3 Best Caterers in Madison, WI

Expert-recommended Top 3 Caterers in Madison, Wisconsin. All of our caterers actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BLUE PLATE CATERING

706 South High Point Road, Suite 40,
Madison, WI 53719 Directions

Since 1992

Specialty:

Arden Tossed Salad Kale Caesar Salad Summer Salad Brandied Chicken Breast Herb Roasted Chicken Tortellini and Chicken with Pesto Braised Short Ribs Classic Beef Bourguignon Slow Cooked Roast Beef Dinner Filet Mignon Cherry Maple Pork Loin Peach Bbq Pork Miso Glazed Salmon Baked Cod Southwestern Stuffed Peppers Stuffed Acorn Squash OCCASIONS: Awards Dinners Conventions Meetings Team-Building Outings Conferences Company Picnics Employee Appreciation and In-Office Parties Family Reunions Retirement Graduation Corporate Lunches Funeral Events Open Houses Fundraisers Weddings Groundbreaking Events

"Blue Plate Catering was founded by Jodi Fowler. She eventually developed into a growing full-service catering service, adding dedicated staff and now employs more than 25 full-time staff. Blue Plate Catering offers the peace of mind of working with a professional caterer. They ensure their food is fresh and delicious, with a farm-to-table home-cooking feel, thanks to their team of highly trained chefs. Blue Plate Catering is full of experienced and enthusiastic staff committed to making your entire event memorable. The company executes the details, allowing you to create enduring memories with your guests.

2026 Update: Blue Plate Catering has received the Best of Madison award for 14 straight years, with more than 30 years of experience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Winner of WI Bride Magazine Best Caterer in 2017, 2020, 2021 & 2022
Executive Choice Award Winner of In Business Magazine in 2017-2022
Outstanding Small Business Award by In Business Magazine in 2019
Frontline Hero Award by NACE in 2020
Dane County Small Business Award by In Business Magazine in 2022
License #B034799

Price:

Continental Breakfast $7.50
All-American Breakfast Starts From $13.95
Flapjack Delight Starts From $13.50
Breakfast Burrito $13.25
Build Your Own Parfait $10.25
Breakfast Stations:
Omelet Station $18.75
Pancake Bar $16.25
Farm To Table Brunch $19.95
Themed Buffets:
Taste Of Italy
Lunch Buffet $15.75
Dinner Buffet $21.25
Grain Bowl
Lunch Buffet $15.95
Dinner Buffet $20.95
Street Tacos
Lunch Buffet $14.95
Dinner Buffet $19.95
Asian Delight
Lunch Buffet $15.25
Lunch Buffet $17.25
Dinner Buffet $19.95
Hot Sandwich Options
Lunch Buffet $13.50
Lunch Buffet $15.25
Dinner Buffet $16.95
Madison Deli Board
Lunch Buffet $17.95
Dinner Buffet $19.95
Pre-Made Sandwiches $16.95

Contact:

(608) 827-7200 (608) 827-9266

Mon-Fri: 8am - 4pm
Sat & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Cranberry Creek Catering - Madison, WI Caterers
Cranberry Creek Catering - Madison, WI Caterers
Cranberry Creek Catering - Madison, WI Caterers
10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

CRANBERRY CREEK CATERING

1501 Lake Point Drive,
Madison, WI 53713 Directions

Since 2005

Specialty:

Slow Cooked Pot Roast Roast Turkey Beef Tips in Burgundy Sauce Asian Plum Chicken Breast Orange Chicken Breast Dijon Lasagna (meat or Meatless) Mashed Potatoes and Gravy Scalloped Potatoes Au Gratin Potatoes Roasted Potatoes and Carrots Smashed Red Potatoes Roasted Red Potatoes Mashed Sweet Potatoes Wild Rice Pilaf Steamed Broccoli Steamed Green Beans OCCASIONS: Weddings Engagement Proposals Holiday and Non-Profit Fundraising Events Cocktail Parties Baby Showers Exclusive Sit-Down Dinners Birthday Celebrations Grand Openings Product Launch Award Ceremonies Gala Dinners Corporate Incentive Programs

"Cranberry Creek Catering is a locally owned and operated business by Jim Norton. The company aims to bring quality food and service to their valuable guests. The team prepares the food using quality ingredients with awesome taste. The minimum catering requirement is 15 guests. They are also excited to announce they have remodeled their space to incorporate lunch meetings and banquets for up to 80 people. Cranberry Creek Catering takes pride in delivering exceptional customer service to ensure every guest feels valued and cared for. They offer menus like boxed lunches, breakfasts, lunch buffets, and others at a reasonable cost.

2026 Update: Cranberry Creek Catering is consistently voted a Best of Madison caterer year after year."

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Guests Under 20:
Service Fee $20
Build A Buffet Order:
Taco Buffet
Per Person Lunch $13
Per Person Dinner $17.50
Lasagna Buffet
Per Person Light Portion $13
Per Person Dinner Portion $17.50
Pasta Buffet
Per Person Light Portion $13
Per Person Dinner Portion $17.50
Salad Buffet Per Person $13
Chicago Dog Buffet Per Person $13
Hearty Chili Buffet Per Person $13

Contact:

(608) 222-9752

Call for Hours

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

UPSTAIRS DOWNSTAIRS CATERING

1617 North Stoughton Road,
Madison, WI 53704

Since 1978

Specialty:

Smoked Salmon Platter Fresh Vegetable Tray Hummus Dip Platter Fiesta Dip Platter Tortellini Skewers Platter Cherry Balsamic Baked Brie Charcuterie Board Apricot Pecan Baked Brie Kids Meal Entrée Caesar Salad Tenderloin Roquefort Wisconsin Chicken Breast Filet of Tenderloin Spinach and Feta Stuffed Chicken Breast Shredded BBQ Beef Herb Roasted Chicken OCCASIONS: Weddings Rehearsal Dinners Holiday Events Garden and Tea Parties Corporate Functions Anniversaries Banquets Special Occasions Gatherings Birthdays Shows Picnics Receptions Christenings Open Houses Work Luncheons Bridal Showers Engagement Proposals

"Upstairs Downstairs Catering is a family-owned and operated company that provides inspired cuisine and exceptional service and works with you to create a menu that fits your taste, budget, and style. Upstairs Downstairs Catering specializes in custom menus and service plans designed for both elegant galas and intimate celebrations. They serve only quality menus, thoughtfully prepared with locally grown ingredients. Their commitment to using local ingredients allows them to create unique, seasonally-inspired menus customized for any style or taste. Upstairs Downstairs Catering offers excellent catering options at an affordable cost to suit a variety of budgets.

2026 Update: Upstairs Downstairs Catering is located in the Lazy Oaf Lounge. The company has been serving the community for more than 40 years and continues to make every guest’s event memorable. They provide an extensive assortment of hot and cold hors d’oeuvres for guests to enjoy while awaiting the main course."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Special Events And Wedding Menu:
Hot Hors D’Oeuvres
Italian Stuffed Mushrooms $19
Stuffed Artichoke Hearts Parmesan $24
Sun Dried Tomato & Goat Cheese Stuffed Mushrooms $20
Mini Crab Cakes With Mustard Cream Sauce $24
Bacon Stuffed Mushrooms $23
Chicken Satay $24
Bleu Cheese & Pecan Stuffed Mushrooms $22
Marinated Beef Tenderloin Skewers $26
Bacon Wrapped Water Chestnuts $23
Mac & Cheese Bites $25
Cocktail Meatballs $17
Spinach & Feta Phyllo Triangles $26
Business Menu:
Hors D’Oeuvres
Petite Sandwiches Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef $30
Petite Sandwiches Tenderloin & Horseradish Sauce $45
Seasonal Sliced Fruit & Berries $3.75
With Cheese Tray $3.25
With Cheese Tray With Sausage $4.50
Fresh Vegetable Tray $3
Antipasto Tray $4
Individual Vegetable Pizza $3
Individual Fruit Pizza $4.75

Contact:

(608) 256-4600 (608) 957-8628

Mon-Sat: 8am - 5pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: