3 Best Gift Shops in Indianapolis, IN

Expert-recommended Top 3 Gift Shops in Indianapolis, Indiana. All of our gift shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

8+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SILVER IN THE CITY

434 Massachusetts Avenue,
Indianapolis, IN 46204 Directions

Since 2000

Specialty:

2027 Planners Calendars Activism Pride Baby Kids Bags Zips Totes Candles Accessories Crafts Kits Games Puzzles Hats Gloves Scarves Kitchen Bar Mugs Cups Nature Travel Self-Reflection Insight Socks Shirts Starlights Prints Stationery Office Trinkets Trays Coffee Table Humor Book Club Journal Storage Box Dishtowel

" Silver IN THE CITY is a locally owned shop that offers a wide range of products, including jewelry and housewares, making it an ideal destination for finding unconventional gifts for birthdays, holidays, and special occasions. Their super-friendly and knowledgeable sales staff are always ready to assist, sharing their product expertise, offering gift suggestions, and even reaching items on the top shelves for you. To accommodate last-minute surprises, they provide a same-day delivery service. They have another branch in Carmel, IN. They offer convenience and accessibility to their valued customers. At Silver in the City, they prioritize creating a welcoming and fun shopping environment. Free shipping on orders over $75.

2026 Highlights: Silver IN THE CITY is a woman-owned independent gift shop and silver jewelry boutique located in the heart of downtown Indianapolis, IN. They run the Silver Linings Fund, providing grants to Indiana-based 501(c)(3) nonprofit organizations. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #2000060100070

Price:

Indianapolis Drinking Glass $20.00
Surprise Bath Bomb $13.00
Sow The Magic Bath Bomb $12.00
Maeve 8oz Bonbon Gift Box Fall Harvest $26.50
Evil Kitty Pin $10.00
Fat Pigeon Pin $10.00
Emo Frog Pin $10.00
Eat The Rich Pin $10.00
Murder Bear Pin $10.00
News Flash Pin $10.00
Serious Goose Pin $10.00
Eff It We Ball Sticker $4.00
Bad Betty Wooden Magnet $6.00
Letterpress Mini Notebook Bag Charm $12.50
Diet Soda Letterpress Spiral Notebook $14.50
Letterpress Top Spiral Notebook $17.50
Strawberry Goose Round Tote $32.00
Fall Fox Round Tote $32.00
Bp Pen Set $16.00
Tiny Treat Mission Bumper Sticker $8.00
Adorro Purple Ghost Claw Clip $12.00
Grip Socks Collection $20.00
Deluxe Cross Stitch $28.00
Holiday Shapes Cookie Cutter $3.50
Today Maybe Tomorrow Notepad $18.00

Discount:

Join Their Mailing List and Receive 10% Off on Your First Purchase

Contact:

(317) 955-9925

Mon-Sat: 10am - 8pm
Sun: 10am - 6pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

8+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BLACK SHEEP GIFTS

5626 East Washington Street,
Indianapolis, IN 46219 Directions

Since 2010

Specialty:

Artisan Goods Vintage Toys Handmade Gifts Personalized Gifts Local Products Pop Culture Toys Retro Items Kids Gifts Greeting Cards Home Decor Stationery Jewelry Accessories Candles Fragrances Body Products Apparel Bags Purses Totes Kitchenware Barware Coffee Mugs Pet Items Books Games Seasonal Gifts

" Black Sheep Gifts is a locally owned and woman-owned business that offers a wide selection of unique games, gifts, and toys. The shop provides a well-organized, spacious, and clean environment, creating a pleasant shopping experience for customers. Black Sheep Gifts has built a reputation for offering exclusive giftware and unique items that meet all your gifting needs. Their selection includes creative and one-of-a-kind gifts, excellent greeting cards, fair trade merchandise, and locally made items. They offer special events tailored for kids and adults, adding excitement to their offerings. Their dedication to customer satisfaction includes free delivery in the Indianapolis area, ensuring convenience and accessibility for their customers.

2026 Highlights: Black Sheep Gifts offers convenient in-store shopping, curbside pickup, and regular delivery services to make shopping easy and flexible. "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #2009122100547

Contact:

(317) 602-5442

Mon-Thu: 11am - 7pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 8pm
Sun: 12pm - 5pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

TWISTED SISTERS

3937 East 82nd Street,
Indianapolis, IN 46240 Directions

Since 2008

Specialty:

Apparel Clothing Accessories Jewelry Permanent Jewelry Purses Totes Gifts Perfumes Soaps Candles Glassware Pottery Charcuterie Kitchenware Tea Towels Cocktail Napkins Mugs Drinkware Home Decor Decorative Pillows Throw Pillows Stationery Desk Accessories Games Mahjong Toys Umbrellas

" Twisted Sisters has a variety ranging from handmade soaps to handbags, scarves, and jewelry. The shop has over 15 years of experience in the field. This gift shop specializes in U.S. and local hand-crafted gifts, accessories, and home decor. They are the go-to boutique for anything from a hostess gift to a wedding present or just something special for yourself. The employees working in this gift shop are devoted to helping their customers. The store offers many products made by local and national artists. They also have painted wine glasses, fun barware, pottery, and some great kitchen items. If you are searching for the perfect gift for any occasion, Twisted Sisters is the ideal shop.

2026 Highlights: Twisted Sisters operates under the playful motto: "Nothing you need, but everything you want". "

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #2008050100033

Contact:

(317) 841-7177

Mon-Fri: 10am - 6pm
Sat: 10am - 5pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: