The Best Sandwich Shops in Buffalo

Handpicked top 3 best sandwich shops in Buffalo, New York. 50-Point Inspection includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and their general excellence. You deserve the best!


194 Allen Street, Buffalo, NY 14201

Since 1981

Philly, Jim's Famous Hoagie, Frenchy, Diavlo, Chicken Cheese Steak, Jefferson, Steak in the Grass, Chicken in the Grass, Turkey Hoagie, Whiz, Cheeseburger Hoagie, Pulled Pork, Veggie Hoagie, Chicken Finger Sub, BBQ Chicken Finger Sub, Jim's Bleu, Stinger, Italian Sausage and Cheese Sub, Royal Sub, Cheeseburger Sub & Bacon Cheeseburger Sub

Taste Assorted Sub, Salami Sub and Capicola Sub - Serves Tuna Sub, Cheese Sub, 2 Finger Snack Pack and 5 Chicken Finger Dinner - Provides 8 Chicken Finger Dinner, 5 Boneless Wings, 10 Boneless Wings & 20 Boneless Wings

Price: Starts from $4


Sun - Thu 10:30 am - 5:00 am
Fri & Sat 10:30 am - 6:00 am


1518 Hertel, Buffalo, NY 14216

Since 1998

Forget About It Sandwich, Big Bird Sandwich, Uncle Guido Sandwich, Don Corleone Sandwich, Sammy the Bull Sandwich, Foot of Ferry Sandwich, Angelina Zooma Zooma Sandwich, Bugsy Siegel Sandwich, Golf Club Sandwich, It’s a Bella Vegalini Sandwich, My Way Sandwich, the Hertel Sandwich, Mama-Mia Sandwich, Big Johnson Sandwich & How-You-Doin Sandwich

Get Chef Salad for $35.50, Antipasto Salad for $49.99 and Deli Sandwich Platter for $57.99 - Try Wrap Tray for $57.99, Bronx Deli Delight for $64.95 - Provides Cookie Tray for $34.99, Half Cannoli Half Cookie for $44.99 & Cannoli Tray for $55.99

Price: Starts from $8.99


Mon - Thu 10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Fri & Sat 10:00 am - 9:00 pm
Sun 11:00 am - 5:00 pm


534 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14222

Since 2013

1322 Original Sandwich, Frank Stallone Sandwich, Muffuletta Sandwich, Tuna Melt Sandwich, Beef on Weck Sandwich, The Cutlet Sandwich, Rachael Ann Sandwich, Reuben Sandwich, Grilled Chicken Sandwich, 534 Elmwood Sandwich, Jimmy’s Cuban Sandwich, Hertel Alley Sandwich, Italian Beef Sandwich, I Love Josie Sandwich & The Hangover Sandwich

Try Homemade Soups Cup for $3.25, Cobb Salad for $11.75 and Build Your Own Salad - Buy Chicken Club for $8.99, Fisherman’s Sandwich for $8.99 and Cajun Shrimp BLT for $9.99 - Get Fish Taco for $8.99 & Sweet Potato Fries for $4.99

Price: Starts from $7.99


Mon - Sat 11:00 am - 9:00 pm
Sun Closed