3 Best Pizza Places in Fort Collins, CO

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Fort Collins, Colorado. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

TOTALLY 80'S PIZZA & MUSEUM

2567 South Shields Street, Unit 4C,
Fort Collins, CO 80526 Directions

Since 2014

Specialities:

Create Your Own Pizza 8 Cheese Cream Cheese Is Made Of These Flamin' Hot Cheetos Frito Pie Garden Supreme Italian Specialty Maui Style Meat Lovers Milli Vanilli Green Chili New Wave Rave Nobody Calls Me Buffalo Chicken Philly Cheese Steak Rad Chicken Bacon and Garlic Totally 80s Supreme Ultimate Pepperoni Veg Out Yippee Ki Yay Mother Clucker BBQ Pepperoni Italian Sausage

"Totally 80's Pizza & Museum is a pizza restaurant serving creative specialty pizzas amid vintage toys and unique 1980s memorabilia. The restaurant is located in Raintree Village Shopping Center. The restaurant offers pizza, appetizers, sides, and salads. The team makes its own pizza dough and sauce with 14 herbs and spices. The Meat Lovers is a signature pizza topped with sausage, salami, crispy bacon, Canadian bacon, and melted mozzarella cheese on a gourmet crust. Customers can create their own pizza using a variety of toppings. Totally 80's Pizza offers a kids' menu.

2026 Highlights: Totally 80's Pizza & Museum offers 10-inch and 14-inch gluten-free pizza crust options, although it is not a gluten-free facility. Birthday guests receive a complimentary root beer float served in a color-changing souvenir cup along with an 80s birthday button. The restaurant features nostalgic memorabilia, retro entertainment, handmade pizza, and family-friendly dining. The owners took over a shuttered, freestanding Pizza Hut building and completely transformed it into the modern museum and parlor. Moving to this Shields Street location allowed the business to double its original size compared to its old Midtown strip-mall spot. This expansion created room for twice as much memorabilia, a dedicated retro arcade zone, a souvenir shop, and on-site parking large enough to host community gatherings like vintage DeLorean car shows."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20141455146

Menu:

CREATE YOUR OWN PIZZA:
Small 9" Pizza $9.20
Medium 12" Pizza $14.35
Large 14" Pizza $17.35
Extra Large 16" Pizza $19.50
PERSONAL SPECIALTY PIZZAS:
8 Cheese Personal $13.35
Cream Cheese Is Made Of These Personal $13.35
Flamin' Hot Cheeto Personal $13.35
Frito Pie Personal $13.35
Garden Supreme Personal $13.35
Italian Specialty Personal $13.35
Maui Style Personal $13.35
Meat Lovers Personal $13.35
Milli Vanilli Green Chili Personal $13.35
New Wave Rave Personal $13.35
Nobody Calls Me Buffalo Chicken Personal $13.35
Philly Cheese Steak Pizza Personal $13.35
Rad Chicken Bacon & Garlic Personal $13.35
Totally 80s Supreme Personal $13.35
Ultimate Pepperoni Personal $13.35
Veg Out Personal $13.35
Yippee Ki Yay Mother Clucker BBQ Personal $13.35
MEDIUM SPECIALTY PIZZAS:
8 Cheese Medium $21.60

Discount:

Get 10% off automatically on your entire bill when ordering directly through the Totally 80s Pizza website

Get Free Museum Entry for 1980s toys, memorabilia, and arcade displays

Contact:

(970) 867-5309

Mon: 4pm - 9pm
Tue-Thu & Sun: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 9:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BEAU JO'S FORT COLLINS

205 North College Avenue,
Fort Collins, CO 80524 Directions

Since 1973

Specialities:

Apple Harmony Bair Paw BBQ Pie Burger Combo Cajun Chicken Cordon Bleu Chip's Pie Dude Ranch Firecracker Hawaii BBQ Hipster Margherita Motherlode Pac Plant Pesto Chicken Sausage Combo Sky Hawk Veggie Combo Yukon Ham/Saus Combo Feisty Islander Little Italy Vegan Sausage Combo Plus Create Your Own Pizzas Pepperoni Italian Sausage Andouille Sausage Hamburger

"Beau Jo's Fort Collins is a chain specializing in Colorado-style, thick-crust pizza with a variety of sauces and calzones. The restaurant also offers salads, buffalo wings, nachos, pasta, calzones, and local Colorado beers. The pizza dough is prepared throughout the day using fresh ingredients and contains locally sourced honey as a natural sweetener instead of sugar. Beau Jo's Pizza Fort Collins offers lunch, dinner, and happy hour menus. The restaurant also has locations in Arvada, Denver, Evergreen, Idaho Springs, Lone Tree, and Steamboat Springs.

2026 Highlights: Beau Jo's accommodates group dining, banquets, private events, and fundraising activities. It also offers gluten-free and dairy-free options to accommodate different dietary needs. The restaurant is known for its Colorado-style Mountain Pie, honey-based dough, and customizable toppings. Beau Jo’s offers delivery, takeout, Gift Cards, and take-and-bake options too."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20131096539

Menu:

Xl5lb Specialty:
Xl5lb Sky Hawk $35.00
Xl5lb Hawaii BBQ $41.00
Xl5lb Hipster $35.00
Xl5lb Pesto Chicken $41.00
Xl5lb Motherlode $41.00
Xl5lb Dude Ranch $41.00
Xl5lb Firecracker $37.00
Xl5lb Pac Plant $37.00
Xl5lb Feisty Islander $37.00
Xl5lb Margherita $35.00
Xl5lb Sausage Combo $37.00
Xl5lb Burger Combo $37.00
Xl5lb Cajun $37.00
Xl5lb Vegansaus Combo $41.00
Xl5lb Chip's Pie $37.00
Xl5lb Yukon $37.00
Xl5lb Lil Italy $37.00
Xl5lb Veggie Combo $35.00
Xl5lb Hambsaus Combo $37.00
Md2lb Specialty:
Md2lb Hipster $19.00
Md2lb Cajun $22.00
Md2lb Vegansaus Combo $25.00
Md2lb Hawaii BBQ $25.00
Md2lb Veggie Combo $19.00
Md2lb Firecracker $22.00
Md2lb Margherita $19.00
Md2lb Motherlode $25.00
Md2lb Burger Combo $22.00
Md2lb Sausage Combo $22.00

Contact:

(970) 498-8898 (970) 329-9545

Mon-Thu & Sun: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 9:30pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM

4709 S Timberline Road,
Fort Collins, CO 80528 Directions

Since 1976

Specialities:

Chicago 7 Meat Me Double Deckeroni Farmer’s Daughter The Classic Thai Pie Veggie 7 Chicken Bacon Ranch Craft Your Own Pizza Pepperoni Italian Sausage Andouille Sausage Canadian Bacon Chicken Bacon Seasoned Ground Beef Red Onions Green Peppers

"Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a family-run restaurant featuring Italian entrees along with a wide beer selection. The restaurant provides a wide range of menu items, including Starters, Wings, Pizza, Calzones, Entrées, Handhelds, and Salads. All their pizzas are prepared with fresh, locally sourced ingredients. Try their Thai Pie, which is a bold fusion pizza topped with sweet Thai chili sauce, mozzarella, pepper jack, cheddar, roasted chicken, mushrooms, red peppers, broccoli, sesame seeds, green onions, and a drizzle of teriyaki sauce. Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Fort Collins offers a full bar, free Wi-Fi, a kids' menu, options for large parties, catering, and a patio area.

2026 Highlights: Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom participates in community activities through fundraisers, donations, youth sports sponsorships, team meals, and school programs. The restaurant offers Chicago-inspired scratch-made pizza, customizable toppings, an extensive craft beer selection, and classic taproom-style food in a sports-oriented neighborhood atmosphere."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #20201461366

Menu:

UNREAL PIZZA DEALS:
Party Pack For 4 $29.99
Party Pack For 6 $59.99
Pizza Party To-Go $125.00
STARTERS:
Firecracker Shrimp $14.99
Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls $12.49
Crispy Brussels & Cauliflower $9.99
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks $10.49
Twisted Tenders $12.49
Fried Pickles $9.49
Mozzarella Sticks $9.99
Spinach Artichoke Dip $11.99
Italian Nachos $14.99
Cheesy Dippin' Strips $10.99
Buffalo Chicken Rolls $12.49
CALZONES:
Chicago 7 Calzone $14.99
Chicago Fire Calzone $14.99
CRAFT YOUR OWN CALZONE:
Entrées:
Spicy Shrimp & Andouille Pasta $19.99
Fish & Chips $15.99
Grilled Lemon Butter Chicken $14.99
Spaghetti & Meatballs $15.49
Chicken Parmesan $16.99
Chicken & Bacon Mac $15.49
Nashville Hot Chicken Bacon Mac $16.49
Chicken Pesto Alfredo $16.99
Oh My Spaghetti Pie $15.49

Discount:

Get a Free Pizza on your birthday for members

Contact:

(970) 207-9456

Mon-Wed & Sun: 11am - 12am
Thu-Sat: 11am - 1am

TBR® Inspection Report: