3 Best Bagel Shops in Pittsburgh, PA

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bagels in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. All of our bagel shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PIGEON BAGELS

5613 Hobart Street,
Pittsburgh, PA 15217 Directions

Since 2017

Specialities:

Cinnamon Sugar and Raisin Cranberry Apple Cinnamon Sesame Seed Asiago Green Chile Dozen Rugelach Dozen Cookies Dozen Scones and Muffins Dozen Lemon Bars and Brownies Dozen Cinnamon Rolls and Babka Rolls Sweet Loaves Challah Loaf 6 Pack of Challah 12 Pack Mini Challah Buns Everything Sesame Marble Plain

"Pigeon Bagels is a certified kosher bagel shop that offers fresh bagels, a full espresso bar, and housemade pastries. The shop is a casual café that prepares small-batch, New York-style bagels, breakfast, and lunch sandwiches. The team is friendly and courteous in serving the cuisine in a comfortable environment. By using quality ingredients, they can make a variety of bagel flavors. Try their light plain bagel, smoked salmon bagel, and asiago-parmesan bagel with plain shmear. They also offer takeaway facilities to customers. Their menu features traditional Jewish baked goods like babka, honey cake, challah, and rugelach.

2026 Highlights: Pigeon Bagels is a women-owned shop. They offer accessible parking near the entrance. This shop accepts payments through credit cards and Apple Pay."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

BAGELS:
Plain $2.24
Bagel Of The Month: Pickle $2.24
Garlic & Sea Salt $2.24
Sesame $2.24
Marble $2.24
Everything $2.24
Add-Ons:
Schmear $2.35
Capers $50.00
Red Onion $50.00
Greens $75.00
Lox $7.70
Whitefish $8.80
Pickled Banana Peppers $1.25
Radish $50.00
Cucumber $75.00
Pickled Beets $1.25
Avocado $2.35
Carrot Lox $3.50
SANDWICHES:
Whitefish $13.25
Veggie $7.55
Classic Lox $13.50
Vegan Carrot Lox $9.30
Bagel & Schmear $4.80

Contact:

(412) 224-2073

Wed-Mon: 7:30am - 2:30pm
Tue: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL

BAGEL FACTORY

5885 Forbes Avenue,
Pittsburgh, PA 15217 Directions

Since 1993

Specialities:

Open-faced Tuna Melt Smoked Whitefish Salad Bagel Turkey Rachel Naked Bagel 1/2 Dozen Bagels Baker’s Dozen Bagels Plain Cream Cheese Bagel Chips Bagel With Plain Cream Cheese Bagel With Flavored Cream Cheese Bagel With Nova Lox Cream Cheese Bagel With Margarine Bagel With Honey Bagel With Butter Bagel With Jam Bagel With Peanut Butter Deli Sandwiches

"The Bagel Factory aims to serve freshly made and tasty food while doing the right thing. Their food is handmade in their kitchen throughout the day with the freshest produce. They strive to bring customers the best bagels, baguettes, paninis, and burgers at great prices. Their team makes their bagels hand-rolled with natural ingredients and offers delivery, Wi-Fi, and takeaway options. The Bagel Factory features creative cream cheeses and breakfast sandwiches, as well as deli options for customers. They have traditional toppings like cream cheese with unique spreads and sandwiches. They offer classic plain bagels and adventurous flavors, like everything bagels.

2026 Highlights: The Bagel Factory offers outdoor seating. Dogs are allowed in this shop."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

BAGELS:
Bagel Chips $5.99
Baker's Dozen Bagels $21.99
Naked Bagel $2.50
12 Dozen Bagels $11.99
HOT ON A BAGEL OR WRAP:
Turkey, Egg & Cheese $5.99
Breakfast Burrito $9.99
Kosher Salami, Egg & Cheese $5.99
Sausage, Egg & Cheese $5.99
Egg & Cheese $5.99
Pizza Bagel $4.99
Ham, Egg & Cheese $6.99
Bacon, Egg & Cheese $6.99
DELI SANDWICHES:
BLT Sandwich $8.99
Hummus & Spinach Sandwich $8.99
Honey Baked Ham Sandwich $9.99
Kosher Salami Sandwich $9.99
Hot Pastrami Sandwich $13.99
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.99
Chicken Salad Sandwich $9.99
Corned Beef Sandwich $15.99
Grilled Cheese Sandwich $7.99
Egg Salad Sandwich $9.99
Turkey Sandwich $9.99
BLT With Turkey Sandwich $12.99

Contact:

(412) 521-8100

Mon,Tue,Thu & Sun: 9am - 3pm
Wed,Fri & Sat: 6am - 3pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

EINSTEIN BROS. BAGELS

4910 Baum Boulevard,
Pittsburgh, PA 15213 Directions

Since 2013

Specialities:

Bagel Cheddar Jalapeno Everything Green Chile Poppy Seed Cinnamon Sugar Garlic Pumpernickel Plain Sesame Seed Spinach Florentine Gourmet Cinnamon Raisin Onion Six-Cheese Asiago Bagel Egg Chocolate Chip Potato Pretzel Blueberry Apple Cinnamon French Toast Cheesy Hash Brown Cranberry

"Einstein Bros. Bagels provides quality bagels and excellent customer service. They are a counter-service chain offering egg sandwiches, soups, salads, baked goods, and a variety of bagels. Their staff prepares fresh products each day using grain flour, seeds, Bob's Red Mill flour, and locally sourced ingredients. Their bagel café is a venue for creative fillings and sides in a relaxed atmosphere with wooden tables. Einstein Bros. Bagels, a casual chain, is known for the design-your-own sandwiches and a wide variety of bagels. They provide catering and Wi-Fi service to customers. Their Baker's Dozen with Shmear is a fresh-from-the-oven value breakfast.

2026 Highlights: Einstein Bros. Bagels accepts payments through credit card and Apple Pay."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Fresh Baked Bagels & Shmear:
Avocado Toast $6.39
Shmear Tubs $6.49
Half Dozen & Shmear- Build Your Own $14.99
Baker'S Dozen & Shmear- Build Your Own $23.89
Baker'S Dozen- Build Your Own $19.99
Nova Lox $11.79
Single Bagel $3.19
Fresh & Ready Baker'S Dozen & Shmear $27.19
Fresh & Ready Baker'S Dozen $20.99
Single Bagel With Shmear $3.19
Half Dozen- Build Your Own $12.09
EVERYDAY BRUNCH BOXES:
Nova Lox Brunch Special $14.89
Brunch Box For Two $17.29
Brunch Box $54.99
Bacon & Cheddar Brunch Special $11.39
Sweets & Sides:
Twice-Baked Hashbrown $2.49
Cinnamon Bliss Roll $6.09
New! White Chocolate Egg Sugar Cookie $2.99
Strawberry & Cream Strudel $3.99
Cinnamon Chip Muffin $3.59
Blueberry Muffin $3.99
Heavenly Chocolate Chip Cookie $3.69
Sea Salt Chips $2.49

Discount:

$9 Off on A Baker’s Dozen Bagels (Every Monday)

Contact:

(412) 688-0813

Mon-Sun: 6am - 2pm

TBR® Inspection Report: