3 Best Cakes in New York City, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Cakes in New York City. All selected cake shops undergo our rigorous 50-Point Inspection, assessing reviews, reputation, history, price, proximity, and more to ensure excellence. No Pay-to-Play!

CALL EMAIL

MAGNOLIA BAKERY

1240 Avenue of the Americas (at 49th Street),
New York City, NY 10020 Directions

Since 1996

Confetti Chocolate Vanilla Carrot Red Velvet Hummingbird German Chocolate and Flourless Chocolate Banana Pudding Heart Sugar Chocolate Chunk Cookie Assortment Red Velvet Banana Pudding Cookies Lemon Bar Double Fudge Brownie Chocolate Chunk Blondie Brownie & Blondie Combo

Magnolia Bakery specializes in making a variety of creative cupcakes. They offer nationwide shipping for a wide range of products, including freshly baked cupcakes, pastries, brownies, chocolate bars, corporate gift packages, and seasonal assortments. Magnolia Bakery provides a traditional American baked products, vintage decor, and a warm and inviting ambience from its beginning. Whether planning a private dinner party, or a corporate gathering, their team works closely with you to prepare delicious and customizable desserts. They also offer cupcake icing and decorating stations to delight and amuse your guests. Their squad of skilled icers create beautifully crafted cakes and cupcakes. Magnolia Bakery has branches in Washington, Dubai, Abu Dhabi, and Manila Doha.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Confetti Cake
3 Layer 6" Cake$59.00
3 Layer 9" Cake$59.00
Chocolate Cake
3 Layer 6" Cake$54.00
2 Layer 9" Cake$54.00
10% Off on Your Birthday

Contact:

(212) 767-1123

Sun-Thu: 8am - 10pm
Fri & Sat: 8am - 11pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

MIA'S BROOKLYN BAKERY

139 Smith Street,
New York City, NY 11201 Directions

Since 2015

Edible Image Flan Lemon Bundt Lemon Raspberry Chocolate Raspberry Valentine's Day Chocolate Strawberry Pillow Heart Raspberry Mousse w/ Crème Brulee Apple Cheesecake Classic Cheesecake Black Forest Blackout Blueberry Cheesecake Burnt Almond Caramel Cheesecake Carrot Cherry Cheesecake Chocolate Fudge Chocolate Layer Chocolate Mousse Coconut Fruit Napoleon German Chocolate Lemon Blueberry Nutella Oreo Oreo Cheesecake & Peach Raspberry

Mia's Brooklyn Bakery offers signature desserts, savory items, a full coffee bar, and an outdoor patio. They specialize in crafting personalized cakes, pastries, and an array of delightful confections. Their commitment to using only the freshest ingredients is evident in every homemade treat they create. You'll find everything from freshly baked pies and pastries to breathtaking cakes at Mia's Brooklyn Bakery. You can customize your Cakes at Mia's Brooklyn Bakery. They can make all types of cakes, and you can enjoy your foods and cakes in their warm environment. Mia's Brooklyn Bakery offers dine in, online order, local delivery and pick up.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Royal Blue Edible Image Cake$68
Flan Mia's Bakery$48
Lemon Bundt Cake Mia's Bakery$30
Lemon Raspberry Tart$35
Chocolate Raspberry Heart Cake$60
Pillow Heart Tart$14

Contact:

(347) 987-3194

Mon-Wed: 7am - 10pm
Thu: 7am - 11pm
Fri & Sat: 7am - 12am
Sun: 7am - 10pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

EILEEN'S SPECIAL CHEESECAKE

17 Cleveland Place,
New York City, NY 10012 Directions

Since 1974

Raspberry Swirl Fall Quarters Sampler Quad Sampler Classic Plain Strawberry Banana Marble Fruit Special Cherry Salted Caramel Blueberry Raspberry Black & White Cheesecakes

Eileen's Special Cheesecake was Founded by Eileen, an entrepreneurial visionary driven by both natural talent and a compassionate spirit. Eileen’s Special Cheesecake has become a favorite, place for cheesecake enthusiasts awaiting the chance to savor their preferred flavors. Their cheesecake is meticulously handmade at the original downtown bakery, where some dedicated employees boast over 40 years of service. The commitment to freshness, use of genuine ingredients, and avoidance of fillers or artificial preservatives. Eileen's Special Cheesecake offers gluten-free, vegan cake options, dine-in and online orders.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Cheesecakes in America, 2019

Price:

Raspberry Swirl$103
Fall Quarters$110
Sampler$115
Quad Sampler$110
Classic Plain$99
Strawberry$108

Contact:

(212) 966-5585

Sun-Thu: 11am - 7pm
Fri & Sat: 11am - 8pm

TBR® Inspection Report: