3 Best Italian Restaurants in New Haven, CT

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in New Haven, Connecticut. All of our italian restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

10+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

ENCORE BY GOODFELLAS

702 State Street,
New Haven, CT 06511 Directions

Since 2023

Specialities:

Risotto Of The Day Lasagna and Meatballs Cavatelli Calabrese Spaghetti Alla Sophia Loren Sicilian Pork Chops New York Strip Chilean Sea Bass Chicken Rollatini Jumbo Shrimp and Scallops Tuna Rib Eye Contadina Duck Porterhouse Veal Chop Atlantic Salmon Filet Cognac Murray's Chicken Swordfish Veal Saltimbocca Chicken Parmigiana Cioppino Lamb Chops Veal Claudio Oysters Two Ways Ricotta Crostini Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Fried Calamari Pane Cotto Meatball Salad Grilled Shrimp

"Encore by Goodfellas is dedicated to providing a combined 50 years of experience in the restaurant industry. The restaurant brings a modern interpretation of an era when dining was an experience. The restaurant is designed as an old-school mobster-themed Italian eatery in a cozy storefront with brick walls and white tablecloths. The Beggars Purse features delicate pasta purses filled with Parmigiano Reggiano, ricotta cheese, and fresh pear, finished with a rich brown butter sage sauce. Encore by Goodfellas presents Copper Cane Wines & Provisions Wine Maker Dinner with Joe Wagner, Owner & Winemaker. They also have vegetarian-friendly, vegan options, and gluten-free options.

2026 Highlights: They feature a newly renovated space with an elegant dining room and a sleek, modern 32-seat bar, creating a stylish and inviting atmosphere for an unforgettable dining experience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Reader's Choice Award "Best Italian Restaurant
Best Italian Restaurant in New Haven County by CT Magazine's 2012 Reader's Choice Awards

Menu:

PASTA:
Rigatoni Vodka $25.00
Penne Arrabbiata $24.00
Gnocchi Pomodoro $24.00
Penne Norcina $25.00
Bucatini Amatriciana $25.00
Orecchiette Bolognese $25.00
Pasta Toscana $26.00
Linguine and Clams $28.00
Beggars Purse $26.00
Ravioli of The Day Mp
Fettuccine Alfredo $26.00
Risotto of The Day Mp
Lasagna and Meatballs $27.00
Cavatelli Calabrese $26.00
Spaghetti alla Sophia Loren $24.00
ENTREE:
Sicilian Pork Chops $29.00
New York Strip $38.00
Chilean Sea Bass $36.00
Chicken Rollatini $27.00
Jumbo Shrimp & Scallops $32.00
Tuna $32.00
Rib Eye Contadina $39.00
Duck $29.00
Porterhouse Veal Chop $36.00
Atlantic Salmon $29.00
Filet Cognac Mp
Murray's Chicken $27.00
Swordfish $30.00
Veal Saltimbocca $29.00
Chicken Parmigiana $27.00
Cioppino $38.00
Lamb Chops $34.00

Contact:

(203) 785-8722

Tue-Thu: 4pm - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 11pm
Sun: 1pm - 8pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BRAZI'S ITALIAN RESTAURANT

201 Food Terminal Plaza,
New Haven, CT 06511 Directions

Since 1993

Specialities:

Pizza Large 16 Pizza Cheese Calzone Small Pizza Kids Chicken Fingers Kids Pasta W/tomato Sauce Kids Pasta W/vodka Sauce Children Ravioli Artichokes Francese Brazi Style Fried Calamari Fried Calamari Broccoli Rabe and Sausage Bruschetta Al Pomodoro Clams Casino Eggplant Rollatini Garlic Bread Mozzarella In Carrozza Fried Hot Peppers W/sausage and Potatoes Side Caesar Salad Arugula Salad Arugula Salad W/chicken Brazi Garden Salad Caesar Salad Chicken Caesar Salad Italian Antipasto Mozzarella Caprese

"Brazi's Italian Restaurant is a family-friendly setting that serves authentic flavor of Italian menus. Savor their Trenette alla Oro, a dish of ruffled noodles tossed with fresh broccoli, grilled chicken, onions, and sun-dried tomatoes in a classic creamy sauce. Their Half Pizza Half Salad dishes are the best of both worlds. Brazi's Italian Restaurant has dining options in three inviting rooms: the banquet room, the lively bar, and the cozy dining room. The restaurant offers happy hour and vegan menus. They accept reservations.

2026 Highlights: They offer several event spaces, including semi-private rooms for up to 60 seated guests and 75 standing, a semi-private bar area for 45 seated or 60 standing guests, and the fully private Amalfi Room, which accommodates up to 50 seated or 75 standing guests."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

PASTA:
Lasagna Al Forno $22.95
Linguini Con Vongole $25.95
Ravioli Alla Brasiere $25.95
Rigatoni Bolognese (L) $25.95
Spaghetti & Meatballs $21.95
L-Trenette Alla Oro
L-Fettuccini Alfredo
L-Penne Alla Vodka
Cavatelli Con Broccoli
Cavatelli Con Rabe
Fettuccini Alfredo
Linguini Puttanesca
Pasta Bella
Penne Alla Vodka
Rigatoni Bolognese
Trenette Alla Oro
Penne Al Salmon $25.95
Tortellini Alla Toscana $24.95
Calamari Al Sugo Dipomodoro $25.95
Ciopinno Amalfitana $45.95
Risotto Al Mare $45.95
Cod Livornese $29.95
Shrimp & Clams Pescatore $28.95
Shrimp Scampi Mediterranea $26.95
TRADITIONAL FAVORITES:
Eggplant Parmigiana $22.95
Italian Combo $22.95
Lasagna Al Forno $22.95
Linguini Con Vongole $25.95
Penne Al Salmon $25.95
Ravioli Alla Brasiere $25.95

Contact:

(203) 498-2488

Mon-Thu: 11:30am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 11:30am - 10pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

4+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

L'ORCIO

806 State Street,
New Haven, CT 06511 Directions

Since 2002

Specialities:

Formaggi Olive Erbiviro Chef's Evoo Sardine Farro Burrata Crochette Gamberi Limoncello Polpo Carnivoro Insalata Mediterranea Carpaccio Di Manzo Insalata Di Cesare Mista Amatriciana Ragu' Pomodoro Vodka Funghi Sorrentina Ricotta Norma Pesto Saltimbocca Di Vitello Salmone Pepe Verde Branzino Arrosto Agnello Ny Strip Pollo Al Limone Pollo Caprese Milanese Cavolletti Di Bruxelles Patate Arrosto Spinaci Aglio E Olio Fagiolini Charlotte

"L'Orcio is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant. The restaurant features modern Italian cuisine, including fresh pasta, served in a townhouse with a trellis-covered patio. They pride themselves on providing homemade pasta to desserts that ensure every bite is filled with authentic and fresh flavors. Finish your meal with their creamy tiramisu or indulge in a plate of handmade gnocchi. The restaurant's chef is Chef d'Amuri. He has a passion for cooking Italian foods. His inspirations are regional Italian recipes that rely on quality ingredients. L'Orcio provides a variety of cocktails and vegan menus.

2026 Highlights: They offer a private dining room for parties and special events of up to 40 guests, including birthdays, graduations, rehearsal dinners, and corporate gatherings."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pasta
Amatriciana $25.00
Ragu' $25.00
Pomodoro $24.00
Vodka $25.00
Funghi $24.00
Sorrentina $25.00
Ricotta $25.00
Norma $23.00
Pesto $24.00
ANTIPASTI:
Formaggi $14.00
Olive $6.00
Erbivoro $15.00
Chef's Evoo $4.00
Sardine $17.00
Farro $14.00
Burrata $14.00
Crocchette $10.00
Gamberi Limoncello $16.00
Polpo $17.00
Carnivoro $16.00
INSALATE:
Insalata Mediterranea $13.00
Carpaccio Di Manzo $17.00
Insalata Di Cesare $13.00
Mista $8.00
PRIMI:
Amatriciana $25.00
Ragu' $25.00
Pomodoro $24.00
Vodka $25.00
Funghi $24.00
Sorrentina $25.00
Ricotta $25.00
Norma $23.00
Pesto $24.00

Contact:

(203) 777-6670

Tue-Thu: 5pm - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 5pm - 9:30pm
Sun: 4pm - 8:30pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: