BEST MILWAUKEE ITALIAN RESTAURANTS

3 Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI

Name: 3 Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Rating: 4.8

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee. All selected italian restaurants undergo our rigorous 50-Point Inspection, assessing reviews, reputation, history, price, proximity, and more to ensure excellence. No Pay-to-Play!

Onesto Milwaukee Italian Restaurants image 1

Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Onesto image 2

Top Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Onesto image 3

CALL

ONESTO

221 North Broadway,
Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 2014

✓ Bolognese ✓ Raviolo ✓ Red Prawn ✓ Rigate alla Vodka ✓ Fusilli ✓ Meatballs and Pasta ✓ Carbonara ✓ Lobster Campanile ✓ Wagyu Beef Carpaccio ✓ Roasted Pepper Bruschetta ✓ Burrata ✓ Baked Taleggio ✓ House Salad ✓ Caesar Salad ✓ Sautéed Calamari ✓ Grilled Octopus ✓ Meat and Cheese Board ✓ Roasted Pear ✓ Warm Mushroom ✓ Seasonal Soup ✓ Confit Potatoes ✓ Spiced Carrots ✓ Broccolini ✓ Lobster Tail ✓ Scallops ✓ Salmon ✓ Chicken Breast & Meatballs

“Onesta offers a modern twist on Italian food by emphasizing fresh, handmade, and flavorful cuisine. They provide authentic Italian cuisine prepared using regionally sourced ingredients. Guests can enjoy freshness and flavor on each bite. Onesto's second floor has a spacious event hall; the warm and inviting urban loft hall is perfect for special parties, weddings and rehearsals, business dinners, and more. They pair their handmade pasta with an outstanding wine and craft cocktail list on their unique menu. They are proud to offer scratch-made Italian food and impeccable service. The menu ensures there is something available for everyone to taste. Onesta offers a wide selection of wines and focuses on delivering the best quality and authentic flavors. Their cozy second-floor event space is perfect for private parties, weddings, rehearsals, business dinners, and more.”

| |

Price:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

Zarletti Milwaukee Italian Restaurants image 1

Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Zarletti image 2

CALL

ZARLETTI

741 North Milwaukee Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 2004

✓ Handmade Pasta ✓ Ragù Della Casa ✓ Ravioli Ai Quattro Formaggi ✓ Pasta Aglio Olio E Peperoncino ✓ Pappardelle Con Funghi ✓ Pasta Salsiccia Al Marsala ✓ Pasta Alla Bolognese ✓ Pasta Alla Carbonara ✓ Antipasti Platter ✓ Bresaola E Parmigiano ✓ Polpette Di Carne ✓ Calamari Ripieni ✓ Gamberi Pancetta ✓ Olive Della Casa ✓ Bruschetta ✓ Beef Tenderloin Skewers ✓ Panzanella ✓ Caprese ✓ Cesare ✓ Insalata Della Casa ✓ Pera E Gorgonzola ✓ Minestrone Della Casa & Zuppa Del Giorno

“Zarletti takes pride in serving high-quality food, with each dish carefully prepared and offered in generous portions. They specialize in northern Italian cuisine, and the skilled team uses traditional cooking methods to create rich, authentic dishes full of flavor. The menu includes various options like classic pasta, appetizers, main courses, and desserts, ensuring something for everyone. Zarletti is known for their friendly service and also offers a wine list to complement your meal. They provide a take-and-bake lasagna option for a special treat, allowing customers to enjoy their favorite dishes at home. Whether dining with family or friends, Zarletti is the perfect spot for a memorable meal.”

Price:

Contact:

TBR® Inspection Report:

Calderone Club Milwaukee Italian Restaurants image 1

Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Calderone Club image 2

CALL

CALDERONE CLUB

842 North Old World 3rd Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53203 Directions

Since 1983

✓ Garlic Bread ✓ Supplí Alla Romana ✓ Mozzarella Marinara ✓ Ravioli Al Pesto ✓ Melanzane Fritte ✓ Fritto Di Calamari ✓ Bruschetta Al Pomodoro ✓ Insalata Caprese ✓ Antipasto Di Montagna ✓ Toasted Ravioli ✓ Lasagna Con Mozzarella E Pomodoro ✓ Gnocchi San Marzano ✓ Spaghetti Al Filetto Di Pomodoro Con Polpette ✓ Cannelloni Ai Quattro Formaggi ✓ Capellini Alla Caprese ✓ Ravioli Della Casa ✓ Linguine Alla Pescatora ✓ Chicken Fettucine Alfredo ✓ Rigatoni Alla Bolognese ✓ Tortellini Al Calderone ✓ Penne Con Salsiccia & Ravioli Di Aragosta

“Calderone Club is known for their authentic Italian cuisine and famous pizza varieties. Their cozy and welcoming atmosphere has become a favorite dining destination in the city. Guests can enjoy thin-crust pizzas, handmade pasta, flavorful panini, and a wide selection of wines. The pasta is made fresh daily, reflecting the care and tradition that define their menu. Classic Italian dishes like fried eggplant, veal piccata, chicken parmesan, and spaghetti with meatballs highlight their dedication to old-school recipes and high-quality ingredients. The staff at Calderone Club is committed to making every guest feel valued and ensuring a satisfying dining experience. Whether you're stopping by for a business lunch, a romantic dinner, or a meal before or after a game, Calderone Club delivers authentic Italian flavors and a memorable visit every time.”

3 Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI