3 Best Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins, CO

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Fort Collins, Colorado. All of our italian restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

6+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

OLIVE GARDEN ITALIAN RESTAURANT FORT COLLINS

3905 South College Avenue,
Fort Collins, CO 80525 Directions

Since 1982

Specialities:

Las Parmigiana Toasted Ravioli Spinach-artichoke Dip Shrimp Fritto Misto Chicken Alfredo Calabrian Steak and Shrimp Bucatini Chicken Scampi Eggplant Parmigiana (v) Shrimp Scampi Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo Homemade Soups Large (serves 12) Homemade Soups (serves 6) Homemade Soups (single Serving) Breadsticks (v) Chocolate Lasagna (v) Black Tie Mousse Cake (v) Strawberry Cream Cake (v)

"Olive Garden Italian Restaurant Fort Collins is a family-friendly chain Italian restaurant that offers pasta, pizza, starters, sides, and desserts. This includes classic entrees such as Chicken Parmigiana, Fettuccine Alfredo, and salads. Enjoy their oven-baked pasta Chicken Tortelloni Alfredo, Five Cheese Ziti al Forno, Three-Meat Manicotti, and Four-Cheese Manicotti. Olive Garden Italian Kitchen Fort Collins provides vegan-friendly options. Complete your meals with their desserts such as Chocolate Lasagna, Black Tie Mousse Cake, and Tiramisu. Try their family-size pan of your favorite dish or pick up a complete family bundle. The restaurant offers special gift cards.

2026 Highlights: They offer nutrition and allergen details on their website, helping customers make informed choices that suit their dietary requirements and preferences."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #11-70100-0018

Menu:

CREATE YOUR OWN PASTA:
Create Your Own Pasta $13.99
APPETIZERS:
Calabrian Hot Honey Chicken Bites: $10.99
Fried Mozzarella: $8.79
Stuffed Ziti Fritta: $8.99
Calamari: $12.29
Lasagna Fritta: $11.29
Meatballs Parmigiana: $11.29
Toasted Ravioli: $9.79
Spinach-Artichoke Dip: $10.99
Shrimp Fritto Misto: $13.29
CLASSIC ENTREES:
Chicken Alfredo: $20.49
Calabrian Steak & Shrimp Bucatini: $23.79
Chicken Scampi: $21.79
Eggplant Parmigiana (V): $18.49
Shrimp Scampi: $21.29
Calabrian Steak & Shrimp Bucatini: $23.79
Steak Gorgonzola Alfredo: $22.29
HOMEMADE SOUPS:
Homemade Soups Large (Serves 12): $29.99
Homemade Soups (Serves 6): $19.29
Homemade Soups (Single Serving): $8.79
Breadsticks & Dipping Sauces:
Breadsticks (V): $4.49
DESSERTS:
Chocolate Lasagna (V): $9.79

Discount:

Get 5% Off for When You Purchase from $500-$999

Get 10% Off for When You Purchase from $1000-more

Contact:

(970) 225-3803

Sun-Thu: 11am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 11pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

RARE ITALIAN

101 South College Avenue,
Fort Collins, CO 80524 Directions

Since 2014

Specialities:

Finochietta Soppressata Coppa Calabrese Mortadella Castelvetrano Olives Pickled Vegetables Peperonata Candied Nuts Onion Dip Arancini Prince Edward Island Mussels Shrimp Bruschetta Calamari Fritti Carpaccio Di Manzo Margherita Pizza Prosciutto Pizza Toscano Pesto Pizza Rare House Salad House Caesar Steakhouse Wedge Salad Steak Salad Vegan Eggplant Parmesan Grilled Chicken Alaskan Halibut Veracruzana

"RARE Italian is a Classic Italian restaurant that is located in a modern space featuring exposed brick, a large communal table and a patio, offering a warm and welcoming space for guests to gather and enjoy. Their menu is deeply inspired by travel experiences throughout central Italy; RARE showcases a rustic, farm-to-table culinary approach featuring traditional dishes and flavors commonly found in the regions of Umbria and Tuscany. The restaurant offers fresh, homemade pasta and cheeses, some of the best in-house dry-aged steaks in Northern Colorado, and an extensive selection of New World and Old World wines, chosen to pair perfectly with their authentic Italian dishes. RARE Italian accepts groups of 10 or more; please call the restaurant for reservations. They invite walk-ins for the dining room, bar, and patio. They also have a happy hour menu.

2026 Highlights: They offer handmade pastas, specialty cheeses, and a curated wine selection to complement their authentic Italian dishes."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20141529742

Menu:

Pasta & Risotto
Lasagne: $25.00
Pasta Primavera: $25.00
Pappardelle Al Ragù: $26.00
Carbonara: $27.00
Polpette Tajarin: $28.00
Shrimp Rigatoni: $28.00
Duck Ragù Gnocchi: $33.00
Lobster Risotto: $40.00
Black Truffle & Mushroom Ravioli: $44.00
Appetizers
Onion Dip: $13.00
Arancini: $14.00
Prince Edward Island Mussels: $17.00
Shrimp Bruschetta: $18.00
Calamari Fritti: $20.00
Carpaccio Di Manzo: $17.00
Margherita Pizza: $17.00
Prosciutto Pizza: $18.00
Toscano Pesto Pizza: $19.00
Entrees
Vegan Eggplant Parmesan: $26.00
Grilled Chicken: $31.00
Alaskan Halibut Veracruzana: $41.00
Seared Bay Scallops: $42.00
Burgers
Dry-Aged Smashburger: $20.00
Truffle Fries Add-On: $3.00

Contact:

(970) 294-4544

Dinner
Mon-Sun: 4pm - 9:15pm
Happy Hour
Mon-Fri: 4pm - 6pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

OREGANO'S

4235 South College Avenue,
Fort Collins, CO 80525 Directions

Since 1993

Specialities:

Alfredo The Dark The Original Bollo Pasta The Coop De Ville Jumbo Chick Parm El Diablo Pasta Lady Is A Scampi Stuffed Riga Tony Hakuna Piccata Zany Ziti Italian Flag Lasagna Julius Caesar Salad (big) Julius Caesar Salad (real Big) Simple House Salad (big) Simple House Salad (real Big) The Pablo Salad The Antipasto Thing Vino Bambino Oregano's Favorite The Big Beefstro Salad The Big Meatball Sandwich Our Chicago Italian Sausage Chick Parm Sandwich

"Oregano's is opened by Mark S. Russell, who took a simple philosophy about life from his father, "the key to happiness is friends, good food, and music. The restaurant provides Italian dishes serving a mix of thin crust and deep-dish pizzas in an easygoing setting. The Chefs use the finest ingredients to prepare mouth-watering dishes. Oregano's welcomes you to enjoy their free garlic or cheese bread and a tasty pizza cookie on your birthday. Oregano's has also served in Tempe, Scottsdale, Phoenix, and Mesa. The restaurant offers happy hour menus, and vegan and kids menus.

2026 Highlights: They offer party food portions for takeout, making it easy to serve guests at your own event. Customers can view the Party Food To Go menu and place an order request online."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #19984

Menu:

PASTA:
Ragin Cajun Chicken Pasta: $18.55
Big Rig Pasta: $16.55
Alfredo The Dark: $16.55
The Original Bollo Pasta: $12.55
The Coop De Ville Jumbo Chick Parm: $18.55
Stuffed Riga Tony: $15.55
Hakuna Piccata: $18.55
OVEN BAKED PASTA:
Zany Ziti: $16.55
Italian Flag Lasagna: $17.55
Tastes
Toasted Ravi-O-Li'S: $9.55
Cheese Chomps Plain: $9.55
Cheese Chomps Garlic Parm: $9.55
Cheese Chomps Dry Rub: $9.55
Kick Butt Garlic Bread (With Cheese): $7.75
Kick Butt Garlic Bread: $6.75
Italian Fried Zucchini: $10.75
Guaca-Tony: $9.95
Boom Dip: $12.55
Bistro Calamari: $10.95
Six Pack Shrimp: $10.95
Dessert
Pizza Cookie - Chocolate Chip: $8.55
Pizza Cookie - Peanut Butter & Chocolate: $8.55
Pizza Cookie - White Chocolate Macadamia Nut: $8.55

Discount:

Get $10 Off for When You Earn Every 150 Points

Get Free Kickbutt Garlic or Cheese Bread by Signing up The Kaboom Club

Contact:

(970) 449-6121

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri-Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report: