3 Best American Restaurants in New York City, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 American Restaurants in New York City, NY. All of our american cuisines actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

7+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

TAVERN ON THE GREEN

67th Street & Central Park West,
New York City, NY 10023 Directions

Since 1934

Specialty:

Tavern Burger Lemon Chicken Under a Brick Grilled Lamb Chops Tavern Cobb Salad Salmon Burger Shaved Sirloin Steak Sandwich Braised Beef Short Rib Sandwich Steak and Eggs Smoked Bacon and Scrambled Egg Flatbread Classic Eggs Benedict Tavern Beef Sliders Grilled Cheese Sandwich Kids Macaroni and Cheese Crispy Chicken Fingers Potato Pancakes Tavern French Toast Mashed Potatoes Shoestring Fries Truffle and Parmesan Fries Truffle Mac and Cheese Lobster Mac'n Cheese Roasted Broccoli with Lemon Haricots Verts Honey Roasted Figs Fresh Burrata and Hearth Roasted Grape Tomatoes Shrimp Cocktail

"Tavern on the Green offers American food in a stylish setting with courtyard and garden seating. This restaurant was started as a simple sheepfold in Central Park, New York City, where 300 Southdown sheep grazed. Calvert Vaux designed them in the Victorian Gothic Revival style. In the 1930s, the building was turned into Central Park’s first restaurant, starting its journey as a famous dining spot. Over time, it underwent several renovations, including the addition of the famous Crystal Room. In 2014, Jim Caiola and David Salama restored the landmark with support from the City of New York. Tavern on the Green is a top dining spot, offering a Classic American Menu and hosting weddings, corporate events, and special gatherings. The restaurant welcomes guests of all ages and provides full accessibility for those using wheelchairs. Their $145 prix-fixe menu includes four delicious courses created by Executive Chef Bill Peet.

2026 Update: Tavern on the Green, a historic Central Park landmark, has been serving elegant American cuisine for over 92 years. Led by proprietors Jim Caiola and David Salama and Executive Chef Bill Peet, it offers courtyard and garden seating, blending modern renovations with iconic charm. The restaurant hosts weddings, corporate events, social celebrations, and premier dining experiences, with indoor and outdoor spaces for 20 to 1,500 guests. Parties of 24–32 can enjoy a seasonal three-course prix-fixe menu in the Central Park Room or Courtyard. Reservations and event bookings can be made via email or the inquiry form, ensuring every detail is expertly managed for a memorable experience."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Appetizer
Honey Roasted Figs $24
Fresh Burrata & Roasted Tomatoes $23
Shrimp Cocktail $29
Roasted Garlic Shrimp $29
Baby Wedge Salad $21
Jumbo Lump Crab Cake $29
Hearts Of Palm & Asparagus Salad $23
Jumbo Crab Meat Cocktail $32
Chopped Vegetable Salad $24
French Country Flatbread $22
EntréE
Lemon Chicken Under A Brick $36
Grilled Lamb Chops $47
Tavern Burger $34
Grilled Rainbow Trout $34
Organic Scottish Salmon $39
Jackfruit Stuffed Bell Pepper $34
Grilled Fish Of The Day $34
Baked Eggplant & Tofu $32
Sides
Mashed Potatoes $16
Roasted Broccoli With Lemon $16
Haricots Verts $16
Shoestring Fries $16
Truffle & Parmesan Fries $20
Truffle Mac & Cheese $20
Lobster Mac N Cheese $29
Appetizer
Grilled Vegetable Bouquet $25
Wild Mushroom Toast $26
Grilled Thick Maple Bacon $21
Meatball Sliders $15
EntréE
Tavern Cobb Salad $33

Contact:

(212) 877-8684

Mon-Thu: 11am - 9pm
Fri: 11am -10pm
Sat: 9am - 10pm
Sun: 9am - 9pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

8+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BEAUTY & ESSEX

146 Essex Street,
New York City, NY 10002 Directions

Since 2010

Specialty:

Little French Dips Rhode Island Lobster Roll Beauty and Essex Burger ‘chicken and Biscuits’ Shrimp and Grits Bec Sandwich Red Velvet Waffles Double Smoked and Maple Cured Bacon ‘new Orleans' Style Breakfast Potatoes Oreo Cookie Pancakes Wonder Wheel Brunch Shandy Brunch Sparkling Brut Mimosa Flight Bande Brunch Fountain Beauty Elixir Green With Envy Emerald Gimlet O.d.b Old Dirty Bramble The Woodsman Lychee Martini Pawn Shop Special Nsfw Thicker Than Water Pink Panther Topaz Manhattan Millionaire Margarita grilled-cheese-smoked-bacon-tomato-soup-dumplings Grilled Shishito Peppers Kale And apple Salad Caesar Salad

"Beauty & Essex provides a luxurious dining experience with four unique dining rooms, including a private room, two bars, and a lounge. This stylish restaurant is designed by AvroKO. Chef Chris Santos creates globally inspired small plates, including the popular grilled cheese and tomato soup dumplings. For a hearty meal, guests can enjoy dishes like braised veal short ribs with tangerine-BBQ glaze and crispy onion rings. The restaurant is great for private events with a private dining room for 10 to 400 guests and flexible dining spaces for groups of 10 to 60. They can host cocktail events with a passed dinner for groups of 30 to 400 people. Their menu includes vegetarian options, and gift cards make a great surprise for loved ones. Enjoy specialty-priced cocktails and menu items at their bar and lounge every day. The menu also features a selection of plant-based and meat-free options.

2026 Update: Beauty & Essex is a dynamic restaurant and lounge where guests step through a pawn shop façade into a world of modern luxury and inventive design. The venue specializes in creative American cuisine and expertly crafted cocktails, offering an unforgettable dining experience for all occasions. Reservations are available for guests seeking a table in the main dining room, intimate spaces like the Vault, or exclusive private rooms such as the Pearl or Locket Room. The restaurant accommodates a variety of events, from casual dinners and brunches to celebrations, corporate gatherings, and private parties. With a focus on exceptional service, curated menus, and a stylish atmosphere, they ensure every guest enjoys a seamless and memorable experience, whether visiting for a night out or a special event."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Bubbles & Brunch Pre Fixe
Bubbles & Brunch Pre Fixe $35
Signature Cocktails
B&E Brunch Fountain $98
Brunch Shandy $17
Brunch Sparkling Brut (Bottle) $20
Mimosa Flight $21
Spritz Flight $22
Beauty Elixir $21
Green With Envy $20
Emerald Gimlet $20
Old Dirty Bramble $21
The Woodsman $20
Lychee Martini $18
Specialty Cocktails
Pawn Shop Special $19
Nsfw $20
Thicker Than Water $19
Pink Panther $19
Luxury Cocktails
Topaz Manhattan $25
Millionaire Margarita $26
Smoke 'Em If You Got 'Em $29
Zero Proof Cocktails
Garden Party $17
Porch Light $15
Sweet Things & Starters
Coconut Chia Seed Parfait $8
Les Nyc Doughnuts $15
Oreo Cookie Pancakes $16
Red Velvet Waffles $15
Wonder Wheel $41
Kale & Apple Salad $17
Brunch Pizzetta $18
Grilled Cheese Soup Dumplings $24
Shrimp Cocktail $25
East & West Coast Oysters $24 $45
Je

Contact:

(212) 614-0146

Mon-Wed: 5pm - 10pm
Thu: 5pm - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 5pm - 12am
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

SERENDIPITY 3

225 E 60th Street,
New York City, NY 10022 Directions

Since 1954

Specialty:

The Ultimate Potato Skins Not Yo’ Ordinary Nachos Guac and Chips Queso and Chips Tex Mex Chili and Chips Fried Mozzarella Boom Boom Shrimp All American Wagyu Sliders Crispy Buttermilk Chicken Tenders Boneless Buffalo Bites Sunday Chicken Dinner Sundae Serendipity Mac n’ Cheese Serendipity Chili Mac Serendipity Bacon Mac Serendipity Truffle Mac Hamburger American Cheeseburger Bacon BBQ Cheeseburger Chili Cheese Burger The Infamous Truffle Burger Vegan Black Bean Burger The Jalapeno Jack Burger Breakfast Burger Pepperoni Pizza Burger Nacho Burger Classic Footlong Chili Cheese Dog Bacon Cheese Dog

2026 Update: Serendipity 3, a celebrated restaurant in New York City, is renowned for its whimsical decor, indulgent desserts, and unique dining experience. Famous for its world-renowned Frozen Hot Chocolate, the restaurant has been delighting locals and visitors for over 72 years. Open every day of the year, Serendipity 3 offers eclectic American cuisine featuring classic favorites such as burgers, footlong hot dogs, hearty salads, sandwiches, pasta, and comforting pot pies, alongside its signature decadent desserts, including pies, cakes, towering ice cream sundaes, and specialty Frozen Hot Chocolates. With locations in Times Square and the Upper East Side, the restaurant ensures a lively, playful atmosphere where every guest can enjoy a memorable and imaginative meal. Reservations can also be made in advance, allowing guests to secure their table ahead of time for a seamless dining experience.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #3199891

Price:

Brunch
Bloody Mary $16.95
Bloody Maria $16.95
Mimosa $15.95
Bellini $15.95
Classics
Margarita $15.95
Aperol Spritz $16.95
Negroni $15.95
Espresso Martini $18.95
Manhattan $15.95
Martini $15.95
Old Fashioned $15.95
Hugo Spritz $16.95
Mojito $15.95
Paloma $15.95
Cosmopolitan $16.95
Lit $15.95
Shots
Green Tea Shot $12
Lemon Drop $12
Kamikaze $12
Jolly Rancher $12
See You Tomorrow $14

Contact:

(646) 212-1442

Mon-Fri: 11am - 11pm
Sat & Sun: 10am - 11pm

TBR® Inspection Report: