3 Best Pizza Places in Madison, WI

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pizzeria in Madison, Wisconsin. All of our pizza places actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

IAN'S PIZZA

100 State Street,
Madison, WI 53703 Directions

Since 2005

Specialities:

Mac N’ Cheese Maui Wowie Spinach Feta Pesto Pizza Tomato Pesto Pizza Buff Chicken Drunken Ravioli Pizza Penne Alfredo Baked Penne All Veg Pizza Smoky The Bandit Pizza Pomodoro Macho Nacho Cheesy Potato Ranch Classic Cheese Classic Pepperoni Southwest and Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wisco Salad Greek Salad Farr Out Salads

"Ian's Pizza is a Wisconsin-based creative pizza company, including its signature mac 'n' cheese pie. They specialize in a wide variety of old-school and original pizza combinations. They offer around two dozen varieties of pizza, ranging from smoked brisket and tots to spinach, feta, and pesto. Their team provides fresh and delicious pizza using ingredients from nearby source farms. You can build your toppings: veggies, Meat, sauces, and Noodles. All their pizzas and everything they serve are handmade every day, including bread, pasta, and pastries. Enjoy their lovely pesto blue portobello, penne pesto, spinach feta pesto, Smoky Bandit, Maui Wowie, and Bandit Uncle. Gift cards are available.

2026 Highlights: The restaurant specializes in a wide variety of old school and original pizza combinations, all available by the slice or whole pie. They create exciting recipes incorporating the finest local ingredients and aim to make the best NY-style."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Pizza
Cheese Or Pepperoni Slice: $4.50
Any Specialty Slice: $5.50
The Shmo Pizza: $12.50
Pepperoni Sausage Pizza: $12.50
Pepperoni Mushroom Pizza: $12.50
Cheese Pizza: $10.00
Pepperoni Pizza: $11.00
Sausage Pizza: $12.50
Mac N’ Cheese Pizza: $12.50
Maui Wowie Pizza: $16.50
Spinach Feta Pesto Pizza: $16.50
Tomato Pesto Pizza: $12.50
Buffalo Chicken Pizza: $15.00
Drunken Ravioli Pizza: $15.00
Chicken Penne Alfredo Pizza: $15.00
Smokey The Bandit Pizza: $16.50
Pomodoro Pizza: $15.00
Macho Nacho Pizza: $16.50
Cheesy Potato W Ranch Pizza: $12.50
All The Veg Pizza: $15.00

Contact:

(608) 257-9248

Sun-Tue: 11am - 10pm
Wed: 11am - 12am
Thu: 11am - 2am
Fri & Sat: 11am - 2:30am

TBR® Inspection Report:

5+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

LUCILLE

101 King Street,
Madison, WI 53703 Directions

Since 2016

Specialities:

Build Your Own Wood-fired Pizza Wood-fired 'the Queen' Wood-fired 'she's A-maize-ing' Wood-fired 'sausage and Rabe' 10 Build Your Own Wood-fired Pizza Wood-fired 'umami Pie' Wood-fired 'mediterranean Large Spring Salad Steel Pan Flourless Fudge Brownie (gf) Large Caesar Salad Empanadas

"Lucille is a vintage, industrial-chic tavern with three floors serving wood-fired & steel-pan pizzas, plus cocktails in Madison, WI. They use fresh and locally sourced ingredients to make quality pizzas. All their pizzas are made fresh for every order. They make pizza dough by blending fresh flour with water and allowing it to ferment for hours. Lucille Pizzas have thin in the crust and are chewy in the middle. Their pizzas are loaded with enormous cheese and fired in the traditional Oven. Recommended dishes at this Lucille are Almyrá with Mint Salsa Verde, Goat Cheese, Spinach, Pickled Sweet Chilis, Roasted Garlic, Sun-Dried Tomatoes, and Currant Gastrique. This Lucille pizza restaurant has takeout, dine-in, gift cards, wheelchair access, and high chair access. Lucille serves alcohol, a full bar, and table service. Lucille is a vegan and vegetarian-friendly pizza restaurant. Lucille has gluten-free options.

2026 Highlights: The restaurant offers warm, fun, and an endlessly interesting mix of inspired programming that challenges, invigorates, and delights its guests by celebrating their craft."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

PIZZAS:
Build Your Own Steel Pan $30.00
Wood-Fired 'Rise & Shine' $28.80
Steel Pan 'The Weekender' $43.20
Steel Pan '6-Mile' $34.80
10" Build Your Own Wood-Fired Pizza $16.80
Steel Pan 'Sausage Fest' $43.20
Wood-Fired 'Umami Pie' $31.20
Wood-Fired 'The Queen' $21.60
14" Build Your Own Wood-Fired Pizza $24.00
Steel Pan 'Cacio Bebe' $42.00
Steel Pan 'Al Pastor' $42.00
Steel Pan 'Standard' $33.60
Wood-Fired 'Sausage & Rabe' $25.20
Wood-Fired 'Mediterranean' $25.20
Steel Pan 'Rise & Shine' $38.40
Wood-Fired 'She'S A-Maize-Ing' $26.40

Discount:

50% Off on All "M" Cocktails

Contact:

(608) 283-0000

Mon-Wed: 3pm - 11pm
Thurs & Sun: 11am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 1am

TBR® Inspection Report:

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

GLASS NICKEL PIZZA CO.

2916 Atwood Avenue,
Madison, WI 53704 Directions

Since 1997

Specialities:

Bacon Cheeseburger Border To Border Buffalo Nickel Mac Daddy Mediterranean Portabella Lugosi Santa Fe Ferd-licious Margherita Pollo Diablo The Ranch Thai Pie Spinach Cheese Bread Nickel Nuggets Chicken Alfredo Chicken Cordon Bleu Boar's Karloff Breakfast Pie Cardiac Arrest Chicky Parm Couch Potato Veluxe White Cheddar Cheese Curds Fried Mac and Cheese Bites Mozzarella Sticks

"Glass Nickel Pizza Co. provides creative pizzas, classic pasta, wings, fish, and shrimp. The restaurant has been in this business for more than 26 years. The restaurant offers dine-in seating service with booths and tables seating for over 80 people. Their Crab Rangoon is topped with crab meat, drizzled with sweet and sour sauce, and finished with wonton strips, fresh green onions, and black sesame seeds. They use the highest quality ingredients to make their pizzas more delicious. They offer special features like takeout, dine-in, wheelchair access, serving alcohol, and a private dining room. Food delivery service and catering service options are available.

2026 Highlights: Their store selects local nonprofits, schools, or other community organizations that align with the requirements and values of its community, creating a tailored approach to giving back and creating a positive, tangible impact on the people around them."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Menu:

Special Pizza Small 10:
Bacon Cheeseburger: $12.99
Board Skarloff: $12.99
Buffalo Nickel: $12.99
Chicken Alfredo: $12.99
Chicky Chicky Parm Parm: $12.99
Chicken Cordon Bleu: $12.99
Deluxe: $12.99
Santa Fe: $12.99
The Ranch: $12.99
Mac Daddy: $12.99
Margherita: $12.99
Mediterranean: $12.99
Pollo Diablo: $12.99
Portabella Lucious: $12.99
Santa Fe Bbq: $12.99
Spinach Alfredo: $12.99
Thai Pie: $12.99
The Hawaiian: $12.99
Veggie Out: $12.99
Vegan Cheese Delight: $12.99
PASTA:
Mix’N Match Pasta Plate: $8.99
Mac & Cheese: $7.99
Chicken Alfredo: $8.99
Homemade Lasagna: $9.99
Cheese Bread: $6.99
French Fries (Small): $2.99
French Fries (Large): $5.99
Mac & Cheese Bites: $6.99
Garlic Toast (2 Slices): $1.99
JalapeñO Poppers Wcream Cheese: $6.99
Side Salad (House): $4.99
Side Salad (Caesar): $4.99
Side Salad (Greek): $4.99

Discount:

$8 Off Any 14" Pizza

Contact:

(608) 245-0880 (608) 729-5529

Sun-Thu: 10:30am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 10:30am - 12am

TBR® Inspection Report: