3 Best Cakes in Indianapolis, IN

Expert recommended Top 3 Cakes in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our cake shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

CAKE BAKE SHOP

6515 Carrollton Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46220 DIRECTIONS

Since 2012

Here’s The Deal:
The Cake Bake Shop is a high-end bakery with outdoor seating offering cakes, pastries & high tea service in glam digs. Gwendolyn is the Founder of this bakery. She has been baking since she was six years old, and over the last 49 years, she has created thousands of cakes for weddings and has baked for many celebrities. Gwendolyn and her bakery have won several awards and appreciation for their tireless work. When you step in through their French doors, the bright candlesticks, antique mirrors, French-inspired fittings, lovely seasonal decorations, and the rich aroma of French chocolate cakes baking in the oven welcomes you. Enjoy a French-pressed coffee with a slice of handmade cake or pastry. It has become Indiana's destination for celebrating birthdays, anniversaries, and all the special occasions life offers. Their team also serves wine, beer & champagne with their cakes. The Cake Bake Shop also has another branch in Camel City Center.

SPECIALTY:
Millionaire, Italian Créme, Snowflake Coconut, Lemon, Chocolate Orange, Red Velvet, Hummingbird, Carrot, Neapolitan, Cream Cake, Pies, Black Forest, Birthday, Raspberry Champagne, Wedding, Desserts, Lemon Blueberry, Wine, Pies, Drinks, Tiramisu, Cookies, Coconut & Blueberry Almond

Price: Cakes Starts from $9
Soups Starts from $12.50
Quiche Starts from $12.50
Cookies Starts from $3.50
Hot Chocolate Starts from $3

... More Prices Cakes Starts from $9
Soups Starts from $12.50
Quiche Starts from $12.50
Cookies Starts from $3.50
Hot Chocolate Starts from $3
Hot Drinks Starts from $4
Wine Starts from $8
Specialty Cocktails Starts from $11
Pies Starts from $10

'Top 5 Bakeries in America' by Central Restaurant

Reservations

[email protected]

thecakebakeshop.com

Reviews | Play Video

Mon & Tue: 10am - 6pm
Wed,Thu & Sun: 10am - 8pm
Fri & Sat: 10am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

TAYLOR'S BAKERY

6216 Allisonville Road, Indianapolis, IN 46220 DIRECTIONS

Since 1913

Here’s The Deal:
Taylor's Bakery is a family bakery with a 100-year history that makes custom cakes, pastries, ice cream & more for takeout. It is a 4th generation, family-owned and operated bakery. Dennis O. Taylor is the Founder of this cake shop in 1877. Their team always uses high-quality and freshest ingredients to make the best and mouth-watering cakes. Their team will work closely with you to create the perfect cakes for your beautiful day and deliver a wide range of flavors, sizes, and decor to suit your wedding theme. They are specialized in making birthday cakes, wedding cakes, and specialty cakes. Taylor's Bakery is a one-stop-solution for all your cake needs.

SPECIALTY:
Custom Speciality Cakes, Doll, Giant Cupcakes, Numeral Shaped, Shaped Cakes, Sheet, Tiered Birthday, Wedding, Graduation, Bread, Rolls, Donuts, Angel Food Cakes, Holiday, Baby Shower, Traditional, Christian Cakes, Pies & Layer Cakes

Online Order

[email protected]

taylorsbakery.com

Reviews | Play Video

Tue-Sat: 8am - 5pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

VANILLA BEAN BAKERY

2324 West 86th Street, Indianapolis, IN 46260 DIRECTIONS

Since 2009

Here’s The Deal:
Vanilla Bean Bakery is a simple, playful, custom-cake bakery offering cupcakes, truffles, cookies & brownies. It was founded in 2010, and its local, family-owned, and managed bakery specializes in making the best and delicious cakes. Their team can help you make your special occasion memorable with personalized cookies, cake pops, and other sweets. They bake all of their products on-site every day, throughout the day, to keep everything as fresh as possible. Their delicious treats are also a perfect way to thank your patrons and staff and get your name out to potential clients. Vanilla provides various flavors of treats every day. When you want to celebrate a special occasion, get a sweet treat from Vanilla Bean Bakery. Get your celebrations sweeter with Vanilla Bean Bakery cakes. Take-out options are also available at Vanilla Bean.

SPECIALTY:
Maple Bacon, Chocolate with Vanilla, Boston Cream, Dark Chocolate Nutella, Vanilla Raspberry, Truffles, Cookies, Orange Cream, Butter Scotch, Chocolate Caramel, Vanilla Chocolate, Yellow Butter, Choc Chip Cookie Dough, Cupcakes, Chocolate Raspberry, Triple Chocolate with Ganache, White Chocolate Strawberry, Caramel Apple Spice & Brownies

Price: Cupcakes Starts from $3
Specialty Cupcakes Starts from $3.75
Vegan Cupcakes Starts from $3
Basic Minis Starts from $12 Per Dozen
Deluxe Minis Starts from $13/Dozen

... More Prices Cupcakes Starts from $3
Specialty Cupcakes Starts from $3.75
Vegan Cupcakes Starts from $3
Basic Minis Starts from $12 Per Dozen
Deluxe Minis Starts from $13/Dozen
Special Deluxe Minis Starts from $15
Vegan Cupcakes Starts from $3
Sugar-Free Cupcake Starts from $3

Online Order

Send Email

vanillabean-bakery.com/cu...

Reviews | Play Video

Mon-Sat: 10am - 6pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: