3 Best Pizza Places in Columbia, SC

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Columbia, South Carolina. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM COLUMBIA

802 Gervais Street, Suite 100,
Columbia, SC 29201 Directions

Since 1976

Specialities:

Chicago 7™ Meat Me™ Double Deckeroni™ Thai Pie Farmer’s Daughter Veggie 7 Chicken Bacon Ranch Craft Your Own Twisted Tenders Spaghetti Pie Chicken Parmesan Chicken Bacon Mac Chicken Pesto Alfredo Spaghetti and Meatballs Nashville Hot Crispy Chicken Sandwich Crispy Chicken Sandwich Chicken Caprese Sandwich Chicken Caesar Wrap BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger Buffalo Chicken Rolls Pizza Party To-

"Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Columbia is a friendly, casual, and well-run pizza restaurant that serves homemade pizza, pasta, and sides. All their ingredients are always fresh. They never compromise the quality of their ingredients because quality ingredients give a unique flavor to the pizzas. They make pizza dough and sauces every day in their kitchen by their experienced chefs. Try their Thai Pie feature with sweet Thai chili sauce, mozzarella, pepper jack, cheddar, roasted chicken, mushrooms, red peppers, broccoli, sesame seeds, green onions, and teriyaki sauce. Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Columbia provides happy hour menus. The restaurant provides amenities such as a full bar, free Wi-Fi, a kid's menu, catering, and a patio area.

2026 Highlights: Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom Columbia offers outdoor seating. Dogs are allowed in this shop."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

UNREAL PIZZA DEALS:
Party Pack For 4 $29.99
Party Pack For 6 $59.99
Pizza Party To-Go $125.00
STARTERS:
Sicilian Pepperoni Rolls™ $11.49
Buffalo Chicken Rolls $11.49
Bavarian Pretzel Sticks $9.99
Twisted Tenders $11.49
Fried Pickles $9.49
Mozzarella Sticks $9.49
Spinach Artichoke Dip $11.49
Italian Nachos $13.99
Cheesy Dippin' Strips $9.99
Firecracker Shrimp $13.99
ENTRÉES:
Spaghetti & Meatballs $13.49
Chicken Parmesan $14.99
Chicken & Bacon Mac $13.99
Nashville Hot Chicken Bacon Mac $14.98
Chicken Pesto Alfredo $14.99
Oh My Spaghetti Pie $13.99
Spaghetti Pie With Meatballs $16.99
Spaghetti Pie With Chicken $16.99
Twisted Tenders Meal $14.49
Grilled Chicken Alfredo $15.99
Spicy Shrimp & Andouille Pasta $19.99
HANDHELDS:
BBQ Bacon Cheeseburger $13.49

Contact:

(803) 252-3100

Mon-Thu: 11am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 1am
Sun: 11am - 12am

TBR® Inspection Report:

9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

MELLOW MUSHROOM COLUMBIA

1009 Gervais Street,
Columbia, SC 29201 Directions

Since 1974

Specialities:

Spinach Artichoke Dip Pretzel Bites Magic Meatballs Bruschetta Cheese Bread Mellow Rollz - 4 Rollz Mellow Rollz - 8 Rollz Add Hot Honey Drizzle Additional Sides Of Saucesuper Pepp Holy Shiitake Pie Mighty Meaty Buffalo Chicken Kosmic Karma Great White Pacific Rim Veg Out Funky Q. Chicken House Special Level Up Your Pizza Experience With A Side Order Of Sauce Greek Salad House Salad Caesar Salad The Elevated Cobb Enlightened Spinach Salad

"Mellow Mushroom Columbia is designed as a funky, art-filled pizza restaurant serving craft beer, calzones, and creative stone-baked pizzas. The restaurant is located in The Vista. Each location is locally owned and operated and provides a unique feel, focused on great customer service and high-quality food. Mellow Mushroom Columbia offers a wide range of menu items, including munchies, greens, calzones, and burgers. The restaurant provides a variety of 20 draft beers and handcrafted cocktails. The restaurant also offers a happy hour menu from Monday to Friday. Mellow Mushroom Columbia provides vegan-friendly menus.

2026 Highlights: Mellow Mushroom Columbia offers free wi-fi access. Accepts payments through credit cards."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

MUNCHIES:
Spinach Artichoke Dip $9.99
Pretzel Bites $9.50
Magic Meatballs $9.99
Bruschetta $8.49
Cheese Bread $6.99
Mellow Rollz - 4 Rollz $8.95
Mellow Rollz - 8 Rollz $14.95
Add Hot Honey Drizzle $0.75
Additional Sides Of Sauce $1.50
WINGS:
5 Wings $8.49
10 Wings $14.99
15 Wings $19.49
CALZONES:
Veggie $13.99
Steak & Cheese $15.49
The Meat Lover $15.49
Cheese $11.49
Build Your Own Calzone $1.50
Burgers
All-American Smashburger $13.99
Hoagies & Sandwiches:
California Club $11.99
LUNCH:
Half Hoagie + Chips $8.00
One Slice (Cheese, Pepperoni Or Byo) $7.00
Two Slices (Cheese, Pepperoni Or Byo) $10.00
Add A Lil Salad (House Or Caesar) To Any Lunch Special $4.00
SWEETS:
Gourmet Cookie $3.99
Mary Jane’s Triple Chocolate Brownie $4.99

Contact:

(803) 933-9201

Mon-Thu & Sun: 11am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 11pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

CICIS PIZZA COLUMBIA

6120 St Andrews Road,
Columbia, SC 29212 Directions

Since 1985

Specialities:

Pepperoni Cheese Beef Sausage Classic Chicken Giant Pizza Veggie Meat Eater Supreme Alfredo Spinach Alfredo Mac and Cheese Buffalo Chicken BBQ Pork Zesty Pepperoni Zesty Veggie Zesty Ham and Cheddar Hawaiian Pizza Stuffed Crust Ultimate Pepperoni BBQ Chicken

"Cicis Pizza Columbia provides a wide range of menu items including specialty pizzas, classic pastas, and salads. The restaurant has expanded to more than 300 restaurants in 30-plus states and has been ranked by CNN Money as the No. 1 'Casual Dining Pizza Restaurant.' For over 4 decades, the restaurant is committed to providing a fun and family-friendly environment for their customers. All their pizzas are freshly prepared using fresh dough that is baked daily by their professional chefs. Cicis Pizza Columbia has a game room to entertain your children. The restaurant offers all-you-can-eat menus and gluten-friendly pizza.

2026 Highlights: Cicis Pizza Columbia accepts payments through credit cards and Apple Pay."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

BUFFET:
Adult Buffet $9.99
Kids' Buffet $5.99

Contact:

(803) 750-5900

Mon-Sun: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report: