3 Best Bagel Shops in New Haven, CT

“Olmo offers original New Haven bagels and a charming indoor and outdoor seating arrangement, creating a pleasant atmosphere for customers. Committed to freshness, they bake a fresh batch of bagels every four hours, ensuring a delightful taste. By using the finest ingredients, Olmo enhances the flavor of their bagels, creating a truly exceptional experience. Their menu is thoughtfully crafted, and the friendly staff makes every customer feel like family. Customers can enjoy freshly baked bagels, babka trays, half a dozen lunch sandwiches, and cookie platters. The dedicated team at Olmo provides excellent service, ensuring a memorable visit.”

Read more

“Bruegger's Bagels is famous for its authentic New York-style kettle-boiled and stone-hearth-baked bagels, made with simple ingredients. They are committed to baking authentic New York-style bagels in small batches throughout the day. Alongside their signature handcrafted beverages, snacks, and sandwiches, they serve a variety of espresso-based drinks made from locally roasted coffee beans. Every day, they make their bagels from scratch using traditional ingredients and kettle-boiling techniques, creating a dense, chewy interior with a crisp exterior. Bruegger's Bagels provides catering services for weddings, parties, corporate events, and meetings.”

Read more

“A.M. Bagel is a small, family-run shop located in the Bradley Pond Professional Center. The owners, Myron and Alexis Seniw, are deeply grateful for the community's support and continuous outpouring of love. They believe that exceptional taste comes from using natural ingredients and baking everything from scratch. Each bagel at A.M. Bagel is carefully rolled, boiled, egg-washed, topped, and baked to perfection, creating a crispy exterior and soft interior. Their commitment to quality is evident in their small-batch production, with all bagels made from scratch daily. A.M. Bagel offers a variety of cream cheese spreads to complement their flavorful bagels. As a delightful gesture, they offer customers a complimentary cookie, which is an experimental creation with a dense texture and a cinnamon and vanilla flavor.”

Read more