ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED BUFFALO, NY SANDWICH SHOPS

3 Best Sandwich Shops in Buffalo, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Buffalo, NY. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Jim's STEAK OUT - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Jim's STEAK OUT - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Jim's STEAK OUT - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Best Sandwich Shops in Buffalo NY - Jim's STEAK OUT video
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

JIM'S STEAK OUT

(4.9 Score)
194 Allen Street,
Buffalo, NY 14201 Directions

Since 1981

Specialty:

✓ Steak and Veggie Hoagie ✓ 8 HOAGIES: Turkey Hoagie ✓ Jefferson ✓ Chicken Finger ✓ Jim's Bleu ✓ Stinger Sub ✓ Chicken Finger Sub ✓ Steak ✓ Cheeseburger ✓ Bacon Cheeseburger ✓ Sausage ✓ BLT ✓ Cheeseburger Subs ✓ Jim's Famous Steak Hoagie ✓ Jim's Famous Chicken Hoagie ✓ Hoagie Deluxe ✓ Philly ✓ Stinger Hoagie ✓ Frenchy ✓ Diavolo ✓ Veggie Hoagie ✓ BLT Sub ✓ Steak & Cheese Sub ✓ Italian Sausage & Cheese Sub ✓ Cheeseburger Sub ✓ Bacon Cheeseburger Sub ✓ Turkey Sub ✓ Ham Sub ✓ Ham & Turkey Sub ✓ Turkey Club Sub ✓ Tuna Sub ✓ Cheese Sub ✓ Grilled Chicken Sandwich ✓ 1/4 LB. Hamburger ✓ 1/4 LB. Cheeseburger ✓ 1/4 LB. Bacon Cheeseburger ✓ JR. Burger

"Jim's Steakout is committed to serving a diverse array of sandwiches at affordable prices. The restaurant is run by Jim, who concentrates on providing all of Elmwood's night owls with high-quality food, his new steak sauce, the renowned Chicken Finger Sub, and good service. The restaurant has 10+ very dedicated, skilled, and hard-working employees. The restaurant uses only high-quality, brand-name products to prepare as tasty a food as possible, and the hoagies are still made the same way he prepared them over 35 years ago. Their food is served fresh, hot, and fast in a convenient and fun environment. The sandwich shop also provides Philly cheese steaks, hoagies, and subs. There are many food choices available for people who prefer vegetarian meals.

2026 Update: Customers can order food for delivery or pick up their order directly from the sandwich shop. Guests can purchase a gift card to give as a present to family members or friends."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

12" Hoagies:
Steak Hoagie 12" $14.99
Steak Hoagie Deluxe 12" $15.99
Chicken Hoagie 12" $14.89
Philly 12" $13.99
Frenchy 12" $14.99
Diavlo 12" $14.59
Stinger Hoagie 12" $16.59
Jefferson 12" $14.99
Turkey Hoagie 12" $14.69
Veggie Hoagie 12" $13.99
8" Hoagies
Frenchy 8" $12.49
Diavlo 8" $11.69
Stinger Hoagie 8" $12.99
Jefferson 8" $12.49
Turkey Hoagie 8" $11.39
Veggie Hoagie 8" $10.49
12" Chicken Finger Subs
Chicken Finger Sub 12" $13.49
Jims Bleu Sub 12" $13.99
Stinger Sub 12" $15.59
6" Chicken Finger Subs
Chicken Finger Sub 6" $8.49
Jims Bleu Sub 6" $8.79
Stinger Sub 6" $10.39
6" Cold Subs
Tuna Sub 6" $7.99
Cheese Sub 6" $7.99
Chicken Fingers & Wings
2 Finger Snack Pack $8.99
5 Finger Dinner $14.99
8 Finger Dinner $19.99
5 Boneless Wings $6.09

Discount:

Get a 5% for Every Dollar Spent on Jim’s SteakOut Menu Items

Contact:

(716) 886-2222

Mon-Wed & Sun: 10:30am - 2am
Thu-Sat: 10:30am - 4am

TBR® Inspection Report:

Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Chris' NY Sandwich Co - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Best Sandwich Shops in Buffalo NY - Chris' NY Sandwich Co video
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL

CHRIS' NY SANDWICH CO

(4.8 Score)
395 Delaware Avenue,
Buffalo, NY 14202 Directions

Since 1990

Specialty:

✓ Ham ✓ Turkey ✓ Tuna ✓ Combo ✓ Corned Beef and Swiss Cheese ✓ Hawaiian Chicken Salad ✓ Smoked Turkey Dill Salad ✓ Vegetarian ✓ Capocollo ✓ Assorted ✓ Classic ✓ Meatloaf ✓ Pastrami and Swiss Cheese ✓ Sausage and Capocollo on Italian ✓ Roast Beef ✓ Eggs and Olive ✓ Salami ✓ Slawich ✓ Hot Hand Carved Turkey Breast ✓ Cold Hand Carved Turkey Breast ✓ Turkey and Roasted Reds ✓ Turkey Jalapeno Club ✓ Fontinella Jerk Turkey Burger ✓ Panko Chicken Avocado Club ✓ Crispy Applewood Bacon ✓ Homemade Coleslaw ✓ Fresh Roasted Hot Peppers ✓ Sweet Red Peppers

"Chris' NY Sandwich Co. is a casual dining restaurant with a simple and sober ambience. The restaurant offers half a dozen types of sandwiches and delivers them to a handful of downtown businesses. The shop expanded its menu to include more sandwiches, soups, salads, and grill items. The dishes are inspired by the top gourmet centers in different regions and are paired aesthetically with sumptuous Swiss cheese, which promises to give guests a standard dining experience. The restaurant also offers various options such as dine-in, takeout, outdoor seating, and delivery. Chris' NY Sandwich Co. includes an accessibility facility for more comfort.

2026 Update: Customer can contact the restaurant by phone call. The business accepts credit cards from major providers for payments from the guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #2571195

Price:

Specialty Sandwiches:
Chiles Poblanos Reales $14.99
Entomatadas $13.49
Nachos Real $12.99
Mexican Hamburger $10.49
Chiles Poblanos $13.99
Add Grilled Chicken Or Steak $5.99
Chimichanga $12.99
Chimichanga Supremas $14.99
Quesadilla Rellena $11.49
Taco Salad $11.99
Special Dinner $15.99
Sopes $12.49
Enchiladas Rancheras $13.99
Tamales El Chilango $13.99
Enchiladas Supremas $12.49
Enchiladas Tapatias $13.99
Trio Tamales $13.99
Chilaquiles Mexicanos $12.99
Flautas Mexicanas $12.99
Guadalajara $12.99
Other Fajita Style Items
Quesadilla Fajita Style Steak Or Chicken $12.99
Quesadilla Fajita Style Shrimp $13.99
Taco Salad Fajita Steak Or Chicken Or Mixed $12.99
Taco Salad Fajita Shrimp $13.99
Nachos Con Fajita $13.49
Shrimp Fajita Nachos $14.99
Togo Orders $0.99

Contact:

(716) 854-6642

Mon-Fri: 11am - 2:30pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

TAILGATE SUBS - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
TAILGATE SUBS - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
TAILGATE SUBS - Buffalo, NY Sandwich Shops
Best Sandwich Shops in Buffalo NY - TAILGATE SUBS video
CALL

TAILGATE SUBS

(4.7 Score)
741 Delaware Road,
Buffalo, NY 14217 Directions

Since 2006

Specialty:

✓ Italian Assorted Sub ✓ Turkey Sub ✓ Turkey Club Sub ✓ Cajun Turkey Sub ✓ Cajun Turkey Club Sub ✓ Ham Sub ✓ Ham and Turkey Sub ✓ Ham and Turkey Club Sub ✓ The King Sub ✓ The Queen Sub ✓ Cajun Queen Sub ✓ Buffalo Chicken Finger Sub ✓ Buffalo Chicken Finger Club Sub ✓ Cajun Chicken Finger Sub ✓ Cajun BBQ Chicken Finger Sub ✓ Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub ✓ Cheeseburger Sub ✓ Cajun Cheeseburger Sub ✓ Bacon Cheeseburger Sub ✓ Sausage Supreme Sub ✓ Royal Sub ✓ Cajun Royal Sub ✓ Half Sub

“2026 Update: Tailgate Subs is a locally owned and operated small restaurant with sandwiches as their main cuisine. Todd Neupert is the sole owner and operator of the business. The restaurant has been in operation in the area for more than 2 decades. Tailgate Subs are served on a toasted Costanzo’s roll with lettuce, tomato, onion, and mozzarella cheese, and soft rolls are also available if customers request, with a choice of mayo, oil, or both, or bleu cheese as a dressing option. American cheese or Swiss cheese is available and can be added when the customer prefers. Orders can be placed by phone by contacting the Sandwich Shop.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Hot Subs:
Buffalo Chicken Finger Sub $13
Buffalo Chicken Finger Club $15
Cajun Chicken Finger Sub $13
Cajun Bbq Chicken Finger Sub $13.50
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub $15
Cheeseburger Sub $12
Cajun Cheeseburger Sub $12
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub $14
Sausage Supreme Sub $12
Royal Sub $14
Cajun Royal Sub $14
Half Subs
Any Hot Or Cold Half Sub $7
Half Sub Combo
Half Sub Combo (1 Side & Drink) $11
Cold Subs
Italian Assorted Sub $12.50
Turkey Sub $12.50
Turkey Club Sub $14
Cajun Turkey Sub $12.50
Cajun Turkey Club Sub $14
Ham Sub $12.50
Ham & Turkey Sub $12.50
Ham & Turkey Club Sub $14
The King Sub $12.50
The Queen Sub $13
Cajun Queen Sub $13
Part Freezers:
Chicken Fingers $29
Pizza Logs $11
Apple Pie Logs $11

Contact:

(716) 877-5401

Mon-Fri: 9am - 5:30pm
Sat-Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for TAILGATE SUBS

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

JIM'S STEAK OUT REVIEWS

I was visiting Buffalo and got the chicken finger sub. It took a while but the chicken fingers were crispy on the outside and tender on the inside coated in a perfectly sour, spicy and salty. Inside was clean and the staff were so friendly!

Very quiet when we went for lunch. Clean and friendly. The clt was so good and the Philly cheese steak was amazing. Our go-to everytime!

Great food and service! Looking forward to a return trip to the place. Had the steak sandwich and tried the fries and o-rings.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

CHRIS' NY SANDWICH CO REVIEWS

Everything we decided to eat was delicious. To be fair, we had a hard time deciding what to eat, because the list of sandwiches is so large and everything sounds so good, but we ended up with the Portabella mushroom one and the goat cheese and turkey burger, and we didn't regret our choice. Chris and his team will ensure you leave their place with a full belly and a smile on your face.

A gem in Buffalo, for sure! Handcrafted soups, sandwiches and entrees that will blow your mind! Chris and his family are on hand, ever so gracious, and always happy to hear about how we enjoy the food, atmosphere, and at the end.....the cookies! Do NOT go away from here without the cookies! When in BFLO, you absolutely MUST go to Chris'!

It is like a NY deli, with seating. Great food, service and atmosphere.

TAILGATE SUBS REVIEWS

If you like fat meaty subs this is the place. He makes the best sausage royal around hands down. If you get a full cold sub it probably has 3/4 to 1 full pound of meat on it. No other sub shop comes remotely close to the amount of meat this place gives you. Hard to tell in the pics but it’s 2 layers of sausage, 2 layers of cheese, and 3 layers of capicola.

I stopped by on a recommendation. Fast and friendly service. My ham sub was made fresh, toasted and was very filling. I could only eat half since i got a large macadamia nut cookie. Great prices. Will definitely be stopping by again when im in the area

Best subs around!!! We take out all the time. Turkey subs and chicken finger subs r the best!! Wish he did catering! Would be great for foot ball games!!!!!!

TBR® Inspection Score Report

JIM'S STEAK OUT Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Business Hours: 9
Contact Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of : 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

CHRIS' NY SANDWICH CO Total Inspection Points: 116/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Contact Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Followers Ratio: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of : 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

TAILGATE SUBS Total Inspection Points: 113/120
Current Evaluation: 8
Reviews Accuracy of : 8
Business Hours: 9
Legitimate Ratings: 9
Social Media: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Pricing: 10
Variety of Menu: 10
Video: 10