ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED PITTSBURGH, PA ITALIAN RESTAURANTS

3 Best Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh, PA

Expert-recommended Top 3 Italian Restaurants in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. All of our italian restaurants actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Sienna Mercato - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
Sienna Mercato - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
Sienna Mercato - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

SIENNA MERCATO

(4.8 Score)
942 Penn Avenue,
Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Directions

Since 2013

Specialty:

✓ Bruschetta Del Giorno ✓ Caesar ✓ Italian Burger ✓ Pesto Chicken Pasta ✓ House Sausage ✓ Preserve Plate ✓ Muffuletta ✓ Short Rib Ragu ✓ Bruschetta Burger ✓ Cacio E Pepe ✓ Jacked Mac Bowl ✓ Johnny Cake ✓ Garlic Shrimp ✓ Chopped Wedge Salad ✓ Prosciutto and Chicken Cacciatore ✓ That's A Spicy Meatball ✓ Shrimp Vodka Pasta ✓ Side Caesar ✓ Arugula Salad ✓ Bolognese Bianco ✓ Italian Classic Bowl ✓ Scallops ✓ Chicken Parmesan ✓ Rigatoni Ala Vodka ✓ Papas Bravas ✓ Candied Berkshire Pork Belly with Jalapeno ✓ House Salad ✓ Sandwiches ✓ Shepherd's Pie ✓ Side Salad ✓ Fresh Bread Basket ✓ Margherita ✓ Seafood Agliolio ✓ Pepperoni ✓ Formaggi ✓ Crispy Chicken Pesto Sandwich

“Sienna Mercato offers a gourmet Italian menu in a warm, farm-inspired room. Their rooftop beer garden offers 32 drafts, cocktails, wine, and light fare. Here, you can have a fun experience in an open-air concept dining area. Sienna Mercato is a 3-story restaurant. Each floor has a unique yet complementary dining destination. Their three-story restaurant is the ideal venue for hosting unforgettable private events that leave a lasting impression on your guests, and they also offer catering options perfect for groups of all sizes. Online reservation, takeout, and online ordering options are available here, and they also offer gift cards. They hosted a professional happy hour in the restaurant's Emporio Front Room, and everything was perfect.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

SAUCY BALL BOWLS
Jacked Mac Bowl: $16.00
Italian Classic Bowl: $16.00
That's A Spicy Meatball: $16.00
Pesto Chicken Pasta: $16.00
SALAD
Arugula Salad: $10.00
Caesar: $10.00
Chopped Wedge Salad: $10.00
House Salad: $10.00
Side Salad: $5.00
Side Caesar: $5.00
SANDWICHES
Muffuletta: $16.00
Crispy Chicken Pesto Sandwich: $16.00
Italian Burger: $16.00
Bruschetta Burger: $16.00
Shrimp Vodka Pasta: $20.00
Shepherd's Pie: $18.00
Chicken Parmesan: $18.00

Contact:

(412) 281-2810

Tue & Wed: 11:30am - 10pm
Thu: 11:30am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 11:30am - 2am
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

DiAnoia's Eatery - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
DiAnoia's Eatery - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
DiAnoia's Eatery - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

DIANOIA'S EATERY

(4.8 Score)
2549 Penn Avenue,
Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Directions

Since 1998

Specialty:

✓ House Salad ✓ Mussels Acqua Pazza ✓ Roasted Potatoes ✓ Roasted Rapini and Chili Flake ✓ Beans and Sausage ✓ Caputo Brother’s Whipped Ricotta ✓ Primavera ✓ Lamb Sugo ✓ Gnocchi Sorrentina Bread Bowl ✓ Garlic ✓ Parm ✓ Spring Carbonara ✓ Escarole ✓ Roasted Asparagus ✓ Carciofo Romana ✓ Cacio E Pepe ✓ Meatballs and Sauce ✓ Spring Panzanella ✓ Italian Chopped Salad ✓ Roasted Cauliflower ✓ Gluten Free Pasta ✓ House Marinated Olives ✓ Gnocchi and Meatballs ✓ Crema Di Pomodoro Secco

“DiAnoia's Eatery provides a cozy and pleasant ambiance for its customers. The restaurant is owned by Chef Dave Anoia and his wife Aimee DiAndrea. They combine the dining experience of your favorite Italian vacation with the warmth and coziness of a friendly neighborhood restaurant. DiAnoia's Eatery is the perfect place for a quick morning breakfast sandwich and zeppole or a sit-down gathering place for friends and family who love to talk with their hands and eat fresh-made pasta. The restaurant is now accepting reservations 6 weeks in advance, and they have a bar and outdoor seating available for walk-in guests. The restaurant has been voted for the consecutive years as the Best Italian Restaurant in Pittsburgh by PGH City Paper. Over five years, managing hundreds of events annually with their private on-site event space and providing exceptional care for their guests.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Egg Sandwich: $6.50
Extra Cheese: +$1.50 / Extra Egg: +$1.50 / Gluten Free Bun: +$2.50
Avocado Toast: $9.00
(Add Egg: +$1.50 / Gluten Free Bun: +$2.50)
Caprese Omelette: $14.00
(Egg whites: +$2.00)
Prosciutto & Mozz Omelette: $16.00
(Egg whites: +$2.00)
Porchetta Eggs Benedict: $15.00
(Gluten Free Bun: +$2.50)
French Toast: $13.00
Italian Stallion: $16.00
Add Sausage: +$3.00
American Breakfast: $13.00
(Gluten Free Bun: +$2.50)
Roasted Potatoes (Small): $7.00
Roasted Potatoes (Large): $10.00
Zeppole (4): $6.00
COLD PANINI
ITALIANO: $16.00
CAPRESE: $15.00
TURKEY: $15.00
PROSCIUTTO: $17.00
PASTA
AGLIO E OLIO: $23.00
SPAGHETTI & RED SAUCE: $19.00
SPAGHETTI & MEATBALLS: $24.00
PASTA ALLA MENTE: $23.00
GNOCCHI & MEATBALLS: $26.00
CACIO E PEPE: $25.00
PORK SUGO: $26.00

Contact:

(412) 918-1875

Tue-Thu: 8am - 9pm
Fri & Sat: 8am - 10pm
Sun: 3pm - 8pm
Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Alla Famiglia - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
Alla Famiglia - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
Alla Famiglia - Pittsburgh, PA Italian Restaurants
CALL EMAIL

ALLA FAMIGLIA

(4.7 Score)
804 East Warrington Avenue,
Pittsburgh, PA 15210 Directions

Since 1997

Specialty:

✓ Porcini and Asparagus Arancini ✓ Cotoletta Del Monzu ✓ Fried Cheese ✓ Porcini Mushroom Sacchetti ✓ Patatine Fritte ✓ and Rosemary Grilled Shrimp ✓ Smoked Provolone ✓ Lemon Pappardelle ✓ Hot Banana Peppers ✓ Mussels Diavolo ✓ Chicken Ala Limon ✓ Oysters on the Half Shell ✓ Greens and Beans ✓ Meatball Gigante ✓ Flash Fried Calamari ✓ Seafood Diavola ✓ Pancetta Wrapped Chilean Sea Bass ✓ Tagliatelle Scoglio Del Mare

“Alla Famiglia brings their traditions and transactions to Allentown, where they present their passion for cooking and their discipline for methodology. Pittsburgh staple Italian Restaurant for over 20 years. It is a Full-service spot specializing in milk-fed veal, homemade pastas, exotics of the sea, and a full pastry department. Alla Famiglia never disappoints for romantic dates, celebratory milestones, or just a night out. They are committed to consistently delivering high-quality Italian food with stellar and friendly service for decades to come. Their award-winning wine list and craft-inspired cocktails complement the decor of the Depression era, reminding them of the people who designed these houses.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Oysters On The Half Shell: $22
Tagliere: $34
Meatball Gigante: $17
Hot Banana Peppers: $17
Fritto Misto: $22
Mussels Diavolo: $20
Greens & Beans: $18
Fried Cheese: $15+
Smoked Provolone: $17
Patatine Fritte: $9
Porchetta: $22
Marsala: $44
Piccata: $42
Parmigiana: $42
Margherita: $44
Pizzaiola: $46
Milanese: $44
Bone In Filet: $107
New York Strip Sirloin: $75
Filet Mignon: $58

Contact:

(412) 488-1440

Mon-Thu: 4pm - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 4pm - 11pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Alla Famiglia

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

SIENNA MERCATO REVIEWS

My mother is visiting from out of state and found this place while searching the map for Italian dinner spots. We came here on a whim and had one of the loveliest dinners we can remember as a mother/daughter duo. Our server, Jacob, was fantastic. He provided warm, friendly, charismatic service and was eager to answer all of our questions about the menu and plates. Not only was Jacob our server, but also the bartender and the cocktails were fab-u-us!! You can NOT go wrong with the charcuterie board which has rotating selections daily, the entrees are very fairly priced for quality and quantity. I ordered cannolis on a whim (there’s a whole family lore behind why I don’t eat cannolis) and you know what… I think after 30 years, I love cannolis again. To the entire staff- thank you for a fantastic evening! We loved it, and went home stuffed and happy.

A Meatball Joint in Pittsburgh is an absolute gem for anyone craving comfort food with a twist! The menu offers a creative and customizable dining experience centered around their signature meatballs, which are hands down great! Addison, our server and General Manager, was professional and courteous! Great restaurant!

Rooftop bar is a vibe, servers are friendly, great happy hour specials. Food good as well. Would recommend limongria, and the happy hour special lemoncello martini I ordered the Parmesan herb fries, would recommend those. I got a meatball slider which was good, but the crack sauce is just chipotle ranch, so I wouldn’t recommend ordering with the slider.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

DIANOIA'S EATERY REVIEWS

I wish we lived closer! We tried this wonderful restaurant while on a recent trip to Pittsburgh and so glad we did! They acommodated our party of 3 last minute on a busy night at the bar. Food is top notch and we had a good view of the amazing staff in and out of the kitchen. Pasta Primavera with Shrimp, Rapini, Gnocchi and Meatballs and the Bolognese Bianco every bite was so delicious. And yummy Tiramisu for dessert.

One of the best Italian restaurants in Pittsburgh. The food is AMAZING and the atmosphere is very nice. We sat near the garage doors so having windows near us was very nice with the natural light. Cannot recommend this place enough. The side salad is definitely shareable and the bread and olive oil is amazing. I did not get a picture of the brussel sprouts but they were also very good. Every single dish does not disappoint. Please try this place!!

Wonderful place to get really good Italian food, a great atmosphere, although it was loud at times, The service and the food are top notch. Highly recommend going there for dinner, the bread is unique and inviting, and the pasta, especially the gnocchi is like pillows of pasta. The specialty cocktails are phenomenal. Definitely try them.

ALLA FAMIGLIA REVIEWS

We were here for a work event in the upper dining area. This place was incredible. From the minute you step in the door. The atmosphere incredible. The food unbelievable. This was my first time here, but it won’t be the last. From the meatball app, to the pasta, the olive oil dipping with hot peppers crazy good, to the salad, to the main course and of course dessert. I had the chilin sea bass. Wow incredible. Plus our server Caitlin was incredible. Knowledgeable, caring and understanding. She hit it out of the ball park. Was it expensive sure. Ever good thing in life is not cheap.

The food was very good. We were sat near the kitchen line, which was a new experience and resulted in an interesting “show” from one of the servers. Thankfully, our server was great in handling it. The portion sizes were quite large, and resulted in plenty of leftovers!

An amazing restaurant. The meatball appetizer is amazing, the Cacio e Pepe pasta is prepared table side and is a must try! Loved the Caesar Salad, the white anchovies made it special.

TBR® Inspection Score Report

SIENNA MERCATO Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Experience: 8
Business Hours: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Acknowledgments: 10
Menu Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 6.4K: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

DIANOIA'S EATERY Total Inspection Points: 114/120
Acknowledgments: 8
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 5.4K: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

ALLA FAMIGLIA Total Inspection Points: 113/120
Acknowledgments: 8
Business Hours: 9
Complete Info: 9
Current Evaluation: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 3.8K: 9
Reviews Study: 9
Menu Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Exact Services: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10