavender vinaigrette. The restaurant also offers online orders and outdoor seating. They also serve great cocktails.

2026 Highlights: Local Yocal BBQ & Grill also provides local craft beer on tap."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0802294839

Menu:

Specialties
Wood Grilled 6oz Wagyu Sirloin $27
Gulf Shrimp & Grits $22
Smoked Chicken Fried Steak $18
Loyo Mac N’Cheese $11
Add Chopped Brisket $8
Bbq Meats
Brisket Plate $25
Ribs Plate $21
Brisket & Ribs Plate $27
Turkey Plate $21
Sausage Plate $19
Add Another Meat $8
Sandwiches
The Hamilton $21
The Og Loyo Burger $16
The Texan $17
Caprese Steak Sandwich $22
Chili Crisp Chicken Sandwich $16
Smoked Turkey Sandwich $17
Ham & Cheese Croissant $16
Starters
Smoked Onion Dip $13
The Pickles And The Pig $18
Smoked Red Pepper Pimento Cheese $14
Hummus $12
Salads
Loyo House $6
Hydromaine Caesar $7
Health-Nut Grain Bowl $17
Ranch House Chopped $18
Brunch
Steak & Eggs $32
Brisket Bruncheladas $18
Country Benedict $17
Chicken & Waffles $18
Brisket Hash $16

Discount:

Get $5 for Dark & Stormy

Contact:

(469) 225-0800

Tue-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 11pm
Sun: 10:30am - 8pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: