ThreeBestRated.com
BEST RATED NEW YORK CITY, NY PUBS

3 Best Pubs in New York City, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Pubs in New York City, NY. All of our pubs actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

Peculier Pub - New York City, NY Pubs
Peculier Pub - New York City, NY Pubs
Peculier Pub - New York City, NY Pubs
Best Pubs in New York City NY - Peculier Pub video
CALL EMAIL

PECULIER PUB

(4.9 Score)
145 Bleecker Street,
New York City, NY 10012 Directions

Since 1981

Specialty:

✓ Belle ✓ Passion4Tea ✓ Mango Mai Tai ✓ Lucky Dog ✓ Fresh Mint Mojito ✓ Speed Racer ✓ Island of Misfits ✓ Tito's Moscow Mule ✓ Spicy Moscow Mule ✓ Mezcal Margarita ✓ Spicy Margarita ✓ Cucumber Jalapeño Margarita ✓ Black Jack ✓ Piña Colada ✓ Frozen Margarita ✓ Frozen Pink Lemonade ✓ Expressionist Martini ✓ Almond Joy Martini ✓ Flirtini Martini ✓ Pinot Grigio Sauvignon Blanc Chardonnay ✓ Rosé Merlot Pinot Noir Cabernet Sauvignon ✓ Viking Blod Mead ✓ Mionetto Prosecco ✓ Curly Fries ✓ Beef Dumplings ✓ Truffle Fries ✓ Bowl of Spicy Beef Chili

“2026 Update: Peculier Pub is known for their vibrant, old-school atmosphere and extensive selection of beers from around the world. A true local favorite, they offer a cozy, unpretentious setting where friends, visitors, and NYU students alike gather to enjoy great drinks, classic pub fare, and lively conversation. Peculier Pub also offers happy hour specials and are a great spot for late-night outings. They have a stock of over 350 different bottled beers and 27 beers on draught. With decades of history and a beer list that highlights international brews and craft favorites, Peculier Pub captures the spirit of Village culture and remains a standout destination for casual nights out and memorable social experiences. They also provide free Wi-Fi and convenient street parking. ”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Cocktails:
Belle $15
Passion4tea $15
Mango Mai Tai $15
Lucky Dog $15
Fresh Mint Mojito $15
Speed Racer $15
Island of Misfits $15
Tito's Moscow Mule $16
Spicy Moscow Mule $16
Mezcal Margarita $16
Spicy Margarita $16
Cucumber Jalapeño Margarita $16
Black Jack $16
Piña Colada $16
Frozen Margarita $16
Frozen Pink Lemonade $16
Expressionist Martini $18
Almond Joy Martini $18
Flirtini Martini $18
Bar Snacks:
Chips and Salsa $4
Popcorn $4
Mozzarella Sticks $9
Jalapeño Poppers $9
Curly Fries $7
Onion Rings $7
Rosemary & Garlic Fries $8

Contact:

(212) 353-1327

Mon-Wed: 4pm - 2am
Thu: 4pm - 3am
Fri: 3pm - 4am
Sat: 1pm - 4am
Sun: 3pm- 1am

TBR® Inspection Report:

McMahon's Public House - New York City, NY Pubs
McMahon's Public House - New York City, NY Pubs
McMahon's Public House - New York City, NY Pubs
Best Pubs in New York City NY - McMahon's Public House video
CALL EMAIL

MCMAHON'S PUBLIC HOUSE

(4.9 Score)
39 5th Avenue,
New York City, NY 11217 Directions

Since 2014

Specialty:

✓ Beer ✓ Guinness ✓ Buffalo Wings ✓ Cider ✓ Taco Pizza ✓ Beef Sandwich Plate ✓ Balvenie ✓ Nacho Grande ✓ Manhattan Bourbon ✓ Shot Hennessy VSOP ✓ Old Fashioned Knob Creek Rye ✓ Triple Decker Club ✓ Burger and Fries ✓ Margarita ✓ Seltzer w Orange Bitters ✓ Cannoli ✓ McMahon's Burger with Fries ✓ Clam Chowder ✓ Heineken ✓ Fish and Chips

“2026 Update: McMahon’s Public House is a lively Irish pub that blends traditional charm with a modern neighborhood vibe. Karen and her husband Mike are proud owners of McMahon's Public House. They are known for their warm and welcoming atmosphere, they offers a diverse menu of classic comfort dishes like fish and chips, shepherd’s pie, burgers, and shareable appetizers, alongside a strong selection of beers, ciders, and whiskeys. They provide a spacious setting ideal for casual dining, watching live sports, or gathering with friends, and also feature outdoor seating and private event spaces for special occasions. McMahon’s Public House is a go-to destination for great food, drinks, and a relaxed pub experience. They also offer convenient catering services for events and gatherings, along with appealing happy hour specials that make it a great spot to unwind.”

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Draft Beer:
Bud Light $7
Smithwicks $9
Coney Island Merman IPA $8
Blue Moon $8
Guinness $10
Coney Island Pilsner $8
Coors Light $7
Bronx Pale Ale $7
Magners Irish Cider $9
Heineken $8
Kona Big Wave $8
Angry Orchard $7
Stella $8
Miller Lite $7
Carlsberg $8
Lagunitas IPA $8
Dog Fish 60 Minute IPA $8
KCBC Hazy IPA $8
Founders IPA $8
Brooklyn Pumpkin $8
Yuengling $7
Modelo $7
Brooklyn Lager $7
Sam Adams Oktoberfest $7
Bottles and Cans:
Bud $6
Juice Force IPA $7
Mich Ultra $6
Coors $6
Whiteclaw Vodka Soda $8
Miller Highlife $5
Bud Light $6
Surfside Iced Tea Lemonade $7
Sea Quench Sour Ale $7
Amstel Light $6

Contact:

(718) 230-4549

Mon-Sun: 11am - 2am

TBR® Inspection Report:

Jack Doyle's - New York City, NY Pubs
Jack Doyle's - New York City, NY Pubs
Jack Doyle's - New York City, NY Pubs
CALL EMAIL

JACK DOYLE'S

(4.8 Score)
240 West 35th Street,
New York City, NY 10001 Directions

Specialty:

✓ Guinness ✓ Fish and Chips ✓ French Onion Soup ✓ Chicken Pot Pie ✓ Bangers and Mash ✓ Sandwich Special ✓ Irish Coffee ✓ Steak Sandwich ✓ Buffalo Wings ✓ Burger with Mushrooms ✓ Budweiser ✓ Delirium Tremens ✓ Kopparberg Strawberry and Lime ✓ Onion Rings ✓ Sweet Potato Fries ✓ French Fries

“2026 Update: Jack Doyle’s is a vibrant Irish pub that combines classic hospitality with a lively Midtown atmosphere. Their menu offers a mix of traditional Irish favorites and American pub fare, complemented by a wide selection of beers, cocktails, and whiskeys. They are known for their energetic setting, it features a spacious layout with multiple bars, large screens for live sports, and regular entertainment that keeps the crowd engaged. They provide an inviting space for everything from casual drinks to group gatherings, making it a popular destination for both locals and visitors looking for a fun, social night out. They also offer delivery services and complimentary Wi-Fi for added convenience.”

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Cans and Bottles:
Budweiser $6
Corona $8
Heineken $8
Peroni $8
Narragansett $8
Sierra Nevada Pale Ale $9
Bud Light $6
Heineken Light $8
Amstel Light $8
Coors Light $6
Corona Light $8
Miller Light $6
Michelob Ultra $6
Left Hand Milk Nitro Stout $8
Duvel $11
Delirium Tremens $11
Chimay $11
Rochefort $14
Magners $12
High Noon $10
Kopparberg Strawberry Lime $8
Rotating Hard Seltzer $9
Heineken $8
Sides:
French Fries $8
Waffle Fries $8
Sweet Potato Fries $8
Fried Brussels Sprouts $8
Onion Rings $8
Mashed Potatoes $8
Truffle Tater Tots $9.95
Irish Breakfast $19.95
Fish & Chips $20.95
Shepherd's Pie $18.95
Corned Beef Reuben on Rye $19.95
Bangers & Mash $19.95

Contact:

(212) 268-1255

Sun-Wed: 10am - 3am
Thu-Sat: 10am - 4am

TBR® Inspection Report:

Video

Write a Review for Jack Doyle's

Our Review Process:

  • All reviews matter:We publish both positive and negative reviews to provide a balanced perspective.
  • No censorship: Businesses cannot pay to remove or modify negative reviews.
  • Verification process: All reviews are checked for authenticity and compliance with our community guidelines before publication.
  • Fair representation: We display reviews of all ratings (1–5 stars) to help users make informed decisions.
  • Independence: We are not affiliated with the businesses we review and receive no compensation for favorable ratings.

Your honest opinion helps others make better choices. Whether your experience was excellent, average, or disappointing, we want to hear from you. For more details, check Community Review Guidelines.

Contact Business

PECULIER PUB REVIEWS

Great selection of beer and cider, and they do take cards with a $20 minimum. Our server was friendly and helpful, everything came quickly. The beer menu is overwhelmingly large, and they have more ciders than I've seen anywhere else in NYC. A good menu for bar bites and food, which is pretty good for bar food. The decorations here are great though, keep an eye out for bottle cap versions of all sorts of famous paintings.

Love coming here but usually it’s a beer night when I go. Came on Friday and ordered a Dirty Martini. Felt like a brave choice but that is what the night needed. The bartender made one so delicious and filthy the entire table talked about it for the rest of the night. Moral of the story, Peculier Pub may not look like a cocktail lounge but take the risk it may just pay off.

My social group meets up here on a weekly basis. The bartenders are very friendly and attentive. The atmosphere is usually chill, it’s a nice local vibe.

These reviews are provided for information purposes and to help you make informed decisions.

To share your experience, click here or send it to reviews@threebestrated.com.

We will display both positive and negative reviews. All submitted reviews are published after verification for authenticity and compliance with our Terms and Conditions, Privacy Policy, and Community Review Guidelines.

MCMAHON'S PUBLIC HOUSE REVIEWS

McMahon’s Public House offers a classic pub experience with a warm, old-school charm. The rich wood interior, brick walls, and vintage sports memorabilia create a cozy atmosphere perfect for relaxing with friends or catching a game. The long bar is impressive, featuring a wide lineup of draft beers and a well-stocked selection of spirits. Multiple TVs ensure you won’t miss any sports action, no matter where you sit. The dining area is spacious, with plenty of tables for larger groups, and the upstairs area adds extra room for events or busy nights. While the menu posted outside shows familiar pub favorites, the real draw here is the inviting vibe, friendly staff, and great drink selection that keeps guests coming back.

I had an amazing night here, the customer service and the drinks were absolutely amazing. We asked the server Katie for recommendation’s and they were all really good. They also show the live games on tv and will show any game you ask for. I will for sure be back! Highly recommend.

Had the BEST evening here. Jerry was the best bartender, so nice, friendly, and very active, didn’t have to wait for service at all. The food and drinks were amazing and I will definitely make the trip back out here!

JACK DOYLE'S REVIEWS

Stopped in here for dinner and a beer. Was seated immediately at around 530pm on a Wednesday. The place was busy but not overly packed. Loud, but expectedly so. I got a John Doyle’s burger that was deceptively small, almost slider sized, but it was packed with two thick patties perfectly cooked to medium as requested. A Shepard Pie was also had that was very good, but I’m not necessarily a shepherd’s pie aficionado. I got a John Doyle’s Lager and it was ice cold and delicious. I would 100% return for that burger and beer!

At Jack Doyle's, my husband and I have forged a wonderful relationship with this bar, particularly during Arsenal games. We thoroughly enjoy their wings, Magners cider, and engaging conversations with fellow fans at the bar. The staff has always been extremely friendly and accommodating when it comes to reserving tables for upcoming games. If you find yourself in New York City and happen to be an Arsenal fan, definitely swing by and check out this bar.

Flew into town a bit early to watch a Vikings game here! It didn’t disappoint. Great atmosphere, and the place was totally decked out in Christmas stuff too! Super fun experience!

TBR® Inspection Score Report

PECULIER PUB Total Inspection Points: 118/120
Page Maintenance: 8
Business Hours: 10
Business Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Experience: 10
Legitimate Ratings: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Social Media: 10
Video: 10
Website Source: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

MCMAHON'S PUBLIC HOUSE Total Inspection Points: 117/120
Business Hours: 9
Experience: 9
Social Media: 9
Business Images: 10
Complete Info: 10
Contact Info: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Page Maintenance: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Accuracy of 2.2K: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Video: 10

TBR® Inspection Score Report

JACK DOYLE'S Total Inspection Points: 115/120
Complete Info: 9
Legitimate Ratings: 9
Responsiveness: 9
Reviews Accuracy of 2.0K: 9
Social Media: 9
Business Hours: 10
Business Images: 10
Contact Info: 10
Location Proximity: 10
Pricing: 10
Reviews Study: 10
Website Source: 10