3 Best Jewelry in Buffalo, NY

Expert-recommended Top 3 Jewelers in Buffalo, NY. All of our Jewelry Stores actually face a rigorous 50-Point Inspection, which includes customer reviews, history, complaints, ratings, satisfaction, trust, cost and general excellence. You deserve only the best!

8+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

BEN GARELICK

5001 Transit Road,
Buffalo, NY 14221 Directions

Since 1952

Specialty:

Gold and Platinum Jewelry Diamond and Silver Jewelry Yellow Gold White and Rose Gold Jewelry Rings Earrings Necklaces Bracelets Pendants Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Birthstone Jewelry Classic and Timeless Jewelry Cufflinks Estate Jewelry Pearl Jewelry Religious Jewelry Ruby Jewelry Eternity Rings Engraved Rings Promise Rings

"Ben Garelick Jewelers is a family-owned jewelry store that has proudly provided a wide variety of fine jewelry and unique pieces for over 65 years. They specialize in bridal rings, offering an extensive selection of diamond shapes and sizes. Their expert jewelers are dedicated to helping you find the perfect ring and answering any questions along the way. They take pride in offering diamonds in a range of cuts, colors, and weights, including one-carat, two-carat, three-carat, and even five-carat stones. In addition, the store provides free cleanings and a lifetime diamond trade-up program. Ben Garelick Jewelers is here to guide you through the diamond-buying process, helping you find a ring that will make you smile for a lifetime. They also offer limited lifetime warranty options and free shipping on all orders.

2026 Highlights: Ben Garelick hosts the largest physical collection of premium designers like Simon G., Noam Carver, Gabriel & Co., and Vahan in the Western New York region. They carry one of the area's largest inventories of Moissanite, Lab-Grown Diamonds, and rare colored gemstones alongside natural earth-mined diamonds."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #129056

Discount:

10% Off on Your First Order

30% Off Any One Piece Sitewide

View Coupon

Contact:

(716) 631-1584 (888) 841-5391 (TEXT ONLY)

Tue-Fri: 10am - 6pm
Sat: 10am - 5pm
Mon & Sun: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report:

CALL EMAIL

COLOSSEUM JEWELRY

Galleria Drive,
Buffalo, NY 14225 Directions

Since 2007

Specialty:

Gold and Diamond Jewelry Silver Jewelry Custom Jewelry Earrings Studs Chains Pendants Bracelets Rings

"Colosseum Jewelry offers the highest quality gold, silver, and diamond jewelry collections. They specialize in turning your custom jewelry ideas into a reality at unbeatable prices. Their collection features a wide array of stunning pieces, each designed to add a touch of elegance and luxury to your life. Explore their collection today and discover why Colosseum Jewelry is the go-to brand for urban luxury. Every item is crafted with precision and care to meet the highest standards of excellence. Colosseum Jewelry prides itself on providing a seamless shopping experience, offering in-store shopping and personalized consultations. They offer free shipping, flexible "buy now, pay later" options, and same-day delivery for your convenience.

2026 Highlights: Colosseum Jewelry has launched an expansion initiative called Buff Ice, aimed at scaling their bold Western New York signature aesthetic to wider national markets. Apply without using credit and get approved to lease up to $5,000 in merchandise."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
License #6732510

Discount:

Get $300 Off on 14 Kw 0.10 Ctw Round Diamond Earring Stud

View Coupon

Contact:

(716) 684-8384

Mon-Sat: 11am - 7pm
Sun: 11am - 6pm

TBR® Inspection Report:

11+ YEARS IN TBR
CALL EMAIL

AURUM JEWELERS

487 Elmwood Avenue,
Buffalo, NY 14222 Directions

Since 1964

Specialty:

Gold and Diamond Jewelry Pearl Collections Bracelets Earrings Necklaces Pendants Engagement Rings Wedding Bands Custom Jewelry Designer Jewelry Maintenance and Repair Cufflinks Timepieces Natural and Lab Diamonds Three Stone Platinum Ring Handmade Platinum Floral Halo Ring Emerald Cut Timeless Brilliant Cut Colorful Gemstone Oval

"Aurum Jewelers is owned by Paul Michaels, who brings over fifty years of knowledge and experience working with fine metals and setting both precious and semi-precious stones for custom and original designs. The store offers a wide selection of vintage, new, and unique pieces, as well as antique silverware. Aurum Jewelers also provides expert services such as pearl or bead restringing, insurance appraisals, and stone setting. They take pride in their exceptional collection of estate and antique jewelry and are committed to helping you find or create the perfect piece. The team takes the time to understand your style and preferences or those of your loved ones while maintaining close communication throughout the design process. In-house jewelry repairs and cleaning services are available, and returns are accepted within 14 days of the purchase date.

2026 Highlights: Aurum Jewelers maintains an out-of-town appraisal pipeline. They coordinate secure, fully insured transit logistics to safely evaluate, document, and photograph high-value family heirlooms for clients residing across the country."

Reviews | Play Video | Write a Review
Best Jewelry Store in Art Voice from 2011 & 2014
Buffalo Spree Magazine for Leadership in Fine Timepieces and Custom Luxury Jewelry Trends 2025
License #5345978

Contact:

(716) 886-1300

Tue-Sat: 10am - 6:30pm
Sun & Mon: Closed

TBR® Inspection Report: