ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED NEW HAVEN, CT BAGEL SHOPS

3 Best Bagel Shops in New Haven, CT

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bagels in New Haven, Connecticut. All of our bagel shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Olmo - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
Olmo - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
Olmo - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
Best Bagel Shops in New Haven CT - Olmo video
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

OLMO

(5.0 Score)
93 Whitney Avenue,
New Haven, CT 06510 Directions

Since 2018

Specialty:

✓ Bagel With Schmear ✓ Bagel With Butter ✓ Lox With Love ✓ Egg With Sandwich (No Cheese) ✓ Egg and Cheese ✓ Bacon Egg and Cheese Sausage Egg and Cheese ✓ Turkey Egg and Cheese ✓ Pastrami Egg and Cheese ✓ Olmo Blt ✓ Hot Turkey & Okonomiyaki

“Olmo offers original New Haven bagels and a charming indoor and outdoor seating arrangement, creating a pleasant atmosphere for customers. Committed to freshness, they bake a fresh batch of bagels every four hours, ensuring a delightful taste. By using the finest ingredients, Olmo enhances the flavor of their bagels, creating a truly exceptional experience. Their menu is thoughtfully crafted, and the friendly staff makes every customer feel like family. Customers can enjoy freshly baked bagels, babka trays, half a dozen lunch sandwiches, and cookie platters. The dedicated team at Olmo provides excellent service, ensuring a memorable visit.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

CLASSIC BAGEL SANDWICHES
Buttered Bagel $2.80
Bagel w Schmear $4.00
Egg Sandwich $4.80
SPECIALTY SANDWICHES
Market Special $10.00
Spicy Deluxe $10.50
Lox With Love $13.75
Okonomiyaki $7.75
Hot Turkey $14.00
Olmo BLT $12.10
Health Nut v2.0 $9.80
DRINKS
Hot Organic Coffee $3.00
Cafe Au Lait $3.00
Cold Brew $4.00
Hot Tea $3.00
London Fog $3.00
Arnold Palmer $3.75
Yuzu Lemonade $3.75
Black Iced Tea $3.75
Hibiscus Iced Tea $3.75
Sparkling Water $2.25
Bottled Water $2.00
Farm Chocolate Milk $4.25
Jarritos $2.50
BULK BAGELS / SCHMEAR
Solo Bagel $2.00
Half Dozen Bagels $10.00
Baker’s Dozen $20.00
Tub of Schmear $7.00
SIDES
Latke $1.75
Blueberry Muffin $3.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie $2.00
Community Chips $2.50

Contact:

(203) 624-3373

Mon-Thu: 7am - 2pm
Fri-Sun: 7am - 4pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Bruegger's Bagels - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
Bruegger's Bagels - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
Bruegger's Bagels - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BRUEGGER'S BAGELS

(4.9 Score)
1 Whitney Avenue,
New Haven, CT 06510 Directions

Since 1983

Specialty:

✓ Single Bagel Without Cream Cheese ✓ Big Bagel Bundle ✓ Cream Cheese Tubs ✓ Baker's Dozen ✓ Brunch Box ✓ Bagel Bundle and Half Dozen ✓ Sriracha Honey Sunrise ✓ Sausage and Cheese ✓ Smokehouse Brisket Egg ✓ Turkey Sausage and Cheese ✓ Skinny Bacon ✓ Avocado and Tomato Egg White ✓ Egg and Cheese ✓ Ham and Cheese ✓ Pastrami ✓ Egg and Swiss ✓ Skinny Zesty Egg White

“Bruegger's Bagels is famous for its authentic New York-style kettle-boiled and stone-hearth-baked bagels, made with simple ingredients. They are committed to baking authentic New York-style bagels in small batches throughout the day. Alongside their signature handcrafted beverages, snacks, and sandwiches, they serve a variety of espresso-based drinks made from locally roasted coffee beans. Every day, they make their bagels from scratch using traditional ingredients and kettle-boiling techniques, creating a dense, chewy interior with a crisp exterior. Bruegger's Bagels provides catering services for weddings, parties, corporate events, and meetings.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

SIDES & DESSERTS
Blueberry Muffin $3.39
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.39
Sea Salt Kettle Chips $2.59
Twice Baked Hashbrown $2.59
JUICES & MORE
Bottled Diet Coke $4.39
Orange Juice Small $6.09
Bottled Water $3.79
Bottled OJ $4.49
Bottled Coke $4.39
EGG SANDWICHES
Egg Turkey Sausage Cheese $8.29
Bacon Avocado Tomato Egg White $9.69
Smokehouse Brisket Egg $9.99
Egg Ham Cheese $8.29
Sriracha Honey Sunrise $8.99
Double-Stack $10.59
Pastrami Egg Swiss $8.89
Farmhouse $9.59
Egg Cheese $7.59
Western $9.09
Egg Sausage Cheese $8.29
Egg Peppered Bacon Cheese $8.29
Vermonter $9.59
SIGNATURE LUNCH SANDWICHES
Western Brisket $11.89
Smoked Salmon $11.89
Leonardo Da Veggie $9.89
Hot Pastrami $10.49
Herby Turkey $10.29
FRESH-BAKED BAGELS
Baker’s Dozen $17.99
Half Dozen Bundle $14.99
Bagels 3 $6.89

Contact:

(203) 773-3199

Mon-Sun: 6am - 2pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

A.M. Bagel - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
A.M. Bagel - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
A.M. Bagel - New Haven, CT Bagel Shops
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

A.M. BAGEL

(4.8 Score)
111 New Haven Avenue, Derby,
New Haven, CT 06418 Directions

Since 2019

Specialty:

✓ Blueberry ✓ Cheddar ✓ Cinnamon Raisin ✓ Egg ✓ Egg Everything ✓ Everything ✓ French Toast ✓ Garlic ✓ Jalapeno Cheddar ✓ Multigrain ✓ Multigrain Everything ✓ Onion ✓ Poppy ✓ Plain ✓ Rye ✓ Salt ✓ Sesame ✓ Whipped Cream Cheese ✓ Scallion Cream Cheese ✓ Weekly Special Cream Cheese ✓ Bagel with Cream Cheese ✓ Bagel with Scallion Cream Cheese ✓ Bagel with Specialty Cream Cheese ✓ Bagel with Butter

“A.M. Bagel is a small, family-run shop located in the Bradley Pond Professional Center. The owners, Myron and Alexis Seniw, are deeply grateful for the community's support and continuous outpouring of love. They believe that exceptional taste comes from using natural ingredients and baking everything from scratch. Each bagel at A.M. Bagel is carefully rolled, boiled, egg-washed, topped, and baked to perfection, creating a crispy exterior and soft interior. Their commitment to quality is evident in their small-batch production, with all bagels made from scratch daily. A.M. Bagel offers a variety of cream cheese spreads to complement their flavorful bagels. As a delightful gesture, they offer customers a complimentary cookie, which is an experimental creation with a dense texture and a cinnamon and vanilla flavor.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review
Connecticut Magazine's Best of Connecticut (Winners) in 2021,2022 & 2023

Price:

BAGELS
Bagel $1.25
1/2 Dozen Bagels $7.00
Bakers Dozen Bagels $14.00
SPREADS
Whipped Cream Cheese $3.50
Scallion Cream Cheese $4.00
Weekly Special Cream Cheese $4.00
SANDWICHES
Bagel With Cream Cheese $2.75
Bagel With Butter $2.00
COFFEE
Hot Coffee $1.79
Iced Coffee $2.50

Contact:

(203) 305-7296

Wed-Fri: 7am - 12pm
Sat & Sun: 8am - 12pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for A.M. Bagel

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

OLMO REVIEWS

I love going to Olmo because they're so welcoming and reliable, but the market specials like the St. Patrick's Day corned beef always keep you on your toes. You never know what unusual tasty combo you'll find when you go in!

This place is a must-visit for any bagel enthusiast. The store offers a range of flavors that are anything but average. We tried The Brick, the Hot Turkey, a classic bacon, egg, and cheese, and a bagel with a smear of spicy scallion cream cheese. Each one had a distinct and exceptional flavor. The bagels were fresh and hot, with the perfect amount of chew. The service is great, though it can be a bit confusing with people waiting in the doorway. Just walk past them and order at the kiosk or from the friendly employee at the back of the store. Overall, it’s well worth a try!

Olmo Bagels in New Haven is an absolute must-visit! I ordered a half dozen this past weekend, and every bagel I tried was incredible. The mobile ordering process was seamless — I was able to bypass the line and pick up my order right off the shelf, which made the experience super convenient.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

BRUEGGER'S BAGELS REVIEWS

I had a fantastic experience at this bagel shop! I had the vegetarian sandwich, and it was absolutely delicious – fresh, flavorful, and packed with tasty ingredients. The bagels were amazing too; I grabbed a few to take home, and they were just as good the next day. The staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was warm and inviting. If you’re in the area, this place is definitely worth a visit for both a great meal and to stock up on some of the best bagels around! Highly recommend.

Awsome place , it lives up to it's name . They have all kinds of bagels you can think of and bagels you didn't even know existed lol. The cream cheese they sell for the bagels is soooo good. I highly recommend the honey walnut cream cheese.

Always a nice group of employees working here. It's nice to sStopped in for a quick bite before visiting Yale with my son who just loves bagels. There was a fresh batch of bagel coming out of the pizza oven and WOW what an aroma! It was the closest thing to heaven. My son had a bacon egg on bagel and I had to sample the everything with cream cheese and chives with fresh coffee. Yum! That’s it! The staff was warm and friendly. Looks like they do advance ordering and have a dedicated pickup area. Street parking is metered. ee everyone so excited to help make your food. Always a pleasure to come here and enjoy the food and service. Highly recommend.

A.M. BAGEL REVIEWS

The best bagel in CT and outside of NY. Very light and airy on the inside, with a nice crisp outside. I usually like to grab a few of the day old bagels they have for sale and I freeze them. It still holds up in quality after being defrosted and toasted.

Simply the best bagels! They have the perfect ratio of chewiness to softness, with a nice crispy top. Their sandwiches are great and the specials are so creative and never disappoint. Even though the line is out the door, don't worry-they get everyone through very quickly! And get there early!

Wow the best bagel I’ve ever had!! Definitely get there early! They change the bagels, cream cheese and specialty sandwich every week/day which is awesome! ALSO great coffee! I recommend

TBR® Inspection Score Report

OLMO Total Inspection Points: 119/120
Reviews Accuracy of : 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Variety of Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

BRUEGGER'S BAGELS Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Reviews Accuracy of : 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Variety of Menu: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

A.M. BAGEL Total Inspection Points: 114/120
Experience: 8
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Location Proximity: 9
Reviews Accuracy of : 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Pricing: 10
Variety of Menu: 10