3 Best Bakeries in Milwaukee, WI

Expert-recommended Top 3 Bakeries in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. All of our bakeries actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

11+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

PETER SCIORTINO BAKERY

1101 East Brady Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 1948

Specialities:

✓Amaretti ✓Apricot Tea ✓Arancini Riceball ✓Assorted Cookie Box ✓Bacio Biscotti ✓Bavarian Pretzel Twist 5oz ✓Bavarian Pretzel Twist 8oz ✓Bear Claw ✓Brat Buns 6 Inch ✓Brat Slider Buns 3 Inch ✓Bread Crumbs Plain 1lb ✓Brioche Buns ✓Brioche Slider Buns ✓Buttercrust Loaf ✓Breakfast Pastries ✓Breadsticks ✓Cakes ✓Cookies ✓Deli ✓Loaves ✓Mini Desserts ✓Pies ✓Pretzels ✓Rolls ✓Custom Orders ✓Wedding Dessert

" Peter Sciortino Bakery is an established resource for housemade breads, Italian pastries, specialty cookies, and some deli meats. Maria S. is the owner of the bakery. The bakery specializes in Italian breads, cookies, and pastries. They pride themselves on the quality and freshness of their products. Their bakers make all of their products from scratch daily to ensure that their customers receive the freshest baked goods. The bakery does special orders for any occasion, including weddings, showers, and meetings. They can also do special orders for those with an allergy or specific dietary need. They also offer ham and roll deals on Sunday mornings, as well as a punch card for getting a free slice of bread after purchasing that much bread. Peter Sciortino Bakery is located on Brady Street.

2026 Highlights: Peter Sciortino Bakery has been providing bakery services for 70 years."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Loaves
Buttercrust Loaf $3.25
French Loaf $3.25
Italian Loaf $3.25
Mini Italian Loaf $1.80
Small French Loaf $1.95
Soft French Torpedo Loaf $3.25
Brat Buns 6 Inch $3.00
Brat Slider Buns 3 Inch $5.40
Brioche Buns Hamburger $3.00
Brioche Slider Buns $5.40
Dinnerslider Rolls $5.40
Knot Twist Rolls Large $3.00
Round Italian Hard Rolls $3.00
Soft Pretzel Brat Buns $3.00
Soft Pretzel Hamburger Buns $3.00
Cookies
Amaretti - Per Pound $19.50
Anise Toast Biscotti - Per Pound $19.50
Apricot Tea - Per Pound $19.50
Assorted Cookie Box - Per Pound $19.50
Bacio Biscotti - Per Pound $19.50
Chocolate Bon Bon - Per Pound $19.50
Chocolate Butter Dipped - Per Pound $19.50
Chocolate Butter Star - Per Pound $19.50

Contact:

(414) 272-4623 (414) 209-7393

Tue-Sat: 7am - 4pm
Sun: 7am - 1pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

SCORDATO BAKERY INC

5011 West Howard Avenue,
Milwaukee, WI 53220 Directions

Since 1996

Specialities:

✓Rainbow Cookie ✓Vanilla Coconut Dip Cookie ✓Fig Cookies ✓Vanilla Bon Bon Cookie ✓Apricot Tea Cookie ✓Chocolate Biscotti Cookie ✓Vanilla Butter Star Cookie ✓Italian Macaroon Cookie ✓1 Lb. Holiday Cookie Tray ✓Holiday Cookie Tray ✓Chocolate Bon Bon Cookie ✓Limoncello Cookie ✓Mocha Crunch Cookie ✓Anise Toast Cookie ✓Napolitane Cookie ✓Pipatelli Cookie

" Scordato Bakery Inc is a family-owned and operated business that specializes in a large assortment of Italian cookies, pastries, cakes, fresh breads, and rolls. Every day, they have fresh long rolls, circle rolls, Italian bread, baguettes, and much more. Scordato Bakery Inc has a wide assortment of different Italian cookies. Their pastries are delicious and fresh, and the staff is friendly and helpful. They have fresh pizza dough you can purchase in the cooler and a large selection of freshly baked breads and rolls. Scordato Bakery offers custom cakes for every occasion with delicious buttercream frosting or real whipped cream frosting. Free wedding cake tastings are by appointment only. They also offer Sunday hot ham with free rolls. Scordato Bakery Inc is located in Howard Avenue Shopping Center.

2026 Highlights: Scordato Bakery Inc. has been providing bakery services for 30 years."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Holiday Cookie Tray (Green) $13.49
Holiday Cookie Tray (Red) $13.49
Amaretti Cookie $10.99
Anise Toast Cookie $10.99
Apricot Fruit Cookie $10.99
Apricot Tea Cookie $10.99
Biscotti Cookie $10.99
Chocolate Biscotti Cookie $10.99
Chocolate Bon Bon Cookie $19.50
Limoncello Cookie $19.50
Mocha Crunch Cookie $19.50
Anise Toast Cookie $19.50
Napolitane Cookie $19.50
Pipatelli Cookie $19.50
Chocolate Biscotti Cookie $19.50
Chocolate Butter Star Cookie $19.50

Contact:

(414) 327-8555

Tue-Fri: 7:30am - 5pm
Sat: 7:30am - 4pm
Sun: 7am - 1:30pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

11+ YEARS ON TBR
CALL EMAIL

GREBE'S BAKERY

5132 West Lincoln Avenue,
Milwaukee, WI 53219 Directions

Since 1937

Specialities:

✓Donuts ✓Cruller Bites ✓Cruller Nuggets ✓Muffins ✓Danish and Brownies ✓Cookies ✓Mini-crullers ✓Donut Holes ✓Coffee ✓Glazed Crullers ✓Boars Head Ovengold Turkey Breast ✓Boars Head Rotisserie Chicken ✓Usingers Beef Summer ✓Usingers Fresh Liver ✓Boars Head Salami ✓Usingers Seasoned Roast Beef ✓Breads ✓Rolls ✓Cakes

" Grebe's Bakery is a family-owned bakery/deli that has been a Milwaukee staple for over 85 years. Irene Grebe was an intelligent, talented woman who took matters into her own hands when her family needed her. The bakery's mission is to continue to provide fresh, quality products and friendly, efficient customer service. Grebe's Bakery offers homemade desserts and American breakfast and lunch staples. The bakery's famous donuts and baked goods are available at your local Speedway, Sendik’s, Sentry, Woodman’s, Piggly Wiggly, Pick ‘n Save, Metro Markets, Fresh Thyme, and Festival Foods. The bakery accepts cash, Visa, MasterCard, Discover, and American Express. Grebe's Bakery delivers fresh to over 200 locations in Milwaukee and throughout southeastern Wisconsin and northeastern Illinois.

2026 Highlights: Grebe's Bakery also offers online ordering, shipping, wholesale services, and seasonal flavors."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Donut: $1.40
Cruller Bites: $4.40
Cruller Nuggets 11oz: $4.40
Glazed Cheese Pocket: $3.00
Cookies: $1.05
Usingers Hard Salami: $11.99
Usingers Seasoned Roast Beef: $11.39
Usingers Beef Summer: $8.09
Usingers Smoked Liver: $7.99
"Hot" 1lb Baked Badger Ham: $9.75
"Cold" 1lb Baked Badger Ham: $9.75
Roasted Turkey Breast: $12.99
Usingers Bologna (Pork&Beef): $7.99
American: $7.99
Baby Swiss: $10.99
Mild Provolone: $7.49
Colby Jack: $8.99
Cheddar: $10.99
White American Potato Salad: $4.25
German Potato Salad: $4.25
Gramma'S Potato Salad: $4.25
Macaroni: $3.99
Macaroni With Ham & Cheese: $5.89
Pistachio Pineapple Fluff: $5.50
Grebes Homemade Tuna Salad: $5.89
Creamy Coleslaw: $3.99
Jumbo Dill Pickle: $1.75
Better Butter Rolls 6pk: $2.75
Plain Split Top Rolls 6pk: $2.75
Sesame Rolls 6pk: $2.75
Homestyle White Bread: $2.20

Contact:

(414) 543-7000 (414) 543-7001

Tue-Sun: 5am - 3pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: