3 Best Bakeries in Akron, OH

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bakeries in Akron, Ohio. All of our bakeries actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

11+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

THE WEST SIDE BAKERY

2303 West Market Street,
Akron, OH 44313 Directions

Since 1995

Specialities:

Almond Banana Chocolate Chip Chip Funfetti Lemon Pumpkin Red Velvet Spice Strawberry Carrot German Chocolate Hazelnut Torte Walnut Torte Caramel Chocolate Coffee Funfetti Hazelnut Lemon Peanut Butter Raspberry Strawberry Toffee White Chocolate Apricot Preserves Cherry Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Ganache Chocolate Mousse Cream Cheese Lemon Curd Mocha Oreo Pineapple Raspberry Preserves Strawberry Preserves

" The West Side Bakery is a simple bakery that offers a variety of pastries, desserts, and standard lunch items, including vegetarian options. They pride themselves on making high-quality products and bringing joy and pleasure to their communities. Their staff is skilled at making airy and fluffy sourdough bread and consistently delivers high-quality products. They use local and seasonal ingredients to create all their pastries from scratch. Their consistent quality and taste make every item they offer delicious. The West Side Bakery provides freshly baked goods, delicious pastries, and unique, artistically decorated cakes, including wedding cakes. Prepaid curbside pickup is available at The West Side Bakery. The bakery is located in Pilgrim.

2026 Highlights: The West Side Bakery offers custom 2D and 3D-shaped cakes, with pricing based on design complexity, cake flavor, and filling."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Bakery in 2010-2014
Best Chocolate Cake 2021, 2019, 2018, 2017, 2016, 2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010, 2009, 2008, 2004 by Akron Life Magazine

Menu:

Custom Cakes
4" Cake $20
6" Cake $34
8" Cake $46
10" Cake $66
12" Cake $90
14" Cake $116
14 Sheet Cake $58
12 Sheet Cake $94
Full Sheet Cake $176
Signature Cakes
Traditional Signature Cakes
4" Cake $22
6" Cake $36
8" Cake $52
10" Cake $74
12" Cake $98
14" Cake $128
14 Sheet Cake $64
12 Sheet Cake $104
Full Sheet Cake $194
Deluxe Signature Cakes
4" Cake $24
6" Cake $40
8" Cake $56
10" Cake $80
12" Cake $108
14" Cake $140
14 Sheet Cake $68
12 Sheet Cake $112
Full Sheet Cake $214
Custom Cupcakes
Regular Cupcake $3.00
Jumbo Cupcake $5.00
Vegan Cupcake $3.50
Wedding Height Cakes
4" Cake $32
6" Cake $50
8" Cake $68
10" Cake $98
12" Cake $136
14" Cake $174
14 Sheet Cake $88
12 Sheet Cake $144

Contact:

(330) 836-4101

Mon-Sat: 8am - 5pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

6+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

SWEET MARY'S BAKERY

76 East Mill Street,
Akron, OH 44308 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

Cinnamon Rolls Lemon Poppy Buns Croissants Scones Coffee cake Big Chewy Cookies Frosted Sugar Cookie Cut-Outs French Macarons Blondies and Brownies Cake (Slice) Cake of the Month Bagels Buttermilk Biscuits Focaccia Croissant Fourre Quiche Housemade Chicken or Egg Salad Sandwiches Pastries

" Sweet Mary's Bakery was owned by Mary Hospodarsky. The bakery is a community-driven micro-bakery specializing in from-scratch pastries, macarons, cheesecake, cookies, and other items baked fresh daily in-house with quality ingredients. Sweet Mary's Bakery offers handmade specialty baked goods. They primarily use all-natural and, whenever possible, local and organic ingredients. Everything is made by hand, in-house, and strictly from scratch. They prioritize working with local suppliers and merchants to support the local community and offer the best possible products to their customers. The bakery's bread, pastries, and sandwiches are all exceptional, and their friendly staff is always ready to assist customers. Sweet Mary's Bakery offers open weekends with a full traditional espresso menu, and specialty drinks.

2026 Highlights: Sweet Mary's Bakery makes fresh baked goods daily from scratch and by hand in small batches."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pastries
Croissants $5.25
Crullers $3.75
Danish $4.50-$6
Pecan Sticky Buns $4.75
Cinnamon Rolls $4.50
Vegan Buns $4.75
Scones $4.25
Coffeecake $3.50, $30
Cookies
Big Chewy Cookies $3-$3.75
Frosted Sugar Cookie Cut-Outs $4.75
French Macarons $3.50, $40
Blondies & Brownies Varies
Cakes & Pie
Cheesecake $6.50-$8.95, $65-$80
Sheet Cake $4.25
GF Cake By The Slice Varies
Pie Of The Week Varies
Savory Options
Bagels $2.65
Buttermilk Biscuits $4-$5
Sausage Gravy $4.50
Egg & Cheese Breakfast Sandwich $9
Cream Cheese & Lox Bagel $12.75
Quiche $5.95-$6.95, $32-$38
Focaccia $4
Savory Croissants $7
Egg Salad Sandwich $8
Chicken Salad Sandwich $12
Specialty Coffees, Teas & Cocoa
Chai Latte $4.50
Matcha Latte $4.50
Fudgy Cocoa $5, $6
Salted Caramel Latte $6

Contact:

(234) 706-6088

Wed-Sun: 9am - 3pm
Mon & Tue: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

SANABEL MIDDLE EAST BAKERY

308 East South Street,
Akron, OH 44311 Directions

Since 1973

Specialities:

Sanabel Pita Sanabel Wheat Tabbouleh House Yogurt Falafel Kafta Chicken and Garlic Shawarma Baklava 1 Piece Rice Pudding Kibbeh Hummus Baba Ghanouj Grape Leaves Peas and Rice Rice With Chicken Lentils and Rice Meat Pies Spinach Pies Spinach and Feta Tomato and Feta Spicy Beef Chicken Pie Cheese Bread Zaatar Bread Zaatar Sandwich

" Sanabel Middle East Bakery is a bakery that serves sandwiches and side dishes along with weekday specials at this casual restaurant. They take pride in baking fresh pita bread every morning and making pastries with the freshest, carefully sourced ingredients. Their staff is committed to delivering high-quality pastries and satisfying customers' needs. They use slow fermentation to create bread with a great texture and deeper flavor. Their pies change regularly but are flavorful and made with high-quality ingredients. Sanabel Middle East Bakery offers Mediterranean dishes to their customers. The bakery also provides catering services for weddings, birthdays, and corporate events.

2026 Highlights: Sanabel Middle East Bakery prepares fresh pita, zaatar, and fatayer from scratch."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pita Bread
Sanabel Pita $2.50
Sandwiches
Falafel $8.99
Kafta $9.50
Chicken & Garlic $9.50
Shawarma $9.99
Dessert
Baklava 1 Piece $1.50
Rice Pudding $3.50
Essentials
Kibbi $2.99
Hummus $7.99
Baba Ghanouj $7.99
Grape Leaves $6.99
From The Oven
Meat Pies $5.75
Spinach Pies $5.50
Spinach & Feta $5.75
Tomato & Feta $5.75
Spicy Beef $5.75
Chicken Pie $5.75
Cheese Bread $5.75
Zaatar Bread $5.75
Zaatar Sandwich $2.99

Contact:

(330) 253-4505

Mon-Sat: 11am - 3pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: