Gotham Bagels is a beloved bagel shop that proudly operates as a locally owned establishment located in Madison, Wisconsin. This bustling New York-style deli is renowned for its hand-rolled bagels, flavorful soups, and an array of hot and cold sandwiches. The exceptional quality of Gotham Bagels is a result of their dedicated staff, who craft each item by hand using only the finest ingredients. Following a traditional method passed down since 1906, every bagel is meticulously rolled by hand at Gotham Bagels. The friendly team at Gotham Bagels provides courteous service, ensuring that each bagel is served warm and fresh at an affordable price. Indulge in their delightful offerings, such as the grilled herb bagel, bagel with tofu spread, and crispy chicken cutlet. Gotham Bagels goes the extra mile by offering free Wi-Fi to its customers, as well as catering services and convenient delivery options. Whether you choose to dine in or take away, Gotham Bagels is dedicated to providing a satisfying experience for bagel enthusiasts.
3 Best Bagel Shops in Madison, WI
Expert recommended Top 3 Bagels in Madison, Wisconsin. All of our bagel shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence.
GOTHAM BAGELS REVIEWS
I've had bagels before. I've had good bagels before. Trying Gotham for the first time made those other bagels seem like pale reflections of what a bagel should be. Hands down the best bagel I've ever had.
I’ve never seen such a wide range of bagel sandwich options. I ordered the Brighton Beach, and it was absolutely marvelous! I mean, those layers are just beautiful.
If you want some authentic NY style bagels, you can get'em here. Baked fresh on the spot. Everything is good. Great coffee, too.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
Bagels Forever Inc. embarked on its journey by opening its first retail bagel bakery on University Avenue in Madison, Wisconsin. With a mission to bring the authentic taste of New York Style Bagels to the Midwest, Bagels Forever has grown from humble beginnings to expand its reach across stores throughout Wisconsin. They also offer convenient online delivery services across the United States to cater to their loyal bagel enthusiasts. At Bagels Forever, their commitment to quality is evident in the use of all-natural ingredients for their bagels, which are boiled and heart-baked in the oven to perfection. Providing delectable bagels at an affordable price is their priority. With a wide variety of menu options to choose from, customers can indulge in a bagel box, Vienna Chicago all-beef hot dog, hard salami, or pizza bagel with pepperoni, among other tempting choices. Bagels Forever offers convenient takeaway facilities for customers on the go.
Specialty:
$Price:
Bagel Sandwich Selections Starts from $4.03
Bagel W/ Cream Cheese $1.75
Bagel W/ Butter $1.06
Bagels Bakers Dozen $7.80
Contact:
Working Hours:
Sat & Sun: 6:30am - 6pm
TBR® Inspection Report:
BAGELS FOREVER INC. REVIEWS
Absolutely delicious bagel sandwich! They were out of turkey so I had to change to salami and I’m so glad it had to happen. I would order the same thing again in a heartbeat. The classic everything bagel was flavorful and the sandwich toppings were fresh; pickles are to die for. Wish I lived closer!
I have loved each experience I've had here. Service is fast, the food tastes great, the prices are very reasonable and there are many options to customize bagel sandwiches. My most recent visit I got a salmon lox bagel sandwich and really enjoyed it! I hope to be back on a regular basis!
Bagels Forever makes excellent bagels. While you can find them in local grocery stores, they are better fresh from the source. They offer a variety of sweet and savory bagels, and they are all good. They also have bagel sandwiches, cream cheese etc.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
Einstein Bros. Bagels stands as a prominent and esteemed bagel shop in Madison, Wisconsin. This casual, counter-serve venue is a haven for bagel enthusiasts, offering an enticing selection of bagel sandwiches and delightful coffee drinks. As a renowned chain, Einstein Bros. Bagels expertly prepares an array of egg sandwiches, soups, salads, baked goods, and, of course, an assortment of bagels. Einstein Bros. Bagels serves as the perfect gathering place to connect with friends or clients while enjoying great food and beverages from their complete espresso bar. The team at Einstein Bros. Bagels prides themselves on using only the freshest and most natural ingredients to deliver a truly delicious taste. Each bagel is fresh, dense, and delightfully chewy, available in a variety of flavorful options. Whether you crave the savory goodness of asiago or gourmet bagels, the comforting warmth of apple cinnamon or cheddar jalapeno, or the unique twists of cheesy hash brown, green chile, blueberry, or chocolate chip, Einstein Bros. Bagels has an assortment to satisfy every palate. Additionally, they offer catering services for special occasions, ensuring that weddings, parties, and events are complemented by their delectable offerings. Dine-in and takeaway facilities are available for customers to enjoy the Einstein Bros. Bagels experience in their preferred way.
Specialty:
$Price:
Single Bagel with Shmear $4.99
Nova Lox $13.38
Baker's Dozen Box $22.49
Half Dozen Bagel Box $14.29
Avocado Toast $6.49
Shmear Tubs $5.99
Single Bagel without Shmear $2.79
Baker's Dozen Bagels $17.89
Half Dozen Bagels $11.79
Contact:
Working Hours:
TBR® Inspection Report:
EINSTEIN BROS. BAGELS MADISON REVIEWS
The bagel sandwiches here always hit the spot! The manager and everyone working here today were giving 110% even though they were high volume and understaffed, great job guys and thank you for your hard work and tasty food!
Great place for a quick breakfast. I love the bagel sandwiches they make and their supreme coffee!
So excited to find an Einstein Brothers while visiting Madison. It's been quite some time since I had a Quad Caramel Macchiato and Everything bagel (Toasted with a schmear of plain cream cheese). Yummy.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.