3 Best Sandwich Shops in New York City, NY

Great food with good portions ans a friendly staff. We had no idea the small sandwiches were so big. I had a chicken cutlet sandwich with roasted peppers lettuce tomato mayo. My wife got the Italian and she said it was grateful, my son loved the meatball sub and my daughter enjoyed the Buffalo chicken cutlet. There were so many options to choose from be sure to look ahead or plan to be overwhelmed by the options. We went during a time where it wasn't busy so we were able to get some seats at the picnic tables outside. Next time I want to try the Steak pizzaiola since it looked really good.

Good local Brooklyn Italian deli, fish Fridays i enjoy, would recommend any day!

Got to stop by and grab a sandwich place is awesome.

TLDR: Hell's Kitchen location of a famous sandwich shop from Tuscany. HUGE handhelds, personal favorites are the Boss and L'Inferno. I've never been to the one in Florence but there's quite a few locations in the city now. What they specialize in is a Tuscan bread known as "schiacciata" which they make sandwiches with. It's somewhat similar to a focaccia but thinner and crisper with less sponginess. The Boss has pecorino/truffle cream, cheese and Tuscan prosciutto. L'Inferno is a shaved porchetta sandwich with nduja, eggplant, arugula - for me it's a bit lighter but packed with flavor. I've been to the shop and also have gotten it delivered, it travels well. The sandwiches are large and if you're not a big eater; you could probably share this with someone. The pro move is to get two and split them. If you go in-person you can see them make each one to order. Solid place for a good sandwich.

All’Antico Vinaio in the US was such a great surprise, especially because they actually offer gluten-free options, unlike in Italy. The gluten-free focaccia was absolutely incredible. I had the one with pecorino, pistachio cream, and mortadella, and it was truly out of this world. The staff was friendly, everything was served quickly, and although there’s usually a line, it moves fairly fast. The only thing that could be improved is the location itself: having more seating available would definitely make the experience even better. Overall, still a fantastic spot!

Wow, absolutely loved this place. The sandwiches are insanely good and huge — even though they’re around $15–$20, you can easily share one. We had the Paradiso with mortadella, pistachio, burrata, etc., and it was amazing. We also tried another one with Parma ham and truffle cream (don’t remember the name), and it was just as delicious. Definitely worth it.