ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED MILWAUKEE, WI ITALIAN RESTAURANTS

3 Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, WI

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee, Wisconsin. All of our italian restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Onesto - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Onesto - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Onesto - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Onesto video
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

ONESTO

(4.9 Score)
221 North Broadway,
Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 2014

Specialty:

✓ Rigate Alla Vodka ✓ Fusilli ✓ Meatballs and Pasta ✓ Bolognese ✓ Campanelle ✓ Carbonara ✓ Ravioli ✓ Gnocchi Wagyu New York Strip ✓ Short Rib ✓ Crab Cake ✓ Marinated Olives ✓ Meat and Cheese Board ✓ Caesar ✓ Golden Beets ✓ Seasonal Soup ✓ Faroe Island Salmon ✓ Diver Scallops

“Onesto serves a modern twist on traditional Italian fare, with an emphasis on fresh, handmade, and flavorful cuisine. The restaurant features a warm, brick-walled interior that enhances its inviting atmosphere. Onesto offers a wide selection of pasta, entrées, appetizers, and salads. The restaurant also boasts an intimate second-floor event space, perfect for private parties, weddings and rehearsal dinners, business events, and more. The restaurant can accommodate up to 75 guests for seated events and 100 guests for reception-style gatherings. Guests can also purchase gift cards and complete their meals with selections from the wine list and a craft cocktail menu.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

APPETIZERS
Burrata: $15
Sautéed Calamari: $16
Crudo: $18
Bruschetta: $11
Warm Mushroom: $14
PASTA
Rigate alla Vodka: $22
Fusilli: $21
Meatballs & Pasta: $21
Bolognese: $22
Campanelle: $25
Carbonara: $25
Ravioli: $26
Gnocchi: $37
Wagyu New York Strip: $57
Short Rib: $36
Crab Cake: $20
Marinated Olives: $16
Meat & Cheese Board: $20
Faroe Island Salmon: $30
Diver Scallops: $36

Contact:

(414) 308-1600

Sun-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Santino's Little Italy - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Santino's Little Italy - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Santino's Little Italy - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Best Italian Restaurants in Milwaukee WI - Santino's Little Italy video
CALL EMAIL

SANTINO'S LITTLE ITALY

(4.8 Score)
352 E Stewart Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53207 Directions

Since 2017

Specialty:

✓ Gigante Meatball Plate ✓ Pasta Carbonara ✓ Pasto Bolognese ✓ Paisano ✓ Deluxe ✓ the Marnara (vegan) ✓ Pesto E Ricotta ✓ Diavolo ✓ Greek ✓ Capricciosa ✓ Agrigento ✓ Margherita ✓ European Chicken Patata ✓ Vegetarian ✓ Sicilian ✓ Canicatti ✓ Da Vinci ✓ Italian Beef Giardiniera ✓ Diavolo Dolce ✓ Parma ✓ Avorio Margherita

“Santino's Little Italy offers traditional Neapolitan pizzas, pasta, and drinks in a rustic setting with an 1890s Brooklyn vibe. The restaurant is located on the same street as the famous Barnacle Buds. Their team of chefs uses locally sourced ingredients and high-quality products, including Caputo 00 flour, Grande mozzarella, and San Marzano tomatoes. Enjoy their pastas served with penne rigate, with the option to add grilled chicken or sautéed shrimp. Gluten-free chickpea pasta is also available. Santino's Little Italy is the perfect place to relax and enjoy quality time with family and friends. The restaurant also offers patio seating for an enjoyable outdoor dining experience.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

ANTIPASTI
Bruschetta: $12.00
Arancini: $14.00
Focaccia with Montamore Cheese & Olive Oil: $17.00
Calamari Fritti: $17.00
“The Bocce Ball”: $16.00
Melanzana Fritti: $16.00
SALADS
House Salad: $8.00
Mediterranean Salad: $16.00
Caprese Salad: $17.00
Santino’s Shrimp Salad: $20.00
Caesar Salad: $16.00
PASTA
Gigante Meatball Plate: $23.00
Pasta Carbonara: $24.00
Pasto Bolognese: $24.00
PIZZA
Paisano: $23.00
Deluxe: $24.00
Pesto E Ricotta: $20.00
Diavolo: $22.00
Greek: $20.00
Capricciosa: $23.00
Agrigento: $22.00
Margherita: $19.00
European Chicken Patata: $22.00
Vegetarian: $20.00
Sicilian: $21.00
Canicatti: $22.00
Da Vinci: $20.00
Italian Beef Giardiniera: $22.00
Diavolo Dolce: $23.00
Parma: $25.00
Create Your Own Pizza: $18.00
Avorio Margherita: $20.00
Roasted Garlic Pizza: $17.00

Contact:

(414) 897-7367

Sun-Thu: 4pm - 8pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Zarletti Downtown - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Zarletti Downtown - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
Zarletti Downtown - Milwaukee, WI Italian Restaurants
4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

ZARLETTI DOWNTOWN

(4.7 Score)
741 North Milwaukee Street,
Milwaukee, WI 53202 Directions

Since 2004

Specialty:

✓ Ravioli Del Giorno ✓ Ragù Della Casa ✓ Ravioli Ai Quattro Formaggi ✓ Pasta Aglio Olio E Peperoncino ✓ Pappardelle Con Funghi ✓ Pasta Salsiccia Al Marsala ✓ Pasta Alla Bolognese ✓ Pasta Alla Carbonara ✓ Ossobuco Strauss ✓ Vitello Al Limone ✓ Pesce Al Pistacchio ✓ Salmone in Padella ✓ Pollo Alla Saltimbocca

“Zarletti Downtown is a small, minimalist Italian restaurant serving a creative Italian menu along with wine by the glass or bottle. Brian C. Zarletti is the owner of Zarletti Downtown. The restaurant has crafted a dining experience focused on flavorful, northern Italian–inspired dishes made using traditional cooking methods. The restaurant takes pride in offering authentic menus at reasonable prices. Zarletti Downtown features a variety of offerings, including homemade pasta, entrées, appetizers, and salads. You can also pre-order a full or half tray of their delicious handmade take-and-bake lasagna for your next meal or gathering.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

APPETIZERS
Bresaola e Parmigiano: $19
Polpette di Carne: $15
Calamari Ripieni: $20
Gamberi Pancetta: $18
Olive della Casa: $9
Bruschetta: $14
Beef Tenderloin Skewers: $20
INSALATE E MINESTRE
Panzanella: $12
Caprese: $16
Cesare: $14
Insalata Della Casa: $10
Pera e Gorgonzola: $16
Premium Olive Oil Tasting Sample: $5
PASTA
Ravioli del Giorno: $29
Ragù della Casa: $32
Ravioli ai Quattro Formaggi: $29
Pasta Aglio Olio e Peperoncino: $22
Pappardelle con Funghi: $29
Pasta Salsiccia al Marsala: $30
Pasta alla Bolognese: $30
Pasta alla Carbonara: $26
Grilled chicken breast: $6
Sauteed shrimp: $12
Italian sausage: $8
Pancetta: $7
ENTREES
Ossobuco: $45
Vitello al Limone: $40
Pesce al Pistacchio: $38
Salmone in Padella: $32
Pollo alla Saltimbocca: $29

Contact:

(414) 225-0000

Mon-Thu: 4:45pm - 8:45pm
Fri & Sat: 4:45pm - 9pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Zarletti Downtown

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

ONESTO REVIEWS

We were greeted quickly and had to wait a bit for our table. We were soon sat. Love the bar area, but don't love the dining area. It's small and we sat up against an empty brick wall. I could see the workers struggling to move around eachother throughout service. However, our server was still gracious. Drinks came out timely even though it was busy and were great. We had a lycheetini and hibiscus lime margarita. Pastas were amazing, would love to try add one next time.

I’ve been here several times over the summer and recently visited again and coincidentally had the same server, I’m unsure of her name but she was phenomenal it might have been a gabrielle or something with a G. Even with the changes of the menu the food is consistently delicious, and I will always come back!.

Onesto met all of our expectations! We were looking for somewhere new and delicious. Service was great and the food was so good and served nice and hot. We had the pasta and meatballs and the rock shrimp pesto. This was the perfect place to celebrate our anniversary. Thank you! We will definitely be back.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

SANTINO'S LITTLE ITALY REVIEWS

Very nicely lit. This is a very relaxing place to have a nice dinner. This is kind of a hidden gem, although lots of people know about this place. You have to make reservations here if you want a table. Service and food are really good. I really enjoyed the atmosphere here.

This place is a must visit when in Milwaukee. Everything about it is immaculate from the atmosphere to the food. Perhaps the main highlight is the service and pride that the staff and owner put into your visit. They knew that we were out for a birthday, and it was the greatest surprise to receive tiramisu on the house to take home and enjoy. Santino's is the definition of an outstanding dining experience. Pasta is good but the pizza is outstanding.

Great place for a date night. The bocce ball app is absolutely the bomb. Pizza was very good as well. Drinks are a hit or miss. I ordered a Italian Margarita and it was served in a regular beer pint glass. Kind of clashes with the aesthetic of the place and came off as lazy. Minor point though. The service is amazing and they have a pretty extensive Vermouth menu which makes this place an authentic Italian restaurant.

ZARLETTI DOWNTOWN REVIEWS

Went there for a birthday dinner and had an absolutely amazing experience! Excellent service from Bryan and the food and wine could not be beat. Had a unique opportunity to have a bottle of Sardinian wine and we were blown away. The bolognese and ravioli were absolutely delicious, and the burrata appetizer with prosciutto was amazing as well. Panna cotta dessert was to die for. The hostess was extremely friendly and the overall atmosphere was perfect. Definitely planning to be back soon!.

A delicious option for a fancy dinner. It is expensive, but it is definitely worth it. I highly recommend the mushroom pasta option, and I got it with sautéed shrimp. The pera cocktail was very good. The rib eye was also the favorite entrée of the group. The bruschetta was a great appetizer as well.

Brian is a fantastic server! Went to celebrate a birthday and enjoyed multiple decadent pasta entrees. He is very knowledgeable on the wine and we also loved our desserts! Definitely recommend.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

ONESTO Total Inspection Points: 118/120
Experience: 8
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Current Evaluation: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Video: 10
Table Reservation: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

SANTINO'S LITTLE ITALY Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Experience: 7
Current Evaluation: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Pricing: 10
Video: 10
Table Reservation: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

ZARLETTI DOWNTOWN Total Inspection Points: 112/120
Current Evaluation: 8
Experience: 8
Reviews Study: 8
Complete Info: 9
Legitimate Ratings: 9
Business Hours: 10
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Table Reservation: 10