3 Best Gift Shops in Buffalo, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Gift Shops in Buffalo, NY. All of our gift shops actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

CALL EMAIL

THIN ICE

4.8 (116)
719 Elmwood Avenue,
Buffalo, NY 14222 Directions

Since 2006

Specialty:

Jewelry Business Card Holder Candles Toddler Tea Coffee Pottery Puzzles Body Notebooks Leather Bath Coasters Games Coloring Book Gifts for Guys Glass Plant Stuff Bags Writing Utensils Wallets Crochet Hooks and Knitting Needles Snail Mail Apparel Staff Favorites Seasonal Home Decor Ornaments Metal Fiber Books Hair Accessories

Thin Ice is a locally owned business that offers an array of handmade jewelry, pottery, and home decor. The store provides a platform for local and regional artists to showcase their craft to the community. Thin Ice proudly features a diverse selection of handcrafted items from over 235 local and national artists. The shop offers a variety of unique pieces, including one-of-a-kind jewelry, handmade cards, hand-blown glass, wheel-thrown pottery, fused glass, and hand-turned wood bowls. Thin Ice remains dedicated to fostering a vibrant, creative community. With room to accommodate even more local artists, it ensures a constantly evolving selection of handmade gifts and art for its customers.

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review

Price:

Buffalo Knot Hats 36M$18
Buffalo Knot Hats 03M$18
Buffalo Headbands Children’s$16
Buffalo Headbands Adult$16
Swarovski Crystal Set$60
Beryl Calcite Necklace$135

Discount:

$5 Off on your next day delivery within 15 miles of Thin Ice!

Contact:

(716) 881-4321

Mon & Sun: 11am - 6pm
Tue-Sat: 10:30am - 7pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe Buffalo Gift Shops image 1
Best Gift Shops in Buffalo NY - Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe image 2
Top Gift Shops in Buffalo NY - Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe image 3
CALL EMAIL

JO-AN'S HALLMARK SHOPPE

4.8 (115)
3600 Delaware Avenue, Sheridan Delawre Plaza,
Buffalo, NY 14217 Directions

Since 1910

Specialty:

Anniversary Pets Encouragement Fashion and Accessories Candy Home Decor Picture Frames Kitchen Bath Body Books Movies Drink Stationery Toys Personalized Gifts Music Ornaments Handbags Office Cards Gift Sets Sympathy Confirmation Baby Food Figurines Candles Albums Purses

Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe specializes in all your gift, ornament, and card needs. The store has an extensive selection of year-round and seasonal gifts, including Keepsake Ornaments, gift wraps, and greeting cards, all at reasonable prices. The shop takes pride in offering a diverse range of gifts and cards to commemorate significant milestones, including anniversaries, birthdays, baby showers, new babies, baptisms, first communions, confirmations, get well, graduations, sympathy, and thank-you notes. Additionally, they offer a variety of thinking-of-you, get well, and sympathy cards. Jo-An's Hallmark Shoppe is proud to feature popular brands such as Pandora, Alex and Ani, and a vast collection of Vera Bradley products, ensuring there's something for everyone to cherish and enjoy.

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Class of 2023 Gift Set$59.95
Photo Card$4.99
Set the Bar High Grad Card$3.59
Jumbo Hats Card$9.99
Cap Autograph Plush$14.99
Happiness Grad Set$47.45

Discount:

Get Free shipping on over $20 with Crown Rewards - $5 Off on your next purchase on orders over $10

Contact:

(716) 875-5588

Mon-Sat: 10am - 8pm
Sun: 12pm - 5pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

Tara Gift Shoppe Buffalo Gift Shops image 1
Best Gift Shops in Buffalo NY - Tara Gift Shoppe image 2
Top Gift Shops in Buffalo NY - Tara Gift Shoppe image 3
CALL EMAIL

TARA GIFT SHOPPE

4.7 (112)
250 Abbott Road,
Buffalo, NY 14220 Directions

Since 1980

Specialty:

Guinness Aran Wear Claddagh Rings Fragrances Music Christmas Masks Irish Baby Kitchen Garden Clothing Gifts Belleek Children Rugby Crystal First Communion For The Bar Home Jewelry Weddings Men Women Drink Father's and Mother's Day Suncatchers

Tara Gift Shoppe has been a beloved destination for Irish gifts and imports for over thirty years. The store's warm and welcoming atmosphere, along with Tara Gift Shop's friendly and knowledgeable staff, treats customers like family. Since its inception, the shop has been dedicated to providing the community with a diverse selection of authentic Irish goods, serving as a cherished destination for all things Irish. Tara Gift Shoppe invites customers to reminisce or explore the rich heritage of Ireland. Their extensive inventory includes the finest offerings from Ireland, featuring renowned brands such as Belleek, Royal Tara, Solvar, O'Connor, Fado, Shanore jewelry, Condron Knitwear, collectibles, music, and more.

Reviews   |   Write a Review

Price:

Part Set Claddagh Ring$840
Buffalo Glass Ornament$14.99
Belleek Shamrock Ring Holder$45
Traditional Aran Knit Pullover$120
Pet Collection Irish Dog$63

Discount:

15% Off on all purchases excluding special orders

Contact:

(716) 825-6700

Mon-Thu, Sat: 10am - 4pm
Fri: 10am - 6pm
Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: