Best Gift Shops in Buffalo

Expert recommended Top 3 Gift Shops in Buffalo, NY. All of our gift shops face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!


719 Elmwood Avenue, Buffalo, NY 14222 Directions

Since 2006

Thin Ice opened in March 2006 to provide a venue for local and national artists to sell their work to the local community. They sell one of the kind jewelry, hand-formed and rolled pottery, hand-made cards, hand-blasted and fused glass, hand-turned wooden bowls, hand-woven leather products, decorative wall art, kaleidoscopes. They have more than 200 artists, more than 95% regional. They also sell jewelry, hand-woven, and fused glass, hand-turned wooden bowls, hand-made scarves, hand-woven leather goods, decorative wall art, kaleidoscopes, cards, and windscreen. Throughout 2011, Thin Ice grew to provide space to collaborate with many more local artists creating handmade gifts and jewelry.

Earrings, Bottoms, Bags, Fragrance, Bracelets, Art, Jumpsuits, Kitchen Accessories, Necklaces, Dresses, Coasters, T-Shirts, Jewelry, Clothing, Albums, Candles, Tops, Fused Glass Tree Pendant, Rings, Jar Glass, Watches, Wine Glasses, Bracelet, Coffee Scoop, Handbags, Nursery, Mugs, Trivets, Party Essentials, Calendars, Tumblers & Tea Collection

Price: Starts from $13

[email protected]


Mon & Sun 11:00 am - 6:00 pm
Tue - Sat 10:30 am - 7:00 pm

TBR® Inspection Report


250 Abbott Road, Buffalo, NY 14220 Directions

Since 1980

Tara Gift Shoppe, WNY 's Original Irish Import Shop, is located in South Buffalo, Ireland's Heritage District. Founded in 1980 and named after the Hill of Tara, the store opened its doors to provide the city with a range of Irish products. Since its inception, it has doubled its retail floor space. The shop attracts tourists from all over the world as they stop reminiscing or checking out the "old neighborhood." Their polite and professional workers made the customer feel like they were family members. Their range includes the finest offers from Ireland: Belleek, Royal Tara, Condron Knitwear, Solvar. They afford Free Shipping on orders over $100.

Blankets, Aran Wear, Tara's Diary, T-Shirts, Origin, Bags, Totes, Fragrances, Platinumware, Kitchen Accessories, Children's Jewellery, Jewelry, Father's Day, Home Goods, Rings, Clothing, Sun Catchers, Kids, Kitchen Linens, Weddings, Earrings, Music, Cards, Garden, Christmas, Mugs, Candles, Food, Mother's Day, Watches, First Communion & Drink

Discount: Save up to 60% on all in-stock Tara's Diary Stacking Rings - Save 50% or more on Little Miss by Shanore this Collection

Price: Starts from $9.99

[email protected]


Call for Hours

TBR® Inspection Report


3600 Delaware Avenue, Sheridan Delawre Plaza, Buffalo, NY 14217 Directions

Jo-An 's Hallmark is proud to present Pandora, Alex, and Ani and a large collection of Vera Bradley. Jo-An 's Hallmark Shoppe is the perfect store for all your important events with a wide selection of year-round and seasonal gifts, gift wraps, keepsake ornaments, and birthday cards. Get one free Just Because of card per month at the participating stores in Hallmark Gold Crown. Sign up online today, and they'll give you a voucher to save $5 on your next order. Plus, a new promo for a free card will arrive in your inbox with your monthly reward report.

Encouragement, Sympathy, Baby, Anniversary, Candy, Congratulations, Confirmation, Picture Frames, Candles, Handbags, Movies, Fashion and Accessories, Figurines, Books, Music, Stuffed Animals, Ornaments, Bath and Body, Purses, Kitchen, Home Decor, Food and Drink, Albums, Office, Stationery, Cards, Gift Sets, Pets, Personalized Gifts & Toys

Price: Starts from $1.99


Mon - Sat 10:00 am - 8:00 pm
Sun 12:00 pm - 5:00 pm

TBR® Inspection Report