3 Best Bagel Shops in Madison, WI

“Gotham Bagels is a locally owned and operated shop that has been serving the community for 18 years. Gotham Bagels is a bustling New York-style deli featuring hand-rolled bagels, soups, and hot and cold sandwiches. Gotham bagels are excellent and their loyal staff makes everything by hand using high-quality ingredients. Each bagel is carefully rolled by hand at Gotham Bagels using a passed-down method dating back to 1906. Try their grilled herb bagel with tofu spread and crispy chicken cutlet. Gotham Bagels offers customers free Wi-Fi, catering services, and a delivery option. Whether you dine in or take out, Gotham Bagels is committed to providing a satisfying experience for bagel enthusiasts.”

Read more

“Bagels Forever Inc. began its first retail bagel bakery on University Avenue in Madison, Wisconsin. They bring New York-style bagels to the Midwest. From their small beginnings, they have developed and now sell their bagels in stores throughout Wisconsin. They also offer online delivery across the United States for those who have come to love their bagels. Their bagels are made from all-natural ingredients at Bagels Forever, then boiled and heart-baked in the oven. They provide delicious bagels at an affordable cost and offer a wide variety of menu options. Enjoy tasting their bagel box, Vienna Chicago all-beef hot dog, hard salami, and pizza bagel with pepperoni. They also offer takeaway services to their customers.”

Read more

“Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison prepares an array of egg sandwiches, soups, salads, baked goods, and, of course, an assortment of bagels. This shop is located in Lakepoint Commons. The team at Einstein Bros. Bagels prides themselves on using only the freshest and most authentic ingredients to provide a truly delicious taste. Each bagel is fresh, dense, and delightfully chewy, available in a variety of flavorful options. Whether you crave the tasty goodness of asiago or gourmet bagels, the comforting warmth of apple cinnamon or cheddar jalapeno, or the unique twists of cheesy hash brown, green chile, blueberry, or chocolate chip, Einstein Bros. Bagels has an assortment to satisfy every palate. Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison offers catering services for special occasions, ensuring that weddings, parties, and events are complemented by their delectable offerings. Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison also offers dine-in and takeout options.”

Read more