3 Best Mexican Restaurants in Buffalo, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Mexican Restaurants in Buffalo, NY. All of our mexican restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

LA TOLTECA

7530 Transit Road,
Buffalo, NY 14221 Directions

Since 2009

Specialities:

Queso Blanco Dip Guacamole Choriqueso Dip Bola Chile Dip Chile Con Queso Dip Taco Salad Bowl La Casa Gf Salad Chicken Avocado Salad Mango Chicken Salad Tropical Shrimp Salad Grande Sampler Mexican Tapas Chori-fries Chiles Toreados Stuffed Jalapeños Shrimp Ceviche Mexican Shrimp Cocktail Botana De Camaron Fish Tacos Tamales

"La Tolteca delights its customers with a wide variety of authentic Mexican dishes and award-winning margaritas, all offered at reasonable prices. This trendy Mexican eatery creates a festive ambiance with vibrant paintings adorning the space. La Tolteca specializes in delivering true Tex-Mex flavor dishes at affordable prices. The restaurant menu showcases an array of mouthwatering options, including burritos, tacos, and nachos, ensuring there's something to please every palate. They take pride in using only the freshest ingredients in their culinary creations. They also have additional branches located in Wilmington, DE. Takeaway and delivery options are readily available for those seeking a convenient dining experience. The restaurant boasts a welcoming and lively atmosphere, adding to the enjoyment of your visit. Furthermore, La Tolteca offers catering for your special events and parties, ensuring a memorable and flavorful experience for your guests.

2026 Highlights: La Tolteca Buffalo brings the vibrant flavors of Mexico to Transit Road with a menu that combines traditional favorites and contemporary specialties."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

SPECIALTIES:
Simpatia Especial Chicken $13.99
Simpatia Especial Shrimp $15.99
Simpatia Especial Steak $14.99
Parrillada $36.99
Chimichangas $13.99
Chimichangas Shrimp $14.99
Brochetaalambre $16.49
Brochetaalambre Seafood $19.99
Taquitos Mexicanos $12.29
Carnitas $16.99
Chilaquiles $13.99
Puntas Al AlbañIl Chicken $15.99
BURRITOS:
Burritos Mexicanos $14.99
Burrito Grande Chicken $13.99
Burrito Grande Steak $14.99
Burritos Deluxe $13.99
Burrito Azteca (Chicken) $14.99
Burrito Azteca (Steak) $15.99
Burrito De Carnitas $15.99
Burrito Del Mar $17.99
Burritos Verdes $13.99
NACHOS:
Nachos SeñOr $11.99
Nachos Seafood $14.99
Nachos Roasted Pork $13.99
Nachos Supreme $14.99
Nachos Maravilla Chicken $13.99
Nachos Maravilla Steak $14.99

Contact:

(716) 565-0105

Mon-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm
Sun: 12am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

LLOYD TACO FACTORY

1503 Hertel Avenue,
Buffalo, NY 14216 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

Grilled Chicken Braised Beef Slow Roasted Pork Stewed Organic Black Bean Tacos El Camino Bowl Los Pollos Hermanos Burritos Tricked Out Nachos Reg Nachos Aztec Brownie Mexican Coca-Cola Jarritos Coors Banquet Bohemia Pilsner CBW Let’s Go Pils Rioja Crianza Pinot Noir and Cabernet Sauvignon

"Lloyd Taco Factory is Buffalo's pioneering food truck and restaurant. Owners Pete and Chris added quesadillas, side salads, and specialty offers to the menu. Its mission is to serve affordable, yet tasty, dishes to the people of Buffalo. Lloyd Taco Factory has been serving top-quality Mexican dishes. They are expanding their offerings with a street-style menu featuring organic black beans and antibiotic. and hormone-free meats. With a strong focus on quality, Lloyd continually expands the realm of what can be placed inside a corn tortilla. Outdoor seating is available, providing a delightful atmosphere to savor favorite foods. The restaurant also offers catering for special events and parties.

2026 Highlights: Lloyd Taco Factory continues to serve Buffalo through dine-in, takeout, catering, and food truck experiences for everyday meals and special events."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #4669180

Menu:

OLD SCHOOL:
Taco $4.09
Burrito $11.89
Tricked Out Nachos $12.89
El Camino Bowl $11.89
NEW SCHOOL:
Dirty South Taco $4.39
Dirty South Burrito $12.49
Crispy Fish Taco $4.39
Crispy Fish Burrito $12.49
Big Lloyd Taco $4.39
Big Lloyd Burrito $12.49
Skinny Thai Taco $4.39
Skinny Thai Burrito $12.49
SIDES:
Box Truck Caviar $5.29
Poppin’ Spring Rolls $6.49
Chorizo Mackin’ Cheese $4.99
Nashville Hot Mackin’ Cheese $4.99
Sticky Sprouts $6.49
Crack-Ed Potatoes $6.49
Reg Nach Chips $7.29
S’More Stuff:
Mother Clucker $13.29
Cortez Salad $7.99
Add Protein $4.49
Drunken Chicken Quesadilla $12.99
LLOYD CLASSICS:
Snozzberry Mule $13
Nautical Disaster $14
Green Hornet $14
Michelada (Mezcal) $14
SWEET:
Churros (One) $2.49
Churros (Six) $12.99
Aztec Brownie $3.69

Contact:

(716) 863-9781

Mon-Thu & Sun: 11am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 12am

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

CASA AZUL

191 Allen Street,
Buffalo, NY 14201 Directions

Since 2017

Specialities:

Carne Asada Baja Bowl Octopus Tostada Mushroom Huarache House Made Mole Chilaquiles Nachos Chips and Salsa Guacamole Queso Fundido Esquite Chorizo Taquitos Charred Caesar

"Casa Azul's menu encompasses both traditional and contemporary regional dishes, appealing to various culinary preferences. They take pride in preparing mouthwatering dishes and crafting fresh sauces, salsas, and tacos in-house daily. Casa Azul is open for lunch and dinner, providing ample opportunities to indulge in flavorful offerings. For those looking to cater an event, they offer comprehensive packages that include handmade tortillas, garnishes, and taco fillings. Vegetarian patrons will be delighted to find numerous options tailored to their preferences, making them a standout choice for those who appreciate vegetarian cuisine. Casa Azul offers outdoor seating, allowing guests to enjoy their favorite dishes in a delightful environment.

2026 Highlights: Casa Azul continues to be a favorite destination for modern Mexican cuisine in Buffalo, offering a colorful atmosphere, warm hospitality, and a thoughtfully crafted menu that brings guests together for memorable dining experiences."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

HOUSE SPECIALTIES:
Carne Asada $30.00
Baja Bowl $15.00
Octopus Tostada $18.00
Mushroom Huarache $17.00
House Made Mole $18.00
Add Chicken $4.00
Add Al Pastor $4.00
Add Beef Barbacoa $5.00
Pescado $24.00
Braised Pork Belly $17.00
STARTERS:
Chilaquiles 'Nachos' $16.00
Chips & Salsa $5.00
Guacamole $10.00
Queso Fundido $13.00
Esquite $9.00
Chorizo Taquitos $17.00
Charred Caesar $15.00

Contact:

(716) 331-3869

Mon-Thu: 4pm - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 12am
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: