3 Best Bagel Shops in Louisville, KY

“Maya Bagel Express specializes in a wide range of food options including bagels, breakfast and lunch sandwiches, pastries, and coffees. Their bagels are homemade daily from scratch. Their primary focus is on perfecting the art of crafting delicious bagels, which comes naturally to them as they come from a baking family. Their breakfast and lunch sandwiches are made to order from only unparalleled and fresh ingredients available for their valued customers. They prioritize product quality and consistency, ensuring that their homemade bagels are prepared from scratch each day. Maya Bagel Express's vision is to spread love and joy within the community, inspire people to achieve great things, and positively impact people's daily lives through the simple pleasures of enjoying a bagel and a coffee.”

Read more

“Payne Street Bake House features a variety of exciting and updated menu options. As a flagship bakeshop counter, Payne Street Bake House specializes in crafting handmade, authentic New York City-style bagels, bialys, lox, cream cheese, and coffee. Using high-quality ingredients like Shepard's Grain flour, Bob's Red Mill flour, seeds, and locally sourced components, their dedicated team prepares fresh products daily. In addition, Payne Street Bake House provides a catering service for both breakfast and lunch, ensuring a delightful experience. Don't miss out on their assortment of bagel sandwiches and wraps, featuring flavors such as turkey, blackened spicy turkey, roast beef, tuna salad, veggie, and hummus.”

Read more

“Bruegger's Bagels St. Matthews is a chain of shops that specializes in serving small-batch, New York-style bagels as well as breakfast and lunch sandwiches. The shop has been in this field for over 42 years, famous for its genuine New York-style bagels, which are boiled in kettles and baked on stone hearths, using just five simple ingredients. They serve a variety of proprietary, 100% made-in-Vermont cream cheeses and freshly prepared breakfast and lunch sandwiches. Alongside their delicious bagels, Bruegger's Bagels St. Matthews offers an extensive selection of exclusive cream cheeses made in Vermont, as well as garden-fresh salads, hearty soups, delectable desserts, freshly prepared breakfast and lunch sandwiches, and custom-roasted coffees. Bruegger's Bagels offers catering, Wi-Fi, dine-in service, and gift cards.”

Read more