Old Chicago Pizza + Taproom is a welcoming and relaxed pizzeria located in Columbia, SC, known for its exceptional selection of cold beers and handcrafted pizzas. Their commitment to using fresh ingredients is unwavering, as they believe that high-quality ingredients are the key to delivering unique and flavorful pizzas. Each day, their experienced chefs prepare fresh pizza dough and sauces in their kitchen, ensuring the utmost freshness and quality. The pizzas are then baked in their traditional oven, resulting in perfectly cooked and expertly topped creations. A visit to Old Chicago is an invitation to indulge in their delectable pizzas, which are sure to satisfy and delight your taste buds. Online ordering option is available here. They provide various discounts as happy hours special. Gift cards are available with them.
Best Pizza Places in Columbia
Handpicked Top 3 Pizzeria in Columbia, South Carolina. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence.
We have a strict “No Pay to Play” policy.
OLD CHICAGO PIZZA + TAPROOM REVIEWS
Our group enjoyed a delicious dinner. We started with cold beverages from the bar & an order of the pretzel sticks, peperoni rolls, & Italian Nachos. The pizza rolls with the marinara sauce were my favorite, yum. We followed up with a couple of meat loaded pizzas. Overall, it was a great meal.
We had the Tavern thin crust, cheese only pizza, and Beer craft burger. All good was good, nice juicy burger and flavorful. It wasn't busy at all on a Monday afternoon. Good place for burger, pizza and some beer.
Best cauliflower crust pizza I’ve had in a while. My husband said his hand tossed was delicious as well. Quick and polite service too!
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
Mellow Mushroom-Columbia, a renowned pizzeria in Columbia, SC, is celebrated for its exceptional offerings since 1974. They specialize in serving stone-baked pizzas, calzones, hoagies, and salads and provide a wide range of vegan and gluten-free options. With an extensive beer selection, including 24 draft options and over 80 bottles, they cater to beer enthusiasts as well. Mellow Mushroom takes pride in its classic Mellow crust, crafted using Appalachian spring water, which adds a unique touch to its pizzas. They prioritize accommodating various dietary needs by offering gluten-free and vegan alternatives for many of their pizzas. A highly recommended choice is their Veg Out pizza, which features a delightful combination of mozzarella, spinach, green peppers, sliced mushrooms, black olives, sweet onions, and Roma tomatoes. Mellow Mushroom invites you to indulge in its flavorful and diverse menu, providing a memorable dining experience for all. Mellow is a beloved choice for residents and students in Forest Acres, Rosewood, and the neighboring areas. They cater to dietary preferences such as gluten-free and vegan options. Situated in a historic two-story brick building that has stood for over a century, the restaurant's interior is adorned with South Carolina Gamecock art. Happy hour special offers are available in week days. They they Free parking spaces are available behind the building for the convenience of patrons.
Specialty:
$Price:
Kosmic Karma - $26.99
Mighty Meaty - $29.99
Funky Q Chicken - $27.99
Buffalo Chicken - $27.99
Merry Prankster - $27.99
Maui Wowie - $27.99
Holy Shiitake - $27.99
House Special - $29.99
Contact:
Working Hours:
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm
TBR® Inspection Report:
MELLOW MUSHROOM - COLUMBIA REVIEWS
Went here for dinner last night, and I have to say mellow mushroom never disappoints. The atmosphere is great, the people are warm and welcoming and the quality of ingredients is excellent. I am not a salad guy, take one look at me and you can tell I’m a meat, bread and cheese man. This will tell you how fresh and great the ingredients are, that I have to highlight the salads! Obviously the pizza and calzone was excellent as well. Amberley was so sweet, and handled our weird requests without hesitations. Try the Reece cookie, it’s worth it.
Rhianna was great server! Pizza was the bomb! Cheese bread was delicious! We cannot wait to return! (Also easiest parking in Columbia.) Vegetarian options: Great veggie pizza options - Kosmic Karma!
I went here for dinner last night with my wife on a double date and it was amazing! We had an order of pretzel bites and I got a BBQ chicken pizza. Both were delicious! Service was also great, our waitress was Katrina.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.

Blaze Pizza, a prominent chain pizzeria, stands out for its commitment to serving high-quality pies within a warm and inviting atmosphere. They prioritize the freshness of their ingredients, starting with the pizza dough, which is made from a blend of quality flour and water. The dough is carefully fermented using natural yeast to enhance its flavor and texture. The pizza sauces at Blaze Pizza are crafted by combining fresh, quality tomatoes with a blend of secret spices, and they are slow-cooked to perfection. A notable characteristic of their pizzas is the generous amount of cheese, contributing to a satisfying and chewy texture. In addition to their signature pizza offerings, Blaze Pizza allows customers to customize their pizzas by selecting toppings that range from classic choices like pepperoni or sausage to more adventurous options like artichokes or spicy vegan chorizo. They also offer spicy chorizo (vegan), vegan cheese (soy-free), and a variety of veggies. Blaze Pizza invites you to experience its dedication to quality and innovation in every bite. Gift cards are available at all of their restaurants.
Specialty:
$Price:
1 Top Pizza - $9.39
Vegetarian Pizza - $16.49
BBQ Chicken - $12.49
White Top - $12.49
Red Vine - $12.49
Green Stripe - $12.49
Vegan Pizza - $12.49
Protein Pizza - $16.49
Art Lover - $12.49
Keto Pizza - $16.49
Hot Link - $12.49
Contact:
Working Hours:
Fri & Sat: 11am - 11pm
Sun: 11am-9pm
TBR® Inspection Report:
BLAZE PIZZA REVIEWS
Great experience, just moved from Florida and starting to enjoy local restaurants. This is now on my favorites list, all the ingredients were fresh, portions generous and staff was friendly. If you want to have a fresh pizza and sales check out Blaze Pizza.
I finally found a Brick Oven style pizza place. I think it has been here a while but I just found it and we love it. Nice place to go to after church or before the movies that is right across the street.
I really love their pizza . The crust stays soft and chewy even after being in the pizza oven just the way I like it. You get to pick your own toppings or order one of the signature pizzas they offer The blood orange lemonade is also really good.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.