Sugar Bakery

Sugar Bakery is a cozy bakery owned by Carol and Brenda, serving dozens of flavors of cupcakes and cakes, with custom orders and cookie favors available. Sugar Bakery is one of the Three Best Rated® Cakes in New Haven, CT.

BEST RATED NEW HAVEN CAKES SUGAR BAKERY

Since 2004

424 Main Street, East Haven, New Haven, CT 06512

4.8 (114)

CALL CONTACT

Contact Business

Video

Reviews

I am not into cupcakes at all but someone recommended this place hence wanted to try. It was worth the hype. Loved the cupcakes .. they were so yumm!! Bought some macarons as well but were too sweet for my taste! Store is very cute! Have variety of cupcakes to choose from! Highly recommend this place for cupcakes.

We're regular Sugar customers because we can't get enough of their incredible cupcakes, so it made sense to use them for our wedding! We transported 13 dozen cupcakes to VT in the middle of August and came home with NONE. Our guests couldn't get enough and Sugar yet again lived up to their stellar reputation. Beautifully done and so delicious!

I didn’t even know they were winners of an episode of cupcake wars! It definitely shows!!!! Such great cupcakes, even the gluten free ones. Delicious and made with love and care. The bakery has a little stationery and gift store up front too.