ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED INDIANAPOLIS, IN CAKES

3 Best Cakes in Indianapolis, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our cake shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

The Cake Bake Shop® Inc. - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
The Cake Bake Shop® Inc. - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
The Cake Bake Shop® Inc. - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Best Cakes in Indianapolis IN - The Cake Bake Shop® Inc. video
11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

THE CAKE BAKE SHOP® INC.

(4.9 Score)
6515 Carrollton Avenue,
Indianapolis, IN 46220 Directions

Since 2012

Specialty:

✓ Cake Flavors: Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch ✓ Celebration ✓ Black and White ✓ Neapolitan ✓ Millionaire ✓ Lemon Blueberry ✓ Pixie Fetti Birthday ✓ Raspberry Champagne ✓ Earl’s Court Chocolate ✓ Carrot ✓ Red Velvet ✓ Blueberry Crumb ✓ Maple Walnut Crumb ✓ All-Butter Pound Cake ✓ Cheesecakes ✓ Walnut Brownies ✓ Coconut Cream Pie OCCASIONS: Birthday ✓ Wedding ✓ Anniversary ✓ Events

"The Cake Bake Shop® Inc. by Gwendolyn Rogers is a charming cake shop and bakery owned by Gwendolyn. Gwendolyn Rogers has created a storybook restaurant in a cottage that took two and a half years for her to design and remodel. The cake shop is a high-end bakery with outdoor seating offering cakes, pastries, and high tea service in glamorous digs. The Cake Bake Shop has garnered international acclaim and has been enjoyed by celebrities such as Elton John, Justin Timberlake, and Ina Garten. The Cake Bake Shop is an ideal venue for celebrating birthdays, weddings, and other special events. The shop offers private event hosting and afternoon tea services. Whether you're seeking a delightful dessert, a cozy spot for tea, or a venue for a special celebration, The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers offers a magical experience that combines culinary excellence with enchanting ambiance.

2026 Update: Gwendolyn has become an Exclusive Partner with Williams-Sonoma, with over 36 homemade dessert items selling on the Williams-Sonoma website, shipping nationwide. They employ over 169 team members in the state of Indiana."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
'Top 5 Bakeries in America' by Central Restaurant

Price:

Cake Slices
Carrot Cake Slice $17.00
Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Slice $18.00
Earls Court Cake Slice $18.00
Gf Black & White Cake Slice $18.00
Lemon Blueberry Cake Slice $17.00
Millionaire Cake Slice $18.00
Neapolitan Cake Slice $17.00
Pixie Fetti Cake Slice $16.00
Raspberry Champagne Cake Slice $18.00
Red Velvet Cake Slice $18.00
Pie Slices
Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Pie Slice $17.00
Coconut Cream Pie Slice $13.00
Key Lime Pie Slice $13.00
Cheesecake, Cookies & Bars
Mixed Berry Cheesecake Slice $17.00
Chocolate Chip Cookie $6.00
Brownie $8.00
Brownie Gf $8.00
Lemon Bar $10.00
Magic Bar $12.00
Raspberry Jam Bar $10.00
Salads
Blackberry Avocado Salad $21.00
Crab NiçOise $36.99
Lemon Caesar Salad $19.00

Contact:

(317) 257-2253

Mon-Sun:10am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Taylor's Bakery - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Taylor's Bakery - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Taylor's Bakery - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Best Cakes in Indianapolis IN - Taylor's Bakery video
5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

TAYLOR'S BAKERY

(4.9 Score)
6216 Allisonville Road,
Indianapolis, IN 46220 Directions

Since 1913

Specialty:

✓ CAKE FLAVOURS: Raspberry ✓ Vanilla ✓ Chocolate Marble ✓ Strawberry ✓ Red Velvet ✓ Coconut ✓ Chocolate Fudge ✓ Butter Chocolate Chunk ✓ Caramel Iced With Pecans ✓ Cherry ✓ Cinnamon ✓ Cream Cheese ✓ White Iced With Pecans ✓ Sour Cream ✓ White ✓ OCCASIONS: Wedding ✓ Birthday ✓ Party ✓ Graduation ✓ Anniversary ✓ Baby Shower

"Taylor's Bakery is a fourth-generation, family-owned cake shop that makes custom cakes, pastries, ice cream, and more for takeout. Dennis O. Taylor is the founder of this cake shop. The offerings of the cake shop are praised for their freshness and quality, with many customers noting the importance of arriving early to get the best selection. Their team can help you make your special occasion memorable with personalized cookies, cake pops, and other sweets. They bake all of their products on-site every day, throughout the day, to keep everything as fresh as possible. They specialize in making birthday cakes, wedding cakes, and specialty cakes. Taylor's Bakery is a one-stop solution for all your cake needs.

2026 Update: Taylor's Bakery was founded by Dennis O. Taylor. The shop has been providing cake service for 113 years."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Mardi Gras King Cake $30.00
White Cupcake White Icing $2.75
Piped Shamrock Cookie $3.75
Chocolate Cupcake With Chocolate Icing $2.75
Triple Chocolate Ganache Cake $32.50
Flower Decoration $38.50
Up To $131.00
Red Velvet Cupcake With Cream Cheese Icing $3.25
Petit Four Piped Heart $4.25
7" Round 2 Layer White Cake $26.00
Raspberry Angel Food Cake $18.00 To $19.00
Assorted Donuts By The Dozen $16.00
Mardi Gras Big Easy King Cake $50.00
Confetti Decoration $38.50 To $131.00
Balloon Decoration $38.50 To $131.00
Petit Four With Rosebud $3.75
Brownie $2.50
Chicken Pot Pie And Vienna Bread Bundle $27.00
Donut Holes By The Dozen $4.00
Two Layer Vintage Heart Cake $75.50
Lemon Bar $2.50
14 Sheet Cake With Seasonal Decorations $42.00
Wrapped Caramel Candy 12oz. Bag $12.99

Discount:

20% Off your first order

Contact:

(317) 251-9575

Tue-Sat: 7am - 5pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Sweet Escape Cake Company - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Sweet Escape Cake Company - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Sweet Escape Cake Company - Indianapolis, IN Cakes
Best Cakes in Indianapolis IN - Sweet Escape Cake Company video
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SWEET ESCAPE CAKE COMPANY

(4.8 Score)
7745 South Meridian Street,
Indianapolis, IN 46217 Directions

Since 2017

Specialty:

✓ CAKE FLAVORS: Creamy Caramel ✓ Chocolate Mousse ✓ Cheesecake Mousse ✓ Cookies N Cream Mousse ✓ White Chocolate Mousse ✓ Strawberry Mousse ✓ Strawberry Preserves ✓ Raspberry Preserves ✓ Orange Preserves ✓ Almond ✓ Banana ✓ Butter Pecan ✓ Carrot Cake ✓ Cherry Chip ✓ Chocolate Mint ✓ Chocolate ✓ Confetti ✓ Cookie Dough ✓ Lemon ✓ Marble ✓ Orange ✓ Pineapple ✓ Raspberry ✓ Red Velvet ✓ Spice ✓ Strawberry ✓ Vanilla ✓ White OCCASIONS: Birthdays ✓ Weddings ✓ Graduation ✓ Baby Shower ✓ Bridal Shower ✓ Retirement Parties ✓ Business Promotion ✓ Anniversary Parties ✓ Team Celebrations ✓ Holiday Celebrations ✓ Teacher Appreciation ✓ Corporate Celebrations ✓ Employee Appreciation

"Sweet Escape Cake Company is a family-owned boutique bakery known for its creativity and craftsmanship. Their skilled bakers and cake artists take pride in crafting beautifully designed cakes, featuring signature flavors and house-made buttercream. From elegant, hand-piped buttercream wedding cakes to sculpted 3D fondant creations for special occasions, as well as royal iced cookies for baby showers or cheerful cookie cakes, every item is made to look distinctive and taste exceptional. No matter the size of your celebration, Sweet Escape Cake Company is ready to meet your needs. They also offer same-day pickup and a selection of treats, including cookies and chocolate-dipped Rice Krispies.

2026 Update: Sweet Escape Cake Company has been providing cake service for 18 years. The cake shop offers same-day delivery service. Their bakery cases are stocked daily with an assortment of gourmet cakes, cupcakes, cake pops, cookies, brownies, chocolate-dipped pretzels, Rice Krispies treats, and more."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Cookie Cake $30.00
6" Blue And White Buttercream Cake $45.00
6" It'S Your Birthday Cake $45.00
6" White And Pink Vintage Cake $50.00
6" Floral Border Cake $45.00
6" Strawberry Cake $45.00
6" Pink Sprinkle Cake $45.00
6" White Rosette Cake $40.00
6" Naked Cake With Pink Drip $45.00
6" Celebration Sprinkle Cake $40.00
6" Soft Green With Floral Cake $45.00
6" Vintage Floral Cake $45.00
6" Blue And White Cake $45.00
6" Pink & Black Polkadot Heart Cake $48.00
6" "A Tini Bit Older" Heart Cake $55.00
6" Purple Butterfly Heart Cake $55.00
6" Vintage White Heart Cake $48.00
6" Pink And Red Vintage Heart Cake $48.00
6" Minion Cake $45.00
6" Happy Face Cake $45.00
6" Minecraft Cake $50.00
6" Black Cat Cake $48.00
6" Fortnite Cake $45.00
6" Unicorn Cake $50.00

Contact:

(317) 840-1562

Mon: 9am - 4pm
Tue-Fri: 9am - 6pm
Sat: 9am - 2pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Sweet Escape Cake Company

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

THE CAKE BAKE SHOP® INC. REVIEWS

This has been on my bucket list for a long time. It was perfect!! The staff was absolutely wonderful. They were able to squeeze us in early, and we have the perfect little table. My husband and I both got the chicken salad on croissant. It's was sooo good. I got the million dollar chocolate cake, and he got the French silk chocolate pie. They were both wonderful!! I can't wait to come back!!

We have been going to this Cake Bake shop for years. We just held my daughter's bridal shower here and it could not have been more perfect! The attention to detail and everyone helping was top notch. It made her day so special. Extra thanks to our server, I believe her name was Nolan. She was great and seemed so genuine and excited for the bride!

Wonderful bridal shower experience. They even had a cake bake crown available for purchase. The printed dinner menu was lovely. The service in the little private dining area was deluxe. 10 of us had a beautiful experience. We came from Louisville for the experience and it was well worth it.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

TAYLOR'S BAKERY REVIEWS

We are the couple who ate our wedding cake topper the weekend after our wedding. We didn’t freeze it and wait to eat it on our first anniversary. But we did make it a tradition to buy an 8” wedding cake every year to eat on our anniversary. A few years ago our caterer stopped selling wedding cakes, and that’s when we found Taylor’s Bakery. This is our 3rd or 4th year buying our anniversary wedding cake from Taylor’s, and every year we have an amazing experience with them. I always call them to order it, and they are so accommodating and friendly. I don’t know if they have an online ordering option, but if they don’t, they should. Don’t get me started on how magnificent their cakes are. Sublime would be a good word for them. Heavenly. I have been to of the great bakeries in Indianapolis, and Taylor’s is still at the top of my list. We will use them as long as they stay in business or until both of us are dead!

We have been ordering our family birthday cakes from here for over 15 years. Also ordered my wedding cake from here and it was just as I dreamed of. Their icing and cake reminds me of what my grandmother and great aunt would make. Which was always perfect! Highly recommend and wouldn’t go anywhere else.

I stopped at Taylor’s bakery. On my way to work. Service is always quick and friendly. The pastries are delicious. We recently ordered a baby shower cake and they worked with us to provide the perfect decoration for our theme. I highly recommend this great bakery.

SWEET ESCAPE CAKE COMPANY REVIEWS

My daughter who lives out of state sent me a picture of a cake she saw on Pinterest she wanted for our twin granddaughters sweet 16 birthday. I told her it was a stretch very intricate and detailed but I would try. I had went to two other places first that I usually go to with no luck! They did an awesome job above and beyond what we expected, it was also 2 flavors and a filling!! I will go to them in the future for any special occasions that I need a cake, cupcakes etc The first photo is the picture I showed them and you can see the results!!

They absolutely nailed the cake inspiration. I loved how my cake looked. I did think the cake was too sweet for me. However the cream cheese mouse filling was good I would have like to have more filling. I do feel like the filling was layered with frosting I got more frosting in the middle rather than the cheesecake filling. I would come back.! Thank you so much for making my wife happy she loved the look of the cake!

I needed cookies for a baby shower in a pinch. They were able to accommodate me with only two weeks notice. The staff was professional and communicative. You can see for yourself, the product was outstanding!

TBR® Inspection Score Report

THE CAKE BAKE SHOP® INC. Total Inspection Points: 118/120
Acknowledgments: 9
Complete Info: 9
Awards History: 10
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 6.8K: 10
Table Reservation: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

TAYLOR'S BAKERY Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 2.7K: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

SWEET ESCAPE CAKE COMPANY Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Experience: 8
Acknowledgments: 9
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Online Order: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 2.0K: 10