3 Best Sandwich Shops in Pittsburgh, PA

Expert-recommended Top 3 Sandwich Shops in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. All of our sandwich shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

9+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

PRIMANTI BROS. RESTAURANT AND BAR

46 18th Street,
Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Directions

Since 1933

Specialty:

Pitts-Burger and Cheese Sandwich Pastrami and Cheese Sandwich Cajun Chicken Sandwich Sirloin Steak and Cheese Sandwich Turkey Breast and Cheese Sandwich Corned Beef and Cheese Sandwich Roast Beef and Cheese Sandwich Italian Sausage and Cheese Sandwich Capicola and Cheese Sandwich Colossal Fish and Cheese Sandwich Deluxe Double Egg and Cheese Sandwich Cheese Combo Kielbasa and Cheese Ham and Cheese Jumbo Baloney and Cheese Bacon and Cheese Southwest Black Bean Burger Genoa Salami and Cheese PB Reuben New Yorker The Capone Joe Dick and Stanley When Pigs Fly The Don Double Roast Cheddar

"Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar is a counter-serve chain that has been offering a diverse array of delicious sandwiches for over 92 years. The restaurant features a warm and welcoming environment with friendly customer service. Their unique dishes include double roast and cheddar, roast beef, pastrami, genoa salami, and reuben. All sandwiches are topped with French fries, onion, and tomatoes. Customers can also taste a wide selection of appetizers and delicious drinks at a great price that ensures customers return regularly by the quality and flavor of the offerings. Primanti Bros. Restaurant and Bar offers dine-in, takeout, and delivery options for the comfort of customers.

2026 Update: Joe Primanti founded the locally-owned restaurant in the region. The sandwich shop offers catering services for events, gatherings, and special occasions."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Almost Famous Sandwiches
Almost Famous Sandwiches
Bacon & Cheese $11.99
Angus Sirloin Steak & Cheese $13.19
Cajun Chicken $11.99
Capicola & Cheese $11.99
Cheese Combo $10.79
Colossal Fish & Cheese $13.79
Corned Beef & Cheese $11.99
Deluxe Double Egg & Cheese $8.99
Ham & Cheese $11.99
Italian Sausage & Cheese $11.99
Pastrami & Cheese $11.99
Pitts-Burger & Cheese $11.99
Roast Beef & Cheese $11.99
Turkey & Cheese $11.99
Tall Boy Sandwiches:
New Yorker $14.99
The Capone $14.39
Pb Reuben $15.59
When Pigs Fly $14.99
The Don $14.99
Primanti-Style Buffalo Chicken Sandwich $14.99
Loaded Fries:
Fresh-Cut Fries $5.99
Fresh-Cut Fries With Cheese $7.19
Cheesesteak Bomb Fries $11.99

Discount:

Get a $5 Off for your next visit when you sign up

Contact:

(412) 263-2142 (412) 325-2455

Mon-Thu & Sun: 8am - 12am
Fri & Sat: 8am - 2am

TBR® Inspection Report:

8+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL

PEPPI'S

927 Western Avenue,
Pittsburgh, PA 15233 Directions

Since 1983

Specialty:

Cathedral Tuna Salad Sandwich Turkey Supreme Bacon Cheeseburger Chicken-Barbecue and Breast Onion Rings the South Philly Chicken Parmesan Pittsburgher Mushroom Swiss Burger Butcher Provolone-Cheese Sandwich Pepper and Pizza Steak Santucci Portobello Mushrooms Capicola N Cheese Hot Sausage Special Spicy Cajun Fries The Sicilian Sandwich

"Peppi's is a local sandwich chain serving a wide range of subs, plus salads and sides, in an old-school space. The restaurant's interior features pictures of famous sports personalities and locals lining the walls. The sandwich shop also has delicious fundraising subs and provides a wide array of cheesesteaks and other great subs and salads. The staff is always friendly and always makes guests feel like they're happy to make something delicious for them. Guests can savor their new blazing saddle, the South Philly hot sausage special, portobello mushrooms, chicken breast salad, and tuna salad sandwich. Peppi's also provides catering services at a reasonable price. The restaurant provides outdoor seat facilities to improve the experience of the guests.

2026 Update: Customers can get in touch with the sandwich shop through completing the registration process on the official website. The business has been in operation for over 42 years in the industry."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #750966

Price:

Hall Of Fame Burger:
The #7 $11.99
New Blazin Saddle $12.25
“Ultra” Cheese Steak $11.99
The Big Wheeler $12.25
The Heath Bar-B-Que $13.25
Joey Porter”Bella” $10.50
Big Nate $12.25
The Wiz $12.25
The New Yorker $10.50
The Phantom $10.75
Amazing Siegfried $11.25
Wally Burger $11.25
The Cathedral $11.25
The Bus $10.50
Santucci (#27) $11.25
Pittsburgher $13.25
Steak Subs:
Mushroom Cheese Steak $9.70
Pepper Steak $9.70
Cheese Steak $9.25
The South Philly $9.25
Pizza Steak $9.70
Regular Steak $8.50
Steak And Egg $9.25
Chicken Subs:
The Butcher $9.45
Chicken Swiss Mushroom $9.60
Chicken Barbeque $9.45
Chicken Parmesan $9.45
Chicken Breast $8.99
Burger & Sausage Subs:
Mushroom Swiss Burger $10.25
The Forbes Field $9.75
Bacon Cheeseburger $10

Contact:

(412) 231-9009

Mon-Fri: 10am - 8pm
Sat: 10am - 5pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

3+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

DIBELLA'S SUBS

16 Market Square,
Pittsburgh, PA 15222 Directions

Since 1918

Specialty:

Godfather DiBella's Cheesesteak Build Your Own - Pick Three Meats Build Your Own - Pick Two Meats Build Your Own - Pick One Meat Turkey Italian Assorted Chicken Bacon Ranch Dagwood Italian Meatball Chicken Philly The Cowboy Buffalo Chicken Albacore Tuna Salad Uncle Louie Veggie DiBella's BLT Roast Beef Classic Sandwich Cheese Sandwich Old Fashioned Sandwich

"DiBella's Subs is a must-visit counter-serve chain known for its delectable submarine rolls, freshly baked in-house and stuffed to order. Their fresh-baked dishes are prepared using time-honored techniques and recipes, ensuring guests get fresh and delicious subs, baked all day. The ultimate goal of the shop is to make the standard sub sandwich that guests have ever had. The famous Grandma DiBella's chocolate chip cookies are a true treat for the taste buds. For a delicious lunch, hosting a meeting, or planning a party, the restaurant offers catering services to make any occasion special. DiBella's Subs also provides online ordering, dine-in, takeout, outdoor seating, and delivery options to enjoy their dishes.

2026 Update: Peter Fox serves as the present CEO and president of the company. The sandwich shop accepts online orders and provides delivery services for customer convenience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

10" Asiago-Crusted Meals:
Turkey Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Chicken Philly Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Cheesesteak Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Godfather Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Spicy Cheesesteak Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Spicy Turkey Club Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Uncle Louie Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Old Fashioned Meal – Priced By Add-Ons
Subs
Godfather $12.89
Dibella'S Cheesesteak $14.19
Build Your Own – Pick Three Meats $12.89
Build Your Own – Pick Two Meats $12.89
Build Your Own – Pick One Meat $12.89
Turkey $12.89
Italian Assorted $12.89
Chicken Bacon Ranch $16.89
Dagwood $12.89
Italian Meatball $14.19
Chicken Philly $14.19
The Cowboy $16.89
Buffalo Chicken $14.19
Albacore Tuna Salad $12.89
Uncle Louie $12.89
Veggie $11.49
Dibella'S Blt $14.19
Roast Beef Classic $12.89
Cheese $12.8

Contact:

(412) 338-8634 (412) 358-8525

Mon-Sat: 10am - 9pm
Sun: 11am - 5pm

TBR® Inspection Report: