3 Best Bagel Shops in New Haven, CT

“Olmo offers original New Haven bagels and a charming seating arrangement indoors and outdoors, providing a pleasant atmosphere for customers. Committed to freshness, they bake a fresh batch of bagels every four hours, ensuring their delightful taste. By utilizing the finest ingredients, Olmo enhances the flavor profile of their bagels, creating a truly exceptional experience. Their menu is thoughtfully crafted, and the friendly staff makes every customer feel like a valued family member. Olmo takes pride in their unique and well-balanced menu, featuring an array of house-made preparations. Customers can enjoy freshly baked bagels, babka trays, half-dozen lunch sandwiches, and cookie platters. The dedicated team at Olmo provides excellent service, ensuring customers have a memorable visit.”

Read more

“Bruegger's Bagels is famous for their authentic New York-style kettle-boiled and stone hearth-baked bagels, made with only five simple ingredients. Bruegger's Bagels is a friendly neighborhood café nestled in the heart of New Haven. They are still committed to baking authentic New York-style bagels in small batches all day long. They serve a variety of espresso-based beverages made from locally roasted coffee beans, as well as signature handcrafted beverages, snacks, and sandwiches. Bruegger's Bagels offers catering services for weddings, parties, events, and meetings. All their bagels are made from scratch every day using traditional ingredients and kettle-boiling techniques to produce a dense, chewy inside with a crusty exterior.”

Read more

“A.M. Bagel is the partnership of Alexis Pollina and Myron Seniw. Both individuals share a deep passion for hospitality, food, health, and fitness, which led to the creation of this shop. This shop is located in Bradley Pond Professional Center. Each bagel at A.M. Bagel is carefully rolled, boiled, egg-washed, topped, and baked to perfection, resulting in a crispy exterior and a soft interior. Their commitment to quality is evident in the small-batch production, with all bagels being made from scratch daily. A.M. Bagel offers a wide selection of cream cheese spreads to complement their flavorful bagels. As a delightful gesture, they even provide customers with a complimentary cookie, an experimental creation featuring a cinnamon and vanilla-forward dense cookie. The owners of A.M. Bagel understand that exceptional taste can only be achieved by utilizing natural ingredients and baking everything from scratch.”

Read more