ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED ROCHESTER, NY SANDWICH SHOPS

3 Best Sandwich Shops in Rochester, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Rochester, NY. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

DiBella's Italian Market - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
DiBella's Italian Market - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
DiBella's Italian Market - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

DIBELLA'S ITALIAN MARKET

(4.9 Score)
620 Jefferson Road, Henrietta,
Rochester, NY 14623 Directions

Since 1918

Specialty:

✓ Godfather ✓ Turkey ✓ Build Your Own - Pick Two Meats ✓ Italian Meatball ✓ Build Your Own - Pick Three Meats ✓ the Cowboy ✓ Veggie ✓ Dibella's Cheesesteak ✓ Buffalo Chicken ✓ Dibella's Blt ✓ Dagwood ✓ Chicken Bacon Ranch ✓ Chicken Philly ✓ Italian Assorted ✓ Uncle Louie ✓ Albacore Tuna Salad ✓ Roast Beef Classic

“DiBellas Subs is a family-owned company with a reputation for quality, value, and consistency that has slowly developed into an Italian import and deli shop. Their fresh-baked bread is at the core of every sandwich. DiBella subs are custom-made right before your eyes. Each sandwich starts at the store's in-house bakery, with freshly baked bread is constantly baked during the day, offering the customer the freshest roll they've possibly ever had. The staff prepares each sandwich using the finest quality meats, cheeses, and condiments, complemented by the option of delicious toppings. They are also happy to cater your next business meeting, party, or any other special occasion.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Subs
Build Your Own - Pick One Meat $8.09
Godfather $8.09
Turkey $8.09
Build Your Own - Pick Two Meats $8.09
Italian Meatball $8.79
Build Your Own $8.09
The Cowboy $9.49
Veggie $8.09
DiBella's Cheesesteak $8.79
Buffalo Chicken $8.79
DiBella's BLT $8.79
Dagwood $8.09
Chicken Bacon Ranch $9.49
Chicken Philly $8.79
Italian Assorted $8.09
Uncle Louie $8.09
Albacore Tuna Salad $8.79
Roast Beef Classic $8.09
Cheese $8.09
Spicy Italian Sausage $8.79
Specialty Salads
Garden Salad $12.69
Antipasto Salad $15.39
Chicken Caesar Salad $15.99
Chicken Bacon Ranch Salad $15.99
Buffalo Chicken Salad $15.99
Turkey Club Salad $15.99

Contact:

(585) 475-1831

Mon-Wed: 10am - 8pm
Thu-Sat: 10am - 9pm
Sun: 11am - 7pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Magnolia's Deli & Cafe - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
Magnolia's Deli & Cafe - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
Magnolia's Deli & Cafe - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
CALL EMAIL

MAGNOLIA'S DELI & CAFE

(4.8 Score)
366 Park Ave,
Rochester, NY 14607 Directions

Since 2003

Specialty:

✓ the Faraday ✓ the Audobon ✓ the Beverly ✓ the Calumet ✓ the Dartmouth ✓ Miss Mary Mac ✓ Mr. Pine ✓ the Rodeo ✓ Harvest Drive ✓ Forestport

“Magnolia's is a family-owned and operated restaurant that has been bringing high-quality food in a relaxed atmosphere to the popular Park Avenue area in Rochester, NY. Their casual dining atmosphere and friendly staff ensure you have a memorable visit every time. They offer gluten-free options for all of their sandwiches, pizzas, and flatbreads, along with a wide variety of vegetarian and vegan choices. As the demand for fresh, quality meals has grown, they decided to expand the café and phase out the deli to provide their customers with the exceptional service they deserve. They love dogs and now offer a special dog menu during the summer months on the patio.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Breakfast
Toast $1.50
Croissant $2.99
Fruit Cup $8.25
Vanilla Yogurt Parfait $9.25
Tropical Yogurt Parfait $9.25
Quiche $14.99
Breakfast Sandwiches
The Faraday $5.99
The Audobon $7.50
The Beverly $7.50
The Calumet $7.50
The Dartmouth $7.50
Miss Mary Mac $8.99
Breakfast Specialty Paninis
The Eastern $9.50
The Western $9.50
Up North $9.50
Down South $9.50
Waffle Sandwiches
Mr. Pine $9.50
The Rodeo $9.50
Harvest Drive $9.50
Forestport $9.50

Contact:

(585) 271-7380

Mon-Wed: 11am - 4pm
Thu & Fri: 11am - 8pm
Sat: 10am - 8pm
Sun: 10am - 4pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef - Rochester, NY Sandwich Shops
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL

AMIEL'S SUBS & ROAST BEEF

(4.8 Score)
3047 West Henrietta Road,
Rochester, NY 14623 Directions

Specialty:

✓ Gyro Sub ✓ Original Assorted ✓ Italian Assorted ✓ Jr's Club Sub ✓ Custom Sub ✓ Genoa Salami ✓ Luncheon Meat ✓ Hot Ham ✓ Capicolla ✓ Ham ✓ Turkey ✓ Smoke House Turkey ✓ real Roast Beef ✓ Tuna ✓ Seafood ✓ Meatball ✓ Vegetarian ✓ Cheese ✓ Roast Beef

“Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef is committed to giving you an unforgettable sandwich experience. They offer tasty food at a reasonable price to their customers. Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef shop has plenty of seating and parking spaces. The sandwich shop serves delicious food that uses quality ingredients and unique signature sauces. They offer all types of hot and cold subs, along with soups and sides. In addition, the beverage selection is expansive, including bottled drinks and fountain drinks. If you're in Rochester and want a delicious sandwich, this is your place. They offer tasty food at a reasonable price to their customers.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

BeefAMiel
BeefAMiel $10.31
BeefWCheese $10.55
Double W/ Cheese $12.95
Double BeefWWorks $13.19
BeefWWorks $10.79
Double BeefAMiel $12.71
Hot Subs
Gyro Sub $10.79
Cajun ChickAMiel $10.55
Buffalo ChickAMiel $10.79
Chicken Parmagiana $10.79
Meatball $10.43
Chicken CordonBleu $10.79
BBQ ChickAMiel $10.55
French Dip $10.79
Chipolte ChickAMiel $10.79
ChickAMiel $10.55
Cold Subs
Seafood Salad $10.55
Turkey Breast $10.55
Amiel Sr’s Original Assorted $10.31
Chicken Salad $10.79
Italian Assorted $10.55
Cooked Salami $10.31
Hot Ham $10.43
Smoked Turkey $10.43
Vegetarian $9.35
Bernie's Favorite $10.55
Custom Sub $10.55
Ham $10.43
Cheese $10.31
Luncheon Meat $10.31
Real Roast Beef $10.79

Contact:

(585) 427-0770

Mon-Sat: 10am - 8pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Amiel's Subs & Roast Beef

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

DIBELLA'S ITALIAN MARKET REVIEWS

Phenomenal sandwiches! Bread is high quality with a fantastic chew, meat was shaved thin and piled high, and don’t forget to add the oil! Game changer! After multiple days in a row of heavy meals, we wanted something fresh but delicious, and these hit the spot perfectly. My husband and I each had a 7” Old Fashioned and our son had an 7” Uncle Louie. Plenty of food and easily some of the BEST sandwiches we have ever had.

DiBella’s is my absolute favorite sub shop in New York. They have the coziest atmosphere, the tastiest food at a good price, and some delicious sides. The people at this location are ALWAYS very friendly and I love coming in.

Good sandwiches - both hot & cold. Bread is delicious. Worth stopping by if you're in the area. Be prepared to wait as sandwiches are made to order.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

MAGNOLIA'S DELI & CAFE REVIEWS

Love Magnolia's! The host and waitress were both so kind and funny, so service was definitely very enjoyable. I love the vibe of Magnolia's too- a nice sidewalk cafe with lots of drink options, both non-alcoholic and alcoholic. The cheesecakes and other baked goods definitely tempted my boyfriend and I and I'm excited to dig into our cheesecake that we got to go. I had a half sandwich, half house salad and it was the perfect portion. The fat free raspberry dressing was so delicious. My boyfriend got the Izudin sandwich as well as a side of pasta salad. He said he wasn't even that hungry but still at the hole thing. Will definitely be back.

The food was very good. We all had sandwiches and enjoyed them a great deal. One person in our party had the cherry soda and really enjoyed that. We went on Mother's Day for a late lunch and it was still very busy, so the andwiches took a while to come to the table. In a very cute area of Rochester

We love Magnolia's! The food is so delicious. The service is great. They were very friendly, attentive and made sure our table was clean and not cluttered. Our food arrived quickly and fresh. This is great place for a quick bite or to catch up with friends for a bit. They also have delicious daily specials. I choice to get the Chicken Bacon Ranch Flat Bread - YUM! we will definitely be back.

AMIEL'S SUBS & ROAST BEEF REVIEWS

This is a 5-star for the food. Excellent freshly baked bread every day is a game changer here. All you have to do is get the original sandwich on seed bread with all the free toppings (make sure to get the spicy mustard) and you’re set. The dine in experience is nothing to write home about so just take it to go. Staff is all very friendly.

I’m a sub lover and Amiels is the best! Love the original assorted sub with original bread. I love everything about their subs. I always ask for extra lettuce because it’s shredded perfectly. Tuna subs are amazing too. It’s like stepping back in time when you walk into their restaurant. The service is great. I highly recommend Amiels !! 5 stars for sure.

The smoked turkey + roast beef sub with all the toppings is great! Just thinking about the spicy peppers makes me hungry. Love the old fashioned interior as well. Great vibes and good staff.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

DIBELLA'S ITALIAN MARKET Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Complete Info: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 3.0K: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

MAGNOLIA'S DELI & CAFE Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Complete Info: 9
Contact Info: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 2.3K: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

AMIEL'S SUBS & ROAST BEEF Total Inspection Points: 114/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Complete Info: 9
Contact Info: 9
Pricing: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 1.3K: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10