3 Best Cakes in New Haven, CT

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in New Haven, Connecticut. All of our cake shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SUGAR BAKERY

424 Main Street, East Haven,
New Haven, CT 06512 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Chocolate Vanilla Red Velvet Strawberry Chocolate and Vanilla Chocolate Chip Cookies and Cream Oreo Golden Oreo Cannoli Pistachio Cannoli Cookie Butter Nutella Raspberry Chocolate German Chocolate Lemon Meringue Neapolitan Confetti Party Time Chocolate Party Time Strawberry Cheesecake Cookies and Cream Cheesecake Reese's Cheesecake Cannoli Cheesecake Cookie Butter Cheesecake Flourless Chocolate Torte Strawberry Dream Strawberries and Cream Dubai Chocolate OCCASIONS: Birthday Wedding Anniversary Graduation Baby Shower Gender Reveal Sports Celebrations (soccer Hockey) Custom Parties

Sugar Bakery offers a wide variety of cupcakes and cakes with options for custom orders and cookie flavors. The cake shop specializes in creating delightful treats for various occasions, including weddings, birthdays, graduations, baby showers, and more. Sugar Bakery is committed to delivering the highest quality cakes made with fresh and natural ingredients. Their friendly staff ensures that cupcakes are baked fresh daily and that every customer receives exceptional service. The cake shop offers gift vouchers and pick-up cakes for weddings and special events at the bakery. Gluten-free and vegan options are also available at the cake shop.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #0842807

Menu:

CLASSIC CAKES:
Flourless Chocolate Torte $38.95
Cookie Butter Cheesecake $45.00
Reese'S Cheesecake $45.00
Cannoli Cheesecake $45.00
Dot Cake From $45.00
Classic Strawberry Shortcake From $45.00
Dubai Chocolate Cake From $100.00
Holy Cannoli From $75.00
Holy Pistachio Cannoli Cake From $85.00
Classic Pistachio Cannoli From $60.00
Cookie Butter Cake From $65.00
Strawberry Dream Cake From $65.00
Nutella Dream Cake From $65.00
Classic Golden Oreo Cake From $45.00
Classic Oreo Explosion Cake From $45.00
Classic White And Black Cake From $40.00
Classic Black And White Cake From $40.00
Raspberry Chocolate Drip Cake From $60.00
Classic Simply Vanilla Cake From $40.00
Classic Simply Chocolate Cake From $40.00
The Matteo From $45.00
Classic Confetti Cake From $45.00
Classic Party Time Cake From $45.00

Contact:

(203) 469-0815

Mon & Sat: 9am - 3pm
Tue-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

KATALINA'S BAKERY

74 Whitney Avenue,
New Haven, CT 06510 Directions

Since 2011

Specialities:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Vanilla Chocolate Red Velvet Carrot Lemon Coconut Lavender Raspberry Nutella Peanut Butter Vanilla Buttercream Chocolate Buttercream Cream Cheese Lemon Curd Strawberry Coffee Buttercream OCCASIONS: Birthday Wedding Baby Shower Bachelorette Party Team Building Club Outings Retirement Party Anniversary Custom Celebrations

Katalina's Bakery offers a range of delicious treats such as cupcakes, brownies, pastries, and coffee. The cake shop provides cakes in various sizes and decorations, suitable for any occasion. Their team makes your special day more memorable with their stunning, handcrafted, premium celebration cakes for all events. All their cakes are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and are free from chemical additives, artificial colors, and other substances. Katalina's Bakery also has a wide selection of cupcakes available for last-minute needs, and their cake makers can provide a quote for customized orders. Katalina's is the ideal place to satisfy your cravings while supporting a socially responsible business.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #1030609

Menu:

CAKE SLICE:
Cake Slice $7.28
Cheesecake $7.02
Coffee Cake $6.18
Pumpkin Cake $6.18
CUPCAKES:
Cupcakes $3.90
Gluten Free Cupcake $5.20
Vegan Cupcake $4.16
COOKIES:
Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.89
Chocolate M&M Cookie $3.89
Coconut Shortbread Cookie $3.89
Ginger Cookie $3.89
Madelines $2.60
Oatmeal Cookie $3.89
Oreo & Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.89
Peanut Butter Cookie $3.89
Wedding Cookie $2.60
Sugar Cookie $3.89
Paleo Cookie $3.90
Mexican Wedding Cookies $2.60
BROWNIES:
Brownies $3.89
Cookie Dough Brownies $6.18
Raspberry Brownie $4.68
Vegan Brownie $3.90
BREAD:
Bread Pudding $4.68
Bread Slice $3.89
Loaf Of Bread $18.72
BARS:
Magic Bars $6.18
Raspberry Almond Bars $6.18
Raspberry Oatmeal Bars $6.18
Lemon Bar $6.18
UNCATEGORIZED:
Box Of Joe $40.88

Contact:

(203) 891-7998

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5pm
Sat: 10am - 2pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

TOUS LES JOURS

831 Chapel Street,
New Haven, CT 06510 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Chocolate Triple Chocolate Mocha Vanilla Strawberry Red Velvet Green Tea Mango Blueberry Lemon Sweet Potato Cheesecake Tiramisu London Fog (Earl Grey) Mixed Fruit Orange Cream Peach Cream Heart Choco OCCASIONS: Birthday Wedding Anniversary Baby Shower Graduation Valentine's Day Mother's Day Father's Day Christmas New Year Children's Parties Holiday Celebrations

Tous Les Jours is a French-Asian bakery that offers unique bakery products and beverages made with the highest quality ingredients. The cake shop offers a wide range of bakery items that are perfect for any occasion. From freshly baked bread to other decadent cakes and pastries, each of their products is made with the finest ingredients and the utmost care. Their skilled bakers create a wide array of delicious treats that are freshly baked and ready to be enjoyed by their customers seeking exceptional taste and quality. They bake every day to provide fresh products using the finest ingredients to produce not only a number of baked goods but also quality baked goods. Tous Les Jours prides itself on sourcing and using carefully selected ingredients and is committed to bringing freshness and quality to their customers.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

CAKE:
Cloud Cake #3 $46.00
Green Tea Cloud Cake #6 $44.20
Green Tea Cloud Cake #2 $44.20
Mocha Cloud Cake #6 $46.00
Mocha Cloud Cake #4 $46.20
Strawberry Cloud Cake #5 $46.20
Strawberry Cloud Cake #3 $47.40
Strawberry Gateau #1 $44.20
Red Velvet Cake #2 $50.40
Strawberry Yoghurt $51.00
Triple Chocolate Mousse #1 $45.20
Vanilla Cloud Mousse Cake #1 $46.20
Cheese Cake #5 $45.00
Heart Choco Cake #2 $44.20
London Fog Cake $44.20
Party Bear Cake #7 $47.80
Pinkberry Strawberry Tiramisu $47.80
Pinkberry Tiramisu #7 $37.40
Tiramisu Cake #2 $44.20
Berry Berry Cake #4 $52.20
Classy Spring Cake #3 $52.20
Jungle Party Cake #2 $51.00
Mango Cloud Cake #1 $53.00
Mango Cloud Cake #4 $53.00
Mango Cloud Cake #2 $53.00
Mango Cloud Cake #6 $53.00
Mango Cloud Cake #8 $53.00

Discount:

Get a free butter or chocolate chip cookie for your sign up in the app

Contact:

(203) 745-5639

Mon-Sun: 7:30am - 8:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report: