3 Best Cakes in Pittsburgh, PA

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. All of our cake shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

CALL EMAIL

OAKMONT BAKERY

1 Sweet Street, Oakmont,
Pittsburgh, PA 15139 Directions

Since 1988

Specialities:

CAKE FLAVOURS: Vanilla Chocolate Red Velvet Carrot Cake Marble Cake Lemon White Chocolate Raspberry Chocolate Peanut Butter Raspberry Torte Chocolate Torte Chocolate Sour Cream Chocolate Chip Blueberry Cranberry Nut Marble Loaf style cakes Fruit-based seasonal cakes custom wedding cake flavours (match fillings like raspberry custard pastry cream buttercream) Black Forest Lemon Torte Yellow Vanilla Snowball Torte Strawberry Bliss Tiramisu Almond Torte American Torte Pumpkin Pudding OCCASIONS: Birthdays Weddings Engagements Anniversaries Baby showers Graduation parties Corporate events Holiday celebration

"Oakmont Bakery is owned and operated by Marc and Susan Serrao. Their space has remarkably expanded to over 12,500 square feet, making Oakmont Bakery one of the greatest retail bakehouses in America. Oakmont Bakery was recognized to receive "Retail Bakery of the Year" by Modern Baking magazine. The most prestigious award in the retail bakeshop is given to only one bakery in the country each year. Marc and Susan are favored to work side by side with many of their family members to offer a positive working environment where lasting relationships are formed. Final payment must be made by cash or credit card. They only deliver within a 30-mile radius of Oakmont Bakery.

2026 Highlights: Oakmont Bakery is focused on expanding daily rotating seasonal specials for cakes, donuts, and pastries. Strong emphasis on large-scale custom cakes for birthdays, weddings, and events. Improved grab-and-go setup for faster service during peak rush hours. Continued growth of signature donuts and pastry variety as a key attraction. Enhanced café-style offerings alongside bakery items for a full all-day experience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

CUPCAKE CAKES
Balloons (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $40.00
Flower Bouquet (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $60.00
Roses (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $40.00
Number Shaped (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $50.00
Sun (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $50.00
Sunflower (2 dz Cupcake Cake) $50.00
DESSERT CAKES
Almond Torte (8?) $38.00
Almond Dolce $6.00
Almond Torte - 1/2 Sheet $85.00
Almond Torte - 1/4 Sheet $48.00
BLACK FOREST
Black Forest (8?) $27.00
Black Forest (1/2 Sheet) $85.00
Black Forest (1/4 Sheet) $48.00
CHOCOLATE TORTE
Chocolate Torte (8?) $38.00
Chocolate Dolce $6.00
Chocolate Torte (1/4 Sheet) $48.00
Chocolate Torte (1/2 Sheet) $85.00
FRENCH CREAM TORTE
French Cream Torte (8?) $27.00
French Cream (1/2 Sheet) $85.00
French Cream (1/4 Sheet) $48.00
DOLCE
Pumpkin Mousse Dolce $6.00
Almond Dolce $6.00
Carrot Dolce $6.00
Chocolate Dolce $6.00
Oakmonter Dolce $6.00

Contact:

(412) 826-1606

Mon-Sat: 6am - 7pm
Sun: 6am - 3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

The Butterwood Bake Consortium  - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
The Butterwood Bake Consortium  - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
The Butterwood Bake Consortium  - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
CALL EMAIL

THE BUTTERWOOD BAKE CONSORTIUM

5222 Butler Street,
Pittsburgh, PA 15201 Directions

Since 2015

Specialities:

Olive Oil Love Cake Tea Cake Vegan Tea Cake Cake Slice Vegan Cake Slice Cake Parfait with Fresh Cream Vegan Cobbler Apple Fig Heart Pie Browned Butter Brownie Frosted Brownie Browned Butter Blondies Cinnamon Pixie Dust Blondies Chocolate Chip Cookie Sandwich (Peanut Butter Cream) Vegan Gingerbread Square Vegan Chocolate Pot de Creme Mixed Pastry Gift Box Vegan Mixed Pastry Gift Box Organic Fruit-Based Seasonal Cakes Espresso Cake Style Desserts Handcake Party Custom Cakes

"The Butterwood Bake Consortium is a dessert cafe presenting cake and pie by the slice, natural treats, party cakes, swoon-worthy KLVN caffe, coffee extract drinks, and organic teas. They didnt use any kind of artificial ingredients or other fillers.. They bake with organic Beehive Flour, Wholesome Sweeteners Organic Evaporated Cane Juice, Multiple Green Brand Cocoa Powder, and clarified butter, cream, and free-range eggs, all obtained from Frankferd Farms natural food. Their team specializes in making wedding cakes, decorated cakes for all occasions, specialty cakes like their famous Burnt Almond torte, fresh pastries, and holiday items.

2026 Highlights: The Butterwood Bake Consortium focuses on clean-label, organic-style desserts with premium ingredients. Expanded menu of cake-by-the-slice, tea cakes, brownies, and layered desserts. Strong growth in vegan and diet-friendly dessert options. Late-night dessert café experience remains a major identity (open late evenings Wed–Sun). They have an specialty custom dessert options and cakes for celebrations and small events. Increased emphasis on café experience: coffee, espresso, tea paired with desserts. Boutique-style bakery positioning with rotating seasonal dessert creations."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #4335235

Menu:

DESSERTS
Vegan Strawberry Cobbler $8.95
Cake Slice $9.95
Vegan Cake Slice $9.95
Olive Oil Love Cakes $7.95
Tea Cakes $4.95
Vegan Tea Cakes $4.95
Browned Butter Blondies $4.95
Cinnamon Pixie Dust Blondies $4.95
Frosted Brownie $4.95
Browned Butter Brownie $4.95
Vegan Blueberry Poppy Bread $5.50
Butterscotch Pudding (Gluten Free) $7.95
Vegan Chocolate Pudding (GF/V) $6.95
Cake Parfait With Fresh Cream $6.75
PARTY ORDERS
Tea Cakes (Party Order of 12) $55.00
Vegan Tea Cakes (Party Order of 12) $55.00
Blondies (Party Order) $55.00
Brownies (Party Order) $55.00
WHOLE CAKES & PIES
Two-Tiered Cake (Non-Vegan or Vegan) $225.00
Three-Tiered Cake $435.00
9" Whole Cake $76.00
9" Whole Cake - Vegan $76.00
9" Whole Pies $55.00
CAKE ADD-ONS
Chocolate Ganache Drip $25.00
Gold Leaf $25.00
Wooden Cake Toppers $22.00
Beeswax Candles $3.00

Contact:

(412) 781-0218

Wed–Sun: 12pm - 11pm
Mon & Tue: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Pastries A-La-Carte - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
Pastries A-La-Carte - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
Pastries A-La-Carte - Pittsburgh, PA Cakes
CALL EMAIL

PASTRIES A-LA-CARTE

81 Clairton Boulevard,
Pittsburgh, PA 15236 Directions

Since 2004

Specialities:

Cake Slices Whole Cakes (Custom Cakes) Tortes Brownies Blondies Cookies Danish Pastries (Various Flavors) Fruit Pastries Cream-Filled Pastries Pies Strudels Layer Cakes Seasonal Specialty Desserts Dessert Bars Cupcake-Style Mini Cakes Bakery Gift Boxes Assorted Party Dessert Trays Specialty Cakes Theme Cakes 3D Cakes Baby Shower and Gender Reveal Cakes Bridal Shower Cakes Flower Top Cakes Kids Cakes Religious Cakes Sports Cakes Graduation Cakes

"Pastries A-La-Carte is a family-owned business that began with the owner baking fresh, unique cakes right from home. Their bee-themed cupcakes are the perfect addition to any celebration. They are available by the half dozen. Their Monster Cookie Torte has two layers of Chocolate cake, one layer of White Vanilla cake, and two layers of edible cookie dough filling. They use only the finest and freshest ingredients. including farm fresh eggs. They have the perfect wedding cake for you. Their cakes for special occasions are baked by their cake-making experts and can be personalized to meet your requirements. The quality of their homemade treats, with designs and personalized touches, is a testament to their commitment to providing exceptional cakes.

2026 Highlights: Pastries A-La-Carte offers a selection of upgraded artisan pastries and tortes, along with expanded options for custom celebration cakes. The bakery provides a wider variety of Danish pastries, and introduces seasonal limited-time desserts. These offerings are presented while the bakery maintains its classic European bakery identity."

Reviews   |   Write a Review
License #3184833

Menu:

CUPCAKES
Apple Crumb Gourmet Cupcake $3.95
Bees and Flowers Cupcakes - Half Dozen $19.50
Birthday Cupcakes Picks - Half Dozen $13.00
Birthday Gourmet Cupcakes $3.95
Burnt Almond Creme Gourmet Cupcake $3.95
Burnt Almond Raspberry Gourmet Cupcake $3.95
Colored Buttercream $15.00
Half Dozen $19.50
COOKIE CAKES (Brownie Cake)
Balloons $26.95
Cookies and Cream $32.95
Dinosaurs $32.95
Dragon $32.95
Flowers $26.95
Halloween Spider Web $32.95
Monster Cookie $32.95
Pittsburgh Penguins $53.95

RED WHITE & BLUE
Apple Pie - 9in $25.75
Cookie Cake - Red, White, & Balloons $26.95
Red, White, & Blue Iced Cutout Cookies $4.75
COOKIES
Alfie's French Creme $1.65
Alfie's French Creme, Chocolate Filled $2.00
Buckeyes $1.65
Caramel Cup $1.65
Chocolate Chip Cookie $1.00
Coconut Macaroon $1.65

Discount:

Get $1 Offer for All Cold Brew

Contact:

(412) 653-2236

Mon - Fri: 7am - 5pm
Sat: 8am - 5pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: