Here’s The Deal: Gotham Bagels is a locally owned and operated bagel shop located in Madison, WI. This shop was established in 2007. Gotham Bagels is a bustling New York-style deli with hand-rolled bagels, soups, and hot and cold sandwiches. Gotham bagels are excellent; the loyal staff makes everything by hand using high-quality ingredients. Each Bagel is carefully rolled by hand at Gotham Bagels using a passed-on method dating to 1906. Try their grilled herb, Bagel with tofu spread, and crispy chicken cutlet. Gotham Bagels offers customers free Wi-Fi, a catering service, and a delivery option. Whether you dine in or take away, Gotham Bagels is committed to providing a satisfying experience for bagel enthusiasts.
3 Best Bagel Shops in Madison, WI
Expert recommended Top 3 Bagels in Madison, Wisconsin. All of our bagel shops actually undergo a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!
TOP 3 GOTHAM BAGELS REVIEWS
Amazing local bagels! This place is always packed. We love them. They have so many lunch and breakfast options here. Bagels are authentic and chewy. And the cream cheese comes in cool flavors like a honey raisin! Staff is super great despite being so busy all day. Great experience here. You bring the whole family.
Bagels are handmade, thick, and come in a variety of styles. They have that proper texture of a New York style bagel. A weekly treat for those of us who work by the Square.
Fantastic bagels, almost as good as back home in Jersey! They seemed to have missed my request that the sandwich be toasted, but the quality was still top-notch, and generous with the lox.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.
Here’s The Deal: Bagels Forever Inc. started its first retail bagel bakery on University Avenue in Madison, Wisconsin. They bring New York Style Bagels to the Midwest. From their small beginnings, they have developed and now sell their bagels in stores throughout Wisconsin. They also offer online delivery across the United States for those who have come to love their bagels the most. Their bagels are made from all-natural ingredients at Bagels Forever, then boiled and heart-baked in the Oven. They provide delicious bagels at an affordable cost. They offer a wide variety of menu options from which you can choose. Enjoy tasting their bagel box, Vienna Chicago all-beef hot dog, hard salami, and pizza bagel with pepperoni. They offer Takeaway facilities to their customers.
Specialty:
$Price:
Bagel Sandwich Selections Starts from $4.03
Bagel W/ Cream Cheese $1.75
Bagel W/ Butter $1.06
Bagels Bakers Dozen $7.80
Contact:
Working Hours:
Sat & Sun: 6:30am - 6pm
TBR® Inspection Report:
TOP 3 BAGELS FOREVER INC. REVIEWS
First time visiting this place and absolutely great tasting. Not bad on the prices at all. Nowadays you usually feel like you're getting taken for a ride when you go somewhere or the cost of something is just extravagant, but I felt that this was very reasonably priced and I appreciated it.
Favorite bagel shop in Madison by a long mile. Great variety of bagels and all of them are delicious. Can order bagels to take home or a sandwich made here. Prices are super reasonable and the lox is one of my favorites of anyplace I’ve had it. Can’t miss stop if you like bagels.
The perfect bagel. It’s crunchy while being soft and fluffy on the inside. Plus the price is amazing! I got multiple sandwiches and their two dozen package for under $40! Definitely a must stop for me.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.
![Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison Madison Bagel Shops Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison Madison Bagel Shops](https://threebestrated.com/images/EinsteinBrosBagelsMadison-Madison-WI.jpeg)
Here’s The Deal: Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison, located in Madison, Wisconsin, since 1997, is a leading bagel shop. This casual, counter-serve venue features an array of bagel sandwiches and great coffee drinks. The shop is perfect for connecting with friends or clients while enjoying food and beverages from their complete espresso bar. The team at Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison uses only the freshest natural ingredients to provide a delicious taste. Their bagels are fresh, dense, and chewy and available in various flavors, including asiago, gourmet bagels, apple cinnamon, cheddar jalapeno, cheesy hash brown, green chile, blueberry, and chocolate chip. Einstein Bros. Bagels Madison also offers catering services for special occasions, including weddings, parties, and events.
Specialty:
$Price:
Single Bagel with Shmear $4.99
Nova Lox $13.38
Baker's Dozen Box $22.49
Half Dozen Bagel Box $14.29
Avocado Toast $6.49
Single Bagel without Shmear $2.79
Baker's Dozen Bagels $17.89
Half Dozen Bagels $11.79
Contact:
Working Hours:
TBR® Inspection Report:
TOP 3 EINSTEIN BROS. BAGELS MADISON REVIEWS
We're here a couple days a week for breakfast, it's ALWAYS good! Best Lox in town, and the pizza bagels are great! The coffee is tasty and the kids love it here. The take home bagels are some of the best in Madison. Everyone is SO nice and friendly and the trivia questions are fun. Definitely stop here for quality bagels, breakfast and lunch. They close early, so order ahead on their app for easy pickup.
Popped in before Easter celebrations for a coffee and bagel sandwiches. Friendly staff. Relatively quick. Good coffee and tasty bagels. A midwestern classic.
Had the Farmhouse Egg Sandwich and it was terrific. Cheesy potatoes was good, just too small. I always enjoy the blueberry muffin.
Help others: Click Here to send review or send us your review to reviews@threebestrated.com. Negative and positive review will be used for rating. Make a difference.
The ratings displayed on our website are derived from our own proprietary tool, incorporating a comprehensive 50-point inspection check that evaluates specific aspects of each business.
These ratings are independent and not influenced only by reviews found on any other online platforms or feedback received directly from customers.