3 Best Caterers in Rochester, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Caterers in Rochester, NY. All of our caterers actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

3+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

BATTATINI'S CATERING

2305 Portland Avenue,
Rochester, NY 14617 Directions

Since 2014

Specialities:

✓Chicken French ✓Homemade Meat Sauce ✓Pasta Salad ✓Lasagna Roll-Ups ✓Sausage ✓Macaroni Salad ✓Homemade Red Sauce ✓Chicken Parm w/ Fettuccine Alfredo ✓Oven Roasted Potatoes ✓Stuffed Shells ✓Baked Italian Chicken ✓Salt Potatoes ✓Alfredo Sauce ✓Roasted Mixed Vegetables ✓Penne w/ Broccoli and Mozzarella ✓Chicken Parmesan or Cutlets ✓Potato Salad ✓Lasagna (Meat or Cheese) ✓Homemade Meatballs ✓Artichoke French ✓Eggplant Parmesan ✓OCCASIONS: Corporate Events and Meetings ✓Family Parties ✓Business Luncheons ✓Baby and Bridal Showers ✓Fundraising Events ✓Social Gatherings ✓Weddings ✓Bereavements/Celebration of Life ✓Graduation Parties

" Battatini's Catering is a family-style catering service offering Italian fare, BBQ specials, and sandwiches for parties and lunches. The catering menu is packed with homemade items you can order by the tray, including Italian favorites. They provide their clients with various options to suit their tastes and budgets. Battatini's Catering offers three family-style buffet pricing levels, each with multiple dishes that can create the perfect menu for your event. They also offer buffet options with a range of trays and platters perfect for smaller events or those needing a more selective menu. Battatini's Catering provides an assortment of mouth-watering pasta, sauces, meats, sides, specialty salads, and so much more. Their entire catering menu is available for order by the tray. Customers can choose from full trays, half trays, or platters.

2026 Highlights: Battatini's Catering has 10 years of experience, and they have a wide range of options to suit all palates and dietary requirements."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Buffet Option One per Person $15
Buffet Option Two per Person $17
Buffet Option Three per Person $19
BBQ Special $18
Wedding Combination $21
Dessert Trays $60
Family-Style Buffet Combo:
Per Person Starts From $15
Appetizers:
Full Tray $100
Half Tray $60
Pasta:
Full Tray $100
Half Tray $60
Meals:
Full Tray $120
Half Tray $60
Specialty Salads:
Full Tray $65
Half Tray $40
Platters:
Full Tray $100
Half Tray $65
Combos:
Full Tray $160
Half Tray $80
Sides:
Full Tray $85
Half Tray $50
BBQ Options:
Full Tray $120
Half Tray $60

Contact:

(585) 544-3663 (212) 921-2888

Open 24 Hours

TBR® Inspection Report:

8+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

MADELINE'S CATERING

565 Blossom Road, Suite L,
Rochester, NY 14610 Directions

Since 1990

Specialities:

✓Vegetable Crudités with Hummus ✓Imported and Domestic Cheeses with Fresh Fruit Garnish and Crackers ✓Brie en Croûte with Raspberry Coulis topped with Berries ✓Grilled Vegetable Platter with Balsamic Glaze *served cold ✓Hummus ✓Baba Ganoush ✓Pita Chips ✓Olives ✓Caprese Platter ✓Farmhouse Cheddar Terrine topped with Dried Cherries ✓Charcuterie Board with Crostinis ✓Assorted Sushi ✓OCCASIONS: Weddings ✓Private Dinners ✓Anniversaries ✓Gala Fundraisers ✓Social Events ✓Rentals ✓Bar and Bat Mitzvahs ✓Picnics ✓Birthday and Holiday Parties ✓Engagement Proposals ✓Bartending ✓Grand Openings ✓Baby Showers ✓Fashion Shows ✓Graduations

" Madeline's Catering is a full-service catering company that provides customizable menus for weddings and other events. Madeline Neville is the founder. The company has a team of highly skilled chefs, servers, and event coordinators committed to providing unforgettable culinary experiences for your guests. Madeline's Catering offers a diverse range of menus and services that can be tailored to meet your specific needs and preferences, from simple snacks and lunch buffets to full-service meals that include hand-passed and stationary appetizers, plated entrées, and bar service staff. Madeline's Catering is also hosting business breakfast meetings and wedding events.

2026 Highlights: Madeline's Catering is located in the Blossom Business Center. They have served thousands of clients and guests, and handle over 700 events a year. They can handle bar services for any catered event. They have numerous menu options that cater to all kinds of dietary restrictions."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #3662227

Price:

Buffet Menu (Per Person Pricing):
Corn Hill Buffet $15.75
South Wedge Buffet $19.50
Rochester Dinner Buffet $20.50
The Browncroft Buffet $29.95
East Ave. Dinner Buffet $35.50
Lunch:
Cold Lunch:
Homemade Soup & Field Green Salad $15.50
Assorted Wraps $16.95
Assorted Panini Sandwiches $17.25
Field Green Salad Station $16.50
Boxed Salad $15.25
Assorted Sandwiches:
With Pasta Salad $14.50
With Homemade Soup $15.50
Hot Lunch:
Taco Station $16.95
Pasta Station $15
Chicken French Station $17
Fajita Rice Bowl Station $17
Mediterranean Rice Bowl Station $19
Chicken Parmesan Station $17
BBQ Pulled Chicken $15.50
Honey Mustard Pulled Chicken $15.50

Contact:

(585) 288-3020 (585) 615-7753

Mon-Sun: 9:30am - 5:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

CHEF'S CATERING

1875 North Union Street, Spencerport,
Rochester, NY 14559 Directions

Since 2011

Specialities:

✓Herb Crusted Prime Rib ✓Chicken French ✓Scalloped Potatoes ✓Italian Sausage Stuffing ✓Baked Pasta Marinara ✓Honey Glazed Carrots ✓Honey Brined Turkey Breast w/ Gravy ✓Garlic Mashed Potatoes ✓Green Bean Casserole ✓Roasted Butternut Squash ✓Chicken Avocado ✓Chef’s Burger ✓BBQ Pulled Pork ✓Black Bean & Corn Fritter ✓Slider Buns ✓Chipotle Ranch Kettle Chips ✓Macaroni Salad ✓OCCASIONS: Weddings ✓Rehearsals ✓Product Launches ✓Lunches ✓Holiday Parties ✓Cocktail Parties ✓Corporate Events ✓Exclusive Sit-Down Dinners ✓Anniversaries ✓Birthday Celebrations ✓Baby and Bridal Showers ✓Award Ceremonies ✓Grand Openings ✓Gala Dinners ✓Engagement Proposals

" Chef's Catering has specialized in custom catering for events, from weddings and banquets to weekly functions. The office is located 11.4 miles away from Rochester, NY. Michael D. Zazzaro is an executive chef who has been working in the food service industry for over 25 years. Chef's Catering provides a wide range of cuisines, including American, Italian, and Asian, as well as gluten-free, dairy-free, and vegetarian options. They also offer an ever-changing menu of fresh, gourmet meals to satisfy all taste buds. Chefs can travel and create freshly prepared menu items with their top-of-the-line food trailer and food truck. Chef's Catering is very flexible and can create custom menus tailored to your preferences.

2026 Highlights: Chef's Catering offers a variety of catering services in Rochester, NY, and surrounding areas."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Food Truck in 2024
Best Caterer in 2023 & 2024
License #7210036

Price:

Lunch & Dinner:
Deluxe Buffet $27
Classic Buffet $21
Italian Buffet $25
BBQ Buffet $25
Picnic Buffet $18
Grazing $28
Stations $34
Asian Inspired Buffet $18
Trash Plate Buffet $18
Cold Cuts & Deli Display $15
Cookout Buffet $18
Taco Bar Buffet $18
Slider Station Buffet $20
Greek Gyro Buffet $20
Thanksgiving Theme Buffet $28
Classic Holiday Buffet $34
Cocktail Holiday Party $30
Dessert:
Dessert Trays:
Small $85
Medium $105
Full-Size Cupcakes:
Per Dozen $40
Cannoli Per Dozen:
Large $25
Small $20
Cheesecake Bites $4.25
Ganache Brownie Squares $4
Large Chocolate Chip Cookies $3

Contact:

(585) 752-2149

Mon -Fri: 8am - 5pm
Sat: 9am - 2pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: